Top Shelf Stories

40 Episodes
Subscribe

By: Jay Chris Tony

In a world that often shuns the uncomfortable, we embrace it with open arms—and open laughs. Our candid narratives around our stories assure you that awkwardness is a shared human experience. Tune in, enjoy the ride, and maybe learn a thing or two.

✂️ Turn this podcast into clips
Kids Love The Worst Campgrounds
#97
Today at 3:00 PM

Send us Fan Mail

We trade stories from a full summer of taking the kids camping across Wisconsin, from polished Yogi Bear style campgrounds to a chaotic spot we nickname The Hills. The big surprise is what the kids value most, and why the “cheap and crappy” weekends end up beating the expensive, corporate ones. 
• comparing state parks, county parks and RV parks across a full spectrum of camping styles 
• why brand name campgrounds feel great once and then fade fast 
• arriving late, parking on steep sites and dealing with the unglamorous parts of RV life 
...


Slang For Self Pleasure
Last Friday at 3:00 PM

Send us Fan Mail

We spiral from a car-thought about masturbation slang into a debate about why guys collect endless euphemisms while women seem to get stuck with a short list. Then we read a questionable “21 euphemisms” article and end on a completely unforgettable story about witnessing a guy masturbating in stop and go traffic. 

• comparing common male masturbation slang and why it spreads through friend groups 
• asking what women actually call masturbation and whether toys change the language 
• fact-checking internet euphemisms and calling out terms that feel made up 
• reacting to a graphic traffi...


He Met The In Laws And Got Tased
#96
11/10/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We trade jokes until Tony’s stun gun on the table opens the door to a Christmas 2001 story that keeps escalating from tequila bullying to a living room stun gun war. By the time a handmade knife gift turns into a shredded sweater and a bleeding neck, we’re left asking what counts as “family fun” and what crosses the line. 
• banter about marriage, kids and the “shocker” joke 
• why Tony owns a Panther 100,000-volt stun gun 
• Christmas Eve at a Wisconsin bar with intimidating in-laws 
• tequila shots, social pressure and forced “bon...


Have We Forgotten How To Drink Water
11/06/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We argue about whether microplastics are even real, then spiral into a surprisingly serious debate about drinking spring water straight from the source. We swap local examples, question what bottled “spring water” really means, and end on whether free water can actually be the best water. 
• debating microplastics and what “clean water” even means 
• claiming many cities have nearby natural springs for free water 
• questioning whether spring water is safe without boiling 
• naming Wisconsin springs like Perry Spring and Big Bend 
• arguing about bottled spring water and how much it is treated 


What Do Our First Drunk Stories Teach Our Kids
#95
11/03/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We trade stories that start with teen sleepovers and end with the kind of first-drunk memories you can’t believe were real, then we connect it all back to what it’s like raising kids now. Along the way we talk rules, trust, getting caught, and the uncomfortable truth that parenting often means warning your kids about mistakes you once made yourself. 
• the “podcast bunker” setup and our usual chaos 
• teens always wanting to sleep over and what they actually do 
• the fear that kids are growing up faster than we did 
• get...


Season Tickets And Side Bitch Energy
10/30/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We argue about a playoff game ticket that goes to a friend of a friend and turns into a full blown debate about loyalty, reliability, and who counts as a main friend. We break down the real reasons invites happen, how social capital gets built, and why last minute plans expose the truth about adult friendship.
• feeling cheated on when a close friend chooses someone else
• Brewers playoff tickets as a once in a lifetime moment
• frustration over not being asked first
• the case for group chats and fair invites<...


Ingredient Labels Are Warning Labels
#94
10/27/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We get brutally honest about how changing what we eat changes how we feel, from cravings and snacking to acid reflux and daily pain. We argue about convenience versus control, then dig into why modern ingredient labels look more like chemistry sets than food. 
• cutting out chemicals and seed oils while keeping food enjoyable 
• choosing pasture-raised chicken and avoiding cheap fried options 
• wild sockeye salmon versus farmed Atlantic salmon and why labels mislead 
• replacing processed snacks with simple whole-food options 
• noticing hunger cues to reduce heartburn and indigestion 
• using inte...


Chris’s wallet
10/16/2026

Send us Fan Mail


Employee taco
10/09/2026

Send us Fan Mail


Time Costs Money
#93
10/06/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We argue about when paying a contractor is worth it and when it’s smarter to build it yourself, using Chris’s blown-down fence as the test case. Along the way we compare bids, vent about trade pricing, and admit how fast “saving money” turns into lost sleep, extra errands, and concrete dust everywhere. 
• weighing DIY vs contractor for a fence rebuild 
• comparing two reputable fence installation quotes with different methods 
• breaking down why tools, crews, overhead, and warranties shape pricing 
• reacting to roofing costs and the feeling of one-day markups 


Target Said No So QuickTrip Said Sure
10/02/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We take a chaotic break to grab more alcohol, then turn a simple Target run into a full-blown story about flirting, confusion, and getting shut down at the register. The night ends with a QuickTrip save and a debate over whether a hat can make a grown man look “too young” to buy a drink. 

• scrambling to hear each other and gearing up to record 
• choosing Target for alcohol and hiking to the back of the store 
• getting unexpectedly hit on at self-checkout and not knowing how to respond 
• joking a...


When A Music Festival Dies
#92
09/30/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We lose a long-running Memorial Day music festival tradition when it gets canceled at the last minute, then we refuse to let the weekend die. We turn the disappointment into a full backyard mini-festival with camping, food, music zones, karaoke, and a surprise live guitar set that makes us want to run it back next year. 

• the slow heartbreak of a favorite festival changing vibes 
• the abrupt cancellation and the scramble to get refunds 
• choosing a DIY backyard music festival over giving up the weekend 
• last-minute logistics like privacy fenc...


A Highway Blowout And The Tool You Forgot
09/25/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We load up the RV for a camping run, then a trailer tire explodes at 65 mph and turns “I’m prepared” into a long shoulder-side reality check. We break down what went wrong, how hard it was to find help, and the simple tool choice that would have saved hours. 
• loading up the RV and trailer with kids for a trip 
• a blowout on the highway and scrambling to get safely over 
• realizing the lug wrench fits the truck not the trailer 
• digging through the tool bag and finding only one useless s...


Warranties Or Bust
#91
09/22/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We argue about whether extended warranties are a smart hedge or a habit that trains us to break things and expect a refund. From car repairs to hoverboards to phone screens, we weigh real claims against the bigger question of what all this coverage is doing to prices and responsibility. 

• why one of us buys warranties on almost everything and the others usually pass 
• extended car warranty logic when a small part triggers a massive labor bill 
• Amazon protection plans for scooters and battery-powered kid gear 
• filing a hoverboard c...


The Service Charge Surprise
09/18/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We go from a feel-good pizza stop to a full-on receipt breakdown when a 10% service charge shows up at the end of the tab. We talk through what takeout fees are meant to cover, why the wording matters, and how one confusing charge can change whether we come back. 
• Chris pulls a receipt from his wallet and sets up the complaint 
• a great pizza joint with great service and a family feel 
• a 10% service charge that looks and feels like a tip 
• the staff explanation for takeout orders covering boxes and de...


Five Bucks For A Crate Of Chaos
#90
09/15/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We turn a Sunday flea market run into a full debate about what’s worth buying, what’s worth flipping, and why nostalgia makes us do questionable math. We swap our best haggling moments, the deals we regret passing on, and the one ridiculous Nintendo find that felt like fate.
• camping routine and the Sunday flea market tradition with friends and family
• the “trash vs treasure” mindset and why browsing junk can be fun
• small wins like a vintage Pepsi straw holder and weird old padlocks
• using Google Lens to price-check c...


A Rare Top Shelf Bottle Shows Up And Sparks A Debate
09/11/2026

Send us Fan Mail

Tony’s giant bottle of high end hard liquor kicks off a roast about sudden drinking habits, beer vs spirits, and what that oversized box is really doing on the table. We end up arguing about favors, tipping, and what happens when you bring a premium bottle around “good friends” who drink it like it’s nothing.

• questioning the sudden move to hard liquor
• breaking down the bottle size and the oversized packaging
• explaining why the bottle is rare and how it was picked up
• debating whether a friend who deliv...


Aging Is A Maintenance Problem
#89
09/08/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We go from brutal jokes to real talk about getting older, losing weight, and why the body starts acting like a neglected car. Jay’s anxiety about checkups turns into a bigger conversation about lifestyle change, preventive care, and what “taking care of yourself” actually looks like. 
• seed oil free eating and why Tony calls it a lifestyle 
• noticeable weight loss and the awkward reality of clothes not fitting 
• aging as wear and tear and why maintenance beats repair 
• the car analogy for health, habits, and long-term outcomes 
• health anxiety after...


Video Podcast Anxiety And The Scar Debate
09/04/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We argue about why anyone wants video and roast each other about being on camera. Then we swap scar stories that somehow turn into Star Wars dreams, table saw injuries, and a BB gun ricochet that will never die. 
• video podcast pressure versus audio-only comfort 
• teasing about faces, confidence, and nicknames 
• “girls dig scars” and the fantasy of a cool Anakin scar 
• biggest scar stories including a table saw thumb 
• the so-called shark bite that is really a river scrape 
• the BB under-the-skin scar story and trying to remove it 
Ever...


I Called 911 To Watch YouTube
#88
09/01/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We go from brick phones and payphones to the modern reality where nobody can work, drive, or even relax without a solid signal. Then Tony walks us through a painfully funny carrier switch that turns into porting-pin chaos after US Cellular becomes T-Mobile and his campground coverage drops to “SOS.” 
• remembering payphones, coins, and answering calls blind 
• how smartphones replace calling and speed up everything 
• why cars and daily life now depend on screens 
• the campground tower problem and why coverage maps lie 
• what the US Cellular to T-Mobile change bre...


The Outfit Audit
08/28/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We roast Jay’s wild color combo and turn a simple outfit into a full-on debate about confidence, comfort, and taste. The jokes spiral into sneaker lace politics, camera-safe excuses, and the kind of petty honesty only close friends can get away with. 
• Tony calls out every color choice in Jay’s fit 
• Jay defends dressing for comfort and avoiding questions 
• a running joke about whether a spouse can sabotage your look 
• the matching cup detail that makes it funnier 
• Adidas Shelltoe talk and the fat laces argument 
• the camera not...


I Learned The Hard Way That Boats Have No Brakes
#87
08/25/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We try on the “captain” identity and immediately get humbled by trim buttons, drifting anchors, and the reality that boats do not stop like cars. Between pier crashes, fish finder skepticism, and the live bait “cheating” debate, we land on the only real moral: teach your kids the skills so they don’t learn the hard way. 
• arguing about what kind of glass door we’re behind 
• fantasizing about becoming a fishing captain and Everglades tour guide 
• renting a pontoon boat for free and immediately bluffing competence 
• fumbling engine trim and throttle contro...


Jury Duty Survival Guide
#86
08/19/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We trade jury duty war stories and find out how fast “easy civic duty” turns into a high-stress audition in a courtroom. We also wrestle with the gap between what feels true and what can actually be proven when twelve strangers have to agree on a verdict. 
• arguing about Apple vs Android and how phones confuse everyone now 
• the real cost of jury duty when you are self-employed 
• what voir dire and jury selection questions look like in the room 
• the temptation to say the “right” thing to avoid getting picked 
...


When Did Car Ownership Become A Subscription?
08/14/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We go from joking around to the real problem of owning a nice car: keeping it clean when you’ve got kids, dogs, road trips, and zero time. We debate detailing costs versus car wash subscriptions and why “nice” quickly turns into another monthly bill. 
• Buying a nicer car and feeling the pressure to maintain it 
• Kids, sticky snacks, dogs, and the reality of a clean interior 
• Bug guts, road grime, and why quick rinses do not cut it 
• What a professional detailing package includes and why prices jump 
• Why people co...


Office Talk Without The Filter
#85
08/12/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We start with a Braveheart tattoo and end up asking why work makes normal people talk like lawyers. Along the way, we vent about HR training, office politics, email-only coworkers, and how direct conversations solve problems faster than a paper trail war. 
• the Braveheart quote behind the tattoo and why it matters 
• how joking about someone’s appearance plays differently at work 
• HR videos, “appropriateness,” and the strange scripts people learn 
• leadership realities like firing someone versus handling harassment claims 
• why corporate speak feels fake and confrontation feels forbidden 
• hand...


As Is, Cash Only
08/07/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We react to a wild Cash Cars Kansas City style pitch and break down what “as is” really demands from the buyer. We also spell out what they consider a “warranty,” why cash is nonnegotiable, and how to protect yourself no before you hand over money. 
• defining “as is” as buyer responsibility 
• motor and transmission as the only real warranty line 
• why “still runs” is not the same as “problem free” 
• how to do a real test drive that reveals breakdowns 
• checking radios, windows, seats, heat, and air before buying 
• cash-only rule...


Teenage Joyrides
#86
08/04/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We trade stories about underage driving, “borrowing” cars, and the dumb logic that makes bad ideas feel smart at 3 AM. The laughs land, but the real thread is how fast luck can run out when you mix friends, speed, and zero consequences. 
• Gift-giving jokes and friend group rivalry 
• Where the line is between joyriding and stealing a car 
• Mailbox smashing story and instant karma 
• Sneaking a mom’s Subaru Outback for late-night cruising 
• Knocking down construction barrels until hitting a concrete-filled one 
• Ditching the wreck, running home, and the blame game 
...


Our Attraction Hot Takes Get Weird Fast
07/31/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We spiral from a simple “favorite” question into a full debate on boob views, sag versus perk, and the wild logic people use to defend their tastes. Along the way, we roast each other with a Home Depot analogy, pivot into gravity and aging, and wonder if women talk about bodies with the same blunt honesty. 
• picking favorites and immediately escalating the question 
• side boob, underboob, and how “imagination” changes the appeal 
• arguing about sag, shape, and what even counts as “bad” 
• the “lay on your back” test as a fake dating standard 
...


When Your Spine Squeezes Like A Jelly Donut
#85
07/28/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We talk through Tony’s yearly herniated disc flare-ups, why the pain can feel impossible to describe, and how the usual medical options kept circling back to “inflammation.” Tony then shares the anti-inflammatory food plan he followed for five weeks and the surprising changes he noticed in pain, cravings, heartburn, and weight. 
• what a neck herniated disc flare feels like and how it radiates into the arm and fingers 
• chiropractor relief versus “fixing” the underlying problem 
• the surgery pitch, the long-term success concerns, and why Tony walks away 
• why pills and nerve blocke...


Stove Outage To DIY Rewire
#84
07/21/2026

Send us Fan Mail


Vegas Fine Dining Whiplash
#83
07/14/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We read a vicious one-star review of the Eiffel Tower Restaurant in Las Vegas, then Tony explains why that same place becomes the best meal and service he has ever had. The gap between those two stories turns into a debate about expectations, seating, pricing on the Strip, and what “fine dining” is supposed to feel like when it’s done right. 
• reading a long one-star review that calls the place a tourist trap 
• reacting to how the same restaurant can have opposite experiences 
• breaking down Las Vegas Strip pricing and why “fancy”...


The Great Razor Blade Rip-Off
#82
07/07/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We bounce from ridiculous sports stats to the very real pain of buying overpriced razor refills, then land on a surprisingly useful set of shaving hacks we swear we will actually try. We debate blade counts, irritation, shower shaving, and all the myths people repeat, while trying to figure out why something as basic as shaving still feels like a scam. 
• Shaq “owns everything” and our talent for making up statistics 
• Free throws as a mental game and why underhand might work 
• Paper notes versus phone notes and the curse of never fini...


What Youth Sports Really Costs Families
#81
06/30/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We take Jay’s Florida trip from pre-flight anxiety to the brutal reality of a youth flag football “world championship” in Orlando. The tournament ends fast, Disney costs a fortune, and the real damage shows up after everyone gets home. 

• Jay’s travel anxiety and fear of flying before the trip 
• How the Orlando flag football world championship invite really works 
• Tournament fees plus the Disney 15-day stay requirement 
• The hidden costs of travel sports for families 
• Rule differences by state and getting blindsided on day one 
• Going 1-3 the firs...


From Gangster Rap To Tile Setter Glory
#80
06/23/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We argue about what we thought we’d be as kids and how adult jobs actually happen through chance, pressure, and a few reckless decisions. Along the way, we bounce from cassette tapes and rap fantasies to real talk about unions, entrepreneurship, and whether you’re building a job or a business. 

• childhood career dreams versus real-world careers 
• cassette tape nostalgia and the short-lived gangster rapper era 
• crime jokes that turn into a Bitcoin glitch story 
• getting forced into tile work and slowly earning pride in mastery 
• why most people nev...


A Cruise Works Because You Cannot Escape It
#79
06/16/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We argue about the best kind of vacation and why planning can either free you up or ruin the fun before you even leave. We get into cruises, road trips, overplanning habits, and the travel stories that make you rethink what “worth it” really means. 
• Cruises as a way to force real downtime and reduce decision fatigue 
• Ship life basics like pools, shows, bars, dining and why sea days work 
• The appeal of port stops and excursions like snorkeling and Mayan ruins 
• Vacation budgeting pressure and the mental load of pre trip plan...


We Accidentally Turned Drug Patents Into A Comedy Bit
06/12/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We start by roasting a too-deep couch that turns sitting into a full-body problem, then slide into winter misery and the slow-motion vibe it puts on everyone. Somehow that turns into a riff on drug branding, Viagra alternatives, and why gas station “male enhancement” pills feel like pure marketing. 
• clowning on the deep couch and numb legs problem 
• wintertime dragging people down and slowing traffic 
• getting called out for obvious made-up money stories 
• joking about side hustles and getting paid by check 
• breaking down how patents and branding shape drug sales 


The Stages Of Raising Kids
#78
06/09/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We debate which stages of raising kids are genuinely fun and which ones test your sanity the most, from helpless babies to toddlers on a mission to break everything. We also get real about teens and adult kids at home, and why rules only matter when we actually enforce them. 
• our favorite child stages and why 
• baby stress vs crawling exploration vs toddler chaos 
• how family parties feel with little kids vs older kids 
• teen attitude, privacy battles, and morning wakeups 
• adult kids living at home, rent talk, and “my house...


How Much Peace Is A Cheeseburger Worth
06/05/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We start with a no-music cold open and immediately feel how weird it is to find our footing without the usual intro. Then we spiral into a drive-thru ordering disaster and land on a real question about when it’s worth correcting mistakes versus protecting our own inner peace. 
• debating whether to start with music or jump straight in 
• a chaotic fast-food drive-thru order that keeps going wrong 
• confusion over whether the worker can’t hear or the speaker is broken 
• the strange pressure to “just get through it” instead of correctin...


We Opened The Rare Bourbon And Still Felt Cheated
#77
06/02/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We start with a rare bourbon gift that accidentally sparks real jealousy and a hard question about who gets treated like the favorite. Then we spiral into parenting, Christmas traditions, and why trying to keep everything “equal” can teach kids the wrong lesson. 
• gift giving turning into an unspoken scoreboard between friends 
• a campground bike purchase showing how fairness rules get weaponized 
• why kids remember everything and adults pretend they do not 
• teaching “life isn’t fair” without raising selfish kids 
• Christmas present counts, big gifts, and holiday overload 
• grandkid...


When You Finally Find Someone Who Won't Rip You Off
#76
05/19/2026

Send us Fan Mail

We celebrate our good fortune in finding honest mechanics who don't take advantage of us when we're vulnerable.

• Finding an auto mechanic who charges fair rates and doesn't mark up parts excessively
• The frustration of auto shops using "book prices" that overestimate repair times
• Why most shops won't let you bring your own parts
• Streamlining your life by paying others for services when your time is more valuable
• How veterinarians and boat mechanics are among the most feared service providers
• The nerve-wracking experience of a potential $6,000 boat repair<...