Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan!

This Missouri Mayhem episode follows two connected missing persons cases from rural Missouri, and the family history that sits at the center of both. It traces the years of instability, alleged abuse, a recorded confession, a recantation, and a later civil verdict that found two people liable for Gary McCullough’s death. Megan and Mindy walk through the complicated relationships between Sandy, Gary, Albert, Chris, and the six daughters caught in the middle, including Lena Chapin, whose own disappearance years later transformed the case again.

Official Missing Person Databases

This episode of Missouri Mayhem’s Still Missing and Unsolved covers two Missouri cold cases: the 2005 disappearance of 13-year-old Bianca Noel Piper in Lincoln County and the 1998 murder of former NFL player Timothy Hall in Kansas City. Host Megan focuses on what is known, what investigators have revisited in recent years, and why both cases remain open.We discuss Bianca’s vulnerability, the search that covered hundreds of square miles, and the renewed investigation in 2025. Then we shift to Timothy Hall’s life, football career, the shooting that killed him, and the unanswered questions surrounding the intended target.

Reso...

Fairyland Park: Kansas City’s Million Dollar Playground, Jazz Stage, and Civil Rights Battleground

Megan and Mindy dig into the complicated history of Fairyland Park at 75th and Prospect in Kansas City, a long-gone amusement park that was once a major summer destination and a significant jazz venue. The story spans thrills, music, segregation, activism, and the eventual decline of the park as Kansas City changed around it.They also trace how Fairyland fit into a larger local tradition of amusement parks, why its music mattered, and how Black Kansas Citians fought to end its discriminatory admission po...

Missouri Mayhem Presents: Still Missing and Unsolved

This debut episode covers two Missouri cases separated by nearly 40 years: the disappearance of Desirea Ann Ferris in Liberty and the 1973 murder of Teresa “Tess” Hilt in Maryville. It focuses on what is known from records and reporting, why both cases still matter, and what unanswered questions remain for investigators and families. In this episode, Megan introduces the new weekly format and walks through the final known movements, phone activity, and case status in Desirea's disappearance before turning to the crime scene, investigation, and evidence loss in Tess Hilt’s unsolv...

PART TWO: This episode follows the fallout at Times Beach after officials confirmed severe dioxin contamination. Flooding spread contaminated soil through the town, and residents were told they could not safely return home. The federal government eventually bought out the community, relocating most families and dismantling the town.The episode covers the painful aftermath for homeowners, the final mayor who stayed through the town’s closure, and the years-long cleanup effort that demolished buildings and incinerated contaminated soil. It also returns to the people and companies tied to the original contamination, highlighting how little accountability many residents felt there wa...

PART ONE - Times Beach, Missouri. A quiet Missouri town became one of the most infamous environmental disasters in American history because of dust control. What started with cheap road oil, horse stables, and one waste hauler's side hustle ended with an entire community being bought out, demolished, and erased from the map. Megan and Mindy trace the shocking chain of events that begins at a horse stable near Moscow Mills and leads all the way to Times Beach, where families lived for years on contaminated ground without knowing it. The story reveals how Russell Bliss's oil spraying tied...

This Missouri Mayhem episode covers the disturbing case of Bertha Gifford, one of the earliest women in the United States to be labeled a serial killer. It follows how a trusted caregiver in rural Missouri built a reputation for compassion, then became the center of a decades-long poisoning investigation.We discuss the small-town setting of Morse Mill and Catawissa, the pattern of sudden illnesses and deaths under Bertha’s care, and how arsenic, exhumations, and a public trial eventually brought the case into focus.

Dedicated True Crime Books

This Missouri Mayhem episode tells the story of Davy and Natalie Lloyd and Judes Montis, their work with Missions in Haiti, and the conditions in Haiti that shaped their lives and the events of May 23, 2024. It explains why the couple stayed committed to ministry despite escalating danger, while also tracing the history of Haiti and the long-term impact of colonial debt, instability, and gang violence.We also hear how Davy’s childhood in Haiti, Natalie’s Missouri roots, and their shared calling to service brought them together. The episode closes by reflecting on their legacy through family, faith, memorial prog...

This Missouri Mayhem episode follows the 38-year search for answers in the disappearance and presumed murder of Ronna Bremer, a 22-year-old mother who vanished in rural Missouri while seven months pregnant. Megan and Mindy trace the case from the original disappearance in 1988 to the 2026 arrest of Joel Bremer, showing how old evidence, renewed detective work, and modern DNA analysis finally brought the case back to life.We discuss the investigation’s long delay, the discovery and identification of Ronna’s skull, the history of domestic violence tied to the marriage, and the recent indictment for the deaths of Ronna and...

In this Missouri Mayhem episode, Mindy and Megan explore the heartbreaking case of the Denham family, whose peaceful lives in a tiny Missouri town shattered in 2016 by a violent crime. We examine the events leading up to the murders, the investigation's details, and the pursuit of justice six years in the making.

Key Topics

Missouri Mayhem: This episode explores the tragic disappearance of Crystal Lynn Kipper in 1997, highlighting the challenges law enforcement faced without modern technology and the lasting impact on her family. Join us for a detailed look at her case, the investigation, and the ongoing search for answers.

This Missouri Mayhem episode recounts the devastating events of February 19, 2016, when a small-town family in Edgerton, Missouri, was brutally murdered in a house fire, leading to a complex investigation and a high-stakes legal case. We explore the community's shock, the details of the crime, the suspect's mysterious disappearance, and the pursuit of justice.

RESOURCES

Trial and Sentencing Coverage (2021–2022)

This episode explores a series of devastating suicides connected to a close-knit college community in Kirksville, Missouri. We analyze the disturbing pattern, the role of a controversial figure, and the wider questions of responsibility and mental health support.

EPISODE CORRECTION - Alex Mullins passed away August of 2016. Not June. We apologize for this error.

Main Topics Covered:

In this episode, we recount the tragic disappearance and murder of 19-year-old Becky Sutton in Missouri, exploring the investigation, the long quest for justice, and the importance of never giving up hope.

Main Topics Covered:

Resources & References

Primary Sources

Discover the hidden world beneath Missouri's surface with Mindy & Megan where limestone caves hold stories of disappearances, legends, and dark histories. Join us as we explore seven chilling tales from the depths of these subterranean sites, revealing the secrets and mysteries that still shroud Missouri's underground.

Research, Databases & Mapping Sites

Missouri's Hidden Titanic Survival: The Caldwell Family Story

Discover the remarkable true story of a Missouri family who survived the Titanic together, defying fate amidst one of history's greatest maritime disasters. This episode explores their journey from Missouri to the sinking Atlantic, highlighting faith, love, and survival against all odds.

Biographical Databases & Archives

In this episode, Megan and Mindy explore the mysterious case of Echo Michelle Lloyd, who vanished from her rural Missouri home in May 2020 amid the chaos of the pandemic. Despite extensive searches and investigations, key questions remain unanswered, highlighting the complexities of rural missing persons cases and the impact of COVID-19 on law enforcement.

If you have any information about Echo Lloyd’s case, please contact the Missouri State Highway Patrol at 573-526-6178 or your local law enforcement.

News Articles & Media Coverage

Discover the tragic case of Bob Eidman, a kind-hearted insurance agent in Missouri whose routine life ended in a shocking daytime murder. This episode explores the details of the crime, the investigation's twists, and the importance of unresolved cold cases. In this episode, we provide a detailed account of Bob Eidman’s background and his routine life in St. Charles, Missouri. We delve into the day of the murder, what investigators found, and the initial leads. Learn how modern DNA technology reawakened the cold case after years of silence, leading to the surprising identification of suspects through DNA matching: Pa...

In this lighthearted bonus episode, Megan explores some of Missouri's most bizarre, funny, and head-scratching laws—many still on the books today. From dancing bans to laundry regulations, discover the surprising history behind these quirky statutes and what they reveal about small-town fears and morals through the ages.

Resources

In this episode, we delve into the tragic story of Jackie Johns, a beloved young woman from Nixa, Missouri, whose life was cut short in 1985. Jackie was a vibrant member of her community, known for her beauty, charm, and aspirations. Her disappearance and subsequent murder shocked the small town, leading to a decades-long quest for justice.We explore the events leading up to her disappearance, the investigation that followed, and the eventual conviction of Gerald Carnahan, a wealthy local resident with a troubling past. The case highlights the importance of DNA evidence and the relentless pursuit of justice by...

Explore the chilling story of a 1977 triple homicide on a remote Missouri military base, where trust and authority turned into terror. Learn about the investigation, the survivor’s incredible resilience, and its lasting impact on the community.

Main Topics:

Historical, investigative, and true...

Join Missouri Mayhem as we unravel the intricate web of deception spun by Pamela Hupp, a woman connected to multiple suspicious deaths—including her own mother, Betsy Faria, and Louis Gumpenberger. This case reveals how cunning manipulation, false claims, and cold-blooded murder can go undetected for years.

In this episode:

In this Missouri Mayhem episode, the sisters delve into the mysterious and controversial case of Libby Caswell, a young woman found dead in 2017. Despite her family's persistent doubts and expert opinions suggesting foul play, the case remains classified as a suicide. We explore the initial circumstances of Libby's death, her background, and her close relationship with her son. The episode highlights her tumultuous relationship with her boyfriend, Devon Martin, marked by documented domestic violence and suspicious behavior.Key evidence and forensic discrepancies, such as ligature marks and scene staging, are examined alongside conflicting witness statements. We discuss the 911 call...

Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder - Are you ready to hear one of Missouri's most haunting and impactful true crime stories? This episode takes you through the emotional journey of two children - Sam & Lindsey Porter, their family’s turmoil, and the quest for justice that changed a community forever.

In this episode:

This Missouri Mayhem episode dives into the chilling and complex case of Robert Eugene Brashears, a serial killer whose crimes spanned across five states over nearly a decade. We explore how forensic science finally brought justice after years of chaos, highlighting the importance of DNA evidence in solving cold cases.

Main Topics Covered:

On this week's Missouri Mayhem episode, discover the rich history, vibrant attractions, and cultural gems of Branson, Missouri—a small town with a major reputation for entertainment and adventure. Whether you're a history buff, thrill-seeker, or family vacationer, this episode covers it all.

In this episode, we explore:

Discover the heartbreaking stories behind two women, Kara Kopetsky and Jessica Runions, whose lives were tragically taken by the same man over a decade apart. This Missouri Mayhem episode explores the dark patterns of abuse, manipulation, and the pursuit of justice that finally brought closure to their families. Main topics covered:

Discover the history, legendary rides, and recent business developments at Kansas City's iconic amusement parks, Worlds of Fun and Oceans of Fun. Join us as we explore exciting stories, urban legends, and the future outlook of these beloved leisure spots.

Key topics:

This week's Missouri Mayhem explores the chilling details of the 1995 Springfield, Missouri Feeney family murders—an unsolved case that continues to puzzle investigators and intrigue true crime enthusiasts. This episode dives into the crime scene, forensic evidence, and the trial that left many questions unanswered.

In this episode:

In this episode, Megan and Mindy explore the harrowing story of racial violence in Springfield, Missouri, that unfolded on Easter weekend in 1906. They delve into the events leading to the lynching of three innocent Black men, the societal context of racial terror, and the lasting impact on the community. This heavy but essential history reveals how prejudice and silence perpetuate injustice and underscores the importance of remembrance and reconciliation.

Primary Archival Collections

Discover the tragic and complex story behind the deadliest structural collapse in U.S. history up to 2001 — the 1981 Hyatt Regency skywalk disaster in Kansas City. Join Megan and Mindy as they delve into the events, survivors' stories, engineering failures, and the haunting legacy that still echoes today.

Main Topics Covered:

Key Investigative & Te...

In this Missouri Mayhem episode, the sisters delve into the dramatic story of the May 22, 2011 EF5 tornado that ravaged Joplin, Missouri — one of the deadliest in U.S. history. Join us as we explore the community’s response, survivor stories, and lessons learned to prepare for future storms.

Key Topics:

In this Missouri Mayhem episode, Mindy & Megan explore the heartbreaking story of Cassidy Rainwater, a mother of six whose life was tragically cut short in the Missouri Ozarks. We delve into her background, the events leading up to her disappearance, and the chilling discovery that unraveled a brutal crime. This case underscores the importance of community vigilance, digital evidence, and the devastating impact of vulnerability in rural areas.

Key Topics:

In this Missouri Mayhem episode, the sisters delve into the perplexing disappearance and death of 19-year-old Tanner Ward in Trenton, Missouri. Despite official rulings of suicide, numerous inconsistencies and unanswered questions keep Tanner’s case alive in the community’s heart. Join us as we explore the facts, theories, and ongoing fight for justice.

IF YOU HAVE MORE INFO ABOUT THIS CASE, PLEASE CONTACT:

Primary News & Reporting

In this Missouri Mayhem episode, Mindy & Megan delve into the heartbreaking case of 18-year-old Kelsey Smith, abducted in broad daylight in Kansas City in 2007. Her story highlights the importance of awareness, quick action, and legislative change to prevent similar tragedies.

Key Topics:

Missouri Mayhem - The Murder of Ken McElroy - Discover the dark history behind Skidmore, Missouri, where community fears and legendary vigilance led to an infamous unresolved murder. This episode explores how a town's attempt at justice spiraled into a centuries-long mystery filled with violence, silence, and unanswered questions.

📚 RESOURCES & FURTHER LISTENING

Missouri Mayhem - In this episode, we explore the fascinating myth surrounding Missouri politician David Rice Atchison, who allegedly served as U.S. President for a single day in 1849. We dive into the historical context of mid-19th century America, the political chaos of 1849, and the truth behind this intriguing legend—plus, what it reveals about history, myth, and power.

EXPANDED REFERENCES

Missouri Mayhem - Join us as we explore the extraordinary life of Wild Bill Hickok — from his early days in Illinois to legendary gunfights in Kansas and South Dakota. Discover the stories behind his rise to fame, his notorious duel, and the mysterious circumstances of his death.

Primary Sources & Historical Records

This Missouri Mayhem episode delves into one of the most disturbing and perplexing crimes in recent Missouri history, focusing on the murder of Elizabeth Olten in October of 2009. The discussion highlights the intersection of violence and mental health, with Alyssa Bustamante ultimately pleading guilty to second-degree murder. The episode emphasizes the importance of addressing mental health crises and provides resources such as the 988 crisis lifeline and BetterHelp.com for those in need. Listeners are encouraged to share the episode to raise awareness about the need for youth services and mental health awareness.

Resources & Further Reading

...

On this episode of Missouri Mayhem, Mindy and Megan delve into the chilling story of Gary Randall Muehlberg, known as The Package Killer. The episode explores Muehlberg's life, his criminal history, and the series of murders he committed in the early 1990s. The hosts discuss the impact of his actions on the victims' families and the eventual breakthrough in the case due to DNA evidence.

Keywords

Gary Randall Muehlberg, package killer, serial killer, DNA evidence, Missouri Mayhem

Reference & Summary Articles

1. Wikipedia – Gary Muehlberg (biographical & case overview) Provides a structured summary of hi...