Two for One

40 Episodes
Subscribe

By: David & Claire

Two Movies, One Story. David and Claire discuss the differences, merits, and faults of two (or more) films derived from the same source material.

✂️ Turn this podcast into clips
Plein Soleil (1960) / The Talented Mr. Ripley (1999)
Plein Soleil (1960) / The Talented Mr. Ripley (1999) episode artwork
#2
Yesterday at 10:02 PM

Source Material: Patricia Highsmith's novel The Talented Mr. Ripley, which introduced the murderous conman in 1955.


3:10 to Yuma (1957/2007)
3:10 to Yuma (1957/2007) episode artwork
#1
10/11/2026

Source Material: Elmore Leonard's 1953 short story about a regular man escorting a notorious outlaw to the train that will take him to prison.


Season 4 Recap: Two for One with David and Claire
Season 4 Recap: Two for One with David and Claire episode artwork
#4
09/12/2026

Recollections, recriminations, and retractions from the past year. What's up next?


Dune (1984/2021&2024)
Dune (1984/2021&2024) episode artwork
#10
09/05/2026

Source Material: Frank Herbert's 1965 science fiction epic Dune. The novel follows the fall of House Atreides and the rise of the teenage Paul Atreides as the messianic Lisan al-Gaib.


Fever Pitch (1997/2005)
Fever Pitch (1997/2005) episode artwork
#9
07/05/2026

Source Material: Arsenal superfan Nick Hornby's honest memoir of his ups and downs with the team.


The Parent Trap (1961/1998)
The Parent Trap (1961/1998) episode artwork
#8
06/07/2026

Source Material: Erich Kästner's Das doppelte Lottchen, about identical twin girls who are separated at birth and rediscover each other at a summer camp.


Suspiria (1977/2018)
Suspiria (1977/2018) episode artwork
#7
05/10/2026

Source Material: Thomas De Quincey's 1845 essay Suspiria de Profundis, loosely adapted for the screen by Dario Argento and Daria Nicolodi.


Special Episode: Clueless
Special Episode: Clueless episode artwork
04/04/2026

Somehow Claire and David missed 1995's Clueless growing up. How does director Amy Heckerling and star Alicia Silverstone's take on Jane Austen's Emma compare to more literal interpretations?


The Thomas Crown Affair (1968/1999)
#6
02/28/2026

Source Material: An original screenplay by Alan Trustman, following a millionaire who orchestrates a bank heist and the insurance investigator hired to track him down.


Mean Girls (2004/2024)
Mean Girls (2004/2024) episode artwork
#5
01/31/2026

Source Material: Rosalind Wiseman's non-fiction guide for parents, Queen Bees and Wannabes, adapted into a screenplay by comedian Tina Fey.


Little Women (1949/1994/2019)
Little Women (1949/1994/2019) episode artwork
#4
12/21/2025

Source Material: Louisa May Alcott's semi-autobiographical novel of four sisters growing into womanhood. First published in 1868, and here reimagined by three different eras of Hollywood.


Mutiny on the Bounty (1935/1962)
#3
11/30/2025

Source Material: The Charles Nordhoff and James Norman Hall novels about the disastrous voyage of an 18th century British warship. The novels were themselves based on the infamous real-world mutiny.


Dawn of the Dead (1978/2004)
Dawn of the Dead (1978/2004) episode artwork
#2
10/26/2025

Source Material: George Romero's screenplay for 1978's influential zombie movie Dawn of the Dead, the second installment in a franchise that began a decade prior with Night of the Living Dead.


High and Low (1963) / Highest 2 Lowest (2025)
High and Low (1963) / Highest 2 Lowest (2025) episode artwork
#1
09/06/2025

Source Material: The American novelist Evan Hunter's novel King's Ransom, though directors Akira Kurosawa and Spike Lee largely use the book as a starting point for their explorations of social problems.


Season 3 Recap: Two for One with David and Claire
Season 3 Recap: Two for One with David and Claire episode artwork
#11
08/16/2025

Another year, another 20+ movies for our heroic podcast hosts.


True Grit (1969/2010)
True Grit (1969/2010) episode artwork
#10
08/03/2025

Source Material: Charles Portis's 1968 novel, in which a young girl searches for a man with "true grit" to pursue her father's killer.


The Poseidon Adventure (1972) / Posideon (2006)
#9
07/13/2025

Source Material: Paul Gallico's 1969 novel. A group of passengers on an ocean liner struggles to reach safety after the ship is capsized by a massive wave.


My Best Friend's Wedding (1997) / La Boda de Mi Mejor Amigo (2019)
My Best Friend's Wedding (1997) / La Boda de Mi Mejor Amigo (2019) episode artwork
#8
06/21/2025

Source Material: Ronald Bass's original screenplay for the 1997 romantic comedy.


The Wages of Fear (1953) / Sorcerer (1977)
The Wages of Fear (1953) / Sorcerer (1977) episode artwork
#7
05/17/2025

Source Material: The 1950 Georges Arnaud novel, in which four men are hired to transport nitroglycerin to the site of an oil well fire.


Romeo and Juliet (1968) / Romeo + Juliet (1996)
Romeo and Juliet (1968) / Romeo + Juliet (1996) episode artwork
#6
03/15/2025

Source Material: William Shakespeare's renowned tragedy. Both films adhere closely to the Bard's text.


The Time Machine (1960/2002)
The Time Machine (1960/2002) episode artwork
#5
02/22/2025

Source Material: H. G. Wells' 1895 novella The Time Machine, a contemplation of humanity's future in a world of accelerating technological innovation and economic inequality.


The Shop Around the Corner (1940) / You've Got Mail (1998)
The Shop Around the Corner (1940) / You've Got Mail (1998) episode artwork
#4
12/22/2024

Source Material: Hungarian-born playwright Miklós László's Parfumerie, a tale of two coworkers who fall in love via the written word, despite not being able to stand each other in real life.


Freaky Friday (1976/2003)
Freaky Friday (1976/2003) episode artwork
#3
11/17/2024

Source Material: The 1973 body swapper by Mary Rodgers, who also wrote the screenplay for the 1976 adaptation.


The Big Sleep (1946/1978)
The Big Sleep (1946/1978) episode artwork
#2
11/17/2024

Source Material: Raymond Chandler's 1939 novel, in which detective Philip Marlowe investigates an apparently simple case of blackmail, but discovers a bottomless well of drugs, lies, sex, and murder.


The Thing from Another World (1951) / The Thing (1982)
The Thing from Another World (1951) / The Thing (1982) episode artwork
#1
10/13/2024

Source Material: John W. Campbell's novella Who Goes There?, adapted by Howard Hawks and Christian Nyby as a fifties monster movie and later remade more faithfully by horror icon John Carpenter.


Special Episode: The Best of Bond
Special Episode: The Best of Bond episode artwork
10/05/2024

Claire and David celebrate the ultimate accomplishment: finishing the entire James Bond anthology, from 1964's Dr. No through 2021's No Time to Die. Dust off your tux, mix yourself a Vesper, and get ready to discuss the ups and downs of the iconic 007.


Season 2 Recap: Two for One with David and Claire
Season 2 Recap: Two for One with David and Claire episode artwork
#11
07/06/2024

Once again, Claire and David reminisce on a year of movies and preview what's to come.


West Side Story (1961/2021)
West Side Story (1961/2021) episode artwork
#10
06/23/2024

Source Material: The Broadway musical, itself based on Shakespeare's romantic tragedy Romeo and Juliet.


That Darn Cat! (1965) / That Darn Cat (1997)
That Darn Cat! (1965) / That Darn Cat (1997) episode artwork
#9
05/25/2024

Source Material: Husband-and-wife duo The Gordons' novel Undercover Cat, in which a cat comes home from his evening prowl with a watch that might be evidence of a crime. The original adaptation is a comedy thriller; the remake is a zany, cartoonish Scooby Doo-style mystery.


The Italian Job (1969/2003)
The Italian Job (1969/2003) episode artwork
#8
04/21/2024

Source Material: The original Michael Caine caper, which some consider iconic. The 2003 remake, a loose reinterpretation, stars Marky Mark.


The Virgin Queen (1955) / Elizabeth: The Golden Age (2007)
The Virgin Queen (1955) / Elizabeth: The Golden Age (2007) episode artwork
#7
03/10/2024

Source Material: The reign of Elizabeth I of England, particularly her relationship with the explorer and privateer Walter Raleigh.


Seven Samurai (1954) / The Magnificent Seven (1960)
Seven Samurai (1954) / The Magnificent Seven (1960) episode artwork
#6
02/17/2024

Source Material: Akira Kurosawa's original samurai epic, remade just a few years later as a Hollywood western.


REC (2007) / Quarantine (2008)
REC (2007) / Quarantine (2008) episode artwork
#5
02/04/2024

Source Material: An original screenplay for the Spanish-language zombie horror movie, remade by Hollywood just a year later.


Scarface (1932/1983)
Scarface (1932/1983) episode artwork
#4
01/21/2024

Source Material: Armitage Trail's novel Scarface, loosely based on the life and crimes of Al Capone. Each film depicts the rise and fall of a first-generation American gangster who believes the world is his.


Special Episode: Predator and Prey
Special Episode: Predator and Prey episode artwork
12/16/2023

How does 2022's Prey stack up against the 1987 original? Explore the past, present, and future of the storied Predator franchise.


Midway (1976/2019)
Midway (1976/2019) episode artwork
#3
11/11/2023

Source Material: A key battle in the Pacific during World War II. Taking place in June 1942, the Battle of Midway was a significant victory for Allies forces.


The Secret Garden (1949/1993/2020)
The Secret Garden (1949/1993/2020) episode artwork
#2
08/27/2023

Source Material: Frances Hodgson Burnett's children's classic The Secret Garden, in which young Mary Lennox moves into her uncle's house and starts uncovering long-buried family secrets.


Thunderball (1965) / Never Say Never Again (1983)
Thunderball (1965) / Never Say Never Again (1983) episode artwork
#1
08/06/2023

Source Material: Ian Fleming's screenplay-turned-novel Thunderball, released in 1961.


Special Episode: Barbenheimer
Special Episode: Barbenheimer episode artwork
07/22/2023

Is Barbenheimer genuine hype or cynical marketing? Can the most anticipated movies of the summer even be compared? Is the strong nuclear force more powerful than Kenergy?


Special Episode: The Disney Remakes
Special Episode: The Disney Remakes episode artwork
07/22/2023

What's the deal with Disney remaking all their animated classics, and why doesn't Two 4 One cover them?