Bookstupid with Claire and Molly
How hard could it be to write a romance novel? We’re going to find out. Follow along weekly as we attempt to write the books we want to read and chat about what’s inspiring us.
36: "Committing" to key lime pie
What does commitment really mean? And what is your relationship to it? These are questions we try to answer this week as we relive a very romantic Friendsgiving. We’re so grateful to all of our donors who contributed to Claire’s Hunger Games journey and we ask that you consider helping get her across the finish line on The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes, even though it’s really boring. We also discuss the magic system of From on Netflix, and John Mulaney’s awesome use of adjectives on SNL. Finally, Molly asks a question we all grapple with: sh...
35: I'm Rosetta, Rosetta Stone
Excuse me, pardon me, could I just— scootch by you there— who, me? Right! On my way, if I could just slink around you— thanks. And THAT’S our impression of Heated Rivalry’s Kip, who’s back in Claire’s life since breaking her dry spell at an AMC mixer. We also talk Wicker, the teased cover art for Emily Henry’s latest, and Ríoghnach Robinson’s Bad Words. Not to get ahead of ourselves, but Robinson’s adult debut might just be a five star romance!
34: Skimbleshanks!
It’s not quite Halloween and it’s not quite Christmas. It’s the lame duck time before Thanksgiving. So we’re serving up piping hot spooky, smutty fan fic short stories set in some of our favorite Halloween cinematic universes. Claire tells us about the Portuguese she learned in Lisbon (it’s two words) and Molly tells us about the newest season of Le Dip (French for Netflix’s The Diplomat.) Speaking of French, Claire recaps the queer French romance that made her sob on Delta Airlines. Au revoir and obrigada!
33: Djonerate
We can see everything. And, maybe relatedly, everything we read and watch seems connected. Should we call a doctor? In addition to deep dives on Nathan Fielder’s latest masterpiece and Julia Louis Dreyfus’ broadway debut in Other Desert Cities, we discuss the media we turn to in times of mental/emotional distress. The saxophones are getting louder, and you know what? Go ahead and call that doctor you mentioned.
32: Mix up the letters and you'll see
This is our call to Shane Gillis’ sisters: get meaner. After contributing to The Discourse for 13 minutes, we dig into our time picking apples. Then we head East of Eden to talk about Zoe Kazan’s take on Cathy. Molly provides an upsetting update on what the young adults are watching: Coven Academy. Finally, we workshop new writing: a one-page script from Molly and new jokes from Claire. Go Brewers!
31: I didn't know he could swim
We rolled right from our perfect Friday night, wherein we shared a large bucket of popcorn equitably and respectfully, straight to Joop Studio on Sunday— stopping only for a Saturday screening of seminal Halloween film Spooky Buddies. The fruits of our weekend labor? An episode where we discuss the above, the film adaptation of Colleen Hoover’s Verity, Jen Beagin’s Big Swiss, The Haunting of Hill House, Katherine Center’s The Shippers (kinda), and Rebecca Yarros’ Threshing Day. Enjoy, piggies!
30: Hold onto your cunny, honey
Did you know about the word cunny? That’s just one of the amazing details in Ryan Murphy’s latest Monster series about Lizzie Borden. We dig into that this week, as well as Brett Goldstein’s All of You and Primetime. Finally, we discuss the new adaptation of The Love Hypothesis and we’re sorry to report that we liked it. You see how this looks, right?
29: You got JK Rowling'd!
You’ve caught us at a rare moment when Claire is neither waiting for her hot plate to heat nor giving in to the temptation to poke the water damage on her ceiling. Also at a special time in her life? Lizzy McAlpine (26). We discuss this and steak suppers, DTF St. Louis, Elspeth, and R.F. Kuang’s Katabasis. Finally, for our writing exercise, we went to a talk between multi-hyphenates David Duchovny and Gina Gershon and got a lesson in horniness from the crowd.
28: Good Wives come from Chicago
Claire fights through her fresh third-degree sunburn to explain the entire plot of Hulu’s Furious to Molly, who’s been busy in The Good Wife universe. Molly also details her experience watching the dystopian Anniversary, starring the Friday Night Lights guy. We also discuss the latest short story from 831 Stories, Vacation Self by Alexandra Romanoff. Spoiler alert: it’s a three-hander.
27: Quadrupedo
Salt air… the rust on your door… the pools are closing, and we’re indulging in end of summer melancholy. This attitude pervades the episode, from Claire’s account of her terrible horrible no good very bad weekend that actually sounds perfectly pleasant, to Molly’s dissection of Hal Ebbott’s bruising debut novel Among Friends, to our own writing exercise of the week: summer short stories. We also cover Tia William’s Seven Days in June, The Lost Boys, Don’t Say Good Luck, and a balloon technology you wouldn’t believe.
26: There will be straddling
What would you do with a week off from work to consume media? Claire answers that question with a thesis that spans The Road to Tender Hearts by Annie Hartnett, Square Waves by Alexandra Romanoff, and the new Anthony Bourdain biopic, Tony. Also this week, Molly threw an event and watched Camp Rock 3. We also workshop some writing, but it’s more like ideas (are you surprised?) Multiple people catch strays in this episode, including Santa Claus and old people writ large.
25: You gotta be smackin le dip
To write sex (Claire) or plots/characters driven by psychosexual desire (Molly’s still figuring out her pivot), we’re going back to the beginning and mining content that triggers sexual awakenings. Get ready for wig talk, animated odysseys, and the butt as an erogenous zone. We also cover Jenny Jacksons’ The Shampoo Effect, a Never Been Kissed rewatch, and Sterling Point, which is inducing TSITP level mania in our households.
24: Boy movies through a lens of menstruation
This week, Claire puts aside her abject hatred for the Marvel universe and joins Molly behind enemy lines. We review three new-ish “boy movies”: The Odyssey, Spider-Man Brand New Day, and Project Hail Mary. Molly raises awareness about her new teen show, Sterling Point, and Claire tries to explain the very solid magic structure of One Night Only.
23: Keep Pa God
This week, Molly emerges from the warm embrace of Stars Hollow to give us the scoop on her first watch of Gilmore Girls. Trigger warning: Dean. Claire, meanwhile, has been living in a log cabin courtesy of the Little House on the Prairie reboot. Also this week, Claire recaps another thriller with a ChatGPT title, and makes the case for not DNFing a book (with a metaphor that is a JOKE by the way.) Finally, we give a long-awaited update on our books.
22: Call the WHO Gemma Chan is here
This week, we provide almost the exact coordinates of where we live. Hint: Molly has Legionnaire's. We have a lot of media to catch up on this week, including the Peacock adaptation of Elin Hilderbrand's Five Star Weekend. Claire read the book and Molly watched the show. Together, we recount most of the plot. Molly reviews Jennifer Lopez's latest, Office Romance, and Claire finally gives her take on 2007's Atonement, which leads us to discuss when and how to use "the worst word you can possibly imagine."
21: You had the T&T of your L
Let&t’s t&talk about&t it&t. If you could decode that, download the limited edition Plum LP of this episode (kidding). We stayed in town this Fourth of July for a very special occasion. To celebrate, we try our hand at one of life’s most challenging writing exercise: vows. Log your bets on Kalshi now for who you think gets to be @killatrav. Also this week, we discuss daddy-daughter romance in Harlan Coben’s I Will Find You. Plus, Molly digs into what she’s loving and what she’s liking just ok from Elle on Prime...
20: Your Senator can't have a Senator
That’s right, we’re talking about Ansel Elgort for at least five minutes again. And this time, we compare him to Nick Robinson, which we’re sure is flattering for him. We watched Voicemails for Isabelle and we can’t stop thinking about Mr. Robinson’s hand acting, or the concept of dessert nachos. Other topics covered this week: Yesteryear by Caro Claire Burke, the Empire State Building engagement, one specific episode of Black Mirror, and Claire’s highly anticipated return to Panem (nurse, she’s reading The Hunger Games again.) Speaking of nurses and things that won’t die, we debate...
19: Ears God made by accident
We’re back, and Molly is cursing more than ever before. Your Bookstupid hosts are fresh off their longest stint apart since Claire studied abroad in college (did you know?? That she studied abroad??). In addition to a much needed catch up on our lives, Ali Hazelwood’s Not in Love x Problematic Summer Romance, Christina Lauren’s (but really Lauren’s) Love and Other Words, Widow’s Bay, and Every Year After, we do a close read on a generational new romance text: Olivia Rodrigo’s You Seem Pretty Sad for a Girl So in Love. Oliva, we have receive...
18: Huffin’ and puffin’ and blowin’ my house down
If you’re reading this, former president of Fordham University Father McShane, we’re going to watch Fifty Shades of Grey. We know about s-e-x and we’re allowed to watch that movie. This week, we talk about the steamy scenes that inspire us, and we’re still figuring out what that means exactly. We also discuss Obsession, the newest season of Four Seasons, and weird dates we witnessed in the wild this week. This is a message to the women of Manhattan: dump him!
17: Race you on the loom!
If it seems like Claire is bursting with energy in this week’s episode, it’s because she can hardly wait another second to talk about the new season of her favorite Scandinavian horror show, The Chestnut Man. Also this week, we discuss the lifestyle movies that made us yearn for womanhood (The Devil Wears Prada), as well as a show that makes us sad about girlhood (The Testaments). Finally, we review a new summer romance — and Little Women fanfic — on shelves now: Our Perfect Storm by Carley Fortune.
16: I just got French whiplash
The state of our writing mirrors the state of our Union: bleak, bordering on hopeless. But we barely talk about the economy and AI in this episode, if you can believe it! Instead, we discuss the Off Campus tv adaptation, Molly’s cult-of-one classic LOL (starring Miley Cyrus and D’mi Moore), and Claire’s latest second chance romance Before I Let Go by Kennedy Ryan — in addition to workshopping our own rough writing. It’s about time you put us in your prayer books.
15: Bad dad, fine king
This week, we catch up after an eventful weekend that includes a James Patterson commencement speech, a trip down memory lane, a mostly sober viewing of The Devil Wears Prada 2, and the rescue of 1,500 beagles. Since we last met, Molly finished Rites of the Starling and Claire (finally) finished The Poisonwood Bible. Also this week, we tackle Claire’s favorite romance trope: airports and airplanes. Hopefully you can’t catch Molly’s chronic cough through your headphones.
14: She's willing to whisk everything
It’s game night! Much like the 76ers and the Knicks, Claire and Molly are facing off in a battle of grit, heart, and skill. That is, we are dusting off Joops’ dad’s friend’s game, Writer Blocks, and writing short stories against a prompt and a time limit. Tune in for this and a misandrist reading of Eternity, a hit job on (one of our favorite writers) Mindy Kaling via review of her (very good) show Running Point, an indictment of old timey romantasy, and a close read of one particular scene in Paradise season 2. Oh, and if you’r...
13: I got the jab at Javits
Nasty people make the best friends and nasty people are smarter than everyone else. That’s one of many very nice takes we drop in this week’s episode, as we cover Grant Ginder’s So Old, So Young, The Drama, and Bigfoot the Musical. We also report from our time at the book lover’s hottest destination, BookCon. One more thing: could you please have some generosity for our basketball team?
12: Move that bus!
Mars is in Aries and we’re embracing conflict— with everyone we’ve ever met and within our books. That’s right, we’re writing again, but ask us anything about it and we’ll clock you! This episode also includes a Spring weather report, a reverse HIPAA violation on Molly’s new therapist, a big announcement re: Claire’s reno, and our final reviews of Something Very Bad is Going to Happen and the Artefacts of the Ouranos series (both need to figure out their magic systems).
12: Move that bus!
Mars is in Aries and we’re embracing conflict— with everyone we’ve ever met and within our books. That’s right, we’re writing again, but ask us anything about it and we’ll clock you! This episode also includes a Spring weather report, a reverse HIPAA violation on Molly’s new therapist, a big announcement re: Claire’s reno, and our final reviews of Something Very Bad is Going to Happen and the Artefacts of the Ouranos series (both need to figure out their magic systems).
11: Frog and Toad are in purgatory
Let's get one thing out of the way: we're not talking about writing this week. What we are talking about this week: bunny brunch, childhood science experiments, glucose, Claire's period, Molly's romantic attachment to Jonathan Groff, Paradise, Harlan Coben and Dan Brown, and so much more. Plus, Molly makes sure that the Epstein files stay top of mind, while Claire reminds us once again about the impending apocalypse. If the audio is a little cooked this week, it's because Joops left us alone and we're doing our best.
10: Maybe we're all pretentious (feat. Catherine Walsh)
This episode is an interview with our first real guest (sorry to our previous guests, who are more so our friends)… Irish romance author extraordinaire, Catherine Walsh! Catherine shares her invaluable writing advice, inspiration, and encouragement. We also chat about her latest, How to Write a Love Story. It’s Molly’s favorite to date (sucker for an editor MMC) and Claire’s second favorite (topped only by the airplane setting of Holiday Romance).
9: My Zepbound story
If you’re watching this episode and you think we’re being held hostage, put down the phone. We moved into a new Joop studio, and we brought our commentary on The Gift of the Magi with us. We’re back from Florida with the bee stings, sunburns, and good retirement vibes to prove it. We delve into what we consumed on our various plane rides. Molly read two new romantasies, Arcana Academy by Elise Kova and Dire Bound by Sable Sorensen (sure). Claire finally watched Fever Pitch and The Social Network. We also met a new AI frenemy at wri...
8: The clam hat stays on
This episode features Ireland as a silent third host. We read St. Patrick’s day short stories we’ve written, inspired by the Emerald Isle herself, and are generally pale and freckled. We show unbelievable restraint with accents, mostly deployed to mock the English. And, as always, we catch up on recent culture and content consumption, including the Traitors finale, Bridgerton part two, Square Waves by Alexandra Romanoff, and School Spirits season 3.
7: Tell Parson Brown’s story
First of all, head to YouTube to see Molly’s latest hat. She may be auditioning for the next season of White Lotus, or the next adaptation of Clueless. This week, we clock in on various casting announcements, including Beach Read and Every Year After. We also roast the hairstyling on Traitors and a troubling trend we’re noticing at boutique fitness classes. Finally, we workshop passages from our drafts and try to find the magic of Christmas.
6: You know who’d make a good Heathcliff? Rob
Get ready to get your Heights Wuthered— we’re talking book AND movie. We’re also engaging in an experiential interpretation of the novel by being insane and finding romance on this, the 200th day of winter. Spoiler, Molly’s “most romantic” this week is a stranger reminding her to buckle her seatbelt. We also talk about Reality Check: Inside America’s Next Top Model, Pillion, Rob Rausch, and Claire’s forever valentine.
5: Me Cottage, MeUndies
At My Cottage, the MeUndies stay on. This week, we change our tune on Bridgerton after seeing the stairwell scene that would make even Belly Conklin blush. Molly recounts the plot of F1 while actively fighting her need to talk about Top Gun: Maverick. Finally, we review the Kindle Unlimited Valentine’s Day short story collection, which somehow includes two murders and two attempted murders.
4: Another, Another, Another Cinderella Story
Will you be our valentine? We wrote you romantic short stories! To round out the bouquet, we offer you incisive commentary on Bridgerton season 4 (first two eps), Finding Her Edge (up until the last 8 min), and Kate Alice Marshall’s What Lies in the Woods (at the halfway mark— but you’ll find that Molly correctly guesses it’s a Slenderman situation). If you decide to accept our valentine offer, you can find Claire at the Irish Exit bar at Penn Station.
3: The birds who stayed
We may not be women in STEM but that doesn’t mean we don’t know chemistry. This week, we briefly put down our hot chocolate to discuss what makes sparks fly off the page and workshop passages from our books. Also on the agenda: Luke and Lorelai, the Beast Games, and a review of Brooke Averick’s debut novel. Plus, we determine that Rob from Traitors has chemistry with…us? Claire wants everyone to know that she’s been corrected on her usage of “viscous” and that she has contact dermatitis on her eye.
2: Wah-la!
It’s the Heated Rivalry episode, you pervs! We’re talking about everyone’s favorite on-page, on-screen, on-ice romance. Our culture catch-up also touches on Tell Me Lies, His and Hers, Katherine Center’s Rom-Commers, and Audible’s full cast Harry Potter productions. And if you notice that Claire is blonder and more starry eyed than usual, it’s because she recently paid a visit to one of the great loves of her life— Charles the hairdresser, whom Molly had to break up with because he kept giving her The Rachel.
1: Demons we met on vacation
Season 2 is here and we’re kicking off with an in-depth exploration of the movie adaptation of Molly’s least favorite Emily Henry novel, People We Meet on Vacation. One thing’s for sure: that’s not Linfield, Ohio. We also talk about our holidays, which included talking to inanimate objects and consuming large helpings of media in a fugue state. Maybe next week Molly will crack The Da Vinci Code or Claire’s Warmie will talk back.
39: We remain so keen
We’re finishing our first season strong, meaning we didn’t finish our books but Molly met Xaden and Claire met a new pen pal. In this episode, Molly slips back into Fourth Wing psychosis and Claire is drinking the Heated Rivalry Kool-Aid. We also look back on our first season of Bookstupid and the many trips we took to Best Buy this year. Finally, we put the team behind the pod, producer Joops and editor Ben, in the hot seats. And don’t worry, season 2 is coming soon.
38: Get behind me, gotpenguin
The lawyer becomes the defendant as Molly commits multiple offenses at puppy play class. Claire is also in the doghouse with the witch who put a curse on her. Will true love’s kiss make her keys come back? Also this week, we discuss Netflix’s The Beast in Me and argue about whether Redemption Babies™️should be allowed to be boys. We also argue over whether boys should be allowed to have secrets as we continue our conversation on Heart the Lover. And get ready for a holiday-inspired writing exercise that has us clutching our Warmie.
37: Earmuff warning for baby
The Climate Clock is on, and we’re racing to write our novels. You may not be getting them by end of year (EOY for my stupidheads with jobs,) but we are pinning down a key element this episode: what is the main character’s deal? You’ll also get a full NYC weather report and Die My Love / Sexy Scaries recaps sure to ruin your week.