That Wasn't The Plan
That Wasn't The Plan Human stories for those struggling to be human.A podcast for anyone whose life took a left turn when you were peacefully asleep. Life doesn't come with a script—thank god, because ours would've been returned for rewrites.Warning: May cause unexpected feelings, snort-laughing, and the overwhelming urge to text us your own "that wasn't the plan" story.Join co-hosts Emily White and Courtney Holland as they navigate the beautiful disasters, plot twists, and "well, that happened" moments that nobody warned you about. From bed bugs, winning the lottery, breaking your neck, and finding a furry lum...
The Woman Who Convinced England’s Doctors She Was Giving Birth to Rabbits - ft. Mary Toft
Send us Fan Mail
November 15, 1726. A small stuffy room in Guildford, Surrey. The King of England’s personal surgeon has traveled down from London — with a gentleman from the Prince of Wales’s household — to watch a 23-year-old farm worker give birth.
To a rabbit.
And within a few hours, he believes she does.
This week we share the story of Mary Toft — the woman who fooled England’s top doctors, scandalized the royal court, and ended up with the word rabbit written next to her name in the parish recor...
I Thought I Was Biting Her Leg - ft. Matt Holland
Send us Fan Mail
It was 3 a.m. He was 22 years old, drunk, and running toward the water at the lake house with his friend Michelle.
Then he dove in.
The lake was shallower than he thought. He felt his head press into the sand and roll. And just like that — in less than 30 seconds — Matt Holland was paralyzed.
This week we’re going back to the vault — one of Emily’s all-time favorite episodes from Season 1 — because some stories are too good to only hear once. Matt Holland, Courtney’s younger brothe...
The Princess Who Collected Egos, A Bird Without Wings - The Story of Khutulun
Send us Fan Mail
In 1280, a prince rode to a royal palace in Central Asia with a thousand horses and a plan to win a wife. He was handsome, wealthy, and by every measure of his time, a very good match. Her parents quietly begged her to let him win.
She threw him on the palace pavement.
This week Emily goes solo with the story of Khutulun — great-great-granddaughter of Genghis Khan, undefeated wrestler, cavalry commander, and the woman who turned down marriage proposals into the most audacious wealth-building strategy the Mongolian st...
Five Stars, Would Not Recommend ft. Annie Edson Taylor
Send us Fan Mail
On October 24th, 1901 — her sixty-third birthday — a retired schoolteacher named Annie Edson Taylor climbed into an oak barrel the size of a pickle cask, had the lid screwed down, had air pumped in with a bicycle pump, and was pushed into the current above Niagara Falls.
Nobody had ever survived going over those falls. Annie knew that. She didn’t care. She had a plan.
This week Emily goes solo again with the extraordinary true story of the first person in history to go over Niagara Falls in a barrel...
The Girls Who Fooled Sherlock Holmes
Send us Fan Mail
In July 1917, a nine-year-old girl named Frances kept falling into a stream in Yorkshire and coming home with wet shoes. When the grown-ups asked why she kept going down there, she said she went to see the fairies. Her sixteen-year-old cousin Elsie — an art student who happened to live in a house with a darkroom under the stairs — said: fine, we’ll prove it.
What happened next fooled newspapers, photography experts, theosophists, and the man who invented the most famous detective mind in the world. It also cost two little girls a secr...
From the Vault: Bed Bugs ft. Dr. Dini Miller
Send us Fan Mail
Emily's on the road this week, so we're pulling one of our favorite early episodes out of the vault — originally released as Episode 6 back in Season 1, when Dr. Dini Miller became our very first-ever TWTP guest. We're re-releasing it for all of you who found the show in Season 2 and haven't dug back yet. If you've ever found a weird bug in your sheets and spiraled on the internet for three hours, this one's for you.
Dr. Dini Miller is a professor at Virginia Tech, an internationally recognized expert in urban pe...
Is Anything Okay? Sunday Brunch Vol 1 - ft. Becky Smith
Send us Fan Mail
Welcome to Sunday Brunch — a new TWTP format where Emily and Courtney invite a friend to the table to talk about the thing that's eating all of us at the same time. For our first one, we called in Becky Smith.
Becky is Emily's longtime close friend, a healthcare provider, and — most importantly for today — a woman who, within the span of about four months, dropped her only son off at college, watched her feisty 82-year-old mother fall twice (once at Becky's own house, once days after college drop-off), and became the so...
What Would Binti Jua Do? - ft. Rescue Animals
Send us Fan Mail
No guest this week — just Emily and Courtney, a rainy day, some research, and an hour of the purest content this podcast has ever produced: animals doing extraordinary things for humans, for each other, and sometimes just because.
This one started with the 9/11 anniversary, a story about rescue dogs, and a myth about beavers keeping a little boy warm. It ended with a dolphin in New Zealand talking two stranded whales home to open ocean. In between: lions in Ethiopia, a sea lion off the Golden Gate Bridge, a gorilla named Bi...
See Something, Say Something - ft. Dena Smiley
Send us Fan Mail
Everything you think you know about human trafficking is probably wrong.
Dena Smiley is Chairman of the Board at Blazing Hope Ranch — a Tennessee-based Christian residential ministry that provides free two-year aftercare, equine-assisted healing, job training, and (for every graduate) a donated car and support finding a home, all for women over 30 who have survived sex trafficking. In 2025, Blazing Hope became the first gold-standard-certified safe house in the state of Tennessee.
Dena didn't plan any of this. She grew up in suburban Southern California, went to UC Sa...
I Woke Up In A Jail Cell - ft. Kurt Kemple
Send us Fan Mail
(We open with a spirited debate about sweet potatoes and mayonnaise. Courtney flashes the camera. Miracle Whip is described as the devil's sauce. And then somehow we pivot to one of the most remarkable guests we've ever had on this show. This is That Wasn't The Plan.)
This week Emily and Courtney sit down with Kurt Kemple — and we need you to hold two things in your head at once.
In 2004, Kurt walked into a bank, slid a note across to the teller, and left with $2,000. He ha...
A Field Guide To Not Dying
Send us Fan Mail
Do I Smell Almonds?
No guest this week — just Emily and Courtney, one gorilla-glued tooth, and a three a.m. Google spiral that took a hard turn into poisons.
What starts as Courtney describing the ongoing chemistry experiment happening in her mouth turns into a tour of everything that can kill you and a lot of things that probably won't. We're talking the top three most poisonous poisons (spoiler: fentanyl is #1, and Buddhism has its own list). Women who spent centuries poisoning husbands because divorce wasn't a th...
Nobody Here Knows Me ft. Annie Elmendorf
Send us Fan Mail
What happens when the story you've been telling yourself for ten years unravels over a single glass of wine on the other side of the world?
Annie Elmendorf is a mother of two, a cyclist, an athlete, and a sister. She's also — as she'll tell you herself — someone who has spent most of her life trying to feel at home in her own body. This is a solo episode with Emily; Courtney couldn't make it. And the story Annie tells is one Annie has never told publicly before.
It star...
Knowledge Artist ft. Dr. Patty Brennan
Send us Fan Mail
"Send me all the genitals" ft. Dr. Patty Brennan
What do you do when the wildest sentence of your career is "I was sure it was a worm"?
Dr. Patty Brennan is a Colombian-born, Cornell-trained evolutionary biologist, a full Professor of Biological Sciences at Mount Holyoke College, and the world's leading expert on vertebrate genital coevolution. She's been featured in The New York Times, National Geographic, Scientific American, The Guardian, Slate, and NPR — and she's a featured scientist in the upcoming documentary Second Nature, narrated by Elliot Pag...
Gen X, Empty Nesters, and A Very Quiet Drive Home ft. Lucas Smith
Send us Fan Mail
What happens when the paperwork for your son's college applications cracks open something you thought you'd buried 35 years ago?
Lucas Smith is a Colorado-native-turned-Seattleite, a software engineer of 15+ years working at the intersection of AI and tech, a multi-instrumentalist, an avid cyclist, a master of the smoker (the grill kind), and the host of the Not Retired Yet podcast. And in about a month, he and his wife are driving their only son six hours south and dropping him off at college.
What was supposed to be college paperwork...
Big Cat Energy ft Daisy Fulgham - Board Certified Sexologist, Sex and Relationship Coach and Wardrobe Stylist
Send us Fan Mail
This week Emily and Courtney sit down with Daisy Fulgham — wardrobe stylist turned sex and relationship coach, devoted wife of 34 years, mother of two, and the woman who, at 54, Googled "sex coaching programs," sat down with her husband, and signed up before she could talk herself out of it. After the first weekend she was completely hooked. After this episode, you will be too.
Daisy is warm, funny, disarmingly wise, and absolutely not here to talk about what you think she's here to talk about. Because this isn't really ab...
Oh Canada, We See You (And We Love You)
Send us Fan Mail
Turns out That Wasn't The Plan is basically a Canadian podcast at this point. Toronto, Vancouver, Montreal, Calgary, Edmonton — you all showed up before anyone south of the border figured out what was happening. So Emily and Courtney decided to do the only reasonable thing: dedicate an entire episode to the Great White North.
Courtney, for the record, is a dual citizen. Born in Newfoundland on a military base. Canada was apparently on the edge of their seat waiting to find out whether she'd claim it. Life happened. She forgot. She fo...
She Grabbed the Shark's Snout
Send us Fan Mail
Welcome back. Season 2. We opened with a tiger shark. Seemed right.
That Wasn't The Plan is back for Season 2 — and we are not easing anyone in gently. Our first guest is Kinga Philipps: journalist, explorer, Shark Week host, Explorers Club Fellow, and one of the coolest humans on the planet. If you don't know Kinga yet, you're about to.
We start where you'd expect — with a flight cancellation. Emily spent the night on the floor of LAX, made it to Australia, made it back, and showed up for...
Season One Finale: 25 Episodes, A Cliffhanger, and a Flying Tooth
Send us Fan Mail
Happy 25th episode, everybody — and welcome to the Season One Finale of That Wasn't The Plan.
Emily and Courtney sit down to close out Season 1 the only way they know how: completely unscripted, slightly unhinged, and somehow still kind of profound. Courtney opens with a literal cliffhanger, lands the plane on a calm, clear decision about her own health at 46, and then the two of them spend the rest of the episode doing what they do best — laughing, oversharing, and somehow turning a discussion about late-night jelly bean habits into...
I Want a Shit Ton of Kids ft. Jonathan Fitzgerald
Send us Fan Mail
This week's guest, Jonathan Fitzgerald, showed up with a life story that none of us were fully prepared for.
Jonathan grew up the middle child of ten in Sarasota, Florida, in a family that could only be described as a force of nature. His parents — both only children, for the record — moved to Virginia to help found a Bible college and wound up with 48 grandchildren. His father delivered seven of the ten kids at home after reading nine books on childbirth, built a prototype birthing chair in his garage, and...
Napster + Arctic weirdos + Classroom bliss = Richard Ault; in a nutshell...
Send us Fan Mail
(We open with Courtney's puppy accidentally getting marijuana poisoning. This is relevant because it sets the tone perfectly for an episode about a man whose life has taken approximately seventeen unexpected turns.)
This week's guest is Richard Ault — and his coworkers call him the most interesting person in the world. After about ten minutes, Emily and Courtney stopped arguing with that assessment.
Richard is a biologist by training, a technologist by accident, and a high school teacher by something that can only be described as the universe in...
Shirts in Your Pants & Other Moral Dilemmas
Send us Fan Mail
No guest. No agenda. No plan. Just Emily and Courtney showing up, catching each other up on their weeks, and somehow covering: shoplifting ethics, a stolen Power Ranger backpack, a suspicious kid at Target, toad venom, recovery, sitting with your feelings, and a stroller left alone in a parking lot that may or may not have had a baby in it.
This is one of those episodes that was never supposed to be anything — and ends up being kind of everything. Grab a coffee, put your earbuds in, and hang out wi...
We Don't Move On. We Move With. ft. Lindsay Brockman
Send us Fan Mail
(Courtney's back, everyone. Let the drinks flow. Also — Courtney's tooth made a brief unscheduled disappearance. We kept it in. You're welcome.)
This week, Emily and Courtney sit down with someone doing some of the most quietly essential work in grief support: Lindsay Brockman, licensed veterinary nurse, certified pet loss grief specialist, and founder of EverKin Pet Loss Support out of Richmond, Virginia. Lindsay has fifteen years across ER, end-of-life, and community animal medicine — and she's seen firsthand what happens when the humans in those exam rooms are left...
Endometriosis: Painful Periods Are Not Normal ft. Hilary Pawlik
Send us Fan Mail
(Fair warning: Emily's mouth was fully uncensored this episode — blame the tech gremlins. Also, our earrings nearly derailed the whole thing. You'll hear it. We kept it in.)
This week, Emily's co-host Courtney Holland is out due to an emergency — but honestly, today's guest doesn't need a wingman. Hilary Morris Pawlik has been Emily's ride-or-die since the eighth grade, and she shows up today to talk about something that affects 1 in 10 women and yet somehow remains one of the most underdiagnosed, underfunded, and dismissed conditions in medicine: endometriosis.
Hi...
What Is Your Body Capable Of?
Send us Fan Mail
Most of us learned to look at our bodies and immediately catalog what's wrong with them. Too big. Too small. Too much. Not enough. Wasting away. Filling out. The wrong shape for the wrong season for the wrong man's opinion.
This week, we're trying something else.
Two world-class athletes — ice mermaid and U.S. record holder Melissa Kegler and former NCAA swimmer Sarah Beth Wood — sit down with us to talk about what it's actually like to live in a body that's been measured, weighed, commented on, and critiqued for...
ChatGPT won her the Powerball - and she gave it all away
Send us Fan Mail
Carrie Edwards bought a lottery ticket online (against her Army buddy's advice), let ChatGPT pick her numbers (also against his advice), forgot she'd opted into a second draw, and won $150,000.
Then she gave every cent of it away. And $42,000 more out of her own pocket to cover the taxes.
The story went viral worldwide — Tamron Hall, Inside Edition, Fox News, Korean headlines at her nail salon. An estimated 6 billion media impressions. And she got there by calling the Virginia Lottery's PR team herself and pitching them on a press co...
Part 2: Hypothermia can be funn! - Ice Mermaid
Send us Fan Mail
Last week, Melissa Kegler said she was going to get her record back.
This week, the universe said, we’ll see about that.
What follows is five months of waiting for water that is somehow both too warm and too frozen, a logistical nightmare involving flights, storms, dams, and one very specific 24-hour window where everything finally (and briefly) aligns.
It is, by all accounts, the worst swim of her life.
Naturally, she does it anyway.
There’s something quietly unhinged about preparing your...
Pt. 1 - The Ice Mermaid, Melissa Kegler
Send us Fan Mail
There are people who set goals.
And then there’s Melissa Kegler—who hears a mildly unhinged suggestion and thinks, yes, that seems reasonable.
In Part 1, we trace the origin story: from pool swimmer to open water wanderer, to casually knocking out the Triple Crown (Catalina, the English Channel, Manhattan… as one does). Along the way: crocodile-adjacent panic, questionable water conditions, dolphins, bioluminescence, and just enough vomiting to keep things grounded.
It’s a story about curiosity, momentum, and the dangerous power of someone asking, “Have you ever thought abo...
Clay Play...And a Hot Take!
Send us Fan Mail
Courtney's tooth fell out again. Emily's hair is orange. Sarah Beth's pit bull has a pink belly. We're off.
Somewhere in the middle of all that, we talk about Rosemary — Courtney's dear friend, gone two years this week. She spent her life helping traumatized kids and reminded us that hurt people don't just hurt people. Hurt people heal people.
Then it gets weird (weirder?). We cover:
Why every woman should embrace being called a bitch (hint: it just means you have a backbone)Sarah Beth's theory that not wa...Never Give Up. Also, Buy an Air Fryer.
Send us Fan Mail
This week, we dispense wisdom. Some of it useful. Some of it… less so.
From brain candy books and existential dread to air fryer eggs, dry skin trauma, and the radical notion of simply not giving up, Emily and Courtney share the life advice they’ve collected, ignored, rediscovered, and occasionally weaponised.
There are thoughts on fear, presence, kindness, and why you should probably talk to your knees. Also: why teenagers don’t know how keys work, and why calm might be a superpower (unconfirmed).
Take what you ne...
We Left With Nothing
Send us Fan Mail
This week, we sit down with my friend Jen Quam Howell (JQ), who—on an otherwise unremarkable night—was woken up by her husband with the words no one prepares for: “The house is on fire. We have to go.”
What follows is exactly what you’d expect and nothing like you’d expect.
Three young kids. One terrifying exit down a burning staircase. A total loss. A hotel room that becomes “hometel.” And a community that quietly, relentlessly shows up—with spreadsheets, sweatpants, and the occasional replacement bra.
We talk about...
How to flag down your own mugger!
Send us Fan Mail
Los Angeles, as it turns out, is less a city and more a series of increasingly poor decisions strung together by sunshine.
This week, Courtney shares a perfectly normal collection of experiences: flagging down her own mugger, accepting a ride from a man who openly admits to past home invasions, being called a “loser” by a spiritual-looking stranger, and—naturally—being offered a glimpse of someone’s testicles before breakfast.
There is crime. There is confusion. There is alarming optimism.
And against all odds, she survives all of it.
<...The Last Virgin
Send us Fan Mail
What happens when you grow up in a deeply religious household where sex is forbidden, masturbation is sinful, and heaven is apparently keeping score?
You wait.
This week we’re joined by our brilliant friend Sarah Beth Schooley Wood—champion swimmer, Antarctica bride, and (for a surprisingly long time) a very committed virgin.
We talk purity culture, religious guilt, awkward first times, late blooming, and the strange realization that maybe… sex isn’t actually a moral emergency.
There are penguins.
There is back hair discourse...
Planes, trains and tears
Send us Fan Mail
What begins as a chic business-class flight to Italy (because we’re grown now) quickly devolves into a transatlantic U-turn, a missing suitcase, an Amtrak sprint through Washington, D.C., a possibly intoxicated Uber driver declaring “Ma’am, I’m gonna get you there,” and approximately fourteen emotional breakdowns.
There are trains. There are planes. There is public weeping. There is emergency lingerie purchased at JFK.
And somehow—miraculously—there is also Italy.
This week, Emily recounts the 48-hour odyssey that proves three things:
You don’t need that much...Mom, if I'm in a wheelchair, I want to play murder ball
Send us Fan Mail
At 22, Matt Holland dove into shallow water, broke his neck, and immediately knew something was very wrong.
This episode has it all: lake house chaos, a midnight helicopter ride, ICU absurdity, fingers-in-the-butt medical exams, and erections.
It’s funny. It’s uncomfortable. It’s very honest. And it’s about what happens when your body stops—but your will doesn’t.
Support the show
Left at the Altar
Send us Fan Mail
This week, Colleen Heiber joins us to discuss being left before the wedding… and almost leaving someone herself. Six weeks out. Invitations printed. Rose petals purchased. Dumpster involved.
We talk red flags, baby fever (and losing it), jam bands, online dating in your late 30s, youth-pastor energy, and the radical act of asking, “Are you sure?”
It’s funny. It’s brutal. It’s hopeful. It’s proof that sometimes the altar isn’t the ending — it’s the escape hatch.
Very much not the plan.
Suppor
Toofless
Send us Fan Mail
What begins as a casual conversation about hair drifts, quite naturally, into fake fangs, missing teeth, addiction, dentures, dental debt, sobriety, and one impressively pragmatic trip to Mexico shortly after losing all top teeth. It’s painful, absurd, and unexpectedly funny—a story about shame, survival, and rebuilding a smile without the benefit of enamel. Dental insurance, as ever, is the real villain. Teeth optional.
Support the show
Bugs in the bed
Send us Fan Mail
Bed bugs: not a moral failing, not a cleanliness issue, and definitely not part of the plan. This week, we’re joined by Dr. Dini Miller—Virginia Tech professor, urban entomology legend, and all-around badass—to talk what bed bugs actually are, how people really get them, why panic makes everything worse, and what actually works. Equal parts horrifying, hilarious, and strangely comforting. Lint rollers encouraged.
Support the show
Not my circus
Send us Fan Mail
Just because children never blessed our loins doesn't mean we don't kinda like them. Well, we do, and we don't.
Babies, motherhood, and the quiet panic of doing life “wrong.” In Not My Circus, Emily and Courtney talk being child-free by choice, by chance, and by biology—with honesty, dark humor, rockin’ nipples, and zero judgment. A conversation about listening to your own small voice, loving the life you actually have, and accepting that not everyone is meant to run the same circus.
Show Notes:
In this episode of 'That...
Addiction talks but sobriety walks
Send us Fan Mail
Courtney’s original life plan was simple: keep drinking, keep using, quietly disappear. Sobriety was not the plan — but it turned out to be the thing that gave her a bigger, funnier, fuller life than she ever imagined. In this episode, we talk addiction, shame, strawberries, bad decisions, dark humor, and why getting sober didn’t end her life — it finally gave her a life worth living.
Show Notes:
Summary
The conversation delves into the personal struggles of addiction, highlighting the impact of choices made during this time. Courtney...
Without a home
Send us Fan Mail
Both Emily and Courtney have had their run-ins with homelessness—sometimes more than once. This week, we delve into what it’s like to live without a roof over your head—and the bizarre blend of humor, humility, and resilience that comes with it. The little moments, the quiet dignity, and the unexpected things you discover about yourself when stability takes a hike. Honest, imperfect, and somehow more human—and maybe a little funnier—than we thought.
Show Notes:
Takeaways
Courtney dressed as The Jesus from The Big Lebowski f...