The Brohio Podcast

This week, we uncover the horrifying story of Carl Tanzler—a man whose obsession with a young patient continued long after her death. Grave robbing, a homemade corpse, and seven years with a terrifying secret inside his home


This episode is sponsored by EarnIn.


Find Us on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/c/Brohiopodcast
We Live Stream All Our Episodes! youtube.com/brohiopodcast

Find us on all the socials @BrohioPodcast

In 1988, Brenda Schaefer disappeared after meeting with her ex-boyfriend, Mel Ignatow. Investigators were convinced Mel had killed her—but when the case finally reached a courtroom, he walked away a free man.Then, months after his acquittal, workers inside Mel’s former home uncovered something hidden beneath the floorboards: photographs proving exactly what had happened to Brenda—and who was responsible.The evidence was horrifying. The timing was unbelievable. And because of double jeopardy, Mel Ignatow couldn’t be tried for her murder again, even after admitting he did it.This is the infuriating story of a carefully planned murder, a disast...

In 1989, single mother Jackie Hernandez moved to San Pedro, California, seeking a fresh start—but she walked into a nightmare instead. What began as simple bumps in the night quickly escalated into one of the most terrifying and well-documented cases in paranormal history.From glowing-eyed apparitions and oozing walls to violent physical attacks on investigators, the entity in Jackie’s home wasn’t just haunting a house—it was hunting her. In this episode, we break down the chilling investigation by Dr. Barry Taff, the infamous "attic incident" where a researcher was nearly strangled by an unseen force, and the unsettli...

Bad neighbors play loud music. Terrible neighbors steal your parking spot. But the neighbors in this episode? They’ve turned everyday life into a full-blown psychological war.This week, we’re reading listener-submitted stories about the absolute worst neighbors imaginable—from petty property-line feuds and unhinged confrontations to behavior so bizarre it’ll make you appreciate the weird guy quietly mowing his lawn at 7 a.m.Lock your doors, check your cameras, and avoid eye contact across the fence. These are your true stories of the Neighbors from Hell.

This episode is sponsored by:BetterHelp
See the reviews...

In August 1987, two Arkansas teenagers stumbled into the woods for a midnight hunting trip and walked right into an active, high-stakes drug drop. Hours later, their bodies were laid out across train tracks to be crushed by a freight train. What started as an absurd official ruling of "accidental marijuana stupor" quickly unraveled into a terrifying web of local corruption, a trail of murdered grand jury witnesses, the CIA-linked Mena airport, and state-level protection reaching all the way to the Governor’s Mansion. Join us as we break down the double homicide, the syndicate, and the dark political coverup that sh...

Ever wondered what happens when you cross the digital gig economy with pure, unadulterated madness? This week, we’re bypassing the wholesome handmade crafts on Etsy to dive into a wild subculture of online spellcasting—where you can Apple Pay your way into obsession love spells, graveyard hexes, or a proxy contract to sell your soul to Lucifer. But it doesn't stop there. We’re also exploring the darkest and dumbest corners of Craigslist, Fiverr, and eBay, from professional breakup proxies and fake paparazzi for hire to bound demon entity listings and haunted dolls with warnings attached. Buckle up, because it get...

Imagine having a secret lover. Now imagine hiding him in your attic crawlspace for nine years while your husband sleeps directly below.

In 1913, Dolly Oesterreich—the wife of a wealthy Milwaukee apron tycoon—seduced a 17-year-old factory mechanic named Otto Sanhuber. To keep the affair alive, Dolly convinced Otto to legally "disappear" and move permanently into her uninsulated attic. For nearly a decade, Otto lived like a subterranean ghost—cleaning, writing pulp fiction, and serving as Dolly's on-demand secret.But when Dolly's husband gets violent, Otto drops down from the ceiling holding two semi-automatic pistols... and things...

A man disappears into the Pennsylvania wilderness after a night of bizarre behavior, strange lights, and a trail that only gets weirder the deeper you go. This week, we dig into the disappearance of Todd Sees — a case tangled up with missing time, UFO rumors, and one of those backwoods mysteries that refuses to sit right.

Sponsored by BetterHelp
Start therapy with BetterHelp and get 10% off your first month at BetterHelp.com/BROHIO.

Sponsored by EarnIn
Download EarnIn and use BROHIO under PODCAST when you sign up.

Find Us...

How far would someone go for a digital obsession? In this episode, we dive into the chilling case of Grant Amato, a 29-year-old nurse from Chuluota, Florida, whose consuming infatuation with an overseas webcam model ultimately tore his family apart.What began as internet chat rooms quickly spiraled into a devastating addiction. In just a matter of months, Grant stole over $200,000 from his parents and brother to fund his online obsession. When his family discovered the massive theft, they gave him an ultimatum: check into rehab for internet addiction, or face the consequences. But Grant refused to cut ties with...

Are we truly in control of our own thoughts, or is someone else pulling the strings? This week, we dive deep into the eerie world of subliminal messages. From hidden backmasked tracks in your favorite rock songs and flashing movie theater ads to weaponized government experiments and secret military frequencies, we unmask the unseen forces designed to bypass your conscious mind. Grab your tinfoil hats and lock the doors—things are about to get weird.

This episode is sponsored by EarnIn. Stop waiting weeks to get paid for the work you’re already doing. Down...

In September 1964, a 26-year-old missile tracking technician named Donald Shrum went bow-hunting in the Tahoe National Forest. He expected to bring home some venison—he didn’t expect to spend 12 grueling hours trapped in a pine tree fighting an interstellar tactical squad.Throw out everything you think you know about sophisticated, peaceful alien abductions. The Cisco Grove incident is a visceral, chaotic, retro-futuristic survival horror movie come to life. We’re talking short humanoids wrapped in seamless silver gimp suits and a five-foot-tall mechanical "robot" that looked like a smoke-belching 1950s refrigerator with glowing red eyes.When the entities surrounded his tr...

This week on Brohio, we dive into the unbelievable and stomach-churning story of Tarrare, the 18th-century Frenchman whose insatiable hunger turned him into a medical mystery. From eating entire baskets of food in one sitting to consuming live animals, garbage, and things no human should ever eat, Tarrare's appetite shocked everyone who encountered him. Was he suffering from a rare medical condition, or was something far stranger going on? Join us as we explore one of history's most bizarre and disturbing true stories.

Special Guest: Daniel B. who was framed on our show last week.

Find...

Ever wonder if your roommate is secretly a psychopath? This week on Brohio, we're diving into Roommates From Hell—a collection of roommate horror stories featuring nightmare tenants, filthy living conditions, bizarre behavior, criminal activity, and the kind of chaos that makes you question humanity. From passive-aggressive warfare to full-blown insanity, these stories prove that sometimes the scariest thing in your house isn't a ghost... it's the person splitting the rent.
Grab a drink, lock your bedroom door, and join us for some of the wildest roommate stories we've ever heard.


Sponsored By:

This week, we are diving deep into one of the most terrifying modern hauntings in American history: The Black Hope Curse. Imagine moving into your dream suburban home in Texas, only to realize the entire subdivision was built directly on top of a forgotten, historic cemetery. From unexplainable shadow figures and violent poltergeist activity to a bizarre string of sudden, tragic deaths among neighbors, this case proves that some graves refuse to stay quiet. Grab a drink and buckle up, because this one gets dark.Today's Sponsors:
EarnIn: Stop waiting two weeks for...

Obsession, manipulation, jealousy, and a brutal murder that unraveled through journals, text messages, and conflicting stories — this week we’re diving into the disturbing case of Ezra McCandless and the killing of Alex Woodworth. What started as a chaotic love triangle turned into one of the most unsettling and psychologically messy murder cases we’ve covered in a while.

This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. You don’t have to be on this journey alone — get 10% off your first month at BetterHelp dot com slash BROHIO.

Find Us on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/c/Brohiopodcast
We Li...

In this episode, we celebrate our 9 year anniversary! Cheers to 90 more!!

Listen to No Such Thing On Apple Podcasts, Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts. New episodes drop every Wednesday. 

Find Us on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/c/Brohiopodcast
We Live Stream All Our Episodes! youtube.com/brohiopodcast

Find us on all the socials @BrohioPodcast

Something isn’t right—and it’s happening now. In the last two years, multiple scientists connected to some of the most sensitive programs in the United States have vanished, been found dead, or had their lives erased in ways that don’t add up. No forced entry. No clear motives. In some cases, not even a body. This week, we dig into the recent wave of cases: a former Air Force Research Laboratory commander who walked into the desert and never came back, a NASA engineer who disappeared within seconds on a public trail, Los Alamos personnel tied to classifi...

What if everything you think is reality… isn’t? This week, we go completely off the rails diving into the darkest, weirdest, and most uncomfortable “what if” scenarios you can imagine. From society-ending blackouts to taboo alternate timelines and reality-breaking conspiracies, we’re asking the questions that stick in your brain at 2AM and won’t let go. No rules, no limits—just chaos, curiosity, and a whole lot of “damn… what if?”

Sponsored by RUGEIT:
Fellas, if things aren’t hitting like they used to, it might be time to level up. Head over to rugeit.com/brohio and take co...

In 1700s France, something stalked the countryside—and it wasn’t just wolves. The Beast of Gévaudan left over 100 people dead, tearing through villages with a level of brutality that made even seasoned hunters question what they were dealing with. Witnesses described something too big, too smart, and way too focused on killing humans. The king sent his best men… and still, it kept coming. Was it a pack of wolves? Some exotic predator? Or something way darker hiding in plain sight? We dig into the blood-soaked history, the theories that don’t sit right, and why this might be one of...

From ancient civilizations that swore the Earth was a flat plane, to modern-day YouTube prophets screaming “the horizon is lying to you,” we unpack the wildest arguments, experiments, and conspiracies fueling the Flat Earth movement. Is it harmless curiosity… or the ultimate middle finger to science and authority?

Find Us on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/c/Brohiopodcast
We Live Stream All Our Episodes! youtube.com/brohiopodcast

Find us on all the socials @BrohioPodcast

A 12-foot redheaded giant in the mountains of Afghanistan… and a U.S. military squad that allegedly never made it back the same.This week, we’re diving into the legend of the Giant of Kandahar—one of the wildest military conspiracy stories out there. Eyewitness accounts, missing reports, government cover-up rumors… and the question: did soldiers really encounter something that shouldn’t exist?We break down the story, the “evidence,” and the theories—from ancient Nephilim to straight-up psy-op. Decide for yourself.

🎧 Also in this episode:
– Sponsored by BetterHelp
When life feels overwhelming, therapy can help.
Get 10% of...

Easter Sunday, 1975. While the rest of Hamilton, Ohio, was hunting eggs and passing the honey-glazed ham, 41-year-old James Ruppert was in his bedroom calibrating a four-piece armory. In less than five minutes, 11 family members—including eight children—were executed in cold blood.

We’re diving into the details of the house on Minor Avenue, where the blood was so thick it dripped through the floorboards. From James’s pathetic "loser" manifesto and the $300,000 motive to the "half-insane" legal loophole that shocked the country, this is the story of the deadliest private-residence shooting in American history. We also dig...

It's like the Battlefield of Love and The Brohio Confessional made a baby!!

Find Us on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/c/Brohiopodcast
We Live Stream All Our Episodes! youtube.com/brohiopodcast

Find us on all the socials @BrohioPodcast

What if your earliest memories aren't actually yours? This week, we’re tearing into the dark history of Project IBIS, a rumored Cold War program that allegedly bypassed adult subjects to experiment on the most vulnerable "blank slate" available: children.We’re breaking down the disturbing logistics of "Orphanage Fronts" and the high-tech conditioning used to rewrite the human nervous system. From ultra-low frequency sleep programming to sensory deprivation tanks designed to trigger "remote viewing," this wasn't just brainwashing—it was biological hacking.Tonight’s Deep Dive:
The Nursery: How the state allegedly sourced...

Episode Description: The Bizarre Mystery of Cindy JamesFor nearly seven years, Canadian nurse Cindy James lived a waking nightmare. It began with threatening phone calls and escalated into a relentless campaign of terror: prowlers, smashed windows, home invasions, and brutal physical assaults. By the time her body was found in June 1989—hogtied and strangled with a nylon stocking in the yard of an abandoned house—the case had become one of the most polarizing mysteries in true crime history.Was Cindy the victim of a calculated, invisible monster who stayed one step ahead of a 24-hour police surveillance team...

In October 1943, something allegedly happened in the Philadelphia Naval Shipyard that the U.S. government has spent decades denying… and conspiracy theorists have spent decades obsessing over. According to the legend, the U.S. Navy attempted to make the USS Eldridge invisible using powerful electromagnetic fields. Sounds cool, right? Until witnesses claimed the ship didn’t just disappear from radar — it vanished completely. Some say it teleported hundreds of miles away to Norfolk, Virginia… and then snapped back. But the real nightmare stories came from the crew. Sailors allegedly fused into the metal hull of the ship. Others caught on fire. So...

Before WebMD convinced you that your headache is terminal, medicine used to be… absolutely unhinged. This week we dive headfirst into the horrifying, hilarious world of Old Time Medicine—when doctors prescribed heroin for coughs, crocodile poop for birth control, and thought the best way to diagnose illness was by drinking your pee like a fine wine. From arsenic beauty wafers to tapeworm diet pills, humanity spent centuries confidently poisoning itself in the name of “science.” We explore the weird cures, the gross treatments, and the moments where medicine was basically guessing with confidence. Spoiler: somehow we survived long enough to inven...

What happens when a high-society fertility nurse decides her husband is no longer part of her "happily ever after"? You get one of the most clinical, cold-blooded, and flat-out jaw-dropping true crime stories in New Jersey history.This week, we’re diving deep into the life of Melanie McGuire—a woman who lived a double life fueled by a "lusty" office affair with a prominent doctor. We’re talking thousands of dirty emails, secret "burner" phones, and a digital paper trail that would make a soap opera writer blush. But when the "Lust" hit a breaking point, Melanie didn't...

This episode is a wild ride through one of the most chaotic events in sporting history. If you thought modern marathons were intense, wait until you hear about the 1904 St. Louis Olympic Marathon—featuring dust clouds, strychnine "performance enhancers," wild dogs, and a winner who hitched a ride in a car for half the race. It’s less of a race and more of a 26-mile fever dream that barely anyone survived.

We also know that life can feel like a grueling marathon sometimes, and you don’t have to run it alone. This episode is brought to you...