Retail Media Breakfast Club

What does it take for a retail media network to stand out in an increasingly crowded landscape? Sometimes, the answer isn't building more ad tech: it's knowing what makes you special as a retailer and doubling down on that. In this episode, an expansion on my recent article for The Drum, I unpack Gopuff's partnership with Instacart, and why adopting its Carrot Ads technology could be a smart move, giving Gopuff access to a much larger pool of advertiser demand while freeing its team to focus on the bespoke campaigns that only Gopuff can deliver.

I explore...

What happens when an ad finds you at exactly the right moment, but still gets the job wrong? I found myself standing in the bolts aisle at Bunnings, using ChatGPT to figure out which bolt I needed for my home studio setup, when an ad helpfully reminded me that I could buy bolts at Bunnings. The problem? I was already there. What I really needed was for my AI assistant to tell me whether the bolt I needed was in stock on the shelf in front of me.

That experience got me thinking about the future of...

AI shopping agents are starting to change how people discover products, compare prices, and actually make purchases. But as these agents take on more of the shopping journey, there’s a much bigger question we need to be asking: who’s going to pay for them, and will they still be working in the shopper’s best interest when they do?

In this episode, I’m sharing some of my favorite moments from Jason Goldberg and Scot Wingo’s discussion on The Jason & Scot Show, including a fascinating story about how Walmart approached AI adoption, why Amazon...

Today I’m looking at what happens to brand loyalty when AI starts doing more of the shopping. We’ve all seen how shoppers stick with the brands they know, even when there might be a cheaper or supposedly better option sitting right next to them. But what happens when an AI assistant starts comparing products, making recommendations and potentially changing the way consumers discover and buy?

I’m drawing on research I co-authored with Bazaarvoice, along with findings from WPP Media, Oxford University’s Saïd Business School, NP Digital and Kantar, to unpack how brand preferenc...

Retail media has spent the last few years chasing growth through connected TV, influencer partnerships, social commerce, and in-store screens. But new research from eMarketer and Bain & Company suggests retail media network leaders are shifting their focus back to onsite advertising, where retailers have more control, higher margins, and a more established path to advertiser budgets. In this episode, an expansion on my recent article for The Drum, I explore why offsite retail media has been harder to scale than expected, what advertiser demand tells us about the industry's biggest growth opportunities, and why proving incremental revenue remains a...

Are bigger retail media networks automatically better? And what really makes a network worth investing in? In this episode, I'm picking up the debate sparked by Brian Spencer at Kroger Precision Marketing about what it takes to build a successful retail media network. Scale matters, but so do audience relevance, addressability, and technology.

I also unpack GrowthLoop's 2026 Commerce Media Investment Index to explore what advertisers really want from audience targeting, whether faster audience fulfillment is worth paying more for, and what United's Connective restructuring reveals about the technology needed to turn valuable audiences into measurable results.

Why are retail media networks bringing back multi-touch attribution (MTA) when many marketers consider it outdated? In part 2 of my MTA series, I explore why Albertsons Media Collective and Best Buy Ads are investing in MTA, and how better measurement could help retailers unlock national brand advertising budgets beyond sponsored products.

I also look at the limits of current MTA solutions, why measurement matters when brands choose retail media networks, and three questions retailers should ask before building their own attribution capabilities. Plus, I preview the next big question in commerce media: are retail media networks growing...

Are there really only 10 or 20 successful retail media networks, or are we overlooking the value of the other 180? A recent LinkedIn post from Brian Spencer at Kroger Precision Marketing sparked a debate about what it takes to be a successful retail media network, and I wanted to dig into one of his key criteria: scale. Because while scale absolutely matters to some advertisers, I think the bigger question is: scale for whom?

In this episode, I unpack why national CPG media teams gravitate toward the biggest retail media networks, what that means for smaller and...

Consumer AI is growing at an incredible pace, but here's the thing: even though millions of people are using AI, very few are actually paying for it. So how are these platforms going to make money, and what does that mean for retail media and the future of shopping?

In this episode, I'm digging into some fascinating new research from Andreessen Horowitz on consumer AI adoption, spending habits, and the business models emerging around these platforms. I explore why people are willing to pay for productivity but not necessarily everyday consumer queries, why advertising could become the...

The retail media landscape is getting more crowded by the week. McDonald’s, Simon Property Group, Delta, and a growing list of other companies are launching commerce media businesses. But does the world actually need more retail media networks? In this episode, I share Matthew Fantazier's latest 'hot take' on the explosion of commerce media and add my own perspective on the biggest question facing these new networks: who is this actually for?

I also dig into the rise of consumer-facing AI agents and what it could mean for advertising, commerce, and consumer trust. If AI agents st...

There’s a lot of talk in retail media about better measurement, incrementality, and finding the one metric that finally tells us what’s really working. But sometimes the metrics we’re using are… well, bulldust. In this episode, I dig into why measurement looks so different depending on which side of the table you’re sitting on, and why retailers and brands can both feel like they’re doing the right thing while talking completely past each other.

I also revisit the question of why ROAS refuses to die. Is it actually a useless metric, or does it pers...

I recently took a closer look at what Best Buy Ads is building, and what it tells us about where retail media is heading. Best Buy was one of the early retailers to launch sponsored product ads, but at its latest showcase, that familiar ad format was barely part of the conversation. Instead, the spotlight was on connected TV, creators, TikTok Shop, its production studio, and new measurement capabilities.

I think that shift tells us something important about the future of retail media. Brands increasingly want retail media to do more than drive an immediate sale, while...

A couple of years ago, two neighborhood cats started visiting our house. We fed them, they kept coming back, and then one day they turned up wearing collars that said, “Do not feed unless starving.” It turned out we weren't the only ones feeding them: and nobody really knew who was feeding them, how often, or how much.

Brands have their own version of this problem. When they add up all the attributed sales from every retail media network they spend with, somehow the total can come out bigger than their actual sales. So when Albertsons and Best...

I’m revisiting one of my most popular episodes from last year: the retail media doom loop. The basic idea is pretty simple — a retailer sees the ad revenue being generated by Amazon and Walmart, launches a retail media network, and quickly grows by moving existing trade and shopper marketing dollars onto a media line. But what happens when that easy growth runs out?

In this episode, I look at what the latest data and conversations with retail media leaders suggest about where the industry is actually headed in 2026 and beyond. I dig into why sponsored search and...

AI is becoming part of how we shop, but how much do consumers actually trust what an AI assistant recommends? In this episode, I’m digging into two new research studies — one from Acosta Group, and one I conducted with Bazaarvoice — to explore what shoppers really think about AI-powered shopping recommendations, advertising, brand discovery, and trust.

I’ll walk through what happens when shoppers encounter ads inside AI tools, why consumers are increasingly taking a “trust but verify” approach, and how AI is changing the way people research products both online and inside physical stores. I’ll also look at w...

Retail media is a creative wasteland. That’s the catchy line coming out of Ipsos’ new Creativity Over Clicks research. And honestly, my first reaction was to get my hackles up. But once I slowed down and looked at what the data was actually saying, I realized the report was confirming something many retail media practitioners have known for a long time: the creative looks the way it does for some very rational reasons.

In this episode, I unpack what Ipsos’ research tells us about retail media creative, shopper mindset, measurement, and the tension between brand building and bo...

I recently spent a week in Poland on a family trip, and while I didn't have nearly as much time for retail media recon as I would have liked, I came away with a few observations that I found genuinely fascinating. From the country's enormous network of parcel lockers being turned into advertising surfaces, to the surprising density of Żabka convenience stores, there is a lot happening in Polish retail and commerce media.

In this episode, I walk through four things that caught my attention on the ground: the emergence of parcel lockers as an out-of-home media n...

Are retail media networks finally getting the hang of collaboration? This week, two major announcements have me thinking about the transition from parallel play to collaborative play in retail media. Best Buy is expanding its partnership with Amazon to sell Fire TV ad inventory, while Instacart and Gopuff are teaming up on both delivery and advertising technology. And these aren’t just interesting partnerships on paper: they could change how brands buy, target, and measure retail media campaigns.

In this episode, I’m breaking down what each company gets out of these deals, why Best Buy’s audien...

We’ve struck a pretty clear deal with advertisers: we tolerate ads in exchange for free or subsidized services. But what happens when those ads show up inside AI assistants that we’re increasingly relying on to help us shop? New research from Bazaarvoice, which I co-authored, reveals that consumers are already questioning whether AI recommendations are truly independent. And that raises some important questions for brands and retail media advertisers.

In this episode, a recap of my recent article for The Drum, I dig into what shoppers actually think about advertising in AI, why sponsored placements aren...

I've got some really good news to share on today's Retail Media Breakfast Club. Despite some of the things that can leave me feeling a little disheartened about the retail media industry, I recently discovered something genuinely exciting: 44% of US retail media networks are led by women. That's substantially higher than the representation of women in VP and SVP roles reported in recent McKinsey research.

I put together a database of named P&L leaders across the NRF's 2026 Top 100 US retailers, and I'm sharing what I found, along with a few theories about why retail media might...

Why do good retailers make bad ad tech decisions? In part two of my series on the different eras of retail media, I’m expanding on my recent article for The Drum, and exploring why choosing the right technology is only part of the equation. The bigger question is: What role does your retail media network actually play in the media plan?

Drawing on insights from Co-op Media Network’s Dean Harris and Ace Hardware’s Molly Hjelm, I look at the different end states for retail media networks, from scaled walled gardens to specialist player...

Retail media technology has already gone through several major reinventions. From retailers building their own ad tech stacks, to point solutions, cloud-based composable technology, and now AI-ready data infrastructure.

In this episode, I’m recapping my recent article for The Drum, and exploring the four eras of retail media tech. More importantly, why these eras aren’t necessarily sequential. Across retail media networks today, you can find very different technology architectures operating at the same time, and I dig into what led up to this moment. 

Tomorrow, in part two, I’ll look at another framewo...

Most shoppers are now using AI tools to shop, and they’re increasingly discovering new brands and products inside a chat window. That raises a practical question for anyone buying or selling commerce media: what does it actually take to get a shopper to switch to a brand they’ve never heard of when an AI assistant recommends it?

In this episode, I’m sharing highlights from the new consumer study I collaborated on with Bazaarvoice, What Is a Brand Worth When AI Does the Shopping? We looked at price sensitivity, brand familiarity, consumer trust, product reviews, catego...

Amazon is extending its DSP into ChatGPT, giving brands that already advertise through Amazon Ads a new way to reach consumers inside the ChatGPT app. But the headline isn’t actually the most interesting part of this announcement. The bigger story is what Amazon is doing with its DSP, and why it increasingly looks less like an Amazon advertising product and more like an advertising aggregation strategy.

In this episode, I’m sharing Jo Lambadjieva's analysis of the Amazon–OpenAI advertising deal, along with a few of my own takeaways for enterprise brands and retailers operating retail media...

There’s a new beef in marketing, and this one hits close to home: can retail media actually build brands, or is it really just trade promotion with a fancy name and a dashboard? Mark Ritson kicked off the debate by arguing that retail media is fundamentally a bottom-of-funnel, defensive investment. Andrew Lipsman pushed back, making the case that retail media can do something brand marketers have wanted for decades: reach people who aren’t currently buying your brand.

In this episode, I dig into both sides of the argument, including the role of retailer data, off-site audi...

Today, I’m digging into a question that has been coming up more and more as retail media expands into a broader commerce media ecosystem: does commerce media really need to be tied to the cart?

I’m narrating a guest contribution essay from Tom Limongello of The Middlemen Podcast that got me thinking differently about the distinction between retail media and commerce media. Specifically why SKUs and assortments are useful ways to understand retail media, but may not actually define it (and why the more important concept could be the shopper mission). Tom's essay also looks at t...

By now, you’ve probably read plenty of coverage about the FTC’s case against Amazon’s ad auction (last week I shared an article on The Drum). But the question I’m more interested in is the one that actually matters if you’re managing an advertising budget or running a retail media network: does any of this change where the money goes?

My prediction, sadly, is no. Though I’d be very happy to be proven wrong. 

In this episode, I break down why cheaper clicks probably wouldn’t mean less money for Amazo...

Retail media has a fragmentation problem. We have better dashboards, better reporting, and better measurement than we did a few years ago. But media buyers are still being asked to navigate an ever-growing number of retail media networks and walled gardens.

In this episode, I look at what’s happening in the UK, where two major retail media aggregation plays launched over the summer: RMX by Plan-Apps from SMG and the dunnhumby network alliance, involving Tesco, B&Q, John Lewis and Waitrose. I also share snippets of a conversation from the Retail Media Therapy podcast with Co-op Me...

After living outside Australia for around 15 years, I’m experiencing retail and shopping here with fresh eyes. And one thing that has really caught my attention is just how much retail media is showing up in the physical world.

In this first Trip Report, I’m taking you on a quick tour of six retail and commerce media activations I spotted around Perth. From Commonwealth Bank and Coles, to JB Hi-Fi, David Jones, Australia Post and digital out-of-home media in shopping centres. This isn’t about declaring one market “better” than another. Instead, I’m looking at what’s happe...

Last Thursday, Ace Hardware took over Wrigley Field in Chicago for the first upfront from Redvest Media, its roughly year-old retail media network. I wasn’t there myself, so I called my friend Tom Limongello, host of The Middlemen Podcast, who was on the ground. I wanted to know what was happening beyond the press releases: who Ace put on stage, what the retailer was really trying to communicate, and what advertisers were saying afterwards.

We dig into what Ace’s executive lineup reveals about the growing integration of retail media with the broader business, why audience inno...

Are retail media networks trying too hard to become media companies? In this episode, I’m sharing a thought-provoking piece from Mike Shields of Next in Media that asks whether the industry’s push toward off-site, full-funnel media is actually the right strategy for most retailers. Plus the tension between putting the “retail” back into retail media and chasing bigger brand budgets through CTV, DSPs and the open web.

I also share some of my own thoughts on where retail media is heading, including the very different economics of on-site versus off-site advertising, why brands are demanding more mea...

Amazon already captures roughly 40% of every dollar spent online in the US, yet it continues to grow at an impressive pace. So I wanted to look at a question we don't hear nearly enough: where does Amazon spend its own advertising money? Because while Amazon gives brands advertising recommendations every day, I think its own media plan may be the more interesting lesson.

In this recap of my recent article for The Drum, I dug into three years of Sensor Tower data to see where Amazon is putting its advertising dollars, which channels are getting the biggest...

Advertising has always been the glamorous side of ecommerce, while product catalog maintenance, reviews, inventory, and other operational work have often been underfunded. But with Amazon’s Sponsored Prompts, that relationship is changing dramatically. This is Part 2 of my Sponsored Prompts series (check out Park 1 here), I’m digging into why your advertising account is now downstream of everything happening in your operations, and why content is no longer just an input to your ads; it is the ad. 

I’m also taking a closer look at product reviews, reporting limitations, bidding, and what Sponsored Prompts could ultimat...

There’s a particular kind of vertigo that comes from watching a podcast you started get better without you. I launched the Ecommerce Braintrust podcast back in 2017, and while I’m no longer running it, I still listen because the team at Acadia is in the trenches every day doing the work.

A recent conversation between my old Acadia colleagues on measurement really got me thinking about a question I hear from brands all the time: if every advertising platform says it’s winning, why don’t the business results reflect that? When Meta, Google, Amazon and retail m...

When Amazon unveiled Sponsored Prompts at Unboxed, I initially dismissed them as a clever but relatively minor addition to Alexa Shopping. But after digging into Andrew Bell's deep analysis of the underlying patent, I realized this format represents something much bigger and potentially far more disruptive.

In this episode, I unpack why Amazon's new AI-powered ad format flips decades of digital advertising on its head by charging advertisers before the persuasive content is even generated! I explore what that means for brands, legal teams, product claims, customer reviews, and the future of retail media. This is Part 1...

What makes one retail media network stand out when so many seem to promise the same thing? In this episode, I explore a fascinating psychology concept called the 'effort heuristic', and explain why it has huge implications for retail media. When buyers can't easily judge technical quality, they look for visible signs that a retailer is investing, innovating, and genuinely building something worthwhile.

I also share why transparency can become a competitive advantage, highlight Costco's retail media strategy as a standout example, and discuss where the line is between showcasing meaningful progress and creating announcement fatigue. If...

I finally did something I'd been meaning to do for a while: I requested the full Amazon Ads Consumer File to see exactly what Amazon knows about me. While I expected a few surprises, what I uncovered wasn't just a look into my own shopping habits. It opened my eyes to how brands that don't even sell on Amazon are increasingly using Amazon's audience data to reach consumers.

In this episode, a recap of my recent article for The Drum, I unpack what I found inside my data export, why companies like airlines, banks, insurers and fast-food...

I've been wrestling with a question that's becoming impossible to ignore: will agentic media buying fundamentally reshape retail media, or even eliminate parts of today's ecosystem? As AI-powered agents begin making more decisions across ad buying, optimization, and measurement, it's worth asking who wins, who loses, and whether the way advertising dollars flow today will look anything like it does a year or two from now.

In this episode, I share highlights from an insightful conversation on the Ad Tech Therapy podcast, where Scott Messer and Jana Meron responded to my question about the future of agentic...

What if ordering lunch sounded like the way many brands buy retail media? That was the inspiration behind my latest comedy skit... but beneath the joke is a serious question about how retail media is changing the way marketers think about growth.

In this episode, I unpack a thoughtful LinkedIn post from Juliana Nodwell, and connect it with several of my past articles about why precision isn't the same as purpose. I explore where retail media truly excels, why brand marketing and retail media serve different jobs, and how confusing the two can actually weaken long-term growth...

We've spent the last year watching retailers race to launch AI shopping assistants, but I think we're asking the wrong question. Instead of obsessing over who has the smartest chatbot, we should be asking: What job are shoppers actually hiring these AI assistants to do?

In this episode, I unpack insights from a fascinating recent conversation on Jason Del Rey's newsletter The Aisle with former Amazon and Walmart product leader Mukesh Jain, explore why "nobody wakes up wanting to chat with a retailer," and explain why the future of AI shopping may have far less...