Talk Gruesome To Me
The Talk Gruesome To Me podcast is where true crime, paranormal, and horror enthusiasts Amy and Dawn dig into movies and shows that make you say, "I’m not sleeping tonight." Because really, who doesn't like a little murder and mayhem? Follow us on all the socials at Talk Gruesome To Me… we promise, it’s not as creepy as it sounds. (Okay, maybe it is.) You can show your support by subscribing and by shopping our merch here (link is under contributors): https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep57: Minisode: Eric Freeman Sims Part 2
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy, Dawn, and special guest Eric Freeman Sims as they wrap up with Part 2 exploring the history, mysteries, and stories behind the Knight House, KY and Goblincon.
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep56: Minisode: Eric Freeman Sims Part 1
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy, Dawn, and special guest Eric Freeman Sims as they kick off Part 1 exploring the history, mysteries, and stories behind the Knight House, Goblincon and Kentucky
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep55: True Crime: The Fox Hollow Murders
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy and Dawn for the final installment of their three-part series as they continue their discussion of Herb Baumeister and the Fox Hollow Farm murders
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep54: Minisode: Mariah and Keijuan
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy & Dawn as they discuss the unsolved murders of 20-year-olds Mariah Strother and Keijuan Baker, who were shot and killed outside an Evansville, Indiana gas station
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep53: Paranormal: Herb Baumeister
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy & Dawn as they take a closer look at Fox Hollow Farm, the former home of serial killer Herb Baumeister. They’ll discuss a couple of paranormal investigations that have attempted to determine whether spirits still remain on the property.
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep52: Minisode: Guest Barbie From New Binge and Nightsong P2
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy & Dawn for part 2 of a fun convo with Barbie from New Binge and NightSong as they dive into music, ghosts, true crime, movies and all kinds of random fun
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep51: Minisode: Guest Barbie From New Binge and Nightsong P1
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy & Dawn for part 1 of a fun convo with Barbie from New Binge and Nightsong as they dive into music, ghosts, true crime, movies and all kinds of random fun
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep50: True Crime: Herbert Baumeister and the Fox Hollow Farm Cover-up
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy and Dawn as they kick off a chilling new trio series with Herbert Baumeister and the Fox Hollow Farm Cover-Up - diving into one of the most disturbing cases and the secrets that refuse to stay buried
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep49: Minisode: Tennessee Part 2
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy and Dawn as they dive into their two-week adventure together in Tennessee with ghost hunts, haunted mansions, and antique lamp purchases. There’s too much to cover…so this is part two!
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep48: Minisode: Tennessee Part 1
Send us Fan Mail
Surprise! Join Amy and Dawn as they dive into their two-week adventure together in Tennessee with ghost hunts, haunted mansions, and antique lamp purchases. There’s too much to cover…so this is part one!
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep47: Minisode: Grounded, Guarded, and Ready
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy & Dawn as they break down paranormal safety: protecting yourself and your home, and how to safely open and close investigations
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep46: Horror: Monster
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy & Dawn as they explore the real story of Aileen Wuornos and discuss how her life and crimes were portrayed in the acclaimed movie Monster
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep45: Minisode: What Happened After the Episode, Cases Revisited
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy & Dawn as they revisit some of the cases they’ve previously covered and break down the latest updates on where those cases stand today
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep44: Paranormal: Sleeping in Serial Killers Motel Room Aileen Wuornos
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy & Dawn as they chat about the documentary Sleeping in a Serial Killer’s Haunted Motel Room: Aileen Wuornos, where true crime meets the paranormal
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep43: Minisode: Real Life Intermission
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy & Dawn for a catch-up episode as they look back on the past couple of months and tease what’s coming next
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep42: True Crime: Aileen: Queen of the Serial Killers
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy & Dawn as they take a deep dive into Netflix’s Aileen: Queen of the Serial Killers, unpacking the disturbing case of Aileen Wuornos and the questions it leaves behind
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep41: Minisode: Anna Kepner
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy & Dawn as they take a closer look at the tragic and troubling cruise ship case of Anna Kepner, examining what happened and the questions that remain
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep40: Horror: Three on a Meathook
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy & Dawn as they revisit the 1970s horror movie Three on a Meathook and unravel the subtle, unsettling ties between the film and the real-life horrors of Ed Gein
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep39: Minisode: Jesse Mack Butler
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy & Dawn as they unpack the shocking and still-unfolding case of Jesse Mack Butler
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
EP38: Paranormal: Ed Gein: The Real Psycho
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy and Dawn as they dig into Ed Gein: The Real Psycho and then break down Dave Schrader’s interview with Cindy Kaza and Steve Shippy about investigating in Plainfield
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep37: Minisode: Jelani Day
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy & Dawn as they unravel the mystery of Jelani Day - the facts, the theories, and the questions that still demand answers
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep36: True Crime: Ed Gein (Documentary and Monsters)
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy and Dawn as they take a chilling deep dive into the twisted mind of Ed Gein, exploring the real-life horrors behind his crimes and how they’re revealed in the doc Unseen Confessions: The Real-Life Psycho and the show Monsters
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep35: True Crime: Autumn & Martez
Send us Fan Mail
Amy and Dawn dive into the unsolved case of 21 year old Autumn Seelye and 28 year old Martez McAtee in Louisville, KY. Despite witnesses and community outcry, their murders remain unsolved and the questions only grow.
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep34: True Crime: Marissa Carmichael
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy & Dawn as they take a deep dive into the disappearance of Marissa Carmichael, unpacking the key details, timelines and unanswered questions surrounding her case
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep33: Horror: The Amityville Horror
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy and Dawn as they unlock the front door to terror (again) and compare the original The Amityville Horror with its remake, because nothing says ‘fun’ like haunted real estate!
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep32: Minisode: Menendez Brothers
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy & Dawn as they unravel the twists and turns of the Menendez brothers case, starting with the shocking events of 1989 and following the story all the way to today.
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep31: Paranormal: Amityville
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy and Dawn as they dive headfirst into the madness of the infamous Amityville house with ghosts, demons, bad vibes, and maybe a possessed lamp or two 👻💡
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep30: Minisode: Bryan Kohberger
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy and Dawn as they break down the case, the timeline, and the disturbing details behind the headlines of this case. In the quiet college town of Moscow, Idaho, four students were brutally murdered, and all eyes turned to Bryan Kohberger.
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep:29: Minisode: Temp New Release Schedule
Send us Fan Mail
Hang out with Amy and Dawn as they spill the beans on a little shake-up to the podcast schedule, but don’t panic, it’s just a short detour!
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep28: True Crime: Amityville Horror Documentary
Send us Fan Mail
Grab your holy water and join Amy and Dawn as they dive into the hype, twisted tales, and totally questionable 'true story' behind the infamous Amityville house!
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep27: Minisode: Dorothy Stratten
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy and Dawn as they chat about the dark and haunting story of Dorothy Stratten, the Playboy Bunny whose promising future ended in shocking tragedy.
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep26: Horror: The Telling
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy and Dawn as they dive into The Telling - a horror movie filmed at the Playboy Mansion, starring none other than Holly and Bridget. Scary? Maybe. Campy? Definitely.
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep25: Minisode: The Skelton Brothers
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy and Dawn as they delve into the mysterious disappearance of the Skelton brothers - three young boys who vanished without a trace in Michigan in 2010 and haven’t been seen since.
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep24: Paranormal: Ghosts of the Playboy Mansion
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy and Dawn as they spill the tea on the Playboy Mansion — from the history to the spooky possibility that it's not just Hef’s legacy haunting the halls!
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep23: Minisode: Podcast Update
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy and Dawn as they spill the tea on where the podcast is headed — now that they're 20+ episodes deep, slightly wiser, and only moderately more professional.
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep22: True Crime: The Playboy Murders
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy and Dawn as they dive headfirst (and heels first) into The Playboy Murders — serving true crime with a side of sass, as they dish on cases featured in the show. Trust us, these stories have more twists than a soap opera in stilettos.
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep21: Minisode: You're Dead, What's Next?
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy and Dawn as they dive into the delightfully morbid world of death, funerals, and what they want done with their meat suits once they’ve ghosted this mortal space.
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep20: Horror: The Autopsy of Jane Doe
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy and Dawn for a deep dive into “The Autopsy of Jane Doe”, where they don’t just give their opinions—they drag Evan and Shannon into the mix for a full-on rating showdown! Tune in as they unravel their theories about the movie. Spoiler: You’ll probably disagree, but that’s part of the fun! Come for the creepy autopsy talk, stay for the laughs (and possibly some wild guesses).
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep19: Minisode: Cleansing Convo
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy and Dawn as they give every possible disclaimer in this episode, all while diving into the wild world of cleansing your house of bad energy (and, you know, maybe a spirit or two). Ghosts, good vibes, and disclaimers—oh my!
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
Ep18: Paranormal: Sleeper Mortuary With Guest Tory
Send us Fan Mail
Join Amy and Dawn as they sit down with their guest Tory, the owner of Sleeper Mortuary! They dive into all things eerie – from creepy paranormal activity and spine-chilling investigations to the mysterious world of haunted objects and, of course, death. Prepare for a conversation that's equal parts entertaining and deep – it's the ultimate dead time chat!
Support the show
https://talkgruesometome.square.site/
