Bonus Point Robbery: The Most Unfair BPS Decisions Ever

20 Episodes
Subscribe

By: 3Peaks

An in-depth exploration of the most controversial Fantasy Premier League bonus point decisions that left managers baffled and fuming. Each episode analyzes matches where stellar performances were overshadowed by questionable bonus point allocations, diving deep into the BPS scoring system's quirks and inconsistencies. This show produced by Ashley Nugnet.

✂️ Clip this podcast
Unmasking the BPS Enigma of Successful Penalty Takers
Unmasking the BPS Enigma of Successful Penalty Takers episode artwork
Today at 11:29 AM

Penalty kicks can be game-changers, yet the BPS system's treatment of successful penalty takers often leaves Fantasy Premier League managers puzzled. This episode will analyze instances where players who have scored from the spot have been left out in the cold when it comes to bonus points. We'll examine the BPS system's valuation of penalty goals, comparing it to other on-pitch contributions, and discuss potential amendments that could better reward these high-pressure moments.


The Unrewarded Workhorses When Midfielders Run the Show
The Unrewarded Workhorses When Midfielders Run the Show episode artwork
06/16/2026

In this exploration, we turn our attention to the tireless midfielders who cover every blade of grass but often find themselves overlooked in the BPS system. We'll analyze matches where these workhorses dominated the game with their relentless running, ball recoveries, and interceptions, yet found themselves short-changed in the bonus point allocation. We'll question the BPS system's valuation of these crucial contributions and discuss potential amendments that could better reward these unsung heroes of the pitch.


When Offside Goals Alter the BPS Landscape
When Offside Goals Alter the BPS Landscape episode artwork
06/09/2026

This episode uncovers the intriguing impact of offside goals on the BPS system. We'll scrutinize matches where goals were disallowed due to offside, yet significantly influenced the bonus point allocation. By focusing on specific instances where Fantasy Premier League managers were left bewildered by the BPS outcome, we'll explore the system's handling of offside goals and its implications for player rewards. The episode will also propose potential amendments to the BPS system to address this perplexing issue.


When Winning Isn't Winning: The BPS Quirk in Draws
When Winning Isn't Winning: The BPS Quirk in Draws episode artwork
06/02/2026

This episode explores the peculiar trend of players from winning teams missing out on bonus points in drawn matches. We'll analyze specific instances where players who scored equalizing goals or made key contributions to level the scoreline were overlooked in the BPS allocation. We'll also examine the BPS system's weighting of match outcomes and its impact on player rewards, while discussing potential adjustments to ensure a fairer distribution of points.


The Injury Time Injustice: When Late Goals Skew the BPS
The Injury Time Injustice: When Late Goals Skew the BPS episode artwork
05/26/2026

In this episode, we delve into the world of injury-time goals and their disproportionate impact on the BPS. We'll explore instances where last-minute goals have not only changed the outcome of the match, but also drastically altered the bonus point distribution, leaving Fantasy Premier League managers in disbelief. Join us as we dissect the BPS system's treatment of injury-time goals and discuss whether it's fair or flawed.


The Tackle Titan's Tragedy: When Defensive Heroics Go Unnoticed
The Tackle Titan's Tragedy: When Defensive Heroics Go Unnoticed episode artwork
05/18/2026

In this episode, we delve into the overlooked realm of defensive midfielders and their often-unrewarded contributions to the game. We'll analyze some of the most baffling BPS decisions where crucial tackles, interceptions, and blocks were seemingly ignored, leaving Fantasy Premier League managers questioning the system's fairness. Join us as we dissect the BPS's treatment of defensive midfielders and explore potential improvements to the scoring system.


The Captain's Curse: When Double Points Don't Deliver
The Captain's Curse: When Double Points Don't Deliver episode artwork
05/11/2026

In this episode, we delve into the frustrating world of captaincy in Fantasy Premier League. We'll analyze instances where the most popular captain choices failed to deliver, despite promising fixtures and form, and how these decisions impacted the BPS and overall scores. We'll also discuss the psychology behind these choices, the risk vs reward debate, and the potential ways to navigate this tricky aspect of the game.


The Assist Anomaly: When Key Passes Don't Make the Cut
The Assist Anomaly: When Key Passes Don't Make the Cut episode artwork
05/04/2026

In this episode, we delve into the overlooked world of assists in the BPS system. Despite their crucial role in game-changing moments, assists often go unrewarded in the bonus point system. We'll analyze some of the most glaring instances where playmakers were robbed of their rightful bonus points, and discuss the possible reasons behind this anomaly.


The Goalkeeper's Gambit: When Saves Don't Save the Day
The Goalkeeper's Gambit: When Saves Don't Save the Day episode artwork
04/27/2026

In this episode, we delve into the paradoxical world of goalkeepers in the BPS system. Despite making numerous saves and showcasing incredible performances, why do they often miss out on bonus points? We'll analyze specific matches where goalkeepers' heroic efforts were overlooked, and discuss potential improvements to the BPS system to better reward these unsung heroes.


The Substitution Scandal: When Bench Points Steal the Show
The Substitution Scandal: When Bench Points Steal the Show episode artwork
04/24/2026

In this episode, we delve into the contentious world of substitute players and their impact on the BPS. We'll explore instances where a substitute's brief yet impactful performance led to a surprising bonus point allocation, leaving managers both amazed and frustrated. Join us as we dissect the BPS system's treatment of substitute players and its implications for Fantasy Premier League strategy.


The Unseen Heroes: The Underappreciated Role of Full-Backs in BPS
The Unseen Heroes: The Underappreciated Role of Full-Backs in BPS episode artwork
#10
03/29/2026

In this episode, we delve into the often overlooked role of full-backs in the BPS system. Despite their crucial contributions to both defense and attack, these players frequently miss out on bonus points. We'll analyze key matches and player performances to highlight this discrepancy and discuss potential improvements to the BPS system to better recognize full-backs.


The Striker's Struggle: When Goals Don't Guarantee Glory
The Striker's Struggle: When Goals Don't Guarantee Glory episode artwork
#9
02/08/2026

In this episode, we delve into the perplexing world of strikers, where scoring goals doesn't always equate to bonus points. We'll analyze specific matches where top-tier strikers were left without bonus points despite their goal-scoring feats, highlighting the inconsistencies within the BPS system. Join us as we dissect the scoring system and discuss potential improvements to ensure fair recognition of every player's contributions.


The System's Breaking Point: When BPS Gets It Completely Wrong
The System's Breaking Point: When BPS Gets It Completely Wrong episode artwork
#8
01/03/2025

A critical examination of the most egregious BPS decisions in Fantasy Premier League history. The episode analyzes multiple matches where the bonus point allocation seemed to completely contradict the eye test and match statistics. We explore potential improvements to the system and how it might be reformed to better reflect actual player performance, including expert opinions from FPL analysts and professional football statisticians.


The Set-Piece Specialists: Corner Kings Without Crowns
The Set-Piece Specialists: Corner Kings Without Crowns episode artwork
#7
12/13/2024

Investigating how set-piece specialists often miss out on bonus points despite creating multiple high-quality chances. The episode focuses on players like James Ward-Prowse and Trent Alexander-Arnold, analyzing matches where their set-piece excellence went unrewarded in the BPS system. We examine how corner kicks, free kicks, and their resulting chances are valued compared to other actions.


The Pass Master's Paradox: When Possession Doesn't Pay
The Pass Master's Paradox: When Possession Doesn't Pay episode artwork
#6
11/22/2024

Analyzing matches where players with exceptional passing statistics and possession control missed out on bonus points. The episode examines specific games where midfield controllers like Thiago and Rodri dominated possession but received minimal BPS recognition. We investigate how the system weighs possession metrics against more direct attacking and defensive contributions.


The Midfielder's Dilemma: Creating vs. Scoring
The Midfielder's Dilemma: Creating vs. Scoring episode artwork
#5
11/01/2024

Exploring cases where creative midfielders lost bonus points despite dominating play and providing multiple assists. The episode focuses on specific matches where players like Kevin De Bruyne and Bruno Fernandes recorded multiple assists but lost bonus points due to BPS calculations favoring other metrics. We analyze how the system sometimes undervalues creative contributions compared to goals and defensive actions.


Defensive Masterclass or BPS Manipulation?
Defensive Masterclass or BPS Manipulation? episode artwork
#4
10/11/2024

An investigation into how defenders accumulate BPS points through various actions, focusing on matches where defensive players secured bonus points despite their team conceding goals. We examine specific cases where center-backs and full-backs accumulated high BPS scores through pass completion and clearances, even in defeats. The episode highlights the potential flaws in how defensive actions are weighted in the BPS system.


The Kane Conspiracy: When Hat-Tricks Don't Count
The Kane Conspiracy: When Hat-Tricks Don't Count episode artwork
#3
09/20/2024

A detailed examination of Harry Kane's hat-trick against Burnley in 2017 where he lost bonus points to defensive players. The episode analyzes how missed chances and passing accuracy negatively impacted Kane's BPS score, while exploring the broader pattern of strikers losing bonus points despite scoring multiple goals. We investigate the statistical anomalies and system biases that led to this controversial decision.


Clean Sheet Supremacy: The GK Bonus Point Phenomenon
Clean Sheet Supremacy: The GK Bonus Point Phenomenon episode artwork
#2
08/30/2024

Investigating the controversial trend of goalkeepers securing maximum bonus points in low-scoring games despite minimal involvement. The episode focuses on specific matches where goalkeepers with just 2-3 saves earned maximum bonus points over attackers with goal contributions. We analyze the BPS weighting system for goalkeeper actions and how it sometimes creates unfair advantages.


The Great Salah Heist of 2018: When 4 Goals Weren't Enough
The Great Salah Heist of 2018: When 4 Goals Weren't Enough episode artwork
#1
08/09/2024

An analysis of Mohamed Salah's incredible four-goal performance against Watford in March 2018, where despite his historic achievement, he barely secured bonus points. The episode examines how the BPS system weighted his missed chances against his goals, comparing it to similar performances that received maximum bonus. We deep dive into the technical aspects of how passing accuracy and defensive actions from other players influenced the final BPS allocation.