iCritic LIVE

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode of iCritic LIVE, we are joined by renowned animation journalist, critic, historian, and publisher Amid Amidi for an in-depth conversation spanning animation history, criticism, and industry trends.

As the co-founder and former publisher/editor-in-chief of Cartoon Brew (2004–2025) and creator of Animation Blast, Amid has spent over two decades serving as a central catalyst for modern animation scholarship and journalism. In this episode, we dive into:

Ward Kimball & Disney History: A sneak peek into Amid’s upcoming biographical study on Ward Kimball—one of Disney’s legendary "Nine Old...

Send us Fan Mail

Part 2 picks up exactly where the first deep dive left off — moving beyond the headline‑level breakdown of the Paramount settlement and into the structural, financial, and strategic consequences that are already reshaping the industry. In this episode of iCritic LIVE, Kevin unpacks the ripple effects across licensing, distribution, streaming partnerships, and long‑term corporate positioning, revealing how this settlement is influencing decisions far outside Paramount’s own walls.

We explore how the agreement is affecting deal‑making, why certain divisions stand to gain or lose, and how the settlement...

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode of iCritic LIVE, Kevin breaks down the full scope of the Paramount settlement — what triggered it, what was actually agreed upon, and how the fallout is reshaping the entertainment landscape. This isn’t just a headline recap; it’s a deep, structured exploration of the legal, financial, and industry‑wide implications that studios, creators, and audiences will be feeling for years.

We walk through the timeline of events, the pressure points that led to the settlement, and the strategic motivations behind Paramount’s decisions. Then we dig into w...

Send us Fan Mail

Anime retail has undergone one of its biggest shake‑ups in decades — and tonight, we’re breaking it all down. In this episode of iCritic LIVE, Kevin sits down with industry veteran Justin Sevakis to unpack Crunchyroll’s controversial consolidation of anime retail, the disappearance of Right Stuf, and what this shift means for collectors, distributors, and the future of physical media.

We explore how paywalls, platform control, and corporate restructuring have reshaped the buying experience for fans, why the loss of independent retailers matters, and how these changes ripple across licensin...

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, we unpack the controversy surrounding a bold statement from Square Enix’s former president, who recently labeled PlayStation 5 physical media collectors as “narcissists.” What did he mean by that—and is there any truth behind the claim?

Join us as we explore the tension between digital convenience and the pride of physical ownership, the psychology of collecting, and how this debate reflects broader shifts in gaming culture. We’ll also look at how fans and industry insiders reacted, and what this says about the future of physical releases in a strea...

Send us Fan Mail

Why did Avatar: Aang The Last Airbender—a high‑profile expansion of one of Nickelodeon’s most valuable franchises—quietly bypass theaters and broadcast in favor of a straight drop onto Paramount+? In this episode, we cut through the hype, nostalgia, and corporate PR to unpack the actual, decidedly unglamorous business logic behind the decision.

From shifting subscriber targets to internal cost‑recovery math, from licensing constraints to the cold reality of modern kids’ content performance, we break down how a franchise with massive cultural weight ended up serving a far more practic...

Send us Fan Mail

Sony’s anime empire might be facing a crossroads — and PlayStation fans could be next in line to feel the impact. In this episode of iCritic LIVE, Kevin T. Rodriguez unpacks the growing controversy surrounding Crunchyroll’s business decisions, from subscription changes to licensing shake-ups, and how they could signal a broader shift in Sony’s entertainment strategy. What does this mean for PlayStation’s ecosystem, cross-media integration, and the future of anime streaming? Kevin connects the dots between corporate synergy and fan backlash, offering a sharp, collector-minded perspective on why this story matters fa...

Send us Fan Mail

Sony’s latest business decisions have sent shockwaves through collectors and gamers alike — but is Grand Theft Auto VI the real culprit behind the death of discs? In this episode of iCritic LIVE, Kevin T. Rodriguez dives deep into how Rockstar’s digital-first juggernaut may have accelerated Sony’s retreat from physical media. From the economics of digital distribution to the cultural loss of tangible ownership, this discussion explores what happens when convenience overtakes collectibility. Expect sharp analysis, industry insight, and a passionate defense of the video game shelf as Kevin breaks down why this...

Send us Fan Mail

This week, The New York Times dropped a bombshell story about Netflix’s new film chief, Dan Lin, and the internal chaos surrounding his leadership. What was meant to be a fresh era of creative collaboration has instead turned into a public relations nightmare — one that’s shaking Hollywood’s confidence in the streamer’s talent relations.

In this episode of iCritic LIVE, we break down:

Send us Fan Mail

For years, film lovers have been waiting for the lights to come back on at the legendary Cinerama Dome. Closed since the start of the pandemic, the Dome has become a symbol of both Hollywood nostalgia and the uncertain future of theatrical exhibition. One passionate fan launched a grassroots campaign to save it—rallying supporters, raising awareness, and pushing for answers.

But in a twist no one saw coming, the campaign has been abruptly halted after the theater’s owners filed a police report, claiming the fan’s efforts amounted to harass...

Send us Fan Mail

The Super Mario Galaxy Movie has become the latest battleground in the never‑ending war between film critics and passionate fandoms. Critics—myself included—have been largely unimpressed with the film’s storytelling, pacing, and creative choices. Fans, on the other hand, have embraced it wholeheartedly, defending it with the kind of intensity usually reserved for console wars and championship games.

In this episode of iCritic LIVE, we dig into why this divide has become so heated, why some fans believe critics are “out of touch,” and how online discourse ha...

Send us Fan Mail

Netflix once treated theaters like an afterthought—but in 2026, the story is more complicated. In this episode of iCritic LIVE, Kevin breaks down the streamer’s latest moves: from investing in theatrical comedies to promising 45-day windows for premium VOD, and even experimenting with IMAX releases for select titles. Is this a genuine pivot toward theatrical respect, or just strategic optics after the Warner Bros acquisition?

We’ll explore:
- Netflix’s 2026 film strategy and why it’s betting on originals over sequels  
- The implications of its failed Warner Bros...

Send us Fan Mail

🎬 What this livestream is all about  
I’m teaming up with Rachel’s Reviews for a full, category‑by‑category breakdown of the 2025 Academy Awards—but with a twist. Instead of predicting what the Oscars will do, we’re deciding what the Oscars *should* do. Expect passionate debates, surprising agreements, and a few “how did the Academy miss this?” moments along the way.

🏆 Categories we’ll be tackling  
- Best Picture  
- Best Director  
- Acting categories (with plenty of strong opinions)  
- Screenplay races  
- Animation,
- Best Song

Send us Fan Mail

 This episode digs into the uncomfortable truth behind Pixar’s newest film: Hopper was never a candidate for hand‑drawn animation—not because the story demanded 3D, but because Disney and Pixar no longer have the infrastructure, workforce, or corporate will to make a 2D feature at all. What looks like a creative choice is really the result of two decades of strategic decisions that hollowed out Disney’s once‑legendary hand‑drawn pipeline.

We explore how Disney’s leadership gradually dismantled its 2D departments, why the studio let go of nearly all of i...

Send us Fan Mail

As Demon Slayer: Infinity Castle opened to massive box office and critical fan reaction, fans wondered whether this could break into the Oscars. But the reality is far simpler—and far less dramatic. The Academy was never going to nominate a movie that functions as a direct, late‑series continuation of an ongoing storyline.

In this episode of iCritic LIVE, Kevin unpacks why Infinity Castle, despite its scale, spectacle, and emotional weight, is fundamentally built for viewers already deep into the Demon Slayer narrative. For Oscar voters who...

Send us Fan Mail

We’re kicking off the new year with a special live episode! 🎉 Join us as we look back on last year’s highlights, talk about what’s next for the podcast, and unveil some exciting updates—yes, including our brand-new website! We’ll chat about upcoming content, community plans, and how you can get involved in shaping what’s ahead.

It’s a casual, interactive hangout to celebrate a fresh start and share our vision for the year ahead. Grab your favorite drink, join the live chat, and let’s ring in the new year tog...

Send us Fan Mail

In this explosive episode of iCritic LIVE, we tackle the shocking news: Netflix is set to buy Warner Bros. Discovery. What does this mean for Hollywood, streaming dominance, and the future of movie theaters? Are theaters doomed—or is there still hope for the big screen experience? Join us as we break down the deal, the industry shake-up, and what it means for audiences everywhere.

Support the show

►Want a question answered on iCritic Live? Send a question here and we'll answer it (if it's a reasonable question): https://stre...

Send us Fan Mail

Dive into the controversial new documentary God & Country in this episode of Discussing the Donald Trump Documentary Christians Don’t Want You to See. With guest co-host Pat Kahnke, we unpack how faith, politics, and power collide in America, exploring why this film challenges narratives some would rather keep hidden. Expect sharp insights, candid conversation, and a deeper look at the intersection of religion and democracy.

Support the show

►Want a question answered on iCritic Live? Send a question here and we'll answer it (if it's a reasonable question): http...

Send us Fan Mail

Draco. Hermione. Abuse as romance. Alchemised didn’t just spark controversy — it invited it. On this episode of iCritic LIVE, we unpack how a toxic ship became a publishing spectacle, why fandom backlash was inevitable, and what it says about the line between fantasy and harm.

Support the show

►Want a question answered on iCritic Live? Send a question here and we'll answer it (if it's a reasonable question): https://streamelements.com/kevintrod/tip

►Get free money just from buying gas!  Download GetUpside to start making an...

Send us Fan Mail

Xbox is making moves—but are they the right ones? In this episode of iCritic LIVE, Kevin breaks down the latest shifts in Microsoft’s gaming strategy, from studio acquisitions and Game Pass evolution to the uncertain fate of physical media and platform exclusivity. It’s not all green lights: we’ll explore the risks, the promises, and why cautious optimism might be the most honest stance right now. Whether you're a lifelong Xbox fan or a skeptical observer, this is the deep dive you didn’t know you needed.

Support the show<...

Send us Fan Mail

🎙️ Is Taylor Swift’s fan devotion a heartfelt connection—or a billion-dollar strategy? In this episode, we unpack the calculated brilliance behind Swift’s empire, from surprise drops to merch rollouts, and ask whether her relationship with fans is more transactional than emotional.

💸 Why does every Swiftie era feel like a marketing masterclass?
 🎤 How does Taylor balance authenticity with empire-building?
 📈 And what does this say about pop stardom in the age of parasocial profit?

Tune in for a sharp, unapologetic look at the business behind the fandom.

Support the show<...

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode of iCritic LIVE, we dive into the surprising reversal by Sinclair Broadcast Group, which has decided to bring Jimmy Kimmel back to its affiliate lineup after previously sidelining the late-night host. What changed—and what does this say about the shifting dynamics between content, controversy, and corporate strategy? We unpack the behind-the-scenes pressures that led to the cave-in, explore Kimmel’s enduring appeal, and examine how this move fits into Sinclair’s broader media posture.

But the story doesn’t end there. Nexstar, another major player in the local TV...

Send us Fan Mail

Charlie Kirk died. Despite not liking the man, his death has been weighing on me.

Support the show

►Want a question answered on iCritic Live? Send a question here and we'll answer it (if it's a reasonable question): https://streamelements.com/kevintrod/tip

►Get free money just from buying gas!  Download GetUpside to start making an average of $50 a day: https://upside.app.link/5TMVT

►Want to invest in stocks commission-free?  Use Robinhood!  Sign up through this link to get a free stock: https://share.robinhood...

Send us Fan Mail

Netflix has officially dropped its first comprehensive guidelines for using generative AI in content production—and the timing couldn’t be more loaded. In this iCritic LIVE episode, we unpack the streaming giant’s attempt to balance innovation with ethics, union pressure, and audience trust.

From The Eternaut’s AI-generated VFX to the controversy surrounding What Jennifer Did, Netflix is no stranger to backlash. Now, with rules that prohibit replicating copyrighted material, replacing union-covered performances, or storing production data without consent, the company is trying to draw a line between “creative aid” and “...

Send us Fan Mail

Netflix just scored its first major box office win with KPop Demon Hunters—a surprise theatrical smash that grossed $18 million in just one weekend across 1,700 screens. But will the streaming giant treat this as a fluke, a fan-service stunt, or a blueprint for future releases?

In this episode, we dissect the cultural phenomenon behind KPop Demon Hunters, from its viral soundtrack and Billboard domination to the sold-out sing-along screenings that turned theaters into concert halls. We explore Netflix’s historically cautious approach to theatrical distribution and ask: Is this the moment they...

Send us Fan Mail

In this eyebrow-raising episode of iCritic LIVE, Kevin dives into the unexpected drama involving Emmy-winning animator Jorge R. Gutierrez—best known for The Book of Life, Maya and the Three, and El Tigre. What started as admiration turned into digital exile when Gutierrez hit the block button... but why?

Was it a misunderstood critique? A clash of creative philosophies? Or something far more bizarre? Kevin unpacks the timeline, the tweets, and the tangled web of creator dynamics that led to this surreal moment. Expect sharp analysis, a dash of hu...

Send us Fan Mail

The title says it all.

Support the show

►Want a question answered on iCritic Live? Send a question here and we'll answer it (if it's a reasonable question): https://streamelements.com/kevintrod/tip

►Get free money just from buying gas!  Download GetUpside to start making an average of $50 a day: https://upside.app.link/5TMVT

►Want to invest in stocks commission-free?  Use Robinhood!  Sign up through this link to get a free stock: https://share.robinhood.com/kevin1823

►PATREON: https://www.patreon.com/KevinTRod

Send us Fan Mail

🧤 Is the 2020s Fantastic Four film secretly brilliant... or just fantastically flawed? In this episode of iCritic LIVE, our panel of middle-aged cinephiles takes a nostalgic stroll back to the superhero origin that dared to predate the MCU boom. With decades of movie-watching wisdom and a dash of generational sass, the crew dissects The Fantastic Four: First Steps—exploring its cultural context, character dynamics, and that infamous rubbery Reed Richards stretch.

🔥 From comic purists to popcorn appreciators, expect sharp insights, hearty laughs, and a deep dive into how this film fit...

Send us Fan Mail

The gloves are off and the satire is on. In this charged episode of iCritic LIVE, Kevin breaks down the political chaos and cultural absurdity surrounding the Trump-inspired South Park storyline. Is it biting satire or bloated spectacle? A comedic masterpiece or a missed opportunity? We dig deep into the episode’s commentary, its character portrayals, and the wider ripple effects on pop culture.  

From media critiques to fan reactions, this isn’t just a takedown—or a defense. It’s a nuanced, no-holds-barred analysis of one of the most talk...

Send us Fan Mail

🔍 The sleuthing gets serious as (AKA: iCritic) examine the bold, if enigmatic, attempt to reintroduce Detective Conan to American audiences. From name changes and cultural localization to shifts in tone and marketing, this episode unpacks the strategy behind the soft reboot and questions whether the series truly found its footing stateside.

🎭 Expect critical analysis, franchise context, and a dash of nostalgia as we explore the challenges of adapting iconic anime for Western viewers. Was it misunderstood genius—or a mystery better left unsolved?

👉 Tune in to hear what worked...

Send us Fan Mail

In this fiery episode of iCritic LIVE, we dive deep into the branding bombshell dropped by TMS Entertainment: the retirement of the Case Closed name in English-speaking markets in favor of the original Detective Conan. What does this shift mean for the franchise’s global identity, and why now, after two decades of Case Closed branding?

Host Kevin peels back the layers—from marketing strategy and localization politics to fandom culture and the enduring legacy of Shinichi Kudo. Expect hot takes, historical context, and a few conspiracy theories for good...

Send us Fan Mail

Step into the forgotten pages of Disney history with iCritic LIVE! In this special episode, "Disney Classics the World Has Forgotten," we dive deep into the hidden gems and long-lost treasures of Disney’s vast catalog. From underrated animated films to theme park attractions lost to time, we’ll uncover the stories behind these forgotten classics and explore what made them so magical. 

Joined by pop culture expert The Girly Nerd, we bring nostalgia, insider knowledge, and a dash of Disney magic to the conversation. Whether you’re a casual fan or a di...

Send us Fan Mail

On this episode of iCritic LIVE, we sit down with the visionary behind MoviePass, founder and CEO Stacy Spikes, for an exclusive discussion about "Mogul by MoviePass." What is Mogul, and how is it set to revolutionize the film industry for independent creators and moviegoers alike? Join us as we delve into the origins of this innovative platform, its mission, and what it means for the future of entertainment. Don’t miss this inspiring conversation with one of the most influential figures in the world of cinema. Tune in now! 🎬🎙️

Subscrib...

Send us Fan Mail

The anime and gaming industries have always been at the forefront of digital innovation, but could Encore be the next game-changer in ecommerce? In this episode, we dive deep into how Encore is reshaping the way fans purchase their favorite anime collectibles and gaming merch. We’ll explore the platform’s unique approach to marketplace dynamics, user engagement, and whether it truly stands as the future of fandom-driven commerce. Is this the evolution we've been waiting for, or just another trend? 

Tune in and find out (and don't forget to like and s...

Send us Fan Mail

Hollywood has a long history of overlooking controversy when it comes to powerful directors. In this episode of iCritic LIVE, we dive into the ongoing debate surrounding filmmaker David O. Russell—a director known for acclaimed films but also allegations of troubling behavior. 

🔹 Why does the industry continue to work with him? 
🔹 What does this say about Hollywood’s standards? 
🔹 How do these decisions impact actors, crews, and audiences? 

Join us as we break down the facts, discuss the ethical dilemmas, and unpack the larger issue of accounta...

Send us Fan Mail

Disney’s latest theme park announcement has sparked controversy among LGBTQ+ fans. In this episode of iCritic LIVE, we dive into the backlash surrounding Disney’s decision to build a new resort in Abu Dhabi—a region where LGBTQ+ rights remain heavily restricted.

We’ll explore concerns about inclusivity, Disney’s past advocacy for LGBTQ+ representation, and whether this move contradicts the company’s stance on diversity. Is Disney prioritizing business over its values? What does this mean for LGBTQ+ travelers?

Join us for an in-depth discussion on the implications...

Send us Fan Mail

Xbox is raising prices, and gamers everywhere are feeling the impact. In this episode of iCritic LIVE, we’re diving deep into the latest price hikes—whether it’s Game Pass, consoles, or game costs—and discussing what it means for the future of gaming.  

Are these increases justified? Will they push gamers away? And most importantly—does this mean it's time to walk away from gaming altogether? We’ll break down the facts, share our frustrations, and explore whether there’s still a reason to stick around.  

Join the discussion...

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode of iCritic LIVE, we're tackling one of the hottest gaming debates circulating online—DreamcastGuy’s claim that Microsoft is “anti-gamer.” But is there any truth to it? Or is this just another take gone too far?  

Join us as we break down his arguments, examine Microsoft’s role in the gaming industry, and explain why this claim just doesn’t hold up. From Game Pass innovations to Xbox’s pro-consumer moves, we’ll explore the facts and challenge the narrative.  

Support the show

►Want a question...

Send us Fan Mail

🎙️ In this episode of iCritic LIVE, we dive into the gaming world's latest buzz: Has Nintendo unknowingly handed Xbox a victory with their game pricing strategy? 💰 With evolving competition and consumer expectations, how might this bold move reshape the landscape for fans of both platforms? Tune in as we break down the trends, reactions, and ripple effects across the industry. Whether you're Team Nintendo or Team Xbox—or just love gaming debates—this episode has something for everyone!

Support the show

►Want a question answered on iCritic Live? Send a q...

Send us Fan Mail

Join us for a special live episode of iCritic as we dive headfirst into the Crunchyroll Anime Awards! From jaw-dropping animation to unforgettable characters, we’re casting our votes in real time—debating the nominees, defending our favorites, and maybe throwing a little shade (in true anime fan fashion). Whether you're a casual watcher or a full-blown otaku, this is your front-row seat to the hottest takes and boldest picks of the season.  

🗳️ It’s anime. It’s awards. It’s iCritic LIVE.

Support the show

►Want a question answere...