Everyone's A Critic

Comedian Alex Mason joins the show to defend the 2000s rom-com classic, How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days (2003) starring Kate Hudson and Matthew McConaughey. Together, we discuss why 2000s magazine and advertising jobs made no logical sense, the $5.2 million real diamond necklace brought onto set, Gwyneth Paltrow originally being cast in the lead role, and why Toronto stands in for NYC in almost every movie. Plus, Alex drops a controversial hot take on When Harry Met Sally, calls out $35 tourist-trap pastrami sandwiches at Katz's Deli, and breaks down the creepiest 90s movie plots that would never get greenlit...

Comedian and presenter Matt Richardson joins the show to defend 1997's unhinged action extravaganza, Con Air. We break down why 90s blockbusters reign supreme over modern hyper-realism, how Nicolas Cage pulled off one of the most legendary runs in cinema history, and why action movies urgently need to bring back the "hat on a hat" philosophy.

⭐ Support the show on Patreon for:

Episodes 24 hours early
Ad Free
Bonus Content
Exclusive Polls and Updates

patreon.com/everyonesacriticpod

Support the show

Support the show on Patreon for:

Comedian Mary O'Connell joins the show to defend the misunderstood 2001 satire Josie and the Pussycats. Tune in as we break down how the movie flawlessly predicted modern algorithm-driven consumerism, discuss the insane alternate casting choices that left Beyoncé and Aaliyah on the cutting room floor, and explore how 73 companies got free product placement in the film.

Plus, we swap stories about Mary accidentally ending up on an OnlyFans reality show, debate the etiquette of proposing in the middle of Berghain, and hear her highly controversial take on why Paddington is a terrible movie.

Catch Mary l...

Comedian and actor Rosalie Minnitt joins the show to defend the 2003 Eddie Murphy family comedy Daddy Day Care. Tune in as we break down its 28% critic score versus its 49% audience score, discuss why the film perfectly encapsulates 2000s "millennial hope-core", swap chaotic stories about her dad catching a nine-hour addiction to a Mary-Kate and Ashley PlayStation 2 game, and explore her controversial take about Iron Man.

Support the show

Support the show on Patreon for:

Episodes 24 hours early
Ad Free
Bonus Content
Exclusive Polls and Updates

patreon.com/everyonesacriticpod<...

In the middle of a very busy schedule, actor and comedian Kiell Smith-Bynoe drops into the studio to defend the 2004 Tony Scott revenge thriller, Man on Fire. We break down the massive divide between the 39% Rotten Tomatoes critic score and the 89% audience score, debating whether the complaints about runtime and violence were justified. We analyze Denzel Washington's legendary performance, Dakota Fanning's prime child-actor era, and the dizzying, choppy camera work of early 2000s action cinema. Kiell also shares behind the scenes stories from the sets of Ghosts and Stath Lets Flats, including the brutal reality of filming the lockdown...

We are diving into the archives this week to bring back an absolute favorite classic episode of Everyone's a Critic!Comedian Emily Wilson stops by the studio to defend the 2011 Adam Sandler and Jennifer Aniston rom-com, Just Go With It. We break down why the critics were entirely wrong to give this film a 19% on Rotten Tomatoes, arguing that it is actually a sweet, character-driven comedy elevated by the incredible real-life chemistry of its leads. We dive deep into the bizarre but hilarious supporting cast, including Nicole Kidman playing a mean-spirited sorority bully, Dave Matthews playing a rude, wealthy...

Actor, comedian, and host of Crowd Control on Dropout, Jacquis Neal joins me to defend the year 2000 Martin Lawrence vehicle, Big Momma's House. We discuss why this broad comedy is vastly underappreciated and how it brilliantly parodies the classic matriarch character originating from the drama Soul Food. We dive into Martin Lawrence's legendary, trailblazing run in the 90s and 2000s, why critics were entirely wrong to slap this film with a 31% on Rotten Tomatoes, and why the suspension of disbelief required for Big Momma's House makes it a much better watch than White Chicks. We also touch upon the...

(Note: Apologies for the slight drop in audio quality this week! We had a corrupted file and had to pull the audio directly from the camera.)Comedian Ali Woods joins me to discuss M. Night Shyamalan's 2008 film, The Happening. We break down why the movie shouldn't be taken too seriously, but rather enjoyed as a highly entertaining 90-minute B-movie.We dive into the bizarre casting of Mark Wahlberg as a high school science teacher, the genuinely captivating first half of the film, and the complete absurdity of plants causing people to commit mass suicide. We also discuss Shyamalan's unique...

(Note: This is a special remastered release of an episode originally recorded in late 2020, available in video format for the very first time!)

Actor and comedian Adam Pally joins me to defend Ace Ventura: When Nature Calls. We discuss why this 1995 Jim Carrey vehicle is an underappreciated masterpiece of physical comedy, with Adam comparing it to Charlie Chaplin's City Lights. We dive into the film's relentless pacing and perfect 82-minute runtime, the unforgettable animatronic rhino birth scene, and the brilliant supporting performance from Tommy Davidson.

Along the way, we discuss Adam's experience working alongside Jim...

Comedian Rory Cargill joins me to defend Die Another Day. The final Pierce Brosnan James Bond film that pushed the 007 franchise to its most absurd limits.We discuss why Die Another Day acts as a fascinating time capsule right before the gritty Daniel Craig era, the bizarre creative choices from director Lee Tamahori, and whether its 55% Rotten Tomatoes score is truly justified. We dive deep into the movie's infamous moments, including the invisible car, Madonna's wildly divisive theme song, Toby Stephens' incredibly posh performance as Gustav Graves, and the shockingly bad CGI kite-surfing sequence. Along the way, we debate...

Comedian Eshaan Akbar joins me to defend Step Brothers. The Will Ferrell and John C. Reilly comedy that has gone from divisive release to modern comedy classic.We discuss why Step Brothers has become one of the most quotable comedies ever made, Will Ferrell's incredible run of films, Adam McKay's influence on modern comedy, and whether Hollywood has quietly stopped making big, original studio comedies like this. We also dive into the film's unforgettable supporting cast, iconic scenes, and why its absurd humour has only got better with age.Away from the movie, Eshaan talks about his stand-up career...

Comedy creator and Beatles expert Toby DB joins me to defend Yesterday. The Richard Curtis and Danny Boyle comedy that imagined a world where nobody remembers The Beatles except one man.

We discuss why Yesterday deserved a far warmer reception from critics, the surprisingly emotional central premise, Richard Curtis' unmistakable dialogue, and the incredible story behind the film's original screenplay, which was apparently much darker before becoming the crowd-pleasing rom-com audiences know today.Along the way we chat about The Beatles' legacy, Danny Boyle's direction, bizarre casting what-ifs, the film's impressive supporting cast, forgotten 2010...

Comedy legend Demi Adejuyigbe joins me to defend Space Jam.We get into why the original Space Jam remains one of the most beloved sports movies of the 90s, why Space Jam: A New Legacy completely misses the point, and what makes the original such a perfect crowd-pleaser decades later. Along the way we discuss Michael Jordan, Bill Murray, Looney Tunes chaos, basketball movies, nostalgia, Ready Player One, and why modern studios still don't understand what audiences actually want from family films.We also talk about Demi's incredible career, from the beloved Punch Up The Jam podcast to his...

Comedian Daman Bamrah joins me to defend Rush Hour 2. The wildly entertaining sequel starring two men who have both become… complicated conversation topics. We jokingly get into the long list of problematic people involved, our nostalgia for the golden era of mid-budget action comedies, and how surreal it is now working alongside comedy icons we grew up watching as kids.📺 Watch the extended video & 80+ more episodes on Patreon:https://patreon.com/everyonesacriticpod🎧 Listen free on all podcast platforms:https://tr.ee/Uqvau4XrN4👤 This episode’s guest:Follow Daman Bamrah –  @damanbamrah  🔥 More episodes you’ll enjoy:Eternals w/ Shabaz Says → https://youtu.b...

Joining me today to defend the spoof comedy Superhero Movie is comedy superstar Finlay Christie. We take a deep dive into the world of spoof movies, why they disappeared for so long and what makes this one stand out. We also discuss the insane movies Finlay originally tried to pick, and bond over our times living in Asia. This episode was recorded around 6 months ago right before the birth of my child and only now have I started to get some time to edit, but I'm back weekly from now on and can only apologise for the disappearance but...

TikTok and Instagram star Ella Wills joins me to defend the squeaky legends themselves, Alvin and the Chipmunks. We dive into the wild world of talking rodents, the insane casting choices that almost happened, and Ella ranks the entire Chipmunks cinematic universe with shocking precision. Plus, we get into her viral sketches, creative process, and what it’s like to have a comedy career that’s already reached amazing heights at just 22.📺 Watch the extended video & 80+ more episodes on Patreon:https://patreon.com/everyonesacriticpod🎧 Listen free on all podcast platforms:https://tr.ee/Uqvau4XrN4👤 This episode’s guest:Follow Ella Wil...

Is Fast & Furious: Tokyo Drift secretly the best movie in the franchise? Comedian Shalaka Kurup thinks so, and she’s here to defend it.We talk about the Fast & Furious legacy, Vin Diesel’s surprising love of Dungeons & Dragons, and the wild DVD boxsets we all bought growing up. If you’ve ever had a heated debate over Dom, Han, or drifting in Shibuya, this one’s for you.📺 Watch the extended video & 80+ more episodes on Patreon:https://patreon.com/everyonesacriticpod🎧 Listen free on all podcast platforms:https://tr.ee/Uqvau4XrN4👤 This episode’s guest:Follow Shalaka Kurup – @shalakakurup🔥 More ep...

Jake Bhardwaj joins Yiannis Cove to defend Jumanji (1995) — the Robin Williams classic full of jungle chaos, giant bugs, and board game nightmares. We dive into childhood nostalgia, the film’s surprisingly dark themes, and whether it still holds up nearly 30 years later.📺 Watch the extended video & 80+ more episodes on Patreon: everyonesacriticpod🎧 Listen free on all podcast platforms:https://tr.ee/Uqvau4XrN4👤 This episode’s guest:Follow Jake Bhardwaj – @jakebhardwajtv📢 Stay connectedInstagram: @yianniscove/@allcriticspodTikTok: @yianniscoveTwitter: @ycoveLetterboxd: https://letterboxd.com/everyonecritic/

Support the show

Support the show on Patreon for:

Episodes 24 hours early
Ad Free
Bonus Co...

Joining me this week on Everyone’s a Critic is comedian Samira Banks. She comes on to defend what is now the sixth Adam Sandler film for the podcast - Click.

We talk her brief history with the movie, the problematic moments that probably don't hold up anymore, and the time Adam Sandler played basketball with a group of comedians in London.

Get full video episodes with 30 minutes extra content, early access, and extra episodes — plus a shoutout as Executive Producer — by joining the Founding Members Tier on Patreon. Only 5 more spots at £3/month!

https...

This week on Everyone’s a Critic I'm joined by social media superstar, Povvo Gang leader, and all around funnyman Shabaz Says.

We get into Marvel’s Eternals, talk about the MCU as a whole, the highs and lows of going viral, and what it really means to represent your community in the middle of internet chaos.

Get full video episodes with 30 minutes extra content, early access, and extra episodes — plus a shoutout as Executive Producer — by joining the Founding Members Tier on Patreon. Only 5 more spots at £3/month!

50% off the highest tier with code...

In this re-mastered and never before released video episode I'm joined by recent Edinburgh Fringe best newcomer nominee Molly McGuinness to talk about what is maybe Mike Myers worst movie - The Cat In The Hat. We talk about Molly's love of it and have a very special call from Steven Anthony Lawrence, AKA Beans from Even Stevens, who talks about his time filming this.

Get video episodes, early access, and bonus content — plus a shoutout as Executive Producer — by joining the Founding Members Tier on Patreon. Only 10 spots at £3/month! https://www.patreon.com/e...

Recorded live at Vault Fest last year, comedian Lorna Rose Treen (BBC Radio 4, Chortle Best Newcomer, Dave Joke of the Fringe 2023) joined me on stage to defend the spoof comedy Epic Movie. She talked about first kisses, her hometown, and Nacho Libre!

Note: Apologies as the audio on this episode is not the greatest because they didn't have a place to plug in my recorder and I wasn't informed until I was going on stage, however I've done my best to make it as clear as possible for everyone. We will be back to crystal clear...

Milo Edwards (Trashfuture, Glue Factory) joins me this week to make the case for Gone In 60 Seconds. We talk about what makes car guys tick, compare it to The Fast and The Furious, and celebrate Nicolas Cage’s wonderfully unhinged performance.

Get video episodes, early access, and bonus content — plus a shoutout as Executive Producer — by joining the Founding Members Tier on Patreon. Only 10 spots at £3/month!

https://www.patreon.com/everyonesacriticpod

Support the show

Support the show on Patreon for:

Episodes 24 hours early
Ad Free
Bonus Content...

The Mummy Returns is famous for its bad CGI, the beginning of The Rock's acting career, and basically nothing else.Joining me to defend the movie is comedian Daniel McKeon. We talk Venom, Harry Potter, and unnecessary sequels made decades later.Enjoying the show?

Get video episodes, early access, and bonus content — plus a shoutout as Executive Producer — by joining the Founding Members Tier on Patreon. Only 10 spots at £3/month!

https://www.patreon.com/everyonesacriticpod

Support the show

Support the show on Patreon for:

Episodes 24 hours early
Ad Free<...

Most people forgot Dirty Dancing: Havana Nights existed — but Pravanya Pillay is here to convince you it’s an underrated gem. We talk about the genuinely great dance sequences, Patrick Swayze’s random cameo (is he a ghost?!), and the unexpectedly spicy politics in this film.Enjoying the show?Get video episodes, early access, and bonus content — plus a shoutout as Executive Producer — by joining the Founding Members Tier on Patreon.Only 10 spots at £5/month!https://www.patreon.com/everyonesacriticpod

Support the show

Support the show on Patreon for:

Episodes 24 hours early
Ad Free

Often described as one of the worst comedies ever made, Jack and Jill has become a punchline of its own. But is there more to it than people remember? Martin Urbano (Jimmy Kimmel Live, Comedy Central) joins me to revisit Adam Sandler’s double role disaster. We talk Al Pacino’s genuinely great performance, the deeply questionable cameos, and why Jack might actually be the real problem.

NOTE: This episode was recorded at the beginning of last year so any reference to release dates is no longer relevant.

Enjoying the show?Get video episodes, earl...

Widely considered to be the worst video game movie ever made, does it truly deserve its reputation? Ken Cheng joins me to discuss Super Mario Bros. We talk the wild lore behind the making of the movie, our favourite video games, and the struggles of translating games to screen.

Support the show

Support the show on Patreon for:

Episodes 24 hours early
Ad Free
Bonus Content
Exclusive Polls and Updates

patreon.com/everyonesacriticpod

Stating that it was his "patriotic duty", Joe Mande joins me to defend the 80s classic Rocky IV. We discuss the endless montages, the unnecessary addition of a robot, and Joe's career in comedy.

Support the show

Support the show on Patreon for:

Episodes 24 hours early
Ad Free
Bonus Content
Exclusive Polls and Updates

patreon.com/everyonesacriticpod

It's the return of the stoner comedy as Sharlin Jahan joins me to defend Dude Where's My Car, a cult classic from the early 00s. We discuss whether it still holds up, whether a sequel should have been made, and why Sharlin was late.

Support the show

Support the show on Patreon for:

Episodes 24 hours early
Ad Free
Bonus Content
Exclusive Polls and Updates

patreon.com/everyonesacriticpod

In an episode that was recorded nearly a year ago (my bad), Carla Gordon joins me to defend the movie A Dog's Purpose. We talk of our love for all things dog related, Carla's hate of Mark Ruffalo, and whether we are more mouse or or rat faced.

Support the show

Support the show on Patreon for:

Episodes 24 hours early
Ad Free
Bonus Content
Exclusive Polls and Updates

patreon.com/everyonesacriticpod

We're back for season 4! Somehow Adam Sandler and Jennifer Aniston took until 2011 to work together - though some would say it was for the best! Emily Wilson joins me to defend Just Go With It, the first of 3 collaborations between the comedy actors. We talk our favourite Sandler movies, Emily's incredible show Fixed, and play a new game for the first time on the podcast.

Support the show

Support the show on Patreon for:

Episodes 24 hours early
Ad Free
Bonus Content
Exclusive Polls and Updates

patreon.com/everyonesacriticpod<...

Pearl Harbor is basically Michael Bay does Titanic, which works about as well as it sounds. Sarah Roberts disagrees and joins me to defend it. We talk the love triangle, overly long action sequence, and Sarah's regular watches during her school lunches.

Support the show

Support the show on Patreon for:

Episodes 24 hours early
Ad Free
Bonus Content
Exclusive Polls and Updates

patreon.com/everyonesacriticpod

A film that Mike Myers was contractually obliged to star in is never a good sign. Molly McGuinness disagrees and joins me to defend The Cat in the Hat. We talk the set design, behind the scenes lore, and a very special guest calls in!

Support the show

Support the show on Patreon for:

Episodes 24 hours early
Ad Free
Bonus Content
Exclusive Polls and Updates

patreon.com/everyonesacriticpod

Steve Martin is arguably one of the funniest people of all time, so surely he's perfect for a remake of The Pink Panther? Leo Reich joins me to tell me why he thinks so, and we discuss the awful accents, hilarious lore, and of course... Beyonce.

Support the show

Support the show on Patreon for:

Episodes 24 hours early
Ad Free
Bonus Content
Exclusive Polls and Updates

patreon.com/everyonesacriticpod

Despite now being seen as a staple of modern horror, evidently Final Destination wasn't well received on release. Maddie Campion joins me to discuss why it's a classic, the amazing death scenes, and the peak 00s cast.

Support the show

Support the show on Patreon for:

Episodes 24 hours early
Ad Free
Bonus Content
Exclusive Polls and Updates

patreon.com/everyonesacriticpod

When news that the creators of The Matrix were making a new original sci-fi movie, expectations were high, and then came Jupiter Ascending. Nic Sampson joins me to discuss gravity boots, Channing Tatum as a human/dog hybrid, and what it's really like shooting on green screen.

Support the show

Support the show on Patreon for:

Episodes 24 hours early
Ad Free
Bonus Content
Exclusive Polls and Updates

patreon.com/everyonesacriticpod

In the late 00s there was a boom of vampire content, from True Blood, to Twilight, and then in 2014 Vampire Academy came around right as the trend was dying. Zoë Paskett joins me to discuss the stacked cast and bizarre tone.

Support the show

Support the show on Patreon for:

Episodes 24 hours early
Ad Free
Bonus Content
Exclusive Polls and Updates

patreon.com/everyonesacriticpod

For what is surprisingly Adam Sandler's first sequel, Lucy Watson joins me to talk about why it's actually a misunderstood hilarious comedy. We discuss the truly huge cast, our love for Shaq, and try to decipher what the plot is!

Support the show

Support the show on Patreon for:

Episodes 24 hours early
Ad Free
Bonus Content
Exclusive Polls and Updates

patreon.com/everyonesacriticpod

Can a teen movie that copies every trope actually be good? Hannah Fairweather joins me to defend John Tucker Must Die. We talk about her taste in what she calls "trash", the ridiculous cast ages, and our love of teen movies and shows.

Support the show

Support the show on Patreon for:

Episodes 24 hours early
Ad Free
Bonus Content
Exclusive Polls and Updates

patreon.com/everyonesacriticpod

A live action version of a beloved cartoon classic, starring the biggest stars of the time - where did it go wrong? Li Sa Choo joins me to defend Scooby Doo. We talk the amazing casting choices, the terrible CGI, and reminisce about the music of the time!

Support the show

Support the show on Patreon for:

Episodes 24 hours early
Ad Free
Bonus Content
Exclusive Polls and Updates

patreon.com/everyonesacriticpod