Praise Be To Pod
Ashley and Bailee are reclaiming their spirituality after leaving the evangelical church behind. Join them for candid conversations about the twists and turns of deconstruction, spirituality, pop culture, mental health, astrology, self-care, and all the things that make life interesting after the altar call. Together, we’ll laugh, reflect, and discover what we still believe in.
Episode 81 | Name it and Claim it: Prosperity Gospel PART 2
In Part 2 [Listen to Part 1 Here] of our series on the prosperity gospel and Word of Faith movement, Ashley and Bailee get personal, sharing stories about how these teachings shaped their faith, finances, worldview, and understanding of God. They also unpack the predatory nature of a theology that promises divine blessings in exchange for belief, obedience, and, often, money.
Together, they examine what happens when the promise of abundance becomes a system that rewards those at the top while asking everyone else to keep believing, giving, and waiting for their breakthrough.
Plus, we talk about...
Episode 80 | Name it and Claim it: Prosperity Gospel Part I
God wants you healthy, wealthy, and blessed... at least that's what many of us in evangelical Christianity were told. In Part 1 of our series on the prosperity gospel and Word of Faith movement, Ashley and Bailee trace the history of these teachings, from their origins and foundational beliefs to the influential figures who helped bring them into the evangelical mainstream and make them a defining feature of modern American Christianity. Together, they critically examine how today’s evangelical Christianity embraced a “greed is good” approach to finances, unpacking how the pursuit and accumulation of wealth became a hallmark of a reli...
Episode 79 | YOU CAN SEE EVERYTHING Part 2: Elizabeth Holmes, Mega Church Pastors, and Weaponized Vulnerability
In Part 2 of their You Can See Everything discussion, Ashley and Bailee unpack the documentary’s biggest questions: Who gets to control the story, and how much should we trust what we’re seeing? From Nathan Fielder’s role as an unreliable narrator to the familiar playbook of scandal-plagued megachurch pastors, they explore the art of salvaging a public image when accountability comes to collect.Â
Along the way, they reflect on their own experiences trusting spiritual leaders whose intentions later came into question – and the eerily familiar tactics they recognized in the documentary's central figures.
* This...
Episode 78 | YOU CAN SEE EVERYTHING Part 1: Following a Fraudulent Visionary
Elizabeth Holmes promised to revolutionize healthcare with just a few drops of blood. So how did Theranos go from Silicon Valley darling to one of the biggest fraud scandals in tech history? Ashley and Bailee trace the company's rise and fall, from Holmes's ambitious vision and meteoric success to the investigations and revelations that brought it all crashing down.
Plus, You Can See Everything and the parallels between Holmes's carefully crafted public image and the personas of megachurch pastors. What happens when powerful leaders build trust, cultivate devoted followers, and face the consequences when the story they've...
Episode 77 | Irish-Catholic Guilt & Evangelical Youth Group with Maggie Crane
From Catholic guilt to evangelical youth group, Maggie Crane has experienced more than one flavor of religious baggage. Ashley and Bailee sit down with the Massachusetts-born, NYC-based comedian to talk about growing up Irish Catholic, finding her way into evangelicalism, and the strange cultural differences between two religious worlds that might have more in common than you'd think.
Plus, purity culture, vaginismus, and what happens when the lessons you learn about your body stick around long after youth group ends.
Content Advisory: This episode discusses religious trauma, purity culture, and vaginismus.
<...
Episode 76 | Spooky Season: Deliverance Ministry
Demons, deliverance, and the belief that every struggle has a spiritual explanation. Ashley and Bailee unpack the origins of deliverance ministry, what it looks like in modern evangelical and charismatic churches, and their own experiences with a practice that can blur the line between spiritual warfare and real-world harm. Together, they explore what happens when everything from anxiety to talking back to your parents gets blamed on demons.
Plus, Bailee shares a story from her past involving a remote gas station selling live guinea pigs, a child cashier, and a mudslide in Topanga Canyon that led her...
Episode 75 | Groomed by the Pulpit: The Predatory Pattern of Pastor John-Paul Miller
He told a whole congregation how wives should behave while doing the opposite behind closed doors. Ashley and Bailee skip the true crime recap of Netflix's Death of a Pastor's Wife and ask the scarier question: how does a church spend years training people to forgive a pastor before anything even comes out?
Plus, a praise report, a sprained foot, and a very serious debate about Nathan Fielder's hotness.
Content Advisory: this episode discusses suicide, sexual abuse, grooming, and religious abuse. The hosts share the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline at the top.
Episode 74 | Discipleship Program and "Biblical Education" Scams
Ashley and Bailee unpack their thoughts and experiences with evangelical discipleship programs (think YWAM, Bethel School of Supernatural Ministry, Teen Mania’s Honor Academy, etc.). They discuss how these programs offered young, disenchanted evangelical millennials an alternative to college, trade school, or other forms of higher education, as well as the immersive culture, community, and spiritual formation they provided. They explore how these experiences shaped their religious experiences and understanding of purpose, and what happens when those who lose their faith are left with no back-up plan.
Support the show
Connect with Us:
Episode 73 | Building Self-Trust After Being So Wrong
This week, Ashley and Bailee explore what it means to rebuild self-trust after spending years in an evangelical culture that taught them not to trust themselves. From being told that “the heart is deceitful” to learning to be suspicious of their own desires, instincts, and decision-making, they unpack how constantly looking outside ourselves for permission and direction can leave us disconnected from our own inner voice.
Together, they talk about what it looks like to begin trusting ourselves again and becoming open to the possibility that not every good decision has to come from sacrifice, suffering, or self...
Episode 72 | Filmmaking, Abortion, & Unoriginal Nicknames with Grace Sims
Ashley and Bailee sit down with filmmaker Grace Sims to talk about her evangelical childhood, her time with Youth With A Mission, and the purity-culture nicknames that followed her through high school. The conversation moves into Grace's gradual deconstruction and the deeply personal story behind her short film, The Country They Call Life, which follows a young woman navigating the decision to end a pregnancy. Grace opens up about her own abortion experience, why she chose to humanize every character in the film rather than write villains, and how she hopes the film builds empathy across the pro-life and...
Episode 71 | 9/11 Never Forget | Part 2
This week, Ashley and Bailee continue their conversation about 9/11, getting into the attacks themselves and the enormous cultural impact they had on a generation of Americans. They talk about how September 11th changed the way Americans understood safety, terrorism, patriotism, and the world around them, and how the aftermath shaped American and Evangelical culture for years to come.
Together, they explore the War on Terror, Islamophobia, surveillance, and the ways 9/11 became woven into American politics, media, religion, and everyday life. They also dig into the evangelical response to the attacks and how growing up evangelical shaped the...
Episode 70 | 9/11 Never Forget | Part 1
This week, Ashley and Bailee begin a two-part conversation about 9/11 and the American evangelical response to one of the most defining events of their generation. But before getting into what happened after September 11th, they take a step back to look at the political, historical, and social climate that led up to the attacks.
Together, they unpack the history of U.S. involvement in the Middle East, the legacy of the Cold War, the rise of Islamic extremism, American foreign policy, and the complicated relationship between the United States and the Middle East. They also dig into...
Episode 69 | Coming Out, Dating, and Deconstructing God with Mike Maeshiro | Part 2
This week, Ashley and Bailee continue their conversation with Mike Maeshiro – delving into what it’s like being LGBTQ+ in an evangelical world where your sexuality is treated as an affliction to overcome. Mike opens up about how being closeted made it nearly impossible to imagine a future for himself, and how pouring himself into ministry served as a distraction from his sexuality and from the possibility that God might actually accept him for who he is.
Together, they explore what happens when the promise of “deliverance” never comes, and how Mike’s experiences eventually led him to questio...
Episode 68 | From Supernatural Ministry to Queer Deconstruction with Mike Maeshiro | Part 1
This week Ashley and Bailee kick things off with the politics of expensive desk chairs, the two hours Bailee lost Uncle Marty, and her unexpected new love affair with baseball (much to Ashley's disapproval). Jacob weighs in with his signature distaste for Rotten Tomatoes ratings.
In our Part 1 interview with Mike Maeshiro, founder of Numa, we go back to the beginning. Mike opens up about knowing he was gay from a young age, and what it was like navigating that reality inside an evangelical world that offered him conversion therapy instead of acceptance. He walks us through...
Episode 67 | Five Love Languages: The Gospel According to Gary Chapman
This week Ashley and Bailee break down the Five Love Languages: where they actually came from (hint: it's more churchy than you think), why zero peer-reviewed studies back them up, and how a 1992 Christian Literature release somehow out-lasted Myers-Briggs as our go-to personality rubric.Â
The author, Gary Chapman, was a Baptist marriage counselor with a Ph.D. in adult education. Somehow his little notebook became the defining relationship framework of the last three decades — and neither of us can figure out how "physical touch" ended up in every guy's Hinge bio.
We're talking origin story, slo...
Episode 66 | What's on Your Heart: Summer Edition
This week, join Ashley and Bailee for a full-length “What's on Your Heart?” episode. From our thoughts on Lindsey Graham to Ashley’s trip to Kenya to Minnesota’s abysmal air quality, we're spending the entire episode catching up on everything that's happened over the summer, sharing what's been on our minds (and hearts), and following every tangent that inevitably comes with it.
What we talk about:
Bailee's moveAshley's trip to KenyaHow Lindsay Graham’s Death brought self-reflectionOur most embarrassing summer momentsMarmot OnlyFansReviewing The Odyssey   …And more!Support the show
C...
Episode 65 | Oh, Heavens! Part 2: What Do You Think Happens When We Die?
This week, Ashley and Bailee continue their conversation on heaven by exploring how the beliefs they inherited about the afterlife shaped the way they lived, loved, and understood the world around them.
Together, they reflect on how evangelical Christianity informed the way they imagined heaven, discussing how those beliefs influenced everything from fear and purpose to relationships, justice, and caring for the present world. They explore what (if anything) about belief in the afterlife they've found meaningful on the other side of deconstruction, and how reimagining heaven has transformed the way they think about what it means...
Episode 64 | Oh, Heavens! Part 1: The History, Mythology, and the Afterlife
This week, Ashley and Bailee kick off a two-part conversation exploring the origins of heaven and revisiting one of the foundational beliefs they were taught growing up in evangelical Christianity.
Together, they reflect on the version of heaven they inherited from the church, and explore how that picture was shaped by centuries of history, theology, and cultural influence. They discuss the historical evolution of beliefs about the afterlife, the surprising impact of Dante's Divine Comedy on modern Christian imagination, and what Jesus may have actually meant when he proclaimed that "the kingdom of heaven is at hand."Â
Episode 63 | Church Skit Nepo Baby with Katherine Scipioni
This week, Ashley and Bailee continue their conversation with their friend Scip as she reflects on growing up in 90s evangelical culture and her journey through deconstruction.
Together, they explore Scip’s upbringing in the Assembly of God church, her experience attending an evangelical Bible college, and the ways those environments shaped (and challenged) her faith. They unpack the unique culture and politics of evangelical higher education, revisit the unforgettable world of puppet teams and human video competitions, and reflect on what it means to untangle the traditions, beliefs, and communities that shaped you while finding your ow...
Episode 62 | If everyone's gay, who will bear children? Sage Advice with Special Guest, Katherine Scipioni
This week, Ashley and Bailee are joined by their friend Katherine Scipioni “Scip” to respond to a parishioner question about navigating family relationships when faith and identity collide.
Together, they discuss the pain of conditional acceptance, responding to a parishioner’s story about her conservative Christian family members choosing not to fully support her upcoming wedding to her fiancée. They explore how evangelical beliefs about marriage shape these responses, the role complementarian marriage can play in reinforcing harmful dynamics, and the complicated work of maintaining relationships with conservative family while honoring your own boundaries.
What...
Episode 61 | UNLEARNING: Are We Still Evangelizing?
This week, Ashley and Bailee explore the lingering ways evangelical Christianity continues to shape their thinking, even after deconstruction.
Together, they reflect on how certain patterns don’t automatically disappear when beliefs change…they often shift form. From over-functioning in relationships to carrying a sense of moral urgency into political spaces, they examine how old frameworks can quietly persist beneath new language and identities—and how unlearning them has been harder than they expected.
What we talk about:
Coach (Ashley’s dog) goes to Camp CourageBailee’s 4th grade crush Aperol spritz o’clockCoup...Episode 60 | Mental Health: Spiritual Bypassing
This week, Ashley and Bailee unpack one of evangelicalism's most enduring coping mechanisms: spiritual bypassing.
Together, they explore the pressure to "choose joy" when life is falling apart, the expectation to stay positive no matter the circumstances, and the ways difficult emotions are often treated as spiritual failures rather than normal parts of being human.
Along the way, they discuss Word of Faith theology, the fear of "speaking things into existence," and what it means to hold onto hope without denying reality.
Support the show
Connect with Us:
📸 Ins...
Episode 59 | Boys Will Be Boys: The Modern Exvangelical Manosphere
This week, Ashley and Bailee fail the Bechdel Test for the very first time with an all-new episode on one of humanity's oldest and most infamous subjects: men.
Together, they unpack some of the dynamics they've noticed in progressive spaces and relationships, exploring the ways patriarchal patterns can persist even as people deconstruct old beliefs and embrace new values. From emotional labor to accountability, they reflect on the ways these systems continue to shape how we relate to one another.
Along the way, they discuss feminism, self-awareness, and what it actually means to do the...
Episode 58 | The Gospel According to White Evangelicalism: Bekha's Story
This week, Bailee and Ashley are joined by a very special guest: Bailee’s childhood best friend, Bekha.Â
Bekha and Bailee first met as children when Bekha's family began attending the charismatic evangelical church that Bailee's parents planted and pastored in their small rural community.Â
While Bekha and Bailee share many memories and experiences from their upbringing in the church, Bekha was also navigating evangelicalism as a biracial, second-generation Honduran American. Together, they reflect on growing up in the same religious environment, the ways their experiences overlapped and diverged, and the journeys that eventually led them...
Episode 57 | One Year of Praise Be to Pod: Stages of Deconstruction
This week, Ashley and Bailee celebrate one year of Praise Be to Pod, reflecting on the journey that brought them here. After a year of conversations about evangelicalism, spirituality, culture, power, and healing, they take stock of how their deconstruction has evolved—and where it might be leading next.
Along the way, they discuss the different stages of deconstruction they've experienced, beliefs they've let go of and reclaimed, and the ways their understanding of faith and identity has shifted. They also explore how their focus has expanded beyond religious systems to broader conversations about history, Christian nationalism, pa...
Episode 56 | The Hollywood Fall from Grace to Evangelical A$$hole with Husband of the Pod, Danny
Content Advisory: This episode explores themes of domestic violence, sexual assault, and violence against LGBTQ+ people
This week, Ashley and Bailee are joined by Ashley’s husband Danny to discuss the infamous pipeline of powerful men who conveniently find God in the middle of public scandal and accountability. Using Shia LaBeouf, Kanye West, and Russell Brand as case studies, we explore why celebrity conversion narratives are so compelling—and why religious communities are often eager to embrace them.
Along the way, we unpack the difference between genuine accountability and performative self-deprecation, the cultural appe...
Episode 55 | The Soft Life Pipe Dream: Selling Womanhood in Late-Stage Capitalism
This week, Ashley and Bailee explore the resurgence of tradwife and homesteading aesthetics, “divine feminine” content, and viral online trends centered around softness, submission, and retreat from modern life — asking what cultural conditions are making these ideas feel especially appealing right now.
We also look at how these movements don’t exist in a vacuum, but often intersect with broader political and religious messaging from the right that idealizes traditional gender roles and re-centers women’s value around domesticity, dependence, and family structure.
At the same time, we reflect on the real fatigue many women feel with...
Episode 54 | Signs & Wonders with Jubilee Dawn: When Miracles Mislead
This week, Ashley and Bailee are joined by Jubilee Dawn for a conversation on “signs and wonders” within charismatic evangelical spaces. Jubilee shares from her experience in Bethel’s School of Supernatural Ministry (often described as “Christian Hogwarts”), reflecting on what it was like being immersed in a culture where prophetic words, miracles, and supernatural “signs” were not just encouraged, but often expected as the primary way of discerning life decisions and spiritual truth.
Together, we explore how environments like these can shape identity and decision-making, and how the constant urgency to never miss when God is speaking can s...
Episode 53 | Save the Children: The Indoctrination Double Standard
This week, Ashley and Bailee engage in a discussion of the evangelical and religious right’s “Save the Children” narrative — exploring how fears around education, media, and social progress are often used to shape public perception and moral urgency. We reflect on how these stories are constructed, who they’re aimed at, and what they reveal about broader anxieties around influence, identity, and who gets to “indoctrinate” children. We also consider the real vulnerabilities of children, how concerns for their protection can be unevenly applied, and how harm is sometimes weaponized to reinforce longstanding patterns of scapegoating.
References:Â ...
Episode 52 | The Myth of a Christian Nation | Part 2: Trickle Down American Exceptionalism
This week, Ashley and Bailee continue their deep-dive into the myth of a “Christian nation,” shifting into the modern era and the forces that shaped evangelical political identity as we know it today.
We explore the cultural and political shifts surrounding the presidencies of Jimmy Carter and Ronald Reagan, and how the rise of the Moral Majority helped cement the alliance between evangelical Christianity and conservative power. From there, we trace how events like 9/11, the War on Terror, and the Obama era fueled fear, urgency, and a deepened sense of “us vs. them” within evangelical spaces.
As the...
Episode 51 | The Myth of a Christian Nation | Part 1: Evangelical Revisionist History
This week, Ashley and Bailee kick off Part 1 of a deep-dive into one of the most widely accepted beliefs in evangelical culture: that the United States was founded as a Christian nation.
From childhood teachings to political messaging, many of us were told that America’s identity is inherently tied to Christianity — but as we started asking questions, that narrative began to unravel.
In this episode, we trace the roots of that belief — from the Founding Fathers and the realities of America’s founding, to the Civil War, where both sides claimed God, to the rise of...
Episode 50 | The Narrow Road | Part 2 | The Threat of Christian Nationalism with Joanna Whaley
In Part 2 of our conversation with Joanna Whaley, we continue unpacking Joanna’s journey from evangelical pastor to political candidate — diving into the intersections of faith, politics, and identity in a time when Christian values and nationalism collide.
Join us as we dive into Joanna’s campaign for the Michigan House of Representatives, how she confronts Christian nationalism in American politics, and the ways the MAGA movement leverages fear and deception to gain power. We also reflect on our grief for family and friends who have been lost to MAGA ideology… and what it looks like to maintain...
Episode 49 | The Narrow Road | Part 1 | From Megachurch Pastor to Progressive Political Activist with Joanna Whaley
In Part 1 of our conversation with Joanna Whaley, candidate for Michigan House of Representatives, Ashley and Bailee sit down with Joanna to unpack her story as a former evangelical pastor navigating identity, faith, and institutional power.
After being outed as a transgender woman by a congregant, Joanna was dismissed from one of Michigan’s largest megachurches—an event that upended every aspect of her life. She candidly shares her experiences surviving conversion therapy, confronting transphobia within the church, and reclaiming her faith and understanding of God in the aftermath.
Join us next week for Part 2!
Episode 48 | The Evangelical Millennials to Social Justice Warrior Pipeline
This week, Ashley and Bailee engage in a discussion and cultural analysis of evangelical millennials — exploring why we are the way that we are. From the militarization of youth at Acquire the Fire to the push to dedicate your life to global missions with YWAM, the evangelical church bombarded us with messages that we were the generation called to “change the world.”
Now that we’re older, we reflect on coming of age during that period of American history — the empty promises we were given, the fading pipe dream of financial prosperity, and the sometimes contentiou...
Episode 47 | The Woman's Place: Roles and Expectations in Evangelical Society
Ashley and Bailee explore the roles and expectations placed on women in evangelical culture, unpacking the theology behind complementarianism, headship, and the idea of women as “helpers.” They discuss how evangelical systems often frame these roles as divine design, placing obedience on a pedestal, establishing marriage and proximity to men as the ultimate metric of a woman’s value, and demonizing dissent as a “Jezebel Spirit.”
The conversation examines the archetype of the “ideal evangelical woman,” the rise in female pastors using their platform to reinforce patriarchal structures, and the ways the church often assumes entitlement to the labor, ene...
Episode 46 | Codependency: Enmeshment, the Savior Complex, and the Compulsive Need to Rescue
Ashley and Bailee critically examine the culture of codependency that runs deep in many Evangelical communities — reinforcing relationship dynamics of enmeshment, overfunctioning, and blurred boundaries. They unpack how the constant pressure from the church to “save people” and “expose their sin” is often used as a tool to maintain control, the ways having a savior complex primes you for self righteousness and resentment, and what unchecked self-sacrifice costs our relationships and sense of self.
The conversation explores how these patterns formed in our own lives and what we’re doing to unlearn them — reclaiming agency, healthier boundaries, and relationsh...
Episode 45 | Reconstructing Lent, Lent for Ex-Evangelicals
Ashley and Bailee get candid about their complicated relationship with Lent and spiritual disciplines after deconstruction — calling out how evangelicals often pride themselves on rejecting liturgical traditions passed down through church history, while still emphasizing self-denial and moral performance.
They discuss how practices like fasting were framed through shame and sacrifice, why Lent was often dismissed as “too Catholic,” and whether spiritual disciplines can be reclaimed in a way that feels life-giving rather than guilt-driven.
Support the show
Connect with Us:
📸 Instagram: @praisebetopod
🎵 Tik...
Episode 44 | Amish Made | Part 2: Inside America's Least Understood Society
Ashley and Bailee return for Part 2 of their Amish series — this time stepping into the present.
They explore modern Amish life: gender roles, education, technology limits, rumspringa, and the quiet authority of the Ordnung. What does separation from the world actually look like today…and how does it function as both protection and control?
They also unpack the evangelical mom obsession with Amish movies — from G-rated romance plotlines to the suspiciously wholesome universe of Michael Landon Jr.. Why are bonnets and barns so deeply romanticized in Christian media? And what does that persistent fantasy of a “sim...
Episode 43 | Amish Made | Part 1: The History of America's Most Traditional Lifestyle
Ashley and Bailee turn their attention to a community often romanticized but rarely understood: the Amish.
In Part 1 of this two-part series, they trace the movement’s origins in the Radical Reformation, unpacking Anabaptism, adult baptism, persecution, and the theological split that gave rise to the Amish. They explore how a desire for faithfulness and separation from the world shaped practices like shunning, communal discipline, and the Ordnung — and how those early convictions still echo today.
Sources:
Amish Studies, Elizabethtown College. (n.d.). Amish origins. https://groups.etown.edu/amishstudies/religion/amish-origins/Anab...Episode 42 | The Conditional Unconditional LOVE of God
Were you obsessed with how much God Loves you? Our Evangelical upbringing taught us that God loves you unconditionally… unless you don’t believe correctly, behave correctly, or die at the wrong time.
This week we’re unpacking the “conditional unconditional love” of God — the version many of us were raised on in evangelical culture.
We play our new game “Cute, Concerning, or Straight to Jail?” where we ask: Would this behavior be cute if God didn’t do it?
We dig into:
Why evangelicals are so obsessed with preaching about God’s loveTh...