MK True Crime

The MK True Crime Show hosts Phil Holloway and Ashleigh Merchant join the program to discuss updates in the Sandra Birchmore trial, the news that Matthew Farwell’s mistresses will be allowed to testify, how their testimony relates to the notorious surveillance footage of Farwell in Birchmore’s apartment building the day prosecutors allege Birchmore died, some of the numerous messages investigators recovered between Farwell and Birchmore, updates in the murder trial of Virginia man Naresh Bhatt, the blood and DNA evidence prosecutors have presented so far, Mamta Bhatt’s last documented cellphone activity, the CCTV footage showing Naresh buying...

In The Well host Mark Geragos is joined by criminal defense attorney Alexandra Kazarian and LA Magazine contributor Lauren Conlin to discuss the latest Cornell 7 legal drama that unfolded on Wednesday, why Jane Doe’s attorney, Thomas Giuffra, filed a response accusing defense lawyers of selectively leaking confidential Cornell Title IX records to the press, why Giuffra attacked TMZ and Mark Geragos in the filing, Alexandra Kazarian analyzes the timeline in Jane Doe’s text messages, the selective roll out of the Cornell 7 IX report by Jane Doe’s legal team and major media outlets, the legal relevance of Jane D...

The MK True Crime Show hosts Phil Holloway and Ashleigh Merchant join the program to discuss updates in the Sandra Birchmore trial, the DNA evidence against former Stoughton police detective Matthew Farwell, the previously unreported facial injuries journalist Michele McPhee described after seeing crime scene photos in court, why the defense is fighting to keep Farwell’s other alleged mistresses off the stand, updates in the Cornell 7 case, why the increasingly available text messages from Jane Doe to one of the accused could make for a tough prosecution, Doe’s attorney’s public statements regarding those text messages, and later...

Positively Legal hosts Mark Eiglarsh and Jonna Spilbor join the show to discuss the case of Texas mother Holly Flores who is accused of stabbing her young children and husband, the parallels and differences between the Flores case and the Lindsay Clancy case, the weird facts that we know in the case so far, Mark and Jonna then discuss the latest developments in the Cornell 7 case, the lawyers discuss Letitia James’ bias and why she should step down from prosecuting the Cornell 7 defendants, the shocking texts that have been revealed between Jane Doe and the accused, the one text th...

The MK True Crime Show host Phil Holloway and guest co-host Jonna Spilbor of Positively Legal join the program to discuss updates in the Cornell 7 case, the various legal teams fighting to get New York Attorney General Letitia James removed from the case as special prosecutor, the social media post that has them arguing she is unable to be an impartial investigator, how James has responded to the controversy, the unusual pre-sentencing hearing of former Florida plastic surgeon Tomasz Kosowski, the motions he argued for ahead of the hearing, mitigating factors presented by an attorney appointed to assist him...

In The Well host Mark Geragos is joined by MK True Crime Show host Ashleigh Merchant to discuss Christa Pike’s botched execution, how the failed execution will affect death penalty cases going forward, the legal debate that ensued immediately following the failed execution, if the state of Tennessee will attempt to execute Pike again, criminal defense attorney Alexandra Kazarian joins Mark and Ashleigh to discuss the latest developments in the Cornell 7 case, what Jane Doe’s newly released text messages to a frat brother reveal, the legal jargon used in the text messages, the discrepancies revealed by drug test...

The MK True Crime Show hosts Dave Aronberg and Ashleigh Merchant join the program to discuss the assault allegations against Kim Zolciak and Kroy Biermann’s fifteen-year-old son, the shocking prior charges he faced in 2023 and why they became public at his 2026 bond hearing, whether or not the teenager will ultimately be charged as an adult, the dismissal of child endangerment charges against the Siders family grandfather, Gary Sr, what his competency evaluation revealed, what it means to be “unrestorable,” even more people connected to the family who are also facing charges, and later Dave and Ashleigh are joined by lic...

Positively Legal hosts Mark Eiglarsh and Jonna Spilbor join the show to discuss the latest in former NFL star Antonio Brown’s delayed plea deal attempted second-degree murder case, why the judge delayed the plea agreement, why Antonio Brown wore a bizarre black face mask at court, Mark and Jonna then discuss the latest developments in the Cornell 7 Case, special prosecutor Letitia James being appointed to investigate the case, the protests erupting on the Cornell University campus, pastor Caleb Flynn sentenced to life for murder of wife Ashley Flynn, the brutal statements written by his young daughters read aloud in...

The MK True Crime Show hosts Ashleigh Merchant and Phil Holloway join the program to discuss the latest updates in the Cornell 7 case, the new details recently released about Cornell’s investigation of Jane Doe’s alleged 2024 assault, the scrutiny of local district attorney Matthew Van Houten, the appointment of New York Attorney General Letitia James as special prosecutor by New York Governor Kathy Hochul, Tennessee’s unsuccessful attempt to execute convicted killer Christa Pike, the mechanisms of capital punishment in the United States, what went wrong in Pike’s lethal injection, where she is now and whether or not the...

In The Well host Mark Geragos is joined by former prosecutor and criminal defense attorney Jacob Kaplan to discuss the Cornell 7 case, why the DA’s office felt pressure to respond, the differences in Jane Doe’s statements, the media’s rush to convict the seven men accused in the court of public opinion, why the snapchat could be used as evidence if criminal charges are pursued, how these allegations are already affecting the seven men accused, the parallels to the Harvey Weinstein retrial, why it’s important to take a step back and not rush to judgement, LA Magazine...

The MK True Crime Show hosts Dave Aronberg and Ashleigh Merchant join the program to discuss the Cornell Seven case, what Jane Doe is alleging happened in the Chi Phi fraternity house in 2024, the civil lawsuit that has resulted in a major public outcry, the district attorney and university’s responses to the allegations, the significance of a newly surfaced interview transcript that tells more of Jane Doe’s account of events than the statement the DA initially cited, the conviction of Caleb Flynn for the murder of his wife Ashley, how his parents responded after the verdict was read...

Positively Legal hosts Mark Eiglarsh and Jonna Spilbor join the show to discuss the “Cornell 7” civil lawsuit filed in September 2026 regarding an alleged October 2024 gang rape at a fraternity house, why Jonna is riled up about the lawsuit, the hard lessons to be learned from this lawsuit, Mark gives an update on his former NFL star client, Antonio Brown, what Mark expects to happen at Brown’s proposed plea deal hearing on Wednesday, the different ways the judge could rule, Lindsay Clancy defense attorney Kevin Reddington’s shocking statements at the status hearing on Tuesday, why his statements are a legal...

The MK True Crime Show hosts Phil Holloway and Ashleigh Merchant join the program to discuss the latest updates in the Nolan Wells case, what a forensic analyst retained by Nolan’s family found while reviewing the teenager’s cellphone, why the results may be less clear than they seem, the unusual way the state received the information about the cellphone extraction, Dr. Kendall Crowns joins the show to break down Nolan’s official autopsy report, the theory and statistics of “dry drowning,” what can and can’t be inferred from the toxicology report, the significance of the bruises on the back...

In The Well host Matt Murphy is joined by MK True Crime Show co-host Dave Aronberg to discuss the latest updates in the Lindsay Clancy case, why the holdout juror’s lawyer called Lindsay a “demon,” the lawyers discuss jurors using their cell phones, Kevin Reddington’s reaction to Patrick Clancy’s “60 Minutes” interview, News Director of East Idaho News, Nate Eaton, joins Matt and Dave to discuss the latest in the Caleb Flynn trial, the bombshell texts read aloud on the stand by Caleb Flynn mistress Alleigha Botner, whether Botner could be charged with anything, why Caleb Flynn’s 911 call raise...

The MK True Crime Show hosts Dave Aronberg and Ashleigh Merchant join the program to discuss the grand jury report in the death of Nolan Wells, why the grand jury returned a “no true bill,” the evidence they reviewed that brought them to that conclusion, what the attorneys involved have said since the report was publicly released, the appeal hearing of Richard Allen, who was convicted in 2024 of the infamous 2017 Delphi Murders, why his attorney is arguing his confessions were the result of psychosis, the evidence that played a key role in his conviction and why Allen’s attorney says i...

Positively Legal hosts Mark Eiglarsh and Jonna Spilbor join the show to discuss Patrick Clancy’s “60 Minutes” interview, reactions to Patrick’s forgiveness, why Lindsay Clancy didn’t ask for forgiveness, whether Clancy defense attorney Kevin Reddington has crossed a line regarding investigating holdout juror, how the Lindsay Clancy trial will affect the jury system going forward, Mark and Jonna then discuss the Tomasz Kosowski trial happening this week, why the plastic surgeon chose to represent himself in a bench trial, why Kosowski’s bizarre behavior may work in his favor, and more.

Mark Eiglarsh: https://www.e...

The MK True Crime Show hosts Phil Holloway and Ashleigh Merchant join the program to discuss the latest updates regarding the holdout juror from the Lindsay Clancy trial, why Kevin Reddington is now asking for the court to investigate him, why it’s a measure that’s unusual but not unheard of, what this saga says about the state of the jury-selection system in the United States, the "60 Minutes" interview Patrick Clancy and his new wife gave CBS, how the two work to honor Patrick’s children as he continues to mourn them, what Patrick had to say about the on...

In The Well hosts Mark Geragos and Matt Murphy join the show to discuss Turtleboy News founder Aidan Kearney doxxing the Lindsay Clancy holdout juror’s identity, why it’s unlikely defense attorney Kevin Reddington was involved in the doxxing, why doxxing is a form of jury intimidation, the lasting effects of the holdout juror’s doxxing on the jury system, NewsNation Senior National Correspondent Brian Entin joins Mark and Matt to discuss his experience on the ground at the Lindsay Clancy trial, Brian’s observations of the holdout juror in the courtroom, why it’s possible Gayle King knew the i...

The MK True Crime Show hosts Dave Aronberg and Ashleigh Merchant join the program to discuss the recent addition to Lindsay Clancy’s legal team as she pursues a double jeopardy motion, the doxxing of the holdout juror, the interview that juror allegedly gave to an independent journalist via phone, the revelation that Elizabeth Siders appeared pregnant at a recent court hearing just months after 16 children were removed from the Ohio “House of Horrors” where she lived with her in-laws, the DA’s decision to not pursue the death penalty in Nick Reiner’s case, why there’s some question as...

Positively Legal hosts Mark Eiglarsh and Jonna Spilbor join the show to discuss the latest updates in Mark’s client former NFL star Antonio Brown’s second-degree attempted murder charge, why the alleged victim is now saying he forgives Brown and won’t be participating in the prosecution, why Mark wants the charges dropped now, Mark and Jonna discuss the Lindsay Clancy jurors speaking out, they react to a juror telling Gayle King that the holdout juror is a black man, what statements from the jurors bothered Jonna, whether the jurors went “rogue,” the lawyers then discuss the trial of former a...

The MK True Crime Show hosts Phil Holloway and Ashleigh Merchant join the program to discuss the troubling information coming out about the holdout juror in the Lindsay Clancy case, the jurors who are now revealing more details about their deliberations in the highly controversial trial, why some of the revelations could be concerning from an attorney’s perspective, updates in the Siders family Ohio “House of Horrors" case, what Gary Sr.’s competency evaluation means for the case going forward, new allegations involving another child against Gary Jr. and Elizabeth Siders, and later Phil and Ashleigh are joined by Chr...

In The Well hosts Mark Geragos and Matt Murphy join the show to discuss the Lindsay Clancy jurors speaking out, what a male juror had to say about the lone holdout in the deliberation room, why the holdout juror is being vilified, what the jurors had to say about Patrick Clancy, LA Magazine contributor Taylor Parise joins Mark and Matt to discuss the Lil Durk murder-for-hire trial happening now, the drama inside the courtroom during closing arguments, why the deliberations are ongoing after multiple jury questions, Mark and Matt are joined by Orange County District Attorney’s Office investigator, Li...

MK True Crime Show hosts Dave Aronberg and Ashleigh Merchant join the show to discuss the frustrating end to the Lindsay Clancy trial, whether the mistrial is an example of reverse jury nullification, the lawyers discuss what Judge Sullivan did right, Dave and Ashleigh discuss defense attorney Kevin Reddington’s media tour, why Reddington asked Trump for a presidential pardon for Lindsay Clancy, whether a plea deal is on the table for Clancy, senior investigative reporter and host of “Criminally Obsessed,” Anne Emerson, joins Dave and Ashleigh to discuss the revelations from the Clancy jurors, why the prosecution’s strategy...

Positively Legal hosts Mark Eiglarsh and Jonna Spilbor join the show to discuss their thoughts on the judge declaring a mistrial in the Lindsay Clancy Case last week, why the jury remained deadlocked 11-1 until the end, why the holdout juror should be defended for his actions, why Judge Sullivan’s actions were commendable, defense attorney Kevin Reddington’s public plea to the President to pardon Lindsay Clancy, the case of Illinois woman Corie Walsh who was arrested last week for murdering her toddler, whether this was a “copycat” murder in connection to the Lindsay Clancy trial, the case of Patri...

Enjoy this special bonus episode featuring a retrospective compilation of our coverage of the Lindsay Clancy trial across the MK True Crime Show, Positively Legal, and In The Well. In this bonus release, we’ve brought together past deep dives, legal breakdowns, and timeline analyses of the explosive trial. 

Phil Holloway: https://x.com/PhilHollowayEsq

Dave Aronberg: https://davearonberglaw.com

Ashleigh Merchant: https://www.criminaldefenseattorneysmarietta.com

Jonna Spilbor: https://jonnaspilbor.com

Mark Eiglarsh: https://www.eiglarshlaw.com

Matt...

In The Well hosts Mark Geragos and Matt Murphy are joined by criminal defense attorney Alan Jackson to discuss their early days working alongside each other in California including the case of Kazuyoshi Miura dubbed “Japanese OJ,” the murder of legendary racing innovator Mickey Thompson, the lawyers discuss the latest developments in the Lindsay Clancy trial, the bombshell revelation of one holdout juror, why this juror may skew towards the prosecution, why the judge read the instruction on reasonable doubt again, why defense attorney Kevin Reddington will continue to push for the holdout juror’s removal, why Matt would have l...

The MK True Crime Show hosts Dave Aronberg and Ashleigh Merchant join the program to discuss the jury’s ongoing deliberations in the Lindsay Clancy trial, what the Tuey-Rodriguez or “dynamite” charge is and why Judge Sullivan used it when he sent the jury back to continue deliberating for a second time, the spectator arrested for allegedly recording the jurors as they left the courthouse, why her attorney characterizes the incident as a misunderstanding, the Commonwealth’s account of her arrest during her arraignment, Massachusetts attorney Katherine Loftus joins Dave and Ashleigh to discuss the odds of a verdict in the C...

Positively Legal hosts Mark Eiglarsh and Jonna Spilbor join the show to discuss Lindsay Clancy jurors’ deadlock, the lawyers discuss the possible reasons why the juror cannot come to a unanimous decision, what happens if the judge declares a mistrial, Mark and Jonna analyze defense attorney Kevin Reddington’s closing argument at the Lindsay Clancy trial, why women are labeling Reddington a “female icon,” what Lindsay Clancy supporters are missing, Mark and Jonna react to the hit Netflix documentary “Death of the Pastor’s Wife,” the traumatic and coercive relationship between JP and Mica Miller, the very serious charges JP Miller is f...

The MK True Crime Show hosts Dave Aronberg and Phil Holloway join the program to discuss jury instructions and closing arguments in the Lindsay Clancy trial, the unusual move Judge Sullivan made when he explained the maximum penalties associated with each charge, Kevin Reddington’s quarters, what they represented and if they were effective, the unexpected way the prosecution began their closing argument, which side was most effective and how their closings compared to their performance throughout proceedings, D4vd’s arraignment hearing on Monday, why he might have parted ways with high-profile defense attorney Blair Berk, whether the sing...

In The Well hosts Mark Geragos and Matt Murphy join the show to discuss the closing arguments in the Lindsay Clancy trial, criticism and praise for both the prosecution and the defense’s arguments, why the prosecution took a completely different tone, the lawyers speculate on what the jury will decide, why trials are won or lost in jury selection, why attorneys need to be focused on the jury during trial, LA Magazine contributor Lauren Conlin joins Mark and Matt from on the ground in Plymouth, Massachusetts at the Lindsay Clancy trial to discuss defense attorney Kevin Reddington’s bril...

The MK True Crime Show hosts Phil Holloway and Ashleigh Merchant join the program to discuss the final witnesses in the Lindsay Clancy murder trial, the mistrial motion drama that unfolded after one expert witness referenced Lindsay’s religion in his testimony, how double jeopardy could apply in the case of a mistrial, what jury charges are and what to expect from them in the Clancy case, the specifics of criminal responsibility and the insanity defense in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, the controversy around a journalist who was caught smiling at the camera on a trial livestream, what she sa...

Positively Legal hosts Mark Eiglarsh and Jonna Spilbor join the show to discuss the latest developments in the Lindsay Clancy trial, the lawyers discuss the testimony by the Commonwealth’s rebuttal expert witness psychologist Dr. Kirk Heilbrun, why Clancy’s voice “command hallucination” is unusual, Dr. Heilbrun’s theory of “altruistic filicide,” the lawyers discuss whether Clancy should be found criminally responsible for the murder of her children, defense attorney Kevin Reddington’s motion for a mistrial after religion is invoked yet again, Mark and Jonna are joined by award-winning journalist Chris Hansen to discuss his thoughts on the Lindsay Clancy t...

The MK True Crime Show hosts Ashleigh Merchant and Dave Aronberg join the program to discuss the latest developments in the Lindsay Clancy trial, why Kevin Reddington moved for a mistrial as we approach closing statements, the defense’s final witness, psychiatrist Dr. Phillip Resnick, how he says Lindsay described feeling the day she took her children’s lives, why he was allowed to testify to the “ultimate issue,” what jurors will hear from Judge Sullivan before they deliberate, the new charges against two members of the Siders family, who were arrested earlier this year on child endangerment charges for hous...

In The Well host Mark Geragos and MK True Crime Show co-host Ashleigh Merchant join the show to discuss the latest developments in the Lindsay Clancy murder trial, the moment when the prosecutor asked the “mortal sin” moment, the lawyers speculate whether the state was going for a mistrial with that question, the lawyers then discuss Karmelo Anthony’s bid for a new trial, why the judge’s recusal in the case was not surprising, the texts messages and evidence revealed in the hearing for a new trial, if Anthony really has a shot at a new trial, LA Magazine...

The MK True Crime Show hosts Dave Aronberg and Ashleigh Merchant join the program to discuss the latest developments in the Lindsay Clancy trial, the testimony of psychologist Dr. Paul Zeizel who evaluated Lindsay in the hospital after the tragedy, what he said when asked if he influenced Lindsay’s account of the killings, conflicting testimony regarding the male voice Lindsay says told her to harm her children and then herself, the breakdown of Lindsay’s injuries after her alleged suicide attempt, the TikTok creator the judge rejected as a witness regarding McLean Hospital, a possible explanation for why Brya...

Positively Legal hosts Mark Eiglarsh and Jonna Spilbor join the show to discuss Luigi Mangione’s guilty plea in his federal case, the lawyers explain what an “open plea” means, predictions on if the double jeopardy argument will rule out Mangione’s New York case, if Mangione could get out of prison in as little as 20 years and what his life would look like, the lawyers discuss the latest in the Lindsay Clancy murder trial, why the defense called Lindsay Clancy’s close family members to the stand first, what Clancy’s sister revealed about the gut feeling she had that Lin...

The MK True Crime Show hosts Ashleigh Merchant and Phil Holloway join the program to discuss Luigi Mangione’s guilty plea to federal stalking charges, what sentence he could face, how the plea will affect his New York murder trial now that his attorneys have moved to dismiss state charges based on double jeopardy, how New York’s double jeopardy protections could spell a long appeals process regardless of whether or not the state case is dismissed, opening arguments in the trial of Duane “Keffe D” Davis, what each side is claiming about Davis’s involvement with the fatal shooting o...

In The Well hosts Matt Murphy and Mark Geragos join the show to discuss the surprise hearing in Luigi Mangione’s federal case, whether Mangione will plead guilty, Mark predicts that the hearing is to hammer out language in the “factual basis” for a plea and what that means, the lawyers discuss how a federal guilty plea deal could potentially trigger state statutory protections or complicate New York's ability to move forward with the state murder trial, Mark and Matt discuss the indictment of Nick Reiner by a grand jury this week for the murder of his parents, Rob and Mi...

The MK True Crime Show hosts Dave Aronberg and Phil Holloway join the program to discuss Luigi Mangione’s final pretrial conference ahead of his New York State murder trial, how the court will accommodate more than 80 media outlets expected to cover the trial, why there’s speculation that Mangione may be seeking a plea deal in his federal case and how that could affect his state case, the news that Chris Watts, who confessed to murdering his pregnant wife and two young daughters, has found love behind bars, the realtor he now intends to marry, what her family did...

Positively Legal hosts Mark Eiglarsh and Jonna Spilbor join the show to discuss a recent issue Jonna is navigating with a client who has complained about her wardrobe, the lawyers discuss recent cases involving parents taking justice into their hands, they discuss the case of a father luring and shooting his 11-year-old daughter’s abuser, the case of Kendra Scott, a Tennessee mother who shot and killed a man she found hiding under her 13-year-old’s bed, whether it will matter to a jury that the man may have been intellectually impaired, the lawyers then discuss the third week of t...