3 Spooked Girls
Join Tara and Jessica every Thursday for a deep dive into significant true crime cases, documentary recaps, urban legend retellings, and the history and haunts of paranormal-linked locations. Then come back every Sunday for our Sunday Scaries fiction series.
Trust Me: The False Prophet Episode 1
Hey Spooksters! This week, we are starting our recap of the Netflix documentary, Trust Me: The False Prophet. Episode 1 is titled And That's How We Met Sam Bateman.
Synopsis: After moving to an FLDS community, a cult expert and her husband grow suspicious about a man named Sam Bateman. They decide to secretly investigate him.
Timestamps:
00:00 - 05:57 Intro
05:58 - 53:31 Recap
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second s...
Sunday Scaries Episode 32 | My Worst Fear. Encountering A Mimic.
Hey Spooksters! This week, concludes our theme of mimics for Sunday Scaries! Today's episode is titled My Worst Fear. Encountering A Mimic.
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms and on YouTube. Click here for more.
Join our book club, Spookster Literary Society!
Check out the following link for our socials, Patreon, YouTube channel, & more https://linktr.ee/3spookedgirls
Do you have a true crime story or paranormal encounter you'd...
The Society of the Woman in the Wilderness: America's First Doomsday Cult
Hey Spooksters! We are headed back to the late 1600s today. The Society of the Woman in the Wilderness was a 17th-century German Pietist, apocalyptic community led by Johannes Kelpius that settled in Pennsylvania in 1694. Believing the world would end that year based on Revelation 12, about 40 celibate monks lived as hermits and mystics in the Wissahickon Valley.
Timestamps:
00:00 - 05:06 Intro
05:07 - 34:38 The Society of the Woman in the Wilderness
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check o...
Sunday Scaries Episode 31 | Has Anyone Heard About The Mimic?
Hey Spooksters! This week, we are continuing our theme of mimics for Sunday Scaries! Today's episode is titled Has Anyone Heard About The Mimic?
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms and on YouTube. Click here for more.
Join our book club, Spookster Literary Society!
Check out the following link for our socials, Patreon, YouTube channel, & more https://linktr.ee/3spookedgirls
Do you have a true crime sto...
The Truth and Tragedy of Moriah Wilson
Hey Spooksters! Today we are recapping the Netflix documentary, The Truth and Tragedy of Moriah Wilson.
Synopsis: Go beyond the headlines in this documentary about pro cyclist Moriah Wilson's vibrant life, shocking murder, and how far her killer went to evade capture.
Timestamps:
00:00 - 06:07 Intro
06:08 - 1:08:38 Recap
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms and...
Sunday Scaries Episode 30 | My Family Was Replaced By Mimics. I Think I Am Next.
Hey Spooksters! This week, we are continuing our theme of mimics for Sunday Scaries! Today's episode is titled My Family Was Replaced By Mimics. I Think I Am Next.
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms and on YouTube. Click here for more.
Join our book club, Spookster Literary Society!
Check out the following link for our socials, Patreon, YouTube channel, & more https://linktr.ee/3sp...
The Skulls (2000)
Hey Spooksters! This week, we are recapping the 2000s classic, The Skulls. If you're interested in watching this, we found it on Tubi!
Synopsis: Deep within the hallowed walls of Ivy League's most prominent campus exists a secret society where power and elite are bred. Only a few are chosen to join where Presidents are groomed, wealthy bloodlines bond, and plots thickened. For Luke McNamara, an invitation to join the prestigious secret college organization, The Skulls, is a dream come true, until murder befalls another student.
Timestamps:
00:00 - 3:54 Intro
03:55 - 06:19 Nostalgia...
Sunday Scaries Episode 29 | The Mimic From My Childhood
Hey Spooksters! This week kicks off our theme of mimics for Sunday Scaries! Today's episode is titled The Mimic From My Childhood.
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms and on YouTube. Click here for more.
Join our book club, Spookster Literary Society!
Check out the following link for our socials, Patreon, YouTube channel, & more https://linktr.ee/3spookedgirls
Do you have a true crime story or paranormal encounter you'd...
Lizzie Halliday: The Worst Woman on Earth
Hey Spooksters! Today, we are diving into the historic case of serial killer, Lizzie Halliday. Lizzie was active during the late 1800s and was the first woman to be sentenced to death by electric chair.
Timestamps:
00:00 - 03:48 Intro
03:49 - 30:53 Lizzie Halliday
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms and on YouTube. Click here for more.
Join our book club, S...
Sunday Scaries Episode 28 | I Work at a National Park That Doesn't Exist
Hey Spooksters! Today will conclude our theme of national parks! This week's story is titled I Work at a National Park That Doesn't Exist.
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms and on YouTube. Click here for more.
Join our book club, Spookster Literary Society!
Check out the following link for our socials, Patreon, YouTube channel, & more https://linktr.ee/3spookedgirls
Do you have a true crime st...
March's Listener Encounters 2026
We're back with another installment of your stories! If you have an encounter you'd like read on the show, please email it to us at 3spookedgirls@gmail.com.
Timestamps:
00:00 - 05:09 Intro
05:10 - 20:12 Stories
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms and on YouTube. Click here for more.
Join our book club, Spookster Literary Society!
Check out the following link for our socia...
Sunday Scaries Episode 27 | We Found a Survivor in the Forest. He Says the Wendigo Let Him Go.
Hey Spooksters! Continuing on with our theme of creepy encounters in national parks, today's story is titled We Found a Survivor in the Forest. He Says the Wendigo Let Him Go.
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms and on YouTube. Click here for more.
Join our book club, Spookster Literary Society!
Check out the following link for our socials, Patreon, YouTube channel, & more htt...
Idaho Urban Legends
Hey Spooksters! Today we are diving into urban legends from Idaho. What state would you like to see next? Let us know on social media!
Timestamps:
00:00 - 06:26 Intro
06:27 - 25:38 Urban Legends
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms and on YouTube. Click here for more.
Join our book club, Spookster Literary Society!
Check out the following link for our socials, Patre...
Vault Release: Crimes Inspired By Horror Movies
Hey Spooksters! This week, we are taking a short intermission from our Sunday Scaries stories and sharing with you something from the Vault! In this episode, we discuss a list of crimes where the perpetrator was 'inspired' by fiction, or in this case, horror movies. If you enjoy content like this, join us on Patreon for as little as $1 for bonus content every month!
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Sea...
St. Patrick's Day Massacre (2025)
Hey Spooksters! Today, we are recapping St. Patrick's Day Massacre (2025). Synopsis: On a trip to Dublin to celebrate St. Patrick's Day, four friends agree to spend the night in an abandoned tavern, where they are stalked by an undead killer in search of revenge for a tragedy that occurred centuries before.
Timestamps:
00:00 - 04:46 Intro
04:47 - 29:41 Recap
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are a...
Sunday Scaries Episode 26 | I Found a Strange Journal in the Restricted Area of a National Park
Hey Spooksters! Continuing on with our theme of creepy encounters in national parks, today's story is titled I Found a Strange Journal in the Restricted Area of a National Park.
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms and on YouTube. Click here for more.
Join our book club, Spookster Literary Society!
Check out the following link for our socials, Patreon, YouTube channel, & more https://linkt...
[FEED DROP] Social Seance Society: Welcome to Panem
Hey Spooksters! This week is a feed drop from Social Seance Society! In this episode covering The Hunger Games, we will recap the book and movie, how this is relevant to society today, discuss our favorite parts, and more. Tune into the rest of our Panem universe deep dive on Social Seance Society!
Follow Social Seance Society on social media https://beacons.ai/socialseancesociety
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Join our book club, Spookster Literary Society!
<...Sunday Scaries Episode 25 | Working for a National Park Nearly Killed Me. Something Wants Me Back
Hey Spooksters! Continuing on with our theme of creepy encounters in national parks, today's story is titled Working for a National Park Nearly Killed Me. Something Wants Me Back.
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms and on YouTube. Click here for more.
Join our book club, Spookster Literary Society!
Check out the following link for our socials, Patreon, YouTube channel, & more https://linktr.ee/3s...
February's Listener Encounters 2026
Hey Spooksters! We are pleased to announce Listener Encounters are back! If you have a spooky story you'd like read on the show, please email us at 3spookedgirls@gmail.com!
Timestamps:
00:00 - 06:07 Intro
06:08 - 23:49 Encounter Stories
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms. Click here for more.
Join our book club, Spookster Literary Society!
Check out the following link for our soci...
Sunday Scaries Episode 24 | There's Something Evil Lurking in Hoosier National Forest
We asked and you answered! In the Facebook group you guys voted to hear some one off stories involving creepy encounters in national parks. This week's story is titled, There's Something Evil Lurking in Hoosier National Forest. Enjoy & stay spooky!
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms and on YouTube. Click here for more.
Join our book club, Spookster Literary Society!
Check out the following link for our so...
The Curse of the Highgate Vampire
Hey Spooksters! This week, we are recapping The Curse of the Highgate Vampire. Synopsis: A group of paranormal thrill-seekers get themselves locked inside a Victorian cemetery that is infamous for being a vampire-hunting ground in 1970s London. They delve into haunting tales of vampires, Satanism, occult rituals, and more.
Timestamps:
00:00 - 03:56 Intro
03:57 - 39:55 Highgate Vampire
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available o...
Sunday Scaries Episode 23 | I Dared My Best Friend to End My Life FINALE
Hey Spooksters! Welcome to the finale of I Dared My Best Friend to End My Life.
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms and on YouTube. Click here for more.
Join our book club, Spookster Literary Society!
Check out the following link for our socials, Patreon, YouTube channel, & more https://linktr.ee/3spookedgirls
Do you have a true crime story or paranormal encounter you'd like to share? Pleas...
Vault Release: Real or Not Real Weird State Laws Pt. 1
Hey Spooksters! Today, we are doing a feed drop from Jessica's Patreon series, Real or Not Real Weird State Laws. If you enjoy this and would like to binge the entire 5-part series, join us on Patreon starting at our $1 tier!
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms and on YouTube. Click here for more.
Join our book club, Spookster Literary Society!
Check out the following link for our...
Sunday Scaries Episode 22 | I Dared My Best Friend to End My Life Pt. 6
Hey Spooksters! Welcome back to Part 6 of I Dared My Best Friend to End My Life.
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms and on YouTube. Click here for more.
Join our book club, Spookster Literary Society!
Check out the following link for our socials, Patreon, YouTube channel, & more https://linktr.ee/3spookedgirls
Do you have a true crime story or paranormal encounter you'd like to share? Pleas...
Kidnapped: Elizabeth Smart Pt. 2
Hey Spooksters! Today continues our recap on the Netflix documentary, Kidnapped: Elizabeth Smart. Elizabeth Ann Smart is an American child safety activist and ABC News commentator who gained national attention at age 14 when she was kidnapped from her Salt Lake City home in 2002. In this documentary, Elizabeth recounts her kidnapping through personal testimony and exclusive footage.
Timestamps:
00:00 - 03:54 Intro
03:55 - 48:25 Recap
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, S...
Sunday Scaries Episode 21 | I Dared My Best Friend to End My Life Pt. 5
Hey Spooksters! Welcome back to Part 5 of I Dared My Best Friend to End My Life.
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms and on YouTube. Click here for more.
Join our book club, Spookster Literary Society!
Check out the following link for our socials, Patreon, YouTube channel, & more https://linktr.ee/3spookedgirls
Do you have a true crime story or paranormal encounter you'd like to share? Pleas...
Kidnapped: Elizabeth Smart Pt. 1
Hey Spooksters! Today starts our recap on the new Netflix documentary, Kidnapped: Elizabeth Smart. Elizabeth Ann Smart is an American child safety activist and ABC News commentator who gained national attention at age 14 when she was kidnapped from her Salt Lake City home in 2002. In this documentary, Elizabeth recounts her kidnapping through personal testimony and exclusive footage.
Timestamps:
00:00 - 05:32 Intro
05:33 - 41:09 Recap
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second s...
Sunday Scaries Episode 20 | I Dared My Best Friend to End My Life Pt. 4
Hey Spooksters! Welcome back to part 4 of I Dared My Best Friend to End My Life.
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms and on YouTube. Click here for more.
Join our book club, Spookster Literary Society!
Check out the following link for our socials, Patreon, YouTube channel, & more https://linktr.ee/3spookedgirls
Do you have a true crime story or paranormal encounter you'd like to share? Pleas...
Wisconsin Urban Legends
Hey Spooksters! Today, we are diving into Wisconsin urban legends. Get ready for an episode full of cryptids, ghosts, and haunted bridges.
Timestamps:
00:00 - 03:44 Intro
03:45 - 23:09 Urban legends
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms and on YouTube. Click here for more.
Join our book club, Spookster Literary Society!
Check out the following link for our socials, Patreon, YouTube channel...
Sunday Scaries Episode 19 | I Dared My Best Friend to End My Life Pt. 3
Hey Spooksters! Welcome back to Part 3 of I Dared My Best Friend to End My Life.
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms and on YouTube. Click here for more.
Join our book club, Spookster Literary Society!
Check out the following link for our socials, Patreon, YouTube channel, & more https://linktr.ee/3spookedgirls
Do you have a true crime story or paranormal encounter you'd like to share? Pleas...
Homicide Hunter: Devil in the Mountains
Hey Spooksters! This week we are recapping a Papa Joe documentary! In Homicide Hunter: Devil in the Mountains, a man is found stabbed and burned. Lt. Joe Kenda launches a manhunt. When the trail goes cold, Kenda connects the dots among a string of otherwise-unrelated heartless murders, leading him into his first and only search for a serial killer.
Episode mentioned: Episode 525 - The Murder of Victor Woods
Timestamps:
00:00 - 04:49 Intro
04:50 - 44:15 Recap
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www...
Sunday Scaries Episode 18 | I Dared My Best Friend to End My Life Pt. 2
Hey Spooksters! This week's Sunday Scaries continues the sequel series to I Dared My Best Friend to Ruin My Life. We hope you enjoy Part 2 of I Dared My Best Friend to End My Life.
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms and on YouTube. Click here for more.
Join our book club, Spookster Literary Society!
Check out the following link for our socials, Patreon, YouTube ch...
True Crime Headlines Pt. 9
Hey Spooksters! This week we are back with another round-up of true crime headlines. The cases mentioned are: Jennifer Dulos, More Than the Prophet Ministries, Terry Arndt, The Tepe Murders, & a Texas Home Build Scam.
Jennifer Dulos coverage:
Episode 103: Stabby Snippets - Jennifer Dulos
Episode 115: Stabby Snippets - Jennifer Dulos Update
Timestamps:
00:00 - 05:13 Intro
05:14 - 35:32 Headlines
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second s...
Sunday Scaries Episode 17 | I Dared My Best Friend to End My Life Pt. 1
Hey Spooksters! This week's Sunday Scaries begins the sequel series to I Dared My Best Friend to Ruin My Life. We hope you enjoy part one of I Dared My Best Friend to End My Life.
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms and on YouTube. Click here for more.
Join our book club, Spookster Literary Society!
Check out the following link for our socials, Patreon...
The Murder of Elsie Jennes
Hey Spooksters! To kick off 2026, we are back with another Papa Joe episode. In this episode of Homicide Hunter, the body of housewife Elsie Jennes is found in the basement of her burning house. Lt Joe Kenda finds no leads until her son William arrives at a police station an hour away from their home.
Timestamps:
00:00 - 04:09 Intro
04:10 - 38:13 Recap
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Se...
Sunday Scaries Episode 16 | I Dared My Best Friend to Ruin My Life FINALE
Hey Spooksters! Welcome back to another Sunday Scaries! Today is Part 8 of I Dared My Best Friend to Ruin My Life. This concludes Series 1 of this story, but stay tuned as we dive into Series 2 starting next Sunday!
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms and on YouTube. Click here for more.
Join our book club, Spookster Literary Society!
Check out the following link for our socials, Pa...
Black Christmas (1974)
Hey Spooksters, Happy Holidays! Today, we are recapping the iconic holiday horror movie, Black Christmas (1974). Synopsis: Set during the Christmas break, the film centers around the Pi Kappa Sigma sorority house, where the sisters receive a series of disturbing phone calls from an anonymous caller known as "The Moaner." As the holiday festivities unfold, the girls become increasingly uneasy due to the threatening nature of the calls. The tension escalates when one of the sisters, Clare, goes missing, prompting the remaining girls to contact the police, who initially dismiss their concerns.
Timestamps:
00:00 - 04:43 Intro
...
Sunday Scaries Episode 15 | I Dared My Best Friend to Ruin My Life Pt. 7
Hey Spooksters! Welcome back to another Sunday Scaries! Today is Part 7 of I Dared My Best Friend to Ruin My Life.
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms and on YouTube. Click here for more.
Join our book club, Spookster Literary Society!
Check out the following link for our socials, Patreon, YouTube channel, & more https://linktr.ee/3spookedgirls
Do you have a true crime story or paranormal encounter you'd li...
The Murder of Donald Ott
Hey Spooksters! This week, we are back with another Papa Joe recap! In this episode entitled, My, My, Merry Christmas, we discuss the murder and investigation of carefree restaurant worker Donald Ott. When Donald is found shot to death on Christmas Day, friends tell police he didn't have an enemy in the world. Then Lt. Joe Kenda learns of a relative with a long criminal history who might hold the key to the mystery.
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out o...
Sunday Scaries Episode 14 | I Dared My Best Friend to Ruin My Life Pt. 6
Hey Spooksters! Welcome back to another Sunday Scaries! Today is Part 6 of I Dared My Best Friend to Ruin My Life.
Do you want AD FREE episodes published a day EARLY? Join the Spookster Fam at www.patreon.com/3spookedgirls
Check out our latest episode on our second show, Social Seance Society! We are available on all podcast platforms and on YouTube. Click here for more.
Join our book club, Spookster Literary Society!
Check out the following link for our socials, Patreon, YouTube channel, & more https://linktr.ee/3spookedgirls
Do you have a true crime story or paranormal encounter you'd li...
