Wheel of Crime Podcast
Jenn and Em are here to share their crazy and terrifying stories in an interesting new style of podcast. Inspired from todays most beloved game shows they bring all kinds of fun to the table, and with their Wheel of Crime they will spin you into a new exciting adventure every Friday night. Welcome to the Wheel. Of. Crime!
3,096 Days Captive: Natascha Kampusch Survives
Send us Fan Mail
Today on the Wheel of Crime Podcast, Jenn and Em spin into a story of survival that shocked the world. When Natascha Kampusch was taken at just 10 years old, she vanished without a trace, beginning a nightmare that would last 3,096 days. Hidden away from the world, she endured years in captivity before making a brave and calculated escape that would finally bring her freedom.
Support the show
Who Killed Ötzi the Iceman? The World’s Oldest Cold Case
Send us Fan Mail
Deep in the Alps, a frozen body lay hidden beneath the ice for over 5,300 years... UNTIL hikers uncovered what would become one of the greatest archaeological discoveries in history. Em and Jenn discuss the ancient mummy, Ă–tzi the Iceman. From his weapons and tattoos to the arrow wound that may have killed him, the ladies uncover the chilling mystery behind the world’s oldest cold case.Â
Support the show
Love, Lies, and a Loaded Gun: Unraveling the Sandra Garner Case
Send us Fan Mail
A late night 911 call, a husband shot in his sleep, and a story that left more questions than answers. Jenn and Em dive into the haunting Sandra Garner case, where love, illness, family betrayal, and suspicious evidence collide. Was it a tragic home invasion or something far more unsettling?
Support the show
Secret Lives of Cryptid Wives: Skinwalker Ranch
Send us Fan Mail
What really happens behind the gates of Skinwalker Ranch? Jenn and Em dive into chilling Utah folklore and shocking secrets tied to one of America's most haunted locations in this spine tingling episode of Wheel of Crime.
Support the show
Douglas Garland Murders: A Canadian Family Vanishes Overnight
Send us Fan Mail
Today on the Wheel of Crime, Jenn and Em dive into the chilling case of Douglas Garland, the man behind one of Canada’s most disturbing family murders. What began as a missing persons case quickly unraveled into something far darker, a long-standing grudge turned sour. The ladies break down what happened to the Liknes family, the investigation that followed, and the questions that still loom.Â
Support the show
Borley Rectory: Most Haunted House in England (And We Hate It)
Send us Fan Mail
Today on Wheel of Crime, Em and Jenn explore Borley Rectory, long known as the most haunted house in England. Built in 1862, the location became infamous for chilling reports of ghostly nuns, phantom footsteps, and unexplained phenomena.Â
Support the show
Horror From Down Under: The Family Cult
Send us Fan Mail
Today on Wheel of Crime, Jenn and Em dive into The Family Cult, a disturbing Australian New Age group led by Anne Hamilton-Byrne. Claiming to be the reincarnation of Jesus, she built a secretive and controlling community that hid shocking abuse behind a spiritual facade.Â
Support the show
Cursed Chair of Thomas Busby: Sit Down and Die
Send us Fan Mail
Today on Wheel of Crime, Em and Jenn explore the chilling legend of a cursed chair from 1702. Before his execution, Thomas Busby allegedly cursed his favorite seat, claiming anyone who sat in it would soon die. The ladies unpack the stories of his alleged victims tied to the chair over the years.
Support the show
The Viral Cincinnati Crawler
Send us Fan Mail
Jenn and Em dive into the viral internet hoax known as the Cincinnati Crawler, breaking down how the unsettling creature story spread across TikTok and Instagram. A modern urban legend fuelled by fear, a fake photo, and the internet’s ability to turn rumour into “reality.”
Support the show
Dyatlov Pass: Evidence That Doesn’t Add Up (Part 2)
Send us Fan Mail
Em and Jenn return for Part 2 of the Dyatlov Pass mystery, continuing the investigation into the tragic fate of the hikers found in the Ural Mountains. The ladies unpack the lingering theories, unexplained injuries, and chilling details that still make this one of the most baffling unsolved cases in history.
Support the show
The Sick and Twisted Toy Box Killer
Send us Fan Mail
Jenn and Em break down the horrifying case of David Parker Ray, one of the most infamous criminals in modern true crime history. They explore the disturbing details of his crimes, the survival accounts, and how he managed to evade capture for years.
Support the show
Dyatlov Pass: The Mystery That Still Isn’t Solved (Part 1)
Send us Fan Mail
Em and Jenn kick off Part 1 of the Dyatlov Pass hikers mystery, exploring the tragic 1959 expedition in the Ural Mountains that ended in the unexplained deaths of nine hikers. They unpack the strange evidence left behind and the early theories that still fuel debate today.
Support the show
Mr. Cruel: Australia’s Unidentified Serial Predator
Send us Fan Mail
Jenn and Em break down the case of Mr. Cruel, the unidentified Australian serial predator responsible for a series of child abductions and assaults that terrorized Melbourne. The ladies dig into the investigation, the surviving evidence, and the unsettling reason this case remains one of Australia’s most notorious unsolved mysteries.
Support the show
Black Lady of Bradley Woods: The Ghost in England’s Forest
Send us Fan Mail
Em and Jenn explore a haunting English folklore tale of a grieving mother whose legend has been passed down through oral tradition for generations. The ladies unpack the story’s origins, the ghostly sightings tied to it, and why it continues to unsettle those who hear it.
Support the show
Scorned Lover Listener Stories That Shocked Us
Send us Fan Mail
Jenn and Em celebrate Valentine’s Day on the Wheel of Crime Podcast with a collection of anonymous listener stories about love, relationships, and things that went VERY wrong. From bizarre romance disasters to unsettling real life encounters, these Valentine’s tales prove love can get creepy fast.
Support the show
Ant Hill Kids Cult: Roch Thériault’s Brutal Reign
Send us Fan Mail
The Ant Hill Kids cult, led by Roch Thériault, is one of the most disturbing true crime cases in Canada. Jenn and Em break down how this violent cult operated, the shocking abuse inside it, and what led to its eventual downfall.
Support the show
Mae Nak: Thailand’s Tragic Love Ghost
Send us Fan Mail
Em and Jenn dive into the tragic legend of Mae Nak Phra Khanong, one of Thailand’s most famous ghost stories rooted in love, loss, and haunting devotion. The ladies explore the origins of the tale, the real life tragedy behind it, and why Mae Nak’s story continues to terrify and fascinate.
Support the show
Ed Edwards: The Serial Killer You’ve Never Heard Of
Send us Fan Mail
Jenn and Em dig into the twisted case of Edward Edwards, a lesser known killer whose story is somehow even more disturbing the deeper you go. From shocking allegations to lingering theories that refuse to die, this is one of those cases that makes you wonder how he stayed under the radar for so long.
Support the show
Black Aggie Curse: America’s Creepiest Statue Myth
Send us Fan Mail
Em and Jenn dive into the chilling lore of Black Aggie, the infamous haunted cemetery statue from Baltimore, Maryland that has terrified locals for decades. They unpack the strange legends, reported paranormal encounters, and why this statue became one of America’s most talked about cursed monuments.
Support the show
Ethan Crumbley Case: Parents on Trial for School Shooting
Send us Fan Mail
Today on the Wheel of Crime Podcast, Jenn and Em break down the case of Ethan Crumbley, and how the tragedy led to an unprecedented trial of his parents for their role leading up to the shooting. They explore the warning signs, the investigation, and the legal fallout that reshaped conversations around responsibility and prevention.
Support the show
Manananggal: A Real Blood-Sucking Legend
Send us Fan Mail
Jenn and Em ring in the New Year on the Wheel of Crime Podcast with a deep dive into the terrifying creature known as the Manananggal, a legendary shapeshifting vampire from Philippine folklore. The ladies unpack the origins of the myth, the gruesome details of its nighttime hunts, and why this creature continues to haunt imaginations.
Support the show
Christmas Special: Listener Stories & Holiday Horror
Send us Fan Mail
Jenn and Em celebrate the 2025 Wheel of Crime Christmas Special with a festive collection of listener submitted stories blending paranormal encounters and true crime. These unsettling real life events turn holiday nostalgia on its head and make you wonder what’s hiding just out of sight this Christmas.
Support the show
Thomas J. Grasso: The Killer Who Can't Get SpaghettiOs
Send us Fan Mail
Jenn and Em dig into the disturbing crimes of Thomas J. Grasso, including the case that led to his execution and the bizarre last meal request that made him internet infamous, and how he became the killer who can't get SpaghettiOs.Â
Support the show
Fouke Monster: Arkansas’ Boggy Creek Creature
Send us Fan Mail
Em and Jenn explore the legend of the Boggy Creek Monster from Fouke, Arkansas. The ladies examine the sightings, folklore, and unsettling stories surrounding this infamous Southern cryptid. A creature that still slips through decades of retellings, leaving behind more questions than answers every time it’s seen.
Support the show
Crazy Conspiracies: Is Garth Brooks a Serial Killer?!
Send us Fan Mail
On today's episode of the Wheel of Crime, the ladies dive into one of the wildest music industry conspiracy theories. Jenn and Em unpack the bizarre claims surrounding country music icon Garth Brooks. From internet rabbit holes to fan fueled theories that refuse to die, this episode explores how a beloved superstar became the center of a viral conspiracy storm.
Support the show
Teke Teke: Japan’s Legless Urban Legend
Send us Fan Mail
Em and Jenn dive into the chilling Japanese urban legend of Teke-Teke. A vengeful spirit said to drag itself through train stations after being horrifically split in two. A fast moving ghost story that has haunted schoolyard whispers and internet forums for decades, proving some legends are impossible to outrun.
Support the show
Real Crime Meets Gaming: World of Warcraft Murder Case
Send us Fan Mail
Jenn and Em dive into spooky true crime and paranormal stories shared on Reddit, where internet confessions and creepy encounters collide. One standout case explores the bizarre World of Warcraft murder case, where gaming obsession and real life violence collide in the most unsettling way. A collection of stories that prove the internet is a horrifying place to be.Â
Support the show
Tales From the High Sea: The Flying Dutchman
Send us Fan Mail
Ahoy ye mateys! Em and Jenn set sail into one of the most famous maritime legends, the ghost ship known as the Flying Dutchman. The ladies dig into the cursed voyage lore and centuries of sailor stories that claim this doomed vessel still drifts the seas, never able to make port.
Support the show
Inside McKamey Manor: Real Life Horror Experience
Send us Fan Mail
From viral footage to shocking allegations and the extreme experiences inside, this episode uncovers the truth behind McKamey Manor and the man behind the curtain, Russ McKamey. Jenn and Em dive into why this haunting experience has become one of the most controversial activities in America.
Support the show
Baba Yaga: Iconic Slavic Witch of Folklore
Send us Fan Mail
Today on the Wheel of Crime Podcast, Emily and Jenn dive into magical and powerful forest crone known in Slavic folklore as Baba Yaga.
Support the show
The Conjuring Case: Real-Life Perron Family Haunting
Send us Fan Mail
Subject of the first Conjuring film, Jenn and Em crack into the case of the Perron Family haunting and the real Bathsheba witch.Â
Support the show
Beast of Bladenboro: North Carolina’s Mysterious Creature
Send us Fan Mail
Today on the Wheel of Crime Podcast, Em and Jenn discuss a string of animal killings in North Carolina. The killings are thought to be done by the infamous cryptid, the Beast of Bladenboro.
Support the show
Tony Todt: The Double Life Behind the Murders
Send us Fan Mail
Today on the Wheel of Crime Podcast Jenn and Emily discuss Tony Todt, who follows in his father's footsteps with a family murder plot.
Support the show
Horror or Hoax? Wisconsin Hodag
Send us Fan Mail
Today on the Wheel of Crime Podcast, Em and Jenn discuss the mythical creature from Wisconsin folklore, the hodag. Is it a hoax or is it really out there?Â
Support the show
Murders, Ghosts and Cryptids Oh My! Summer Listener Stories
Send us Fan Mail
Jenn and Em dive into wild listener submitted stories on the Wheel of Crime Podcast, featuring a mix of true crime experiences and paranormal encounters. From unsettling real life crimes to unexplained supernatural moments, these stories will leave you questioning what’s real long after the episode ends.
Support the show
Kóoshdaa Káa: The Shape-Shifting Spirit Legend
Send us Fan Mail
Today on the Wheel of Crime Podcast, Jenn and Em discuss the folklore of the Kóoshdaa Káa.
Support the show
Escape from Alcatraz! The Unsolved Prison Break
Send us Fan Mail
Today on the Wheel of Crime Podcast Jenn and Em discuss the three men who escaped the infamous Alcatraz prison in 1962.Â
Support the show
Ed and Lorraine Investigations: Smurl Family Haunting
Send us Fan Mail
Today on the Wheel of Crime Podcast, Jenn and Em discuss one of Ed and Lorraine Warren's famous case, the Smurl family haunting.
Support the show
The White Lady: Global Ghost Legends
Send us Fan Mail
Today on the Wheel of Crime Podcast, Em and Jenn discuss the legend of the white ladies from various countries across the globe.
Support the show
Plymouth Mail Robbery: Britain’s Forgotten Heist
Send us Fan Mail
Today on the Wheel of Crime Podcast, Jenn and Em discuss the Great Plymouth Mail Robbery, which still remains a mystery to this day.
Support the show
