Brain in a Vat
Thought experiments and conversations with philosophers. Hosted by Dr Jason Werbeloff and Mark Oppenheimer.
Philosophy Through Fiction | Kolby Granville
Can fiction reveal moral truths that abstract philosophy cannot?
Kolby Granville, founder of After Dinner Conversation, joins to discuss how fiction can illuminate philosophical questions and challenge our moral intuitions. Through stories about deathbed promises, time travel, and artificial intelligence, we consider how fiction exposes the tension between philosophical reasoning and lived experience.
Chapters:
[00:00] Introduction to Kolby Granville
[00:32] The Deathbed Promise
[02:16] Moral Obligations Beyond Death
[11:06] The Problem of Hypothetical Bias
[15:30] How Moral Choices Shape Identity
[20:34] Time Travel...
Wrestling with God: Religion, Language, and Civilization | Ilan Stavans
Would humans invent God if they had never encountered religion? Is religious belief an inevitable part of human civilization?
Ilan Stavans examines the relationship between language, religion, and human thought. He argues that language enables us to conceptualize the divine and that religious beliefs help shape collective identities, political power, and entire civilizations.
The conversation considers how different cultures understand God, whether atheism can exist independently of religious belief, and why spirituality persists despite declining religious participation. Stavans also discusses how artificial intelligence and simulation theory challenge traditional conceptions...
The Function of Consciousness | Alexander Klein
We welcome Alexander Klein to examine the role of consciousness in behavior. Drawing on William James’s evolutionary theory and nineteenth-century experiments on frogs, Klein considers whether consciousness is essential to purposeful action or merely accompanies it. The conversation questions how we identify consciousness in animals and AI, and whether its evolutionary function can account for the subjective richness of experience.
Chapters:
[00:00] Introduction
[00:11] The Brainless Frog Experiment
[09:06] Access and Phenomenal Consciousness
[12:11] Consciousness in AI
[17:03] Philosophical Zombies
[20:21] Is Consciousness Universal?
[24:14] The Ev...
Political Bias in Academia and the Threat to Democracy | Hrishikesh Joshi
Hrishikesh Joshi dissects whether political homogeneity in academia poses a problem for democracy.
He ultimately argues that universities wield significant influence over society while remaining largely insulated from democratic control. Comparing the academy to an ideological “guild” that shapes future elites and political thought, Joshi concludes that greater intellectual pluralism would strengthen both democratic legitimacy and the pursuit of truth.
Chapters:
[00:00] Introduction
[00:15] Democracy Beyond Elections
[05:44] Competing “Guilds”
[10:56] Political Homogeneity in Academia
[20:24] The Academy’s Political Influence
[26:10] Shaping Politics O...
Decoding Reactions: Signal and Noise in Personal Interactions | Mark Schroeder
Mark Schroeder discusses When Things Get Personal, his account of how we interpret one another and why those interpretations so often go wrong.
Our interactions are filled with noise, factors that don’t reflect the person themselves, complicating what we can infer about an individual from their behavior.
Schroeder dissects the complex relationship between behavior, agency, and identity, as well as our tendency to treat someone’s actions as evidence of their character.
Chapters:
[00:00] Signal and Noise
[04:11] Seeing People as Prot...
The Truth About Honesty, Lies, and Deception | Christian Miller
Christian Miller, author of The Honesty Crisis, joins to explore the nature and ethics of honesty. He examines what it means to be honest, when lying can be morally justified, and the difference between honesty and simply telling the truth. Miller considers these questions through cases involving deepfakes, delusion, infidelity, and our obligations to tell the truth.
Chapters:
[00:00] Introducing Christian Miller
[00:29] The Nazi at the Door
[07:17] Honesty or Compassion
[14:24] The Importance of Honesty
[18:26] Deepfakes and the Erosion of Trust
[23:03] Honest Falsehoods and...
The Costs of Open Borders | Lionel Shriver
Lionel Shriver returns to discuss her new novel, 'A Better Life,' and the philosophical debate over immigration and open borders.
Inspired by a proposed New York City program to pay residents to house migrants, the novel turns one family's home into a thought experiment about immigration and humanitarian obligations.
Shriver examines the arguments for and against open borders, as well as challenges surrounding assimilation and national identity. She also considers what happens when abstract commitments to helping others require bearing the costs and responsibilities yourself in practice.
<...The Man Who Exposed Jason Arday: Cancelled at Cambridge | Nathan Cofnas
Nathan Cofnas, the academic who recently drew widespread attention for exposing plagiarism allegations against Cambridge professor Jason Arday, returns to Brain in a Vat to discuss academic freedom, institutional conformity, and his own controversial departure from Cambridge.
Cofnas argues that universities create incentives for academics to conform, particularly when scholarship challenges prevailing political and moral assumptions. He recounts the backlash to his writing on race and intelligence, including student petitions, protests, complaints, and the lengthy Cambridge investigation that followed.
Can universities remain committed to free inquiry when students and...
Free Speech, Schools, and Children | Jimmy Mullen
Former Brain in a Vat producer Jimmy Mullen returns to discuss free speech in schools, exploring how educational institutions should balance student expression with their responsibility to maintain an environment conducive to learning.
Drawing on constitutional law and landmark cases on student free speech, the conversation explores viewpoint neutrality, the role of political disagreement in education, and the limits of school authority.
It ultimately considers how schools can prepare children to think independently while participating in a democratic society.
Chapters:
[00:00] Two Cases...
Sexual Ethics on Campus: Consent and Power | Colin McGinn
Colin McGinn joins to discuss sexual ethics on campus. Drawing on thought experiments and his own experiences in academia, McGinn argues that universities too often conflate harassment with consensual relationships while overstating the role of power imbalances. He explains why he believes current policies can undermine academic freedom, due process, and the proper limits of institutional authority.
Chapters:
[00:00] Introduction
[00:16] A Thought Experiment
[08:19] Microenticements
[12:09] Harassment vs. Consensual Relationships
[22:38] Reporting Relationships
[36:06] The Power Imbalance
[45:06] MeToo, Cancellation, and Academia
[49:53] Devil's Advocate<...
The Philosophy of Pluribus | Spencer Case
Spencer Case returns to discuss Pluribus, one of the most philosophically ambitious science fiction series in recent years. The conversation explores whether individuality is worth preserving if giving it up would create a happier and more peaceful world, raising questions about personal identity, autonomy, and the ethics of a hive mind.
Chapters:
[00:00] Welcome
[00:58] Pluribus Explained
[03:09] The Hive Mind Thought Experiment
[04:34] Do You Survive the Joining?
[12:05] Personal Identity and Point of View
[16:58] Unjoining and Consent
[21:04] Autonomy or Happiness?
[30:30] Utilitarianism...
The Time-Meaning Conundrum | Rivka Weinberg
Rivka Weinberg returns to argue that time is both the source of meaning and its greatest threat, making meaningful lives possible while also guaranteeing loss and impermanence. The conversation explores the relationship between suffering and meaning, whether ultimate meaning is attainable, and why temporary achievements may remain valuable even if nothing lasts forever.
Chapters:
[00:00] Introduction
[04:44] The Time-Meaning Conundrum
[06:35] Religion, Suffering, and Meaning
[16:13] Immortality and the Afterlife
[21:06] Why Ultimate Meaning Is Impossible
[28:06] Cosmic Purpose and Heaven
[33:54] Hedonism and Long-Term Commitment
<...Should You Need Permission to Take Medicine? | Jessica Flanigan
Do adults have a right to decide what goes into their own bodies, even when experts believe they're making a mistake?
Jessica Flanigan returns to defend a radical idea: competent adults should have the freedom to access pharmaceuticals without needing permission from doctors or government regulators. Flanigan argues that the same principles underlying informed consent also support a right to self-medicate.
The conversation explores medical paternalism through debates over prescription requirements, addiction, public health, gender-affirming care, and assisted dying. We scrutinize the limits of state authority and whether doctors...
Can Torture Be Justified? | Stephen Kershnar
We welcome back Stephen Kershnar to discuss the ethics of torture. Kershnar argues that some criminals deserve torture because severe wrongdoing can cause a person to forfeit protections against extreme punishment. He critiques the idea that there are moral constraints the state must never cross.
The dialogue also examines objections to torture concerning human dignity, bodily integrity, and the dangers of granting the state such power.
Chapters
[00:00] Introduction
[00:43] Why Punitive Torture?
[04:57] Defining Torture
[08:22] Solitary Confinement Today
[10:15] Deterrence versus Retribution<...
A World Without Scarcity | Steven Kotler
What happens to human beings in a world without scarcity? If all our needs were met, would we actually be better off? Will technological progress lead to utopia or collapse?
Humans are living through massive improvements in material conditions. More people have access to food, energy, and technology than ever before. Steven Kotler examines what this kind of abundance does to us. It may support a more comfortable life, but it can also erode the conditions that sustain a sense of purpose.
We also discuss how attention and identity...
Living with Adversity | David Benatar
What does it mean to live with adversity? How ought we respond to the suffering of others? How can we adapt to hardship?
Adversity is a universal experience. Nearly everyone, at some point, faces physical, psychological, or social challenges, and yet suffering often goes unnoticed.
David Benatar joins us to discuss these questions on the human condition, provoked by his book 'Living with Adversity,' a collection of personal accounts of suffering.
Read Benatar's book here: https://wipfandstock.com/9798385266708/living-with-adversity/
Risky Storytelling | Kevin Allison
Kevin Allison, creator of the RISK! podcast, recounts a high school prank at an all-boys Jesuit school in 1986. After a crush teased him by repeatedly spitting on him, Kevin later mailed him a sealed container of feces labeled “enjoy the cookies.”
In retelling the story, Kevin considers how the prank mixes humiliation and a possible form of intimacy, situated within his experience of growing up gay under Catholic doctrine. For Kevin, telling such stories has become an opportunity for self-reflection.
Beyond this, Kevin argues that sharing what is usually cons...
Free Speech, Hate Speech, and Mental Health | Chloe Carmichael
Clinical psychologist Chloe Carmichael, author of "Can I Say That?," examines how free expression relates to psychological well-being and social trust. Carmichael argues that suppressing disagreement drives resentment and misperception, rather than resolving conflict. She also scrutinizes the role of safe spaces, the spread of therapeutic language, and what limits on speech might be justified in public versus private life.
[00:00] Introduction to Chloe Carmichael
[00:29] Mark’s Workplace Story
[02:33] Repression and Mental Health
[09:47] Reeducation versus dialogue
[13:58] Campus safe spaces
[21:30] Public speech
[22:37] Therapy language an...
The Bias against Conservatism in Higher Education | Amy Wax
Amy Wax joins us to discuss the ideological landscape of higher education. Wax reflects on her conflict with the University of Pennsylvania and argues that universities have become increasingly hostile to conservative viewpoints. The conversation explores ideological bias on campus, academic freedom, and the challenges conservatives face within modern higher education.
[00:00] Welcome to the Discussion
[00:23] Amy Wax and Penn Suspension
[07:01] Lawsuit and Double Standards
[15:01] Speech Versus Action Rules
[25:33] Why Academia Stays One Sided
[35:29] Classroom Power Imbalance
[40:14] Public Private Speech Rules
[44:18...
The Nature of the Sexes | Tomás Bogardus (with Stephen Kershnar)
Tomás Bogardus joins to discuss his book "The Nature of the Sexes" and argues for a reproductive-functional account of biological sex. According to Bogardus, males and females are defined by the reproductive function their bodies are structured to perform: producing sperm or eggs. Even when that function is not realized and no sperm or eggs are produced, a person’s sex remains the same, because it is grounded in biological organization. To defend this view, Bogardus considers intersex and DSD cases, critiques contextualist accounts that treat sex as domain-dependent, and argues for a unified meaning of “male” and “female.”...
God Is Not Praiseworthy | Stephen Kershnar and Nathan Bray
Brain in a Vat is back from hiatus with a deep dive into the philosophy of religion. Stephen Kershnar and Nathan Bray join us to ask whether God can be morally responsible and whether worship makes sense if God could not have done otherwise.
The discussion begins with a thought experiment about gratitude and worship. If worship expresses praise for morally responsible action, can a perfectly good God deserve it at all? Kershnar and Bray argue that divine perfection may undermine responsibility rather than secure it.
From there, Kershnar...
Facial Distortions and Prosopometamorphopsia | Brad Duchaine (Rebroadcast)
In this special episode of Brain in a Vat, Brad Duchaine from the Psychological and Brain Sciences Department at Dartmouth discusses prosopometamorphopsia (PMO) – a condition where individuals see distorted faces.
The episode explores various manifestations of PMO, including seeing demonic features, dragons, or entirely different faces, and distinguishes it from prosopagnosia (face blindness). It delves into the neurological basis of PMO, touching upon structural and functional differences in the brains of those affected.
We discuss the significant impact PMO and prosopagnosia have on individuals' social interactions and quality of li...
Should We Stay or Should We Go | Lionel Shriver (Rebroadcast)
When is death preferable to living? Are there fates worse than death? And what sort of future society should we build?
Lionel Shriver discusses her latest novel, Should We Stay or Should We Go.
Parental Licensing | Connor Kianpour (Rebroadcast)
Should you be required to get a parental license from the State before you can raise your own children? Do the wishes of parents matter at all – or should we only care about the best interests of their children?
Can AI Bring Our Loved Ones Back? Inside Reflekta AI’s Digital Afterlife | Miles Spencer
In this special episode of Brain in a Vat, we step outside our usual format to interview Miles Spencer, founder of Reflekta — a company using cutting-edge AI to recreate digital reflections of loved ones who’ve passed away.
Miles shares his personal journey of using Reflekta to reconnect with his late father and explains how the system blends voice recordings, photos, and written biographies to create realistic digital personas. The discussion covers the emotional impact, ethical questions, and philosophical issues raised by this technology, from preserving family memories to reviving historical or fictional figures.
Cultural Appropriation | Stephen Kershnar (Rebroadcast)
Is it permissible for members of one group to appropriate the cultural practices of another? Is there anything wrong with cultural appropriation at all, or are there benefits to cultural appropriation?
Aztec Philosophy: What the Aztecs Knew About Life | Sebastian Purcell
How did the Aztecs understand life, morality, and human purpose? What can Aztec philosophy teach us about living well?
Sebastian Purcell guides us through Aztec thought, beginning with a thought experiment from Homer’s Odyssey and moving into the core ideas of Aztec wisdom.
Along the way, he contrasts Aztec ethics with Western traditions and applies them to modern debates on morality, from sex and meat consumption to life’s ultimate purpose. The conversation also takes on difficult topics like human sacrifice and sexual norms, showing how Aztec thought cont...
The Assassination of Charlie Kirk
In this special episode of Brain in a Vat, Mark and Jasondiscuss the tragic assassination of political commentator, Charlie Kirk. The episode discusses Kirk's commitment to open dialogue and civil discourse, particularly on college campuses, and critique the societal implications of hisdeath.
The episode delves into themes of free speech, academicfreedom, and the dangerous conflation of words and violence. Jason and Mark also address arguments attempting to justify or minimize Kirk's assassination,advocating instead for a return to civility and the importance of open, reasoned debate.
00:00 Introduction and Tribute to Charlie Kirk<...
Using AI to Fight Crime | David Boonin (Rebroadcast)
Is racial profiling always wrong, even if used by an AI to decrease crime? Should we use AI to judge criminal cases, recommend sentences for the guilty, or decide parole for prisoners?
Chapters:
[00:00] Introduction to AI in Crime Fighting
[00:12] Thought Experiment: The Looting Scenario
[06:32] Predictive Policing and AI
[10:13] Debating the Ethics of AI in Law Enforcement
[23:26] Affirmative Action and Racial Profiling
[37:51] Balancing Crime Reduction and Social Engineering
[39:00] AI in Sentencing: Benefits and Challenges
[40:08] Algorithmic Transparency and Legal Implications<...
Are We Free at Work? Marx on Capitalism Today | Brian Leiter
In this episode of Brain in a Vat, we’re joined by Brian Leiter, co-author (with Jamie Edwards) of a new book on Marx. We explore whether workers in contemporary capitalism are truly free—or trapped in a form of “wage slavery.” Leiter uses thought experiments to probe the limits of workplace freedom. He also examines Marx’s labor theory of value—its strengths and flaws—and shows how modern capitalism both confirms and diverges from Marx’s predictions.
The conversation then turns to labor, technological change, human nature, and artificial intelligence—culminating in a pressing questio...
The Possible Worlds of David Lewis | Barry Lam (Rebroadcast)
What are possible worlds? Could you have been born to different parents, and could an object be both completely green and completely red? Barry Lam explains how David Lewis’s views on possible worlds can help us understand everything from time travel to the nature of who we are.
Procreative Ethics | Rivka Weinberg (Rebroadcast)
Is it wrong to bring new life into the world? Is adopting a child a moral obligation? Is parenting meaningful?
Imagine There’s No Gender | Holly Lawford-Smith [with Raja Halwani] (Rebroadcast)
Would the world be better if we didn’t recognize genders?
In such a world, there would be males and females, but nothing associated with what it means to be male or female other than biological facts. Men and women would be equally likely to be social leaders. And there would be no stereotypically male or female behavior.
In this world, there’d be true sex equality, and, it seems, no need for trans activists. Should we fight for such a world?
The Moral Lives of Spies | Cécile Fabre
What does a spy owe — to their country, their conscience, or their cause? In this episode, Cécile Fabre investigates the moral lives of Cold War operatives like Kim Philby and Oleg Gordievsky. With Fabre, we probe the strange morality of spies and the ethical paradoxes they inhabit.
Is it ever right to betray your country? Can deception be a moral duty? These questions come to life through real stories of espionage. Competing ethical frameworks — such as utilitarian, deontological, and virtue-based — offer different judgments on such acts. We also confront the role of ideology, the wei...
The Right to Sex | Raja Halwani (Rebroadcast)
Do we have a right to sex, and is there an obligation to sexually fulfill the disabled? Should sex work be not only legal, but obligatory?
[00:00] Introduction and Guest Welcome
[00:16] Exploring the Right to Sex: Thought Experiment
[03:43] Negative vs. Positive Rights to Sex
[09:50] State-Sponsored Sex Work and Ethical Considerations
[11:52] Sexual Obligations and Imperfect Duties
[23:51] Rights to Sex in Relationships and Marriage
[30:43] Philosophical Grounds and Parallel Cases
[31:29] Moral Implications of Ending Sexual Activity
[34:17] Third-Party Interference in Sexual Rights
[37:39] Sexual...
Decriminalizing Sex Work | Jessica Flanigan
In this episode of Brain in a Vat, we welcome back Jessica Flanigan for a discussion on the decriminalization of sex work.
Using a decriminalization framework, Flanigan examines the ethics of sex work and the role of state regulation.
The conversation explores autonomy, consent, and coercion. It also addresses the stigma surrounding sex work, its possible benefits, and the impact of market dynamics on both workers and clients. Flanigan offers a nuanced perspective on a complex and often controversial topic.
Check out our related...
Disgust | Martha Nussbaum (Rebroadcast)
What exactly makes us feel disgusted? Is disgust for a person or group ever justified? And is disgust useful, or should we try to eliminate it?
Chapters:
[00:00] Introduction to Disgust and Cognitive Content
[00:11] Paul Rosen's Experiments on Disgust
[02:16] Disgust and Its Connection to Animality and Mortality
[03:05] Projective Disgust and Social Implications
[05:06] Disgust in Legal Theory and Practice
[08:00] Personal Anecdotes on Disgust and Social Change
[11:18] Disgust Towards Transphobia and Body Malleability
[13:24] Disgust in Art and Pornography
[22:17] Disgust...
Patriotism Unpacked | Spencer Case (Rebroadcast)
What does it mean to be patriotic, or to love your country? Some argue that patriotism is virtuous because it allows us to transcend our selfish needs and act for the good of our community. But others argue that patriotism is overly narrow-minded, arbitrary and sometimes immoral.
Microdigressions Podcast: https://www.youtube.com/@Micro-Digressions
Chapters:
[00:00] Introduction to Brain Nevada
[00:27] Exploring John Lennon's 'Imagine'
[01:11] Critique of Utopian Ideals
[01:52] Possessions and National Identities
[05:44] The Role of Security Companies
[06:19] Metaphysics...
Is Tarot a Tool for Thought? | Georgi Gardiner
In this episode of Brain in a Vat, Georgi Gardiner returns to explore the epistemic value of tarot: its capacity to shape self-understanding, spark creative reflection, and influence major life decisions.
Drawing on personal experience and philosophical analysis, Georgi examines how tarot can serve as a mirror for introspection while also raising concerns about confirmation bias and self-deception. The discussion also considers the history and diversity of tarot practices, and compares tarot with artificial intelligence as a tool for navigating uncertainty and meaning.
Whether you are a skeptic, a...
Living The Philosophical Life | Agnes Callard
In this episode, Brain in a Vat is joined by public philosopher and author Agnes Callard to explore the relevance of philosophy in everyday life. Drawing from her work on Socrates, Agnes makes a case for why philosophical inquiry matters, now more than ever. From the pig farmer analogy to Socratic love, this conversation is a deep dive into how philosophy is a way of life.
Chapters:
[00:00] Introduction to the Guest and Topic
[00:44] The Monologue vs. Dialogue Experiment
[06:50] Philosophical Training and the Element of Surprise<...