The Final Trace
The Final Trace is a true crime podcast digging into chilling disappearances, cold cases, and mysteries that still leave us searching for answers. Hosted by Hopper Dailey & Mckenzie, each chapter steps into final moments, overlooked clues, and theories that linger. Every story is a chapter - not the whole book. Just one page of someones story... the page where everything changed. From strange sightings to unsettling truths, we follow the clues wherever they lead. New Chapters every True Crime Tuesday.
A Short Trace | The Plum Tree Murder
📍 Evansville, Indiana | October 31, 1925
🎙️ A Short Trace | The Plum Tree Murder
Halloween night, 1925.
An Evansville couple returned home to a horrifying discovery. Hanging from a plum tree in their front yard was the body of a man, suspended by his own necktie.
At first glance, it appeared to be a suicide. But the evidence told a very different story.
The victim was a 35-year-old who had seemingly vanished before his body was discovered. And when investigators examined his remains, they uncovered injuries that suggested something far more sinister.
Someone had murd...
Mysterious Death: Brendan Santo
📍 East Lansing, Michigan | October 29, 2021
🎙️ Chapter 70 | The Final Trace of Brendan Santo
It was Halloween weekend at Michigan State University. The campus was buzzing with students, parties, and football excitement. But for eighteen-year-old Brendan Santo, a night out with friends would end in tragedy.
Brendan vanished after leaving a residence hall, setting off a massive search that lasted nearly three months. When his body was finally discovered in the Red Cedar River, investigators believed they had their answer.
But not everyone agreed.
Questions about surveillance cameras, a mishandled phone, and conflicting interpre...
Mysterious Death: Olene Emberton
📍 Tipton, Indiana | October 16, 1965
🎙️ Chapter 69 | The Final Trace of Olene Emberton
A night at the movies. A short drive home. And a young woman who would never make it back.
In October 1965, Olene Emberton vanished after an evening at the theater in her small Indiana hometown. What began as a missing-person investigation soon took a devastating turn when her body was discovered.
No obvious signs of violence. No clear cause of death. And a father convinced he knew who was responsible.
More than sixty years later, the mystery remains.
What hap...
Darkcast Halloween Special: Stories Your Mummy Never Told You.
🎃 Stories Your Mummy Never Told You | A Darkcast Network Halloween Special 👻
The candles are lit. The doors are locked. And somewhere in the darkness... someone has a story to tell.
This Halloween, the Darkcast Network is gathering around the microphone once again, bringing together eight podcasts for a night of chilling tales, eerie encounters, and mysteries that refuse to stay buried.
From unsettling legends to stories that might make you question every creak in your house, there's something waiting in the shadows for everyone.
So grab a blanket, turn down the lights...
Mysterious Death: Christopher Case
📍 Seattle, Washington | April 1991
🎙️ Chapter 68 | The Final Trace of Christopher Case
Seven days.
That's how long Christopher Case reportedly believed he had left to live.
After a disturbing encounter with a woman in San Francisco, the 35-year-old music executive became convinced that someone had placed a deadly curse on him.
What followed was a terrifying week of unexplained experiences, desperate phone calls, and an increasingly frantic attempt to protect himself from something he believed was coming.
On April 18, 1991, Christopher was found dead inside his Seattle apartment.
Candle...
Murdered: Philip Peters
📍 Denver, Colorado | October 17, 1941
🎙️ Chapter 67 | The Final Trace of Philip Peters: The Denver Ghost House
When 73-year-old Philip Peters was found brutally murdered inside his Denver home, investigators were left with more questions than answers.
There were no signs of forced entry. No clear motive. And no suspect.
But Philip's death was only the beginning.
In the months that followed, his grieving wife, Helen, began experiencing strange things inside their home.
Footsteps echoed through empty rooms. Objects disappeared. Unexplained noises filled the night.
Soon, ne...
Murdered: The Axeman of New Orleans
📍 New Orleans, Louisiana | 1918–1919
🎙️ Chapter 66 | The Final Trace of the Axeman of New Orleans
For more than a year, someone was slipping into New Orleans homes in the dead of night.
The attacks were brutal. The weapon was often found nearby. And whoever was responsible seemed to disappear as quietly as they came.
Then a letter arrived.
The writer claimed to be the Axeman — and warned that at 12:15 a.m., he would walk the streets of New Orleans again.
But this time, he offered the city a way out.
...
Murdered: Ann Harmeier
📍 Martinsville, Indiana | September 12, 1977
🎙️ Chapter 65 | The Final Trace of Ann Harmeier
Twenty-year-old Indiana University student Ann Harmeier was driving back to Bloomington for a morning class when her Pontiac overheated along State Road 37.
Hours later, her mother found the car still sitting along the highway—locked, abandoned, and with its battery drained from the emergency flashers.
Ann was nowhere to be found.
For 36 days, her face appeared on thousands of posters, bumper stickers, and billboards as a massive search spread across Indiana. Then, a farmer harvesting his cornfield made a devastating discovery...
Mysterious Death: Jonathan Luna
📍 Baltimore, Maryland → Lancaster County, Pennsylvania | December 3–4, 2003
🎙️ Chapter 64 | The Final Trace of Jonathan Luna
At 11:38 p.m., federal prosecutor Jonathan Luna left his Baltimore office without his cell phone or the glasses he needed to drive.
By dawn, his Honda was sitting above a creek nearly 90 miles away—and Jonathan was dead.
Investigators could retrace much of his strange overnight journey through toll records, an ATM withdrawal, and a late-night gas stop. But the evidence only created more questions.
$36,000 had vanished. Jonathan had 36 wounds. His own knife was found closed. And two groups of...
Missing: Sneha Philip
📍 Lower Manhattan, New York | September 10, 2001
🎙️ Chapter 63 | The Final Trace of Sneha Anne Philip
On the evening of September 10th, 2001, 31-year-old physician Dr. Sneha Anne Philip was captured on surveillance shopping at a department store just blocks from her apartment.
It would be the last confirmed trace of her.
Hours later, the world changed.
In the chaos of September 11th, Sneha’s disappearance became tangled with one of the darkest days in American history. A mysterious figure caught on surveillance. Shopping bags that were never found. Thirteen missing ho...
Missing: Lauren Spierer
📍 Bloomington, Indiana | June 3, 2011
🎙️ Chapter 62 | The Final Trace of Lauren Spierer
For hours, Lauren Spierer’s movements through Bloomington can be pieced together almost minute by minute.
Until suddenly… they can’t.
In the early morning hours of June 3, 2011, the 20-year-old Indiana University student vanished. Her phone and shoes were left behind. Her apartment was only a few blocks away. And according to the last person known to be with her, Lauren walked into the darkness around 4:30 a.m.
She has never been seen again.
Fifteen years later, we retrace Lauren...
Solved: Jayna Murray
📍 Bethesda, Maryland | March 11, 2011
🎙️ Chapter 61 | The Final Trace of Jayna Murray
On a Friday night in one of Bethesda’s busiest shopping districts, two coworkers returned to the Lululemon store where they worked.
By morning, 30-year-old Jayna Murray was dead. Her coworker was found bound, bleeding, and alive—with a terrifying story of what had happened behind those locked doors.
Police began searching for two violent men believed to be responsible.
But inside the blood-soaked store, the evidence was beginning to tell a very different story.
What happened that night would...
Murdered: Bryan Haltom
📍 Spencer, Indiana | July 17, 1996
🎙️ Chapter 60 | The Final Trace of Bryan Haltom
Just after midnight, 18-year-old Bryan Haltom was driving his red Trans Am through the quiet streets of Spencer, Indiana, when an encounter with another car followed him onto U.S. 231.
Minutes later, Bryan was dead.
The other driver vanished into the night.
What initially appeared to be a senseless act of road rage would soon raise questions that have lingered for three decades. A disputed timeline, strange rumors, and the possibility that Bryan's encounter with a strang...
Mysterious Death: Erin Valenti
📍 San Jose, California | October 2019
🎙️ Chapter 14 Revisited | Mysterious Death: Erin Valenti
We’ve told Erin Valenti’s story before.
But we’ve never told it like this.
After first covering Erin’s strange and unsettling final days, we went back—reexamining the timeline, digging deeper into the medical findings, and exploring new information and theories we never touched the first time around.
Erin’s death was officially ruled natural. But the mystery of what she was experiencing in those final hours has never really gone away.
“It’s all a game.”
“It’s a thou...
Introducing: Our True Crime Podcast
Today, we're doing something a little different! Introducing you to one of our favorite podcast!
We're handing The Final Trace feed over to our friends Cam and Jen from Our True Crime Podcast for a special feed swap!
In this episode, they take us back to March 26, 1990, and the murder of Elizabeth Mackintosh: a case we had never heard before, and one we think you're going to want to hear.
If you're new to Our True Crime Podcast, consider this your introduction. Cam and Jen have been telling true crime stories together for...
Mysterious Disappearance: Frederick Valentich
📍 Bass Strait, Australia | October 21, 1978
🎙️ Chapter 59 | The Final Trace of Frederick Valentich
🔎 Mysterious Disappearance
Twenty-year-old pilot Frederick Valentich took off from Melbourne for what should have been a routine flight to King Island.
Less than an hour later, he contacted Melbourne Flight Service with a strange question: Was there any known traffic below 5,000 feet?
There wasn’t.
But Frederick could see something in the sky with him.
For the next several minutes, an air traffic controller listened as the pilot described what was happening out...
Mysterious Death: Michael Dean Riley
📍 Indianapolis, IN | Year: 1976
🎧 Chapter 58 — The Final Trace of Michael Dean Riley
A walk home.
A missing college student.
A discovery that raised more questions than answers.
This week on The Final Trace, we revisit the 1976 case of Ball State student Michael Dean Riley. Fifty years later, investigators know how Michael died—but what happened during a Fourth of July party remains one of Indiana's most haunting unsolved mysteries.
Join us as we follow Michael's final known journey... and examine the theories that still leave one questi...
Missing: Molly Dattilo
📍Indianapolis, IN | Year: 2004
🎧 Chapter 57 - The Final Trace of Molly Dattilo
On the night of July 6, 2004, 23-year-old Molly Dattilo spent the evening with new acquaintances, made a phone call from a pay phone outside a Thornton's gas station in Indianapolis... and vanished.
The call disconnected before a single word was spoken.
More than twenty years later, investigators believe Molly was the victim of homicide, yet no one has ever been criminally charged in her disappearance. In this chapter, we follow Molly's final known movements, examine the qu...
Missing: Mark Tomich
📍 Indianapolis, IN | Year: 1992
🎧 Chapter 56 — The Final Trace of Mark Tomich
🚘 His BMW made it to work.
Mark Edward Tomich didn't.
On a quiet March morning in 1992, Mark left home for what should have been another ordinary day at Eli Lilly. His coworkers never saw him. His locked BMW was later found in the parking lot... but Mark had vanished.
Thirty-four years later, one question still remains:
What happened between saying "I'll see you later"... and never being seen again?
S...
Missing: Prisma Reyes
📍 Dallas, TX | Year: 2019
🎧 Chapter 55 — The Final Trace of Prisma Reyes
Some disappearances leave almost nothing behind.
Prisma Reyes left behind hours of evidence.
Surveillance cameras.
Phone records.
Witnesses.
A timeline investigators can follow almost minute by minute.
And yet... the most important piece of the puzzle is still missing.
📄 Official Case History & Articles
WFAA News — Four Years Later Case Overview: The core news text outlining the complete 2019 timeline, off...
Solved: Jill Behrman
📍 Bloomington, Indiana | Year: 2000
🎧 Chapter 54 — The Final Trace of Jill Behrman
Nineteen-year-old Jill Behrman set out on a routine morning bike ride through the rolling hills of southern Indiana.
She never came home.
What followed was nearly three years of searches, false confessions, dead-end leads, and a community desperate for answers.
When Jill was finally found, investigators believed they had solved the case.
But decades later, questions still linger about the investigation, the evidence, and whether every piece of the story was ever unc...
Mysterious Death: Joseph Smedley
📍 Bloomington, Indiana | Year: 2015
🎧 Chapter 53 — The Final Trace of Joseph Smedley
Twenty-year-old Joseph Smedley had big dreams. An Indiana University biochemistry student with plans to one day create life-saving medications, he was known for his kindness, his infectious smile, and the positive energy he brought to everyone around him.
Then, in the early morning hours of September 28th, his sister received a chilling text message:
"Viv, I love you. I'm leaving the country… I'm sorry."
Five days later, Joseph was found floating in the shallow waters of Griffy Lak...
Mysterious Death: Mary Grimes Wallace
📍 Xenia, Ohio | Year: 1954
🎧 Chapter 52 — The Final Trace of Mary Grimes Wallace
On a bitter January morning, a train crew discovered the body of a woman lying on the railroad tracks outside of town.
Authorities quickly identified her as thirty-two-year-old Mary Grimes Wallace.
But almost immediately, the case began to unravel.
There was little blood at the scene.
A mysterious man was seen walking away from the tracks.
And investigators questioned whether the victim had died somewhere else entirely.
Then, years later, a rumor su...
Solved: Mike Sewell
📍 Brownstown, Indiana | Year: 1971
🎧 Chapter 51: The Final Trace of Mike Sewell
Three teenage friends.
A handmade cabin hidden along the White River.
And a winter night that would haunt a small Indiana town for more than half a century.
When a fire reduced the cabin to ashes, investigators identified only two victims. The third boy, 16-year-old Mike Sewell, vanished without a trace.
Rumors spread.
Theories took hold.
And for fifty-two years, families searched for answers.
Did Mike s...
Mysterious Death: Kristy Kelley
📍 Boonville, Indiana | Year: 2014
🎧 Chapter 50: The Final Trace of Kristy Kelley
Kristy Kelley was a 27-year-old mother of two, rebuilding her life after a divorce and looking forward to what came next.
On the night of August 14, 2014, she met friends for what should have been an ordinary night out.
But sometime after leaving a local VFW, Kristy vanished.
For thirty-two days, her family searched.
Then her SUV was discovered submerged in a remote pond with Kristy still inside.
Authorities quickly ruled...
Rouge Transmissions IV: Part II
Rogue Transmissions--the edgy, semi-annual anthology of indie podcasts--is invading your podcast feed with DUNGEONPUNK PART 2 ... a symphony of 80s nostalgia, dystopian cyberpunk, and savage swords drawn against both super sorcery & super science. Featuring an adventuring party of your indie podcast favorites!
FIRST UP, Octoberpod presents "Byzantium Slab: The Shell Remember" a wraparound tale of adventure on the savage streets of the dystopian Witch Kingdom (featuring the voice talents of Ari Shey, MJ McAddams, and Family Plot podcast's Arthur Williams).
THEN: The Final Trace investigates the satanic panic epidemic of the 1980s & the case of Bink...
Rouge Transmissions IV: Part 1
Rogue Transmissions--the edgy, semi-annual anthology of indie podcasts--is invading your podcast feed with DUNGEONPUNK PART 1 ... a symphony of 80s nostalgia, dystopian cyberpunk, and savage swords drawn against both super sorcery & super science. Featuring an adventuring party of your indie podcast favorites!
FIRST UP, Octoberpod presents "Byzantium Slab: Life Without A Soul" a wraparound tale of savagery & adventure in the dystopian Kingdom of the Witch King (featuring the voice talents of Ari Shey, MJ McAddams, and Family Plot podcast's Arthur Williams).
THEN: Our True Crime Podcast presents "The Acid King of the 80s" a true crime...
Missing: Deanna Merryfield
📍Killeen, Texas | Year: 1990
🎧 Chapter 49: The Final Trace of Deanna Merryfield
Thirteen-year-old Deanna Merryfield slipped out of her grandmother’s house in the early morning hours to visit her twin sister just two miles away.
By 3:30 AM, she was standing outside a bedroom window.
Moments later… she climbed into a bronze-colored car with two teenage boys.
She was never seen again.
Labeled a runaway almost immediately, Deanna’s disappearance received little investigation in those critical early days. But while the case went quiet… her younger sister Melissa never...
Missing: Billy Martin
📍Brazil, Indiana | Year: 1957
🎧 Chapter 48: The Final Trace of Billy Martin
Seven-year-old Billy Martin was playing outside his family’s home on a warm summer afternoon while his mother cleaned inside, waiting for her husband to return home from National Guard training.
But sometime around 3:30 PM… Billy vanished.
The last person believed to have seen him was a family friend and lodger known as “Tex” Higgins — a drifter whose story would quickly come under scrutiny.
Search crews combed fields, ponds, mineshafts, and nearby farmland.
Rumors spread across Clay Coun...
Missing: Jared McColloch
📍Knox County Indiana | Year: 2023
🎧 Chapter 47: The Final Trace of Jared McColloch
Jared McColloch left his home in Louisiana expecting to make a routine trip north.
But somewhere between Illinois and Indiana… something changed.
In the early morning hours, Jared’s movements became difficult to follow.
A confusing timeline stretched across state lines and a daylight savings time change.
His truck was eventually discovered abandoned near the Wabash River.
Jared was never found.
And the deeper investigators looked into his final hours… the stranger the...
Missing: Zachary Bernhardt
📍 Clearwater, Florida | Year: 2000
🎧 Chapter 46 — The Final Trace of Zachary Bernhardt
On September 11, 2000, 8-year-old Zachary Bernhardt vanished from his bed in a locked apartment in Clearwater, Florida. His mother claimed she stepped out to clear her head at 4:00 A.M., but neighbors and investigators tell a different story. Today, we dive into the timeline, the suspicious inconsistencies, and why this remains the longest-running active Amber Alert in Florida history.
🚨 TAKE ACTION: DO YOU HAVE INFORMATION?
If you have any information regarding the disappearance of Zachary Bernhardt, please contact:
Clearwate...
Murdered: Lowell Badger
📍 Merom, Indiana | Year: 2012
🎧 Chapter 45 — The Final Trace of Lowell Badger
Lowell Badger lived a life of routine, faith, and quiet consistency.
But on a cold December night, that peace was shattered inside his own home.
For eleven years, his family waited—while the truth remained just out of reach.
Until the silence finally broke.
Primary News Reports & Investigation Details
Lowell Badger Cold Case Summary (Indiana St...
Murdered: Sherry Lee Gibson
📍 Vincennes, Indiana | Year: 1975
🎧 Chapter 44 — The Final Trace of Sherry Lee Gibson
A knock in the dark.
A scream no one heard.
And a fire meant to erase everything.
For years, the case was closed.
The killer was named.
The story… finished.
But the truth doesn’t always stay buried.
A confession from a church pew.
A second story that matched the first—26 years later.
And a realization that the wrong ending had been written all along.
Some stories don’t disappea...
Murdered: Alistair Wilson
📍Nairn, Scotland I Year: 2004
🎧 Chapter 43 — The Final Trace of Alistair Wilson
It was supposed to be an ordinary night.
Bedtime stories upstairs.
Children getting ready for bed.
Then came a knock.
Minutes later, Alistair Wilson was dead — and the person responsible vanished into the dark, leaving behind more questions than answers.
Sources & Further Reading:
BBC News: https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-scotland-highlands-islands-63839186
Police Scotland: https://www.scotland.police.uk/what-s-happening/campaigns/2022/december/alistair-wilson-murder-investigation/
The Guardian: https://www.theguardian.com/uk-new...
Murdered: Lisa McCracken
📍Vincennes, Indiana | Year: 1987
🎧 Chapter 42 — The Final Trace of Lisa McCracken
She was 19 years old.
Outgoing. Kind. The kind of person you didn’t forget.
But inside her apartment on North 6th Street… something went terribly wrong.
Lisa McCracken was found murdered—her life cut short in a place that should have been safe.
And for years, the person responsible walked free.
Until decades later… science caught up with the truth.
But even with a name… some questions never fully fade.
Learn more ab...
Murdered: Blair Adams
📍Knoxville, Tennessee | Year: 1996
🎧 Chapter 41: The Final Trace of Blair Adams
In July 1996, 31-year-old Blair Adams fled his home in fear—telling friends and family that someone was trying to kill him.
Within days, he crossed international borders, carrying thousands of dollars in cash and gold.
Then, in a quiet parking lot in Knoxville, Tennessee… Blair was found dead.
Partially undressed.
Surrounded by scattered money.
And with no clear cause of death.
Nearly three decades later, the questions remain.
What was Blair runn...
Missing: Fauna Frey
📍 Grants Pass, Oregon I Year: 2020
🎧 Chapter 40: The Final Trace of Fauna Frey
Just days after the sudden death of her brother, Fauna Frey set out on what she told her father would be a simple trip—one last mission to deliver her brother’s silver coins to his friends.
But somewhere along the winding roads of southern Oregon… the story began to drift.
Then Fauna vanished.
Months later, her Jeep was discovered hidden deep off a remote logging road—locked, abandoned, and surrounded by wilderness.
Her purse wa...
Murdered: Brook Baker
📍Vincennes, Indiana I Year: 1997
🎧 Chapter 39: The Final Trace of Brook Baker
In 1997, 19-year-old Brook Baker was brutally murdered inside her home.
The crime stunned the small Indiana community—and despite the evidence left behind, the case quickly went cold.
For years, Brook’s family waited for answers… until the person responsible struck again.
And when investigators finally connected the dots, the truth was even more chilling than anyone imagined.
The Final Trace of Brook Baker
The Kil...
Bonus Mini: Missing Jacob Pritchett
📍 Brownsville, Brooklyn — New York City
🎧 Bonus Mini: The Final Trace of Jacob Pritchett
A boy disappears.
A story begins to unravel.
And investigators now believe the truth may be far darker than anyone first imagined.
Jacob Pritchett vanished without a trace — but the clues left behind point to a case that may be more than just a disappearance.
In this bonus mini episode, we tell you the haunting story behind a boy who "never existed".
If you have any information about the disappearance of Jacob Prit...
Mysterious Death: George Smith
📍Mediterranean Sea — aboard a Royal Caribbean cruise. | Year: 2005
🎧 Chapter 38: The Final Trace of George Smith
A honeymoon meant to celebrate a new beginning ended in mystery just days after it began.
When George Smith disappeared from a Royal Caribbean cruise ship in 2005, investigators discovered a troubling clue — a dark bloodstain on a canopy below the couple’s balcony. Witnesses described chaos in a nearby cabin, but George was never seen again.
Two decades later, the question still remains:
Did George fall… or was he pushed?
Not...