Crime Daddies

Crime Daddies Tip Line: Volume 5 is here, and this time we're digging into two disturbing chapters of Missouri history.

Hunter takes us to St. Louis to cover Maury Travis, the serial killer whose crimes shocked the region in the early 2000s. As investigators worked to connect a series of murders, a chilling letter and a map sent to a local newspaper helped lead authorities to Travis. The investigation uncovered horrifying evidence and left investigators with lingering questions about the true number of his victims.

Then Jacob takes us back to the 1840s in Jackson, Missouri...

Some horror movies are meant to scare us. But what happens when someone decides to take that fiction and turn it into reality?

This week on Crime Daddies, Hunter tells Jacob the heartbreaking story of Cassie Jo Stoddart, a 16-year-old Idaho high school student whose life was brutally cut short in September 2006. What should have been an ordinary weekend house-sitting for family turned into a real-life nightmare that shocked a community and left a lasting impact on everyone who heard her story.

At the center of this case were two teenagers fascinated by horror movies...

October isn't over yet, and neither is our spooky season! This week, Crime Daddies is bringing you another Halloween crime that proves real life can be stranger, and far more disturbing, than any scary movie.

On Halloween night in 2011, a dispute over something as simple as a bag of missing Halloween candy turned deadly. Jacob tells Hunter the story of Ledell Peoples and Maria Adams, whose argument escalated into a violent attack that ultimately cost Maria her life.

What should have been an ordinary Halloween turned into a horrifying tragedy, leaving behind a case that...

THE BOOGIE WOODS

If you're from Southeast Missouri, chances are you've heard of the Boogie Woods.

It's the kind of place that seems to have a story for everything. Strange things seen between the trees. Ghosts, unexplained noises, mysterious figures, and enough local legends to make you think twice about heading into the woods after dark.

But underneath all of those stories is something very real.

In this episode of Crime Daddies, Hunter takes Jacob into the Boogie Woods of Southeast Missouri to talk about the real crime that helped cement...

BONUS EPISODE: THE CORNELL 7

This isn't a normal Crime Daddies episode.

We're still talking true crime, but this time we're talking about it as two dads — and what happens when a story makes you look at your own kids and ask, "What can I do to make sure they're safe?"

In this bonus episode, Jacob and Hunter discuss the allegations surrounding the Cornell 7 — a case involving a former Cornell University student who alleges that she was drugged and sexually assaulted by seven members of the Chi Phi fraternity in October 2024. The allegations are the...

What would you do if you found out your wife's lover had been secretly living in your attic for years?

Yeah… that's not a hypothetical.

This week on Crime Daddies, Jacob tells Hunter one of the strangest true-crime stories to come out of 1920s Los Angeles — the bizarre love triangle involving Fred Oesterreich, his wife Dolly, and Otto Sanhuber, the man who secretly lived in the attic of their home.

The story begins years before the murder, when Dolly meets Otto, a teenage sewing-machine repairman who works at Fred's factory. What starts as an a...

The Crime Daddies Tip Line is back, and this episode takes us into three very different cases involving women whose stories deserve to be heard.

Jacob kicks things off with two cases from Dunklin County, Missouri: Angel Avery and Michelle Anders. He digs into the circumstances surrounding their stories, the investigations, and the questions that remain along the way.

Then Hunter takes over to tell the story of Gina Dawn Brooks, another case filled with unanswered questions, strange circumstances, and a story that sticks with you long after you hear it.

Three women...

The Crime Daddies delve into the 'Most Badass Dad Ever' case, unfolding the tragic events that occurred in Oakley, Utah. Rolf's survival and escape are highlighted, along with the psychological evaluation and legal process. The jury selection and legal challenges add complexity to the case. The conversation covers the trial, penalty phase, and sentencing of Taylor and Delhi, as well as the impact on the family and the legal developments that followed. It also explores themes of survival, resilience, and the impact of the crime on the victims and their loved ones.

Takeaways

This week, Jacob takes Hunter on a deep dive into the disturbing story of Kelly Cochran—a woman whose ordinary Midwestern life eventually unraveled into murder, manipulation, and a trail of conflicting stories.

After moving to Michigan with her husband Jason, Kelly began an affair with coworker Chris Regan. What followed was a deadly chain of events involving a supposed “murder pact,” Chris's disappearance, his remains being hidden in the Michigan wilderness, and eventually Jason's own death.

But Kelly wasn't done telling her story. As investigators closed in, she changed her story again and again, leavin...

In 1977, four teenagers were pulled over at Fort Leonard Wood by Military Policeman Johnny Lee Thornton. He told them their car matched the description of a robbery suspect—but there was one problem: the robbery never happened.

What followed was a terrifying night that left three teenagers dead and one survivor, Juanita Deckard, fighting to stay alive in the freezing Missouri woods.

This week, Hunter tells Jacob the story of Thornton, the evidence that eventually exposed him, his bizarre insanity defense, and the disturbing questions about whether he may have been connected to ot...

The Crime Daddies are back with some more listener submitted Tip Line stories. The main focus of the episode is on three Missouri mysteries: the story of Gail Sherry King, the unsolved mystery of Alton Lake Jane Doe, and the disappearance of Megan Latham.

Then, the podcast episode delves into the story of Rosemary Taylor Sisk, a woman from Bernie, Missouri, whose life was tragically cut short. It explores the details of her relationships, the events leading up to her shooting, the trial, and the aftermath. The episode also reflects on the impact of domestic violence and...

This week your Crime Daddies begin discuss the history and ambiance of Savannah, Georgia, setting the stage for the main case. The chapter concludes with the lead-up to the fatal confrontation between Jim Williams and Danny Hansford.

The Mercer House murder case involves the shooting of Danny Hansford by Jim Williams, leading to four trials and a controversial verdict. The case has sparked public interest, inspired a best-selling book, and influenced tourism in Savannah. The story raises questions about self-defense, manipulation of evidence, and the influence of social connections.

Takeaways

The boys begin this episode with a discussion about the Ozarks and its historical significance. It then transitions into the story of Alis Ben Johns, a fugitive and serial killer, and his violent acts in central Missouri. The narrative covers his confrontations, escapes, and the escalating danger he poses to the community.

A six-month crime spree in Missouri led to a series of violent incidents, including robberies, home invasions, and murders, committed by fugitive Alis Ben Johns. The capture of Johns ended the violence, but the story remains a chilling reminder of how quickly violence can spread...

On this episode of Crime Daddies, Jacob shares a horror story he first heard in college—that just blocks away from his dorm in Murray, Kentucky, was the birthplace of a cult led by a self-proclaimed 500-year-old vampire. Creepy local legend... or was he just an idiot for believing it?

As it turns out, the truth is far more disturbing.

Join us as we unravel the infamous case of the Kentucky Vampire Clan and its leader, Rod Ferrell. We explore how a group of teenagers became consumed by fantasy, the brutal double homicide that shocked Fl...

The conversation this week comes from you the listeners as the boys hop into another edition of their Crime Daddies Tip Line podcast, the setting of Poplar Bluff, Missouri, crime statistics and comparison, the murder of Tommy Rowland, the investigation and prosecution, the Midwest Mafia and organized crime, challenges in solving the case, and the murder of Cecil and Ethel Phillips in Malden in the 1990s.

The conversation delves into the shocking discovery of a crime scene, the investigation process, and the subsequent trial and verdict. It explores the significance of circumstantial evidence and the meticulous process...

Imagine living in a place you’ve called home for years, surrounded by friendly neighbors, children playing outside, and a sense of belonging. Then, one day, everything changes when you discover that the ground beneath your feet is literally toxic. This is the haunting reality of Times Beach, Missouri—a town that, due to corporate negligence, was wiped off the map. In this post, we will explore the chilling story of how one community fell victim to environmental disaster and what it means for us today.

Takeaways

In today’s episode, we dive deep into Malden, Missouri—a seemingly quiet town hiding a chilling history.

From its origins shaped by railroads to the devastating tornado that struck in 2018, Malden's facade masks a darker truth. We explore the 1981 double murder that shocked the community, revealing how crime intertwines with the fabric of small-town life.

Join us as we unravel the unsettling events and the chilling confessions of the perpetrator. It’s a reminder that beneath calm exteriors, profound stories often lie in wait.

Takeaways

Stockholm Syndrome has become a buzzword we hear everywhere, but do we really understand its roots? Most of us associate it with emotional attachment to abusers, but it’s more complicated than that.

Researchers now view it as a survival response to prolonged trauma, where fear and dependency blur the lines between love and harm.

In today’s episode, we dive into a shocking case that illustrates this phenomenon.

How do we separate love from fear in our relationships?

Takeaways

Meet Robert Eugene Brashers, a man who lived under the radar, committing terrible crimes while the world remained oblivious. From a near-fatal attack on a young woman to becoming a prime suspect in the infamous yogurt shop murders, his chilling story unfolds like a thriller.

But what made him different? Most serial killers leave warning signs, yet Brashers blended in, leaving authorities scrambling to connect the dots for decades.

His tale is a haunting reminder of how darkness can hide in plain sight.

What do you think?

Takeaways

The first official episode of the Crime Daddies Tip Line covers a tragic case in Bon Terre, Missouri, involving multiple victims and a complex web of relationships. The case challenges our understanding of family and the devastating impact of mental illness and domestic issues.

The 2nd story takes us to Essex, Missouri, a small town with a close-knit community. It delves into the psychological theories of Sigmund Freud, particularly the Oedipus Complex, and the impact of childhood relationships on adult behavior. The case involves elder abuse and the tragic death of an 83-year-old woman, Nadine...

Today, we’re talking about a shocking event from our hometown - the Red Fox Lounge shootout in Dexter, Missouri. On July 17, 1982, a group of friends turned on each other in a tragic moment fueled by paranoia and distrust.

In a place where everyone knows everyone, how could friends become foes? This isn’t just a story about crime; it’s about community, trust, and the dark undercurrents that can run beneath the surface.

Maybe that’s the real lesson: sometimes, the most familiar faces can hide the deepest secrets.

🔗 Listen to the full episod...

In the world of true crime, some stories stand out for their sheer horror and the chilling circumstances surrounding them. One such case is that of the Kitterman family, which took place in Grandin, Missouri, in 1973. In this episode, we will unravel the events that led to this tragic incident, exploring the background of the family, the details of the crime, and the investigation that followed. This case serves as a haunting reminder of the fragility of life and the mysteries that can surround a crime.

Takeaways

<...

When you grow up in tough circumstances, it shapes your decisions and outlook on life. It can lead to feelings of hopelessness and even crime.

Brenda Smith's story highlights this reality. Her life was filled with love and warmth, yet she faced the harshness of her environment.

Every decision made under pressure can lead to consequences that echo through generations. It’s essential to understand the context behind actions.

Listen to the full story and reflect on how our backgrounds shape our choices.

Takeaways

In December 1969, two friends living together in St. Charles, Missouri, had their lives turned upside down. After a day of silence, their coworkers sent someone to check on them, only to uncover a horrifying scene.

The investigation revealed not just a tragic end, but the complexities of friendship, responsibility, and the shadows lurking in everyday life.

Why does it always seem like the best people are the ones who face the worst?

Takeaways

On December 18, 1994, Allison was just getting home from a night out, but her life took a terrifying turn when she was attacked in her own car. With a knife held against her, she was forced into a nightmare that would test her will to survive.

What happened next was horrifying. Two men, already facing serious charges, assaulted her and left her for dead after a brutal attack that would leave most people without hope.

But Allison wasn’t ready to give up. Against all odds, she fought through unimaginable pain, crawling to safety while holding he...

In this quick 5 minute announcement episode, we’re introducing two new parts of Crime Daddies.

The Tip Line is now open for listeners to suggest cases they think we should look into. We ask that submissions include your name, email address, and at least two sources so we can keep future case suggestions organized and responsible.

We’re also introducing the Crime Daddies Digest, our monthly newsletter where we’ll share updates, corrections, follow ups, behind the scenes notes, and anything else we want our listeners to know.

This is a short update, but it...

This episode delves into the complex case of Mischelle Lawless, exploring the investigation, evidence, witness accounts, and ongoing questions surrounding her tragic death in 1992. Hunter & Jacob discuss the case's details, potential suspects, and the quest for justice that continues decades later.

Takeaways

Chapters

Imagine opening up a McDonald's for your shift, only to have someone drop in from the ceiling. Sounds like a movie, right? This was the reality for many employees who encountered the notorious Roof Man, who orchestrated his heists with unsettling calmness.

He didn’t just break in; he’d spend hours hiding, waiting for the right moment to make his move. Instead of chaos, he brought a bizarre sense of control to the situation. He’d joke with employees, even suggesting they grab a jacket before locking them in a freezer!

Why does this matter...

Today, we're diving into the dark world of Timothy Krajcir, the "bandana rapist" who turned a quiet river town into a scene from a nightmare.

From his troubled childhood to his horrifying crimes, this is a story that will leave you questioning how well you really know the people around you.

Join us as we unravel the chilling details of a man who lived a double life—one as a caring EMT and another as a brutal predator.

Takeaways

This is the tragic story of Miranda Dowdy, a 12-year-old girl from Poplar Bluff who was supposed to be safe with family but met a horrific fate.

In August 2005, while staying with relatives, Miranda vanished one night. Time passed, and when she was reported missing, the search turned dire.

Her body was found in a barn, and the details shook the community: 34 stab wounds and signs of a violent struggle.

What makes this even more chilling is that her cousin was the last known person with her. This case is a stark reminder...

Today, we dive into the mysterious disappearance of Lynn Marie Messer. On July 8, 2014, she vanished from her family farm under suspicious circumstances. Her husband claimed she left without a trace, but evidence suggested something more sinister at play.

As we peel back the layers, the story reveals inconsistencies and unsettling truths: a suicide note that raises eyebrows, a family fighting to find answers, and a shocking discovery nearly two years later.

What does this say about the lives we portray? Sometimes, the truth is buried beneath the surface.

Takeaways

It all started on January 24th, 2006, when Dale Butler returned home after work to find his wife Teresa missing, leaving their young sons unattended. Panic set in as the clues unfolded: no signs of forced entry, yet valuables were gone.

What happened next is a tangled web of deceit, drugs, and a chilling confession that will leave you questioning everything. 🕵️‍♂️

Join us as we unravel the mystery that haunted a small town for years.

Takeaways

Chapters

Hunter and Jacob this week dive into a tragedy that happened just floors below where they’re sitting right now.

Inside the Las Vegas Hilton, now known as the Westgate, a fire broke out on February 10, 1981, and quickly turned into a disaster that killed eight people and injured hundreds more.

At first, a young busboy was seen as a hero. He reported the fire, tried to stop it, and warned guests. But as investigators began digging deeper, his story started to change.

And what they uncovered raised a much bigger question. Was...

The episode delves into the life and crimes of Tommy Lynn Sales, a nomadic serial killer with a troubled childhood. It explores his criminal activities, arrests, and imprisonment, as well as the murders he was connected to and convicted of. The episode also provides insights into the psychology and behavior of serial killers, shedding light on the disturbing nature of their crimes. The conversation delves into the chilling details of Tommy Lynn Sells, a prolific serial killer known for his geographical transience and a trail of gruesome murders across the United States. The chapters cover his crimes, the impact...

Hunter and Jacob take you back to 1961 Odessa, Texas, where a case unfolds that still leaves more questions than answers.

In this episode, you can expect a deep dive into the life of 17-year-old Betty Williams, from her home life and emotional struggles to the way she was perceived in a small, tightly wound community that didn’t quite know what to do with her. We walk through her relationship with John “Mack” Herring, the breakup that changed everything, and the warning signs that, looking back, feel impossible to ignore.

From there, we break down the ni...

Two women were found brutally murdered in a quiet Missouri town… and the man responsible thought he could outsmart everyone.

In this episode of Crime Daddies, Jacob and Hunter dive into the chilling case out of Tallapoosa, Missouri, where a broken relationship, drugs, and a carefully planned escape turned into something far more sinister.

We break down the full timeline from the tension between Shirley and Cecil, to the night everything changed, and the horrifying discovery that followed. From there, we walk through Cecil Barriner’s actions after the murders, his shifting story, his denial, and...

The Crime Daddies podcast hosts, Hunter and Jacob, introduce themselves and share their background, including their shared passion for true crime. The conversation covers their childhood experiences with true crime, their similar backgrounds, and their motivation for starting the podcast.

Takeaways

Chapters

Hunter & Jacob introduce themselves as the "Crime Daddies," two dads from Missouri with a fascination for true crime. In this trailer episode, they talk about what inspired them to start the podcast, the types of cases they plan to cover, and the perspective they bring to these stories.

While the cases are often dark and disturbing, the Crime Daddies approach them with honest reactions, real conversation, and a little dark humor along the way.

This is the beginning of Crime Daddies.

Topics in this episode