The Perfect Collapse

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

Season 2, Episode 1: The Perfect Collapse: Lucy Letby

In this six-episode mini-season, we explore the case of Ms Lucy Letby. In a single year, 17 babies on one neonatal unit in England died or suddenly collapsed. Ms Lucy Letby, a junior nurse, was on duty for every event. A jury convicted her of seven counts of murder and eight counts of attempted murder. She is serving 15 life sentences and has always maintained her innocence.

This episode...

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

Episode 18: The Perfect Collapse: After the Verdict — A Final Conversation with Psychiatrist Dr. K

In the final episode of season one of The Perfect Collapse, I sit down with Psychiatrist Dr. K for the last conversation about the Lindsay Clancy case. We discuss the questions that extend far beyond the verdict: parasocial relationships, resentment of motherhood, Latarsha Sanders, Lindsay Clancy's case through a black woman’s perspective, as well as the potential for copycat murders.

We also examine the black male hold...

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

Episode 17: The Perfect Collapse: The Verdict

The jury couldn't agree. Not on insanity, not on manslaughter, and not on murder in the first or second degree. After seven days and thirty-eight hours of deliberation, marked by accusations of a lying juror and a judge who refused to remove him, and an emergency appeal to the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, Lindsay Clancy's trial ended in a mistrial, deadlocked 11 to 1.

This episode breaks down what the Commonwealth can do next and what happens...

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

Episode 16: The Perfect Collapse: Closing Statements

Closing statements concluded today in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Lindsay Clancy. We walk through the judge's instructions to the jury: the four possible verdicts, the legal standard for criminal responsibility, and the distinctions between not guilty by reason of insanity (NGRI), first-degree murder, second-degree murder, and manslaughter. We then play both closing arguments in full.

*********************

Everyone has an opinion. Few have read the record. The Perfect Collapse examines high-profile criminal cases through...

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

Episode 15: The Perfect Collapse: Control or Collapse?

Was Lindsay Clancy severely depressed, or was she psychotic? Two forensic psychiatrists examined her and came back with opposite conclusions. We break down the testimony of Dr. Avram Mack and Dr. Phillip Resnick, and what the postpartum psychosis question means for a not guilty by reason of insanity verdict.

*********************

Everyone has an opinion. Few have read the record. The Perfect Collapse examines high-profile criminal cases through a forensic psychology lens using court...

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

Episode 14: The Perfect Collapse: Interview with Psychiatrist Dr. K

In this special episode of The Perfect Collapse, I sit down with psychiatrist Dr. K to discuss post-partum disorders to include psychosis, medication cycling, and personality disorders while exploring psychiatric concepts that have come up throughout the Lindsay Clancy case.

This is not a forensic evaluation of Lindsay Clancy. Dr. K has never evaluated her and does not offer a diagnosis.

************************

Everyone has an opinion. Few have read...

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

Episode 13: The Perfect Collapse: A Profound Lack of Insight

In this episode of The Perfect Collapse, we take a closer look at the psychiatric testimony presented during Lindsay Clancy’s trial and her lengthy prescription history in the months before the murders of Cora Clancy, Dawson Clancy, and Callan Clancy. We also look at medication noncompliance and the many reasons a patient may not take psychiatric medication as prescribed.

Next time on The Perfect Collapse, a psychiatrist joins us to discuss po...

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

Episode 12: The Perfect Collapse: Forensic Psychiatrist Testimony BONUS EPISODE

A bonus episode isolating the forensic psychiatric testimony heard so far in the Lindsay Clancy trial. Lindsay has already admitted to killing her three children, so the real question is her mental state when it happened. Testimony comes from two Brigham and Women's psychiatrists: Dr. Jhilam Biswas, who examined Lindsay Clancy on January 26, 2023, two days after the killings, and Dr. Sejal Shah, who evaluated her following her spinal surgery.

*****************

Everyone...

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

Episode 11: The Perfect Collapse: Latarsha Sanders' Verdict, Lindsay Clancy's Trial

This week's episode highlights the testimony of Dr. Kelly McDonough, the South Shore Hospital ER physician who treated Lindsay Clancy immediately after her fall. The episode then pivots to Latarsha Sanders, convicted of killing her two sons in 2018 in Brockton, Massachusetts after an undiagnosed psychotic break. Her Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court appeal challenges the language used against her by the prosecuting attorney and the rejection of her psychiatric records as evidence.

***********************************<...

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

Episode 10: The Perfect Collapse: Sympathy Is Not Evidence

Firefighter Robert Costanzo testifies to what he saw the night Lindsay Clancy was found injured — and Reddington argues the dark got in the way. This whole case keeps circling back to the same question: is what looks convincing on the surface, the truth? This episode widens our argument to a condition that, like narcissism, sits quietly for years until something breaks the coping mechanisms holding it in place. Then, we place Lindsay Clancy's case beside th...

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

Episode 9: The Perfect Collapse: Patrick Clancy's Testimony BONUS EPISODE

Patrick Clancy's testimony continues — direct examination by ADA Jennifer Sprague and cross-examination by defense attorney Kevin Reddington, in full and uninterrupted. Court resumes tomorrow Thursday, July 30th with a viewing of the Clancy home at 47 Summer Street in Duxbury scheduled for Friday, July 31st.

*****************

Everyone has an opinion. Few have read the record. The Perfect Collapse examines high-profile criminal cases through a forensic psychology lens using court filings, medical timelines, an...

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

Episode 8: The Perfect Collapse: Patrick Clancy's Testimony BONUS EPISODE

Patrick Clancy's direct examination by Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague, in full and uninterrupted.

*********************

Everyone has an opinion. Few have read the record. The Perfect Collapse examines high-profile criminal cases through a forensic psychology lens using court filings, medical timelines, and legal records—starting with the Lindsay Clancy trial. No dramatization. No hot takes. Just primary sources, rigorous analysis, and the questions mainstream coverage never asked.

DISCLAIMER

...

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

Episode 7: The Perfect Collapse: Opening Statements

Jury selection wrapped in four days. Opening statements are done. Hear both sides lay out their case for the first time — and what their word choices reveal about the strategy ahead.

*******************

Everyone has an opinion. Few have read the record. The Perfect Collapse examines high-profile criminal cases through a forensic psychology lens using court filings, medical timelines, and legal records—starting with the Lindsay Clancy trial. No dramatization. No hot takes. Just primary sour...

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

Episode 6: The Perfect Collapse: Twelve Strangers

Recorded on the first day of trial, this episode opens with the full biography of both Lindsay and Patrick Clancy. From there, the episode shifts into examining jury selection and draws an extended comparison to Aaron Hernandez's 2015 trial, using his massive jury pool and the resulting change to Massachusetts voir dire law.

***********************

Everyone has an opinion. Few have read the record. The Perfect Collapse examines high-profile criminal cases through a forensic psychology lens...

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

Episode 5: The Perfect Collapse: All Over Facebook

With the trial just a week from jury selection, mixed public reaction to the Lindsay Clancy case spilled from social media directly into Plymouth County Superior Court. We hear Reddington's denied bid to put laypersons sympathetic to Lindsay Clancy's situation on the stand and ADA Sprague's rebuttal. Along the way: we examine comments in support and in opposition. We also take a closer look at Patrick Clancy, and whether the sympathy he's been given so far...

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

Episode 4: The Perfect Collapse: History Precedes Her

Lindsay Clancy's defense attempted to separate her case from the criminal justice process entirely, and failed. This episode covers that bifurcation attempt and the denial that followed, alongside a legal parallel few have drawn: the case of Latarsha Sanders, currently under appeal in the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court.

*************

Everyone has an opinion. Few have read the record. The Perfect Collapse examines high-profile criminal cases through a forensic psychology lens using court filings...

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

Episode 3: The Perfect Collapse: Two Lawsuits, Two Stories

Civil lawsuits filed in the aftermath of the case reveal detail the criminal indictment never touches. This episode cross-references those filings against a major magazine profile that shaped public sympathy for Lindsay Clancy, and asks which version the documents support.

********************

Everyone has an opinion. Few have read the record. The Perfect Collapse examines high-profile criminal cases through a forensic psychology lens using court filings, medical timelines, and legal records—starting with th...

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

Episode 2, Part 2: The Perfect Collapse: The Framework

The comparisons so far have raised more questions than they've answered. This episode introduces the psychological framework this season has been building toward, and applies it directly to the four months explored in Episode Two Part One. What looked like a sudden collapse starts to look like something else entirely.

****************

Everyone has an opinion. Few have read the record. The Perfect Collapse examines high-profile criminal cases through a forensic psychology lens using...

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

Episode 2, Part 1: The Perfect Collapse: In the Middle of Something

Public narrative treats Lindsay Clancy's January 24th account as a sudden psychotic break. The record tells a different story. This episode reconstructs the four months leading up to the murders, using primary documents rather than secondhand accounts. We also examine the comparison invoked constantly since the case broke: Andrea Yates. The similarities are real. So are the differences, and they may be the most important part of this story.

***********

...

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

Episode One: The Perfect Collapse: Lindsay Clancy

On January 24th, 2023, Lindsay Clancy strangled her three children in the family's Duxbury, Massachusetts home. Days later, her husband Patrick released a public statement asking for forgiveness, and it raised over a million dollars. This episode reads the statement that shaped how the world understood it and examines what the statement includes, what it leaves out, and why that gap matters as Lindsay Clancy's trial approaches on July 20th.

*********************

Everyone has an...