How to Make Films and Influence People

Peter and Andrew break down Sidney Lumet’s 1957 classic 12 Angry Men, exploring how this single-room drama became a timeless lesson in justice, persuasion, and American democracy. They analyze the film’s unique approach to character development, its allegorical power, and why it’s still shown in law schools and psychology classes today.

In their remake scenarios, they tackle a contained challenge: How do you make a jury room drama family-friendly? Could it work as a school disciplinary board story? What would a no-budget or Rashomon-style version look like? Would it be better as a modern TV series or a g...

Peter and Andrew tackle Alfred Hitchcock's 1958 psychological thriller Vertigo, exploring why critics have called it the greatest film ever made. They analyze Jimmy Stewart's obsessive detective, the film's groundbreaking camera techniques, and whether this complex meditation on identity and control works better as art than entertainment. Plus, they debate if it's even really a detective story at all.

In their remake scenarios, they face a psychological puzzle: How do you adapt Hitchcock's most personal film? Could it work as a school-based family drama? What would a no-budget version focus on? Would it be better as a series...

Peter and Andrew examine Damien Chazelle's intense 2014 drama Whiplash, exploring the toxic relationship between an ambitious young drummer and his abusive instructor. They analyze J.K. Simmons' powerhouse performance, discuss whether the film glorifies or condemns abusive teaching methods, and examine how this "sports movie set in music" captures the pursuit of greatness at any cost.

In their remake scenarios, they face a contained challenge: How do you adapt a two-person psychological thriller? Could it work as a family-friendly animated film? What would change in a no-budget version of an already low-budget movie? Would expanding it to...

Peter and Andrew examine Joseph Mankiewicz's 1950 masterpiece All About Eve, exploring how this dialogue-driven drama about ambition and betrayal in the theater world remains timelessly relevant. They analyze the film's sharp wit, discuss the legendary performances that earned four female Oscar nominations, and examine how the story's themes of aging, power, and manipulation transcend its Broadway setting.

In their remake scenarios, they tackle a structural challenge: How do you update a dialogue-heavy classic? Could it work as a High School Musical-style family film? What would a no-budget version focus on? Would it work better as a modern...

Peter and Andrew explore Hayao Miyazaki's 2001 animated masterpiece Spirited Away, examining how it captures the essence of childhood through a young girl's journey in a magical spirit world. They discuss Miyazaki's unique animation style, the film's approach to fairy tale darkness, and why it resonates differently with audiences depending on their familiarity with Studio Ghibli's storytelling approach.

In their remake scenarios, they face a creative challenge: How do you adapt pure imagination? Could it work as a live-action horror film? What would a no-budget costume version look like? Would it be better as a TV series exploring...

Peter and Andrew explore Francis Ford Coppola's ambitious 1974 sequel The Godfather Part II, analyzing its groundbreaking dual timeline structure that tells both Vito's rise and Michael's fall. They discuss whether this complex narrative experiment improves on the original, examine Robert De Niro's performance as young Vito, and debate why the film feels more like a meditation on power than a traditional sequel.

In their remake scenarios, they tackle a structural puzzle: How do you adapt a three-hour epic with two storylines? Could the Vito story work as a standalone family film? What would a no-budget version focus...

Peter and Andrew tackle Francis Ford Coppola's 1972 masterpiece The Godfather, exploring why it's widely considered the greatest film ever made. They analyze the film's unique structure following Michael's transformation, discuss Marlon Brando's iconic performance, and examine how the movie merges pulpy crime action with profound themes about family, power, and the American Dream.

In their remake scenarios, they face their most ambitious challenge: How do you remake perfection? Could it work as a family farm drama? What would a no-budget version focus on? Would it be better as a prestige TV series?

Plus, they celebrate...

Peter and Andrew tackle the beloved Christmas classic It's a Wonderful Life in their holiday special, examining how Frank Capra's 1946 film became a cultural phenomenon despite its initial box office failure. They explore the film's unusual structure, George Bailey's repeated business failures, and whether the movie's message about friendship and community still resonates today.

In their remake scenarios, they face a festive challenge: How do you improve on a Christmas classic? Could the Muppets save this story? What would a no-budget version look like? Plus, they share their top 5 Christmas movies and discuss the little-known German New...

Peter and Andrew dive into Quentin Tarantino's groundbreaking 1994 masterpiece Pulp Fiction, exploring how its nonlinear storytelling, unforgettable dialogue, and interwoven storylines revolutionized cinema. They analyze the film's unique structure, discuss whether it holds up as one of the greatest films ever made, and examine how it spawned countless imitators who missed the point.

In their remake scenarios, they face their biggest challenge yet: How do you make Pulp Fiction family-friendly? What would a no-budget version look like? Could it work as a sitcom? Plus, they rank Tarantino's filmography and discuss why this film's influence extends far beyond...

Peter and Andrew explore the 1938 swashbuckling classic The Adventures of Robin Hood, examining how Errol Flynn's iconic performance and Michael Curtiz's direction created the template for all future action-adventure films. They discuss the film's surprisingly fast pace, its colorful Technicolor cinematography, and how it balances thrilling sword fights with deeper themes of class and justice.

In their remake scenarios, they tackle a unique challenge: How do you improve on a film that's already pretty family-friendly? What would a gritty no-budget version look like? Could it work as a modern TV series? Plus, they dive into the fascinating...

Peter and Andrew tackle the beloved 1997 drama Good Will Hunting, exploring how Matt Damon and Ben Affleck's Oscar-winning screenplay creates a surprisingly grounded story about genius, friendship, and finding your path. They analyze the film's lived-in authenticity, Robin Williams' powerful performance, and how the movie balances intimate character moments with bigger emotional beats. In their remake scenarios, they face an interesting challenge: How do you adapt a story that's already pretty small-scale? Could it work as a Disney family film? What would a no-budget version look like? The hosts also share what they've been watching lately, including Rocky Horror...

Peter and Andrew dive into Bong Joon Ho's Oscar-winning masterpiece Parasite, exploring how it masterfully blends genres while delivering a devastating critique of economic inequality. They discuss the film's brilliant structure that shifts from heist comedy to psychological thriller, and how it uses smell as a metaphor for class divisions in Korean society.

The hosts analyze the film's universal themes and why it resonated globally, plus explore Korean cultural context including the country's rapid economic growth. They break down the genius twist that reframes everything and discuss why this represents cinema at its finest.

In...

Peter and Andrew tackle their most challenging film yet: Andrei Tarkovsky's enigmatic masterpiece Mirror, a non-narrative exploration of memory, nostalgia, and Soviet history. They discuss how the film abandons traditional storytelling in favor of a dreamlike meditation on childhood, war, and personal trauma, and why Tarkovsky prioritized artistic expression over audience accessibility. The hosts explore the film's beautiful but confusing structure, its blend of personal and historical memory, and how it feels more like visual poetry than cinema. They also discuss their different approaches to screenwriting - whether to outline extensively or dive straight into writing - based on...

Peter and Andrew dive deep into Christopher Nolan's masterpiece The Dark Knight, exploring how it transcended the superhero genre to become a complex meditation on chaos, order, and moral compromise. They discuss Heath Ledger's iconic Joker performance, the film's post-9/11 themes of surveillance and security, and how it changed superhero cinema forever.

In their signature "Hollywood Remake" segment, they tackle the impossible: How would you make The Dark Knight family-friendly? What about on a shoestring budget? Or as a 10-part Netflix series? Plus, they reveal the results of their listener poll for their screenplay project and discuss...

Peter and Andrew explore Billy Wilder's Oscar-winning classic The Apartment, a deceptively light comedy that tackles heavy themes of loneliness, corporate culture, and moral compromise in 1960s America. They analyze how Wilder crafts sympathetic characters caught in morally complex situations and discuss the film's surprising depth beneath its entertaining surface.

The duo then imagines how to remake this adult-themed story: Could it work as a family film starring Winnie the Pooh? How would you shoot it with no budget? Would it work better as a modern Netflix series? Plus, listener poll results and their latest viewing recommendations.<...

Peter and Andrew tackle Gillo Pontecorvo's groundbreaking war film The Battle of Algiers, examining how it revolutionized the genre by refusing to pick heroes and villains. They discuss the film's documentary-style approach, its complex portrayal of colonial conflict, and why it remains one of cinema's most powerful anti-war statements.

In their remake scenarios, they face a big challenge: How do you make a brutal war film family-friendly? (Spoiler: animated animals might be involved.) Plus, they explore how this story might work as a prestige TV series and discuss their ongoing screenplay project.

The hosts also...