Midnight Evidence

26 Episodes
Subscribe

By: Jessy Lucas

Midnight Evidence is a true crime podcast dedicated to exploring real criminal cases, unsolved mysteries, disappearances, and the investigations that sought answers. Through detailed research and compelling storytelling, each episode examines the evidence, timelines, key individuals, and unanswered questions surrounding some of the world's most intriguing cases. 

✂️ Clip this podcast
They Stole $19 Million in Ten Minutes and Left the FBI With One Tiny Clue
They Stole $19 Million in Ten Minutes and Left the FBI With One Tiny Clue episode artwork
#26
Yesterday at 9:58 PM

In a meticulously orchestrated act of betrayal, six masked men executed the largest cash robbery in American history, disappearing into the night with nearly nineteen million dollars while leaving investigators with only a single fragment of evidence. As greed, deception, and insider knowledge unraveled a web of conspiracy, the relentless pursuit of justice exposed how even the most perfect crimes are ultimately haunted by the smallest mistakes.

Thank you for listening to Midnight Evidence. If you enjoyed this episode, please follow the podcast, leave a rating, and share it with fellow true crime enthusiasts. You can find us...


The Cartel's Kingdom of Blood: How Poverty, Power, and Betrayal Destroyed Thousands of Lives
The Cartel's Kingdom of Blood: How Poverty, Power, and Betrayal Destroyed Thousands of Lives episode artwork
#25
Yesterday at 12:08 PM

Behind the billions of dollars, lavish lifestyles, and ruthless power lies a terrifying world where poverty breeds violence, loyalty is paid for with blood, and entire families are left searching for loved ones who vanished without a trace. This gripping true crime story exposes the dark reality of the Sinaloa Cartel and the devastating human cost hidden beneath one of history's most powerful criminal empires.

Thank you for listening to Midnight Evidence. If you enjoyed this episode, please follow the podcast, leave a rating, and share it with fellow true crime enthusiasts. You can find us on Spreaker...


He Pretended to Be a Teenager… What Happened Next Horrified America | True Crime
He Pretended to Be a Teenager… What Happened Next Horrified America | True Crime episode artwork
#24
Last Saturday at 11:44 AM

A trusted police officer. A fake identity. A terrifying obsession. What started with innocent Instagram messages ended in a tragedy that shocked the entire country. In this chilling true crime story narrated by Jessy Lucas, uncover the disturbing double life of Austin Lee Edwards and the horrifying events that followed. This is a case you'll never forget.

Thank you for listening to Midnight Evidence. If you enjoyed this episode, please follow the podcast, leave a rating, and share it with fellow true crime enthusiasts. You can find us on Spreaker and your favorite podcast platforms. Until next time...


🎙️ He Smiled While Police Searched His House | The Chilling Case of Alexis Gabe
🎙️ He Smiled While Police Searched His House | The Chilling Case of Alexis Gabe episode artwork
#23
06/15/2026

She went to her boyfriend's house to end their relationship... and was never seen alive again.

What followed was a chilling web of lies, shocking mistakes, and a horrifying secret hidden in plain sight. Join Jessy Lucas as we uncover the disturbing case of Alexis Gabe and the boyfriend who smiled while police unknowingly searched for the truth just feet away.

Thank you for listening to Midnight Evidence. If you enjoyed this episode, please follow the podcast, leave a rating, and share it with fellow true crime enthusiasts. You can find us on Spreaker and your...


The Husband's Impossible Story: The Chilling Mystery of Barbara Kendhammer
The Husband's Impossible Story: The Chilling Mystery of Barbara Kendhammer episode artwork
#22
06/15/2026

A shattered windshield. A dying wife. And a husband with an unbelievable story. Was Barbara Kendhammer the victim of a tragic accident—or the target of a carefully staged murder? Join Jessy Lucas as we unravel one of Wisconsin's most haunting and controversial true crime mysteries.

Thank you for listening to Midnight Evidence. If you enjoyed this episode, please follow the podcast, leave a rating, and share it with fellow true crime enthusiasts. You can find us on Spreaker and your favorite podcast platforms. Until next time, stay curious, stay informed, and remember, every case leaves a trail.


He Helped Search for His Missing Wife… But Prosecutors Say He Already Knew She Was Dead | The Sariah Barney Cas
He Helped Search for His Missing Wife… But Prosecutors Say He Already Knew She Was Dead | The Sariah Barney Cas episode artwork
#21
06/14/2026

A young newlywed couple. A promising future. And a disappearance that would soon turn into every family's worst nightmare.
When 21-year-old National Guard medic Sariah Barney vanished, her loved ones launched a desperate search across Anchorage, Alaska. Friends, family, and volunteers refused to give up hope.
But according to prosecutors, one person involved in the search already knew the devastating truth.
As investigators uncovered changing stories, mysterious text messages, suspicious purchases, and a horrifying discovery hidden near the couple's apartment, the case took a dark turn that shocked an entire community.
Was this a grieving husband...


The Stairwell Murder: How Teenage Jealousy Turned Into a Real-Life Nightmare
The Stairwell Murder: How Teenage Jealousy Turned Into a Real-Life Nightmare episode artwork
#20
06/13/2026

He thought he was meeting someone he trusted. Minutes later, he was trapped inside a stairwell fighting for his life. What police uncovered afterward would expose a terrifying plot hidden behind teenage jealousy—and shock an entire community.

Thank you for listening to Midnight Evidence. If you enjoyed this episode, please follow the podcast, leave a rating, and share it with fellow true crime enthusiasts. You can find us on Spreaker and your favorite podcast platforms. Until next time, stay curious, stay informed, and remember, every case leaves a trail.

This episode includes AI-generated content.


She Promised Them a Sleepover… But Police Say She Had a Deadly Secret | True Crime
She Promised Them a Sleepover… But Police Say She Had a Deadly Secret | True Crime episode artwork
#19
06/13/2026

She called them into the car with promises of a fun sleepover, popcorn, and a special night they would never forget.
But according to investigators, something far more sinister was unfolding.
In this disturbing true-crime story, Jessy Lucas explores the shocking case of a mother accused of carrying out a carefully planned act that nearly ended in unimaginable tragedy. From heartbreaking social media posts and hidden warning signs to a desperate 911 call and the discovery that stunned detectives, this case raises haunting questions no one can easily answer.
How could a loving mother allegedly turn against the...


The Smell That Exposed a Horrifying Secret | Australia's Most Disturbing True Crime Case
The Smell That Exposed a Horrifying Secret | Australia's Most Disturbing True Crime Case episode artwork
#18
06/12/2026

In October 2014, residents of a luxury apartment complex in Brisbane, Australia, began complaining about a strange and unbearable smell coming from a ground-floor unit. The tenant claimed he had simply burned meat while making broth.
But when police entered the apartment, they uncovered a scene that would become one of Australia's most shocking and disturbing true-crime cases.
Behind the horror was a marriage built on secrets, hidden identities, financial struggles, and years of deception. What started as a seemingly ordinary relationship slowly spiraled into tragedy, ending in a way no one could have imagined.

Thank you...


The Gainesville Ripper: The Serial Killer Who Turned a College Town Into a Nightmare
The Gainesville Ripper: The Serial Killer Who Turned a College Town Into a Nightmare episode artwork
#17
06/11/2026

In August 1990, a quiet college town was preparing for a new semester.
Students were moving into dorms. Parents were saying goodbye. The future seemed full of promise.
But hidden in the shadows, a predator was watching.
Over the course of just four terrifying days, five young students would be brutally murdered in a killing spree so horrifying that it sent shockwaves across America. Fear consumed Gainesville, Florida, as residents locked their doors, armed themselves, and wondered who would be next.
In this chilling true crime episode, we uncover the disturbing life of Danny Rolling—the man kn...


She Vanished Before Dawn... But Her Husband's Secrets Didn't
She Vanished Before Dawn... But Her Husband's Secrets Didn't episode artwork
#16
06/11/2026

A young mother disappears without her phone, passport, or car. Her husband pleads for help on live television—but investigators soon uncover evidence suggesting he may already know exactly where she is.

Thank you for listening to Midnight Evidence. If you enjoyed this episode, please follow the podcast, leave a rating, and share it with fellow true crime enthusiasts. You can find us on Spreaker and your favorite podcast platforms. Until next time, stay curious, stay informed, and remember, every case leaves a trail.

This episode includes AI-generated content.


She Went on a First Date... Then Vanished Forever | The Chilling Case of Sade Robinso
She Went on a First Date... Then Vanished Forever | The Chilling Case of Sade Robinso episode artwork
#15
06/10/2026

A 19-year-old college student leaves home for what should have been an exciting first date.
She never returns.
Hours later, a gruesome discovery on the shores of Lake Michigan sends detectives into a race against time. A burned car. A mysterious trail of digital evidence. A hidden location known only to a select few. And a suspect whose secrets become more disturbing with every revelation.
What happened during Sade Robinson's final hours?
In this gripping true crime episode, Jessy Lucas takes you deep inside one of the most shocking murder investigations in recent history, uncovering the...


The Monster Next Door: Jeffrey Dahmer's Chilling Confession | Inside the Mind of a Serial Killer
The Monster Next Door: Jeffrey Dahmer's Chilling Confession | Inside the Mind of a Serial Killer episode artwork
#14
06/10/2026

What if the most dangerous person in your city looked completely ordinary?
In this haunting episode, Jessy Lucas takes you deep inside the disturbing world of Jeffrey Dahmer—a man who lived among unsuspecting neighbors while hiding secrets too horrifying to imagine. Through chilling confessions, shocking revelations, and the untold psychology behind one of history's most infamous killers, you'll discover how a quiet, seemingly harmless man managed to evade justice for years.
From the first victim to the moment his nightmare finally came crashing down, this episode uncovers the dark obsession, manipulation, and terrifying reality that turned an or...


The Monster Behind the Mask: The Twisted Life of Sharon Marshall
The Monster Behind the Mask: The Twisted Life of Sharon Marshall episode artwork
#13
06/09/2026

A brilliant young woman with dreams of working for NASA. A loving mother. A promising future. But behind her perfect smile hid a terrifying secret that no one could have imagined. What investigators eventually uncovered would reveal decades of kidnapping, abuse, murder, stolen identities, and one of the most disturbing criminals in American history. This is a true story so shocking it sounds fictional—but every horrifying detail is real.

Thank you for listening to Midnight Evidence. If you enjoyed this episode, please follow the podcast, leave a rating, and share it with fellow true crime enthusiasts. You ca...


The Basement Secret: A 911 Call, a Hidden Affair, and a Murder Nobody Saw Coming
The Basement Secret: A 911 Call, a Hidden Affair, and a Murder Nobody Saw Coming episode artwork
#12
06/09/2026

The Basement Secret follows the chilling case of a husband who claimed he found his wife hanging in their basement. What looked like a suicide soon unraveled into a web of lies, a secret affair, forensic contradictions, and a murder investigation that would take years to solve. Was it suicide—or the perfect cover-up? Listen now to discover the truth.

Thank you for listening to Midnight Evidence. If you enjoyed this episode, please follow the podcast, leave a rating, and share it with fellow true crime enthusiasts. You can find us on Spreaker and your favorite podcast platforms. Un...


THE NIGHTMARE KILLER: Did He Murder His Twin Sister While Asleep?
THE NIGHTMARE KILLER: Did He Murder His Twin Sister While Asleep? episode artwork
#11
06/08/2026

A terrified 17-year-old calls 911 before dawn with a chilling confession:
"I just killed my sister."
But what happened next would leave detectives, sleep experts, prosecutors, and jurors divided for years.
Benjamin Elliott claimed he wasn't awake when he stabbed his twin sister, Meghan. He insisted it felt like a dream. Investigators found no obvious motive, no history of violence, and no signs of conflict between the siblings. Yet Meghan was dead, and Benjamin was the only person who could explain why.
Could a teenager really commit a brutal killing while sleepwalking?
Or was this one...


She Believed Her Children Were Zombies | The Lori Vallow Horror Story
She Believed Her Children Were Zombies | The Lori Vallow Horror Story episode artwork
#10
06/07/2026

She was once known as a loving mother and devoted wife. But after becoming obsessed with apocalyptic prophecies and dangerous cult beliefs, Lori Vallow's life took a dark and deadly turn. As mysterious deaths began to surround her and her two children vanished without a trace, investigators uncovered a nightmare far more disturbing than anyone could have imagined. Join Jessy Lucas as we explore one of the most shocking true crime cases in modern history—a story filled with manipulation, delusion, murder, and unimaginable betrayal.

Thank you for listening to Midnight Evidence. If you enjoyed this episode, please fo...


THE NIGHT THE HUNTER BECAME THE HUNTED | A Hostage Nightmare That Shocked Police
THE NIGHT THE HUNTER BECAME THE HUNTED | A Hostage Nightmare That Shocked Police episode artwork
#9
06/07/2026

A desperate fugitive on the run, a terrified family trapped inside their own home, and a citywide manhunt racing toward a deadly conclusion. This true-crime story reveals how one violent rampage escalated into a hostage crisis that pushed police to their limits.













Thank you for listening to Midnight Evidence. If you enjoyed this episode, please follow the podcast, leave a rating, and share it with fellow true crime enthusiasts. You can find us on Spreaker and your favorite podcast platforms. Until next time, stay curious, stay...


The Woman in the Garage | A True Crime Story of Lies, Betrayal, and Murder
The Woman in the Garage | A True Crime Story of Lies, Betrayal, and Murder episode artwork
#8
06/06/2026

A grandmother disappears without a trace. Her daughter claims she's safe. Police conduct multiple welfare checks and find nothing unusual. But when investigators finally uncover the truth, they realize they were standing only feet away from a horrifying secret the entire time. Join Jessy Lucas as we unravel a case filled with deception, family conflict, and a shocking discovery that changed everything. 

Thank you for listening to Midnight Evidence. If you enjoyed this episode, please follow the podcast, leave a rating, and share it with fellow true crime enthusiasts. You can find us on Spreaker and your favorite p...


He Killed His Best Friend... Then Helped Search for Him
He Killed His Best Friend... Then Helped Search for Him episode artwork
#7
06/05/2026

Aaron Davis vanished after spending the night with his lifelong friend. As police searched for answers, they uncovered blood, disturbing messages, and a horrifying secret hidden where nobody expected. What began as a missing-person case soon became one of the most chilling betrayals imaginable.

Thank you for listening to Midnight Evidence. If you enjoyed this episode, please follow the podcast, leave a rating, and share it with fellow true crime enthusiasts. You can find us on Spreaker and your favorite podcast platforms. Until next time, stay curious, stay informed, and remember, every case leaves a trail.

...


Man horrified after learning his girlfriend evil secret
Man horrified after learning his girlfriend evil secret episode artwork
#6
06/05/2026

A rising cycling star is found brutally murdered inside a friend's home. What first appears to be a robbery quickly unravels into a chilling tale of jealousy, obsession, secret relationships, and a killer who believed she could outrun justice. Follow Jessy Lucas as she uncovers the shocking investigation that led detectives from a bloody crime scene in Texas to an international manhunt thousands of miles away. 

Thank you for listening to Midnight Evidence. If you enjoyed this episode, please follow the podcast, leave a rating, and share it with fellow true crime enthusiasts. You can find us on S...


The Monster Next Door: The Serial Killer Who Hid 4 Bodies in an Airport Parking Lot
The Monster Next Door: The Serial Killer Who Hid 4 Bodies in an Airport Parking Lot episode artwork
#5
06/04/2026

Four missing people. One abandoned truck. A serial killer hiding in plain sight. What investigators uncovered would become one of the most disturbing true-crime cases in recent history.



  multiple disappearances, hidden bodies, shocking confessions, and a killer who managed to deceive everyone around him. As detectives race against time, they uncover a trail of secrets leading to a man whose crimes were more terrifying than anyone could have imagined.Join Jessy Lucas as we dive deep into this disturbing true-crime case that proves evil can hide behind the most ordinary face.





The Stalker Who Never Existed: How a Husband Fooled Everyone
The Stalker Who Never Existed: How a Husband Fooled Everyone episode artwork
#4
06/04/2026

For months, Crystal lived in fear of a stalker who seemed to know her every move. When she was found murdered, detectives launched a nationwide hunt for the suspect. What they uncovered instead was a twisted scheme so elaborate that it fooled police, family, and even the victim herself. Hosted by Jessy Lucas, this is one of the most disturbing true crime cases of deception ever uncovered.

Thank you for listening to Midnight Evidence. If you enjoyed this episode, please follow the podcast, leave a rating, and share it with fellow true crime enthusiasts. You can find us...


She Followed Them All Night... Then Mariah Wilson Was Found Dead
She Followed Them All Night... Then Mariah Wilson Was Found Dead episode artwork
#3
06/01/2026

A rising sports star was found brutally murdered inside an Austin home. At first, it looked like a robbery. But investigators soon uncovered a dark trail of jealousy, secret relationships, surveillance footage, and a shocking love triangle. What followed was an international manhunt that ended thousands of miles from the crime scene.This is the chilling true story of Mariah Wilson's murder and the obsessive jealousy that led to a devastating tragedy.

Thank you for listening to Midnight Evidence. If you enjoyed this episode, please follow the podcast, leave a rating, and share it with fellow true crime...


If I Go Missing, It's No Accident" | The Martha Freytag Case
If I Go Missing, It's No Accident" | The Martha Freytag Case episode artwork
#2
05/31/2026

Just weeks before she disappeared, Martha Freytag made a chilling prediction. When she vanished without a trace, police dismissed the warning. But her daughter refused to give up. What followed was a terrifying investigation that led detectives to a shallow grave, a shocking confession, and one of the most haunting true-crime cases you'll ever hear.

Thank you for listening to Midnight Evidence. If you enjoyed this episode, please follow the podcast, leave a rating, and share it with fellow true crime enthusiasts. You can find us on Spreaker and your favorite podcast platforms. Until next time, stay curious...


She Practiced the Route 7 Times Before the Fatal Crash...
She Practiced the Route 7 Times Before the Fatal Crash... episode artwork
#1
05/30/2026

When a teenage girl survived a horrific crash that killed her boyfriend and friend, everyone called it a tragic accident. But investigators soon uncovered threatening messages, disturbing behavior, and a discovery hidden inside her phone that changed everything.The truth behind this case is more terrifying than anyone imagined.

Thank you for listening to Midnight Evidence. If you enjoyed this episode, please follow the podcast, leave a rating, and share it with fellow true crime enthusiasts. You can find us on Spreaker and your favorite podcast platforms. Until next time, stay curious, stay informed, and remember, every case...