All The Damn Crime
Welcome to All The Damn Crim — a weekly true crime podcast covering the gruesome, the obscure, and the unsolved.Hosted by John, a defense investigator, and Joel, a documentary filmmaker, the show blends sharp storytelling with real investigative insight. Together, they break down cases from every angle.Each week we explore missing persons, cold cases, serial crimes, controversial investigations, and bizarre true crime stories from around the world. Some cases are solved, some remain mysteries, and some defy explanation entirely.Deep-dive true crime with smart-ish conversation, dark stories, and gallows humor.New episodes every week. Maura Murray, JonBenét Ramsey, Made...
Parade Massacres: Three Attacks, Three Communities
Send us Fan Mail
Parades are supposed to bring people together. Families line the streets, music plays, and communities celebrate. But in three horrifying cases, those celebrations turned into mass-casualty attacks.
This week on All the Damn Crime, we're covering the 2022 Highland Park Fourth of July parade shooting, where Robert Crimo III killed seven people and wounded dozens; the 2016 Berlin Christmas Market attack, where Anis Amri drove a hijacked truck into a crowded market; and the 2015 Oklahoma State University Homecoming parade attack, where Adacia Chambers drove into the crowd, killing four people and...
Karen Greenlee, The Morgue Rat
Send us Fan Mail
This week on All the Damn Crime, we're exploring paraphilic disorders and the disturbing psychology of necrophilia before diving into one of the strangest criminal cases you'll hear.
In 1979, Karen Greenlee was working as an apprentice embalmer in Sacramento, California, when she stole a hearse carrying the body of 33-year-old John Mercure—and disappeared. When authorities found her, they uncovered a confession describing sexual encounters with numerous deceased men. But here's the shocking part: California had no specific law against necrophilia at the time.
So what exactly is...
Released from Death Row and then 92 Days of Terror
Send us Fan Mail
This week on All the Damn Crime, we're looking at Reginald McFadden, a convicted murderer whose release from prison became a cautionary tale about clemency, parole, and the consequences of getting it wrong.
At just 16, McFadden took part in the murder of 66-year-old Sonia Rosenbaum. After serving nearly 25 years of a life sentence, his sentence was commuted, and in July 1994, he walked free. Just 92 days later, he was arrested for two more murders and a brutal sexual assault.
How did McFadden convince officials he deserved...
The Sirloin Stockade Massacre: Oklahoma’s Night of Terror
Send us Fan Mail
This week on All the Damn Crime, we're going back to Oklahoma in 1978 for one of the state's most infamous murder cases: the Sirloin Stockade murders.
Roger Dale Stafford, his wife Verna, and his brother Harold robbed a Sirloin Stockade in Oklahoma City and murdered six employees as the restaurant was closing for the night. But that wasn't the beginning of the story. Just weeks earlier, the Lorenz family had been murdered after stopping to help a stranded motorist on Interstate 35.
Nine people were dead...
Christa Pike: Days From Death Row
Send us Fan Mail
This week on All the Damn Crime, we're talking about Christa Pike, the only woman currently on Tennessee's death row, whose execution is scheduled for September 30, 2026. Pike was sentenced to death for the 1995 murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer when Pike was 18. If carried out, it would be Tennessee's first execution of a woman in more than 200 years.
We break down Pike's crime, her decades on death row, her recent legal challenges and clemency request, and what's happening as her execution date approaches.
Then we turn t...
Mica Miller: The Death of the Pastor’s Wife
Send us Fan Mail
Netflix's Death of the Pastor's Wife has brought the story of Mica Miller back into the national spotlight. This week, we take a closer look at the documentary and the complicated story behind it.
Mica died in April 2024 from a self-inflicted gunshot wound, but her death came after a turbulent marriage and separation from pastor John-Paul Miller. Friends and family interviewed in the documentary describe allegations of controlling and abusive behavior, while prosecutors have separately accused John-Paul of cyberstalking Mica before her death. He has pleaded not guilty.
What d...
A Deadly Family Dinner and Oregon's Quintuple Homicide
Send us Fan Mail
This week on All the Damn Crime, we're covering two breaking stories involving devastating acts of violence against families.
First, we head to Montana, where 44-year-old Alan Michael Smith allegedly opened fire on his own family during a gathering near Billings, killing eight relatives—including four children—before dying from a self-inflicted gunshot wound. Smith had reportedly been asked to leave his parents' home weeks earlier, but authorities have not established that as a motive.
Then we turn to Oregon, where authorities say Benjamin Parker allegedly killed his g...
The Happiest Littlest Hobo on Death Row: The Tragic Story of Joe Arridy
Send us Fan Mail
Joe Arridy was 23 years old when Colorado executed him for a murder he almost certainly did not commit. Arridy had an intellectual disability and was highly suggestible. Police obtained a confession implicating him in the rape and murder of 15-year-old Dorothy Drain, but evidence later showed serious problems with the confession and with the prosecution's case.
Even as his execution approached, Arridy's attorneys fought desperately to stop it. He received nine stays of execution before finally being killed in the gas chamber on January 6, 1939. More than seven decades later, he was p...
The Godfather of Our Collective True Crime Obsession: The Mysterious Death of Edgar Allan Poe
Send us Fan Mail
Edgar Allan Poe spent his career writing about murder, madness, mysterious deaths, and detectives searching for answers. Then, in 1849, Poe himself became the subject of a mystery no detective has ever solved.
He disappeared during a trip to Baltimore and resurfaced days later in a state of severe distress. He was taken to a hospital, where his condition deteriorated. His doctors couldn't establish a clear cause of death, and Poe never provided a coherent explanation of what happened to him.
One of the most intriguing theories is cooping<...
The Serial Killer Cop?
Send us Fan Mail
James Aren Duckett was convicted of one horrific murder—but investigators believed there may have been more. After Teresa McAbee was found dead in 1987, evidence led police to the officer who had been the last person seen with her. Duckett was convicted and sentenced to death, while investigators later connected him to the deaths of other women and girls. He was never charged in those additional cases, leaving a disturbing question: How many victims could James Aren Duckett have had? We examine the evidence, the unanswered questions, and the case of a p...
The Yorkshire Witch and The Prophetic Chicken
Send us Fan Mail
Long before modern scams, Mary Bateman mastered the art of deception. Claiming supernatural powers, she manipulated families into believing their lives depended on her rituals and remedies. What followed was a trail of fraud, forged documents, and murder by poison that made her one of England's most infamous criminals. This episode dives into the myths, the murders, and the truth behind the Yorkshire Witch.
Original Yorkshire Witch, Mary Bateman case, Yorkshire Witch murders, poison killings, historical fraud, English criminal history, fake psychic, fortune teller murder, arsenic killer, Leeds t...
53 Days of Terror: America's Deadliest Killing Couple
Send us Fan Mail
During the summer of 1984, Alton Coleman and Debra Brown launched a 53-day crime spree that terrorized the Midwest. Crossing six states, the pair kidnapped, raped, tortured, robbed, and murdered victims ranging from young children to elderly couples. Their crimes shocked the nation and resulted in one of the largest multi-state manhunts in FBI history. This episode follows the trail of violence, the hunt that finally ended their reign of terror, and the disturbing relationship that fueled one of America's most notorious killer duos.
Midwest killing spree, Alton Coleman m...
The "Standing Man" of Muskegon Lake: The Todd Geib Mystery
Send us Fan Mail
A crowded party. A series of frantic phone calls. A disappearance that launched one of Michigan's largest volunteer searches. When Todd Geib's body was finally found, investigators faced a troubling question: how did he end up in a location that had already been searched? This episode examines the timeline, the evidence, the official findings, and the lingering mysteries that continue to divide investigators and armchair detectives alike.
Todd Geib mystery, Todd Geib missing, Michigan disappearance, Casnovia party case, mysterious drowning Michigan, Ovid Hall Lake case, Michigan cold case, m...
John Cannan and the Mystery of Suzy Lamplugh
Send us Fan Mail
John Cannan terrorized women across England with a series of violent sexual assaults before being convicted of murder. But his notoriety grew even further when police identified him as the leading suspect in the disappearance of Suzy Lamplugh. This week, we examine Cannan's known crimes, the investigation that followed him for decades, and the unanswered questions surrounding one of Britain's most infamous missing persons cases.
John Cannan, John Cannan crimes, Suzy Lamplugh disappearance, Suzy Lamplugh suspect, British serial killer, UK true crime, John Cannan murderer, c...
Murder at Disneyland
Send us Fan Mail
Disneyland is known as "The Happiest Place on Earth," but in 1981, it became the scene of its first homicide. Eighteen-year-old Mel C. Yorba was fatally stabbed during a private event after a confrontation with another guest. What happened afterward sparked decades of speculation. Instead of calling paramedics to the scene, Disney employees transported Yorba to a nearby hospital in an unmarked company van, a decision that led to a wrongful death lawsuit and helped fuel the enduring myth that "no one dies at Disneyland." In this episode, we separate fact from fiction as...
The "Littlest" Civil Rights Figure was a Cop Killer
Send us Fan Mail
In 1974, 20-year-old Joan Little was jailed in North Carolina when she claimed a white jailer sexually assaulted her at knifepoint. Little fought back, killing the jailer and escaping custody. What followed became one of the most significant trials of the Civil Rights era, drawing national attention from activists, civil rights leaders, and women's rights organizations. This episode explores the events inside the jail, the murder trial that followed, and how Joan Little became a symbol of self-defense, racial justice, and women's rights.
Welcome to All The Damn Crim — a wee...
Charlie Brandt: The Killer of Women
Send us Fan Mail
A quiet family gathering in Florida ended in horror when Charlie Brandt killed his wife and niece before taking his own life. As investigators searched for answers, they discovered a violent past and clues that pointed toward other unsolved murders. This episode dives into the disturbing evidence, unanswered questions, and the theory that Charlie Brandt's killing spree may have lasted decades.
Welcome to All The Damn Crim — a weekly true crime podcast covering the gruesome, the obscure, the unbelievable, and the unsolved.
Hosted by John, a d...
The Devil in Dior Goes Missing
Send us Fan Mail
Melissa Caddick built a reputation as a successful financial advisor while allegedly operating a scheme that drained millions from unsuspecting investors. Just as regulators closed in and raided her home, she disappeared. Then came the shocking discovery: a running shoe containing human remains linked to Caddick. Yet her body was never recovered. This episode explores the rise and fall of Melissa Caddick, the victims left behind, and the mystery that continues to captivate Australia.
Welcome to All The Damn Crim — a weekly true crime podcast covering the gruesome, the obs...
When Police Use Entrapment
Send us Fan Mail
In this episode, we examine one of the most controversial questions in criminal justice: when does a police investigation become entrapment? From the FBI's pursuit of the Wolverine Watchmen accused of plotting to kidnap Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer, to federal agents creating fake drug stash houses to lure suspects into robbery conspiracies, law enforcement has long relied on undercover operations to stop crimes before they happen. But critics argue that some of these cases blur the line between catching criminals and creating them.
We'll also look at one of the most...
The Norfolk 4 Scandal: Innocent Men on Trial for Murder
Send us Fan Mail
Norfolk 4 explained, Norfolk Four documentary, Michelle Moore Bosko case, false confession psychology, DNA evidence murder case, wrongful conviction podcast, criminal interrogation tactics, police pressure confessions, Navy sailors innocence case, true crime podcast, legal injustice America, forensic evidence ignored, Virginia murder case, criminal justice reform, law enforcement controversy, homicide investigation errors, innocence case analysis, criminal psychology interrogation, real crime stories, law and crime podcast, podcast discovery keywords, wrongful conviction history, justice system scandal, investigative corruption case, American legal failures, courtroom controversy, forensic science mistakes, dark true crime stories, police interrogation abuse, shocking crime cases.<...
The .22 Caliber Killers: Murder and Fear in East St. Louis
Send us Fan Mail
On December 8, 1978, Davis and Holman committed their first murder. And on that day, they allegedly robbed and killed 78-year-old Frieda Mueller. The two were alleged to have fatally shot her before stealing her television set, billfold, and checkbook. Davis and Holman were never tried for killing Mueller, but her murder was mentioned during their trials.[6]
On December 22, 1978, exactly two weeks after they killed their first victim, 89-year-old Charles Biebel, who used a wheelchair, was fatally shot inside his trailer home. His daughter, Jean Biebel Moore, discovered his body later that evening...
A Parade Turned Deadly: The Crimes of Darrell Brooks
Send us Fan Mail
In 2021, a holiday celebration in Waukesha became a national tragedy after an SUV tore through parade barricades and crowds. This episode explores the attack carried out by Darrell Brooks, the warning signs before the incident, and the emotional aftermath for survivors and victims’ families.
Welcome to All The Damn Crim — a weekly true crime podcast covering the gruesome, the obscure, the unbelievable, and the unsolved.
Hosted by John, a defense investigator, and Joel, a documentary filmmaker and comedian, the show blends sharp storytelling with...
Here Comes the Crime: 3 Weddings That Ended With Criminal Cases
Send us Fan Mail
What should be the happiest day of someone’s life can quickly become the worst. This episode explores three cases where weddings turned into crime scenes—featuring a revenge-fueled attack, a deadly shooting, and a celebration that ended in chaos and arrest.
Welcome to All The Damn Crim — a weekly true crime podcast covering the gruesome, the obscure, the unbelievable, and the unsolved.
Hosted by John, a defense investigator, and Joel, a documentary filmmaker and comedian, the show blends sharp storytelling with real investi...
Blood in Broken Arrow: The Bever Brothers Case Revisited
Send us Fan Mail
The Bever brothers’ attack on their own family shocked the nation—but the story isn’t over. With Robert Bever now speaking from prison, this episode dives into the original crime, the psychological elements behind it, and what his statements may reveal about the truth behind the massacre.
Welcome to All The Damn Crim — a weekly true crime podcast covering the gruesome, the obscure, the unbelievable, and the unsolved.
Hosted by John, a defense investigator, and Joel, a documentary filmmaker and comedian, the show blen...
The Green Widow: How Mary Ellen Samuels Hired Hitmen to Cash In on Her Husband's Death
Send us Fan Mail
When Hollywood camera operator Bob Samuels decided to finalize his divorce, his wife Mary Ellen made a different decision — she hired someone to kill him. On this episode of All the Damn Crime, we dig into the 1988 murder-for-hire case that rocked Northridge, California: a scheming widow, a $500,000 insurance payout, a nude photo covered in cash, and a second murder to cover it all up. Mary Ellen Samuels didn't just want her husband dead — she wanted to make sure no one could ever talk. Keywords: Mary Ellen Samuels, Green Widow, Bob Samuels murder, murder for...
The Suitcase Killer: The Crimes of John Martin Scripps
Send us Fan Mail
British killer John Martin Scripps earned the nickname “The Suitcase Killer” after dismembered remains of his victims were found across Asia. This episode traces his crimes in Singapore and beyond, the investigation that led to his arrest, and how authorities pieced together a horrifying international murder case.
The Day the World Changed: The Assassination of Franz Ferdinand
Send us Fan Mail
On June 28, 1914, a single gunshot in Sarajevo changed the course of history. Archduke Franz Ferdinand of Austria was assassinated by a young nationalist, setting off a chain reaction that led to World War I. In this episode, we break down the plot, the failed attempts, and how one moment ignited a global conflict.
Vanished at the Campsite: The Madison Scott Mystery
Send us Fan Mail
A party in the woods. A tent left behind. A young woman gone without a trace. Madison Scott disappeared overnight in 2011, sparking one of Canada’s most haunting missing person cases. Even after her remains were found 12 years later, investigators are still searching for the truth behind what happened.
The AI Crime Wave: Influence, Delusion, and Digital Evidence
Send us Fan Mail
Artificial intelligence is transforming everyday life—but it’s also appearing in criminal cases. In this episode we examine how influence, delusion, and technology collide. We revisit the texting suicide case involving Michelle Carter, explore a lawsuit alleging an AI chatbot from Google encouraged dangerous behavior, discuss the killing of Suzanne Adams, and look at a federal investigation into AI-generated child exploitation imagery. These cases raise a chilling question: what happens when the “voice” influencing someone isn’t human?
When the Internet Was New: The Kacie Woody 'Yahoo Messenger' Murder
Send us Fan Mail
In 2002, 13-year-old Kacie Woody disappeared from her home in Arkansas after secretly communicating online with, Jazzman_Df, who she believed to be a teenage boy. What investigators uncovered was a chilling case of online grooming that ended in tragedy. This episode explores how the internet predator gained Kacie’s trust, the desperate search for her, and the case that helped shape conversations about online safety for children.
When the internet was new, in 2002.
Till Death Do Us Part: Valentine’s Day Crimes Pt. 2
Send us Fan Mail
Behind the flowers and candlelight, some love stories hide darker truths. In this special drop-in episode, we examine the murder of Grace Millane, the tragic deaths of Jordan Linn and Cody Johnson, and the decades-long legal nightmare surrounding David Camm’s wrongful conviction. Three cases. One theme: when love becomes lethal.
Fingerprints and False Imprisonments
Send us Fan Mail
Fingerprints were once the gold standard in criminal evidence—until wrongful identifications exposed their limits. We recount the Shirley McKie ordeal, the Madrid commuter train bombing print error, and the New York State Police Troop C scandal, examining how each case unfolded and what it taught the justice system about forensic reliability.
The Dark Side of Oz: Abuse, Drugs, and Exploitation in 1939 Hollywood
Send us Fan Mail
Long before #MeToo, the Wizard of Oz set operated under unchecked power. We explore how Judy Garland was chemically controlled, how actors were injured and silenced, and how MGM normalized behavior that would be criminal today—all in the name of movie magic.
Drop In Episode: Alex Pretti & Renée Good: Fatal Encounters with Federal Agents
Send us Fan Mail
Two Minnesota residents — ICU nurse Alex Pretti and mother Renée Good — were killed by federal immigration agents during enforcement operations in Minneapolis. This episode reviews video evidence, conflicting official claims, and why these deaths have ignited protests, legal battles, and calls to rethink ICE tactics.
The Gainesville Ripper: The Danny Rolling Murders
Send us Fan Mail
In August 1990, University of Florida students were targeted in a brutal killing spree that shook Gainesville and captivated the nation. Known as the Gainesville Ripper, Danny Rolling murdered five students in their apartments before his capture. In this episode, we trace the murders, the investigation, and how forensic and community action brought a violent predator to justice.
When Interrogation Goes Too Far: The Fontana False Murder Case
Send us Fan Mail
Police interrogation is designed to uncover the truth—but in Tom Perez Jr.’s case, it nearly destroyed a man. Pressured for 17 hours with misleading evidence, threats about his dog, and relentless questioning, Perez falsely confessed to a crime that never occurred. This episode breaks down how coercive tactics can produce dangerous results.
Nome, Alaska's Killer Cop
Send us Fan Mail
In rural Alaska, Sonya Ivanoff’s life was cut short by someone meant to keep her safe. We explore the events leading up to her death, the courtroom reckoning, and why this case continues to be cited in conversations about police accountability.
From Police Officer to Prisoner: The Tartaglione Murders Explained
Send us Fan Mail
Once trusted as a New York City police officer, Nicholas Tartaglione would go on to murder four people—including his own associates. We unpack the role Clayton Tiffany played, the motive behind the killings, and how investigators finally brought the case to court.
Home of Horror: The Eastburn Slaying and the Long Road to Justice
Send us Fan Mail
Three family members murdered in 1985. No confession, little evidence, and an 11-year-old survivor who couldn’t share what she witnessed. We trace how the Eastburn murders went cold, the suspects that rose and fell, and the breakthrough that finally unlocked the mystery.
Unit 731: Japan’s Secret Bio-Weapons Program in China
Send us Fan Mail
While the world remembers the Holocaust, fewer know about Unit 731. This episode uncovers Japan’s biological experiments in China, the scientists who ran them, and the immunity deals that allowed war criminals to walk free in exchange for data.
