Horror Whiskey Company

id O.J. Simpson have an accomplice? And should an execution ever be livestreamed?Welcome back to **Horror Whiskey Company Episode 87**, where Jamie and Peter dive into another wild week of true crime, horror news, and questionable decisions.This week, we're breaking down new allegations surrounding the O.J. Simpson murders, the controversy over a proposed execution livestream, and the disturbing Sandra Birchmore murder case involving former police officer Matthew Farwell.We also revisit the Amanda Overstreet freezer case after members of our TikTok community shared new information.Then we're switching gears to horror! We're talking about Ryan Murphy's...

Welcome back to **Horror Whiskey Company!** 🥃💀Episode 86 is loaded with disturbing true crime updates, horror news, questionable decisions, and enough whiskey-fueled debates to get us into trouble.Jamie and Peter revisit the Lindsay Clancy case, discuss a possible new connection to the infamous 1982 Chicago Tylenol Murders, and dive into the unbelievable story of a death row inmate who survived two execution attempts.We also cover a pastor convicted of murdering his wife, the controversy surrounding Ryan Murphy's Lizzie Borden adaptation, and whether American Horror Story has completely lost its way.Then we're getting into spooky season with upcoming horror releas...

On September 2006, 16-year-old Cassie Jo Stoddart was housesitting for her aunt and uncle outside Pocatello, Idaho when what seemed like a normal night with friends turned into a nightmare.Two teenagers, Brian Draper and Torey Adamcik, had been secretly planning a murder. They created a kill list, bought knives, hid inside the house, cut the power — and even filmed themselves before and after the attack.The case would eventually become known as “The Scream Murders” because of the killers’ fascination with horror movies and their recorded comments about wanting to create a real-life version of Scream.But was the movie re...

This week on Horror Whiskey Company, the true crime news is absolutely stacked.We start with the fallout from the Lindsay Clancy mistrial and the one juror who prevented a unanimous verdict. Then we head to Philadelphia, where the investigation surrounding Eugene and R.C. Horsch continues to get stranger as authorities uncover items potentially connected to multiple missing women.We also break down the latest twist in the Luigi Mangione case and the argument over double jeopardy, a masked man chasing people through Philadelphia who picked the WRONG person to mess with, and the bizarre case of Florida...

The Monster of Florence stopped killing in 1985—but the chaos surrounding the case was only beginning.

In Part 2, Jamie and Peter follow the investigation as Italian authorities turn their attention to Pietro Pacciani, Giancarlo Lotti and Mario Vanni—the alleged group infamously known as the “Snack Buddies.” What follows is a maze of questionable evidence, shifting confessions, overturned verdicts and accusations of a secret satanic cult purchasing body parts from the killer.

We also examine the mysterious death of Dr. Francesco Narducci, the arrests of journalist Mario Spezi and author Douglas Preston, the investigation’s surprising...

For 17 years, couples parked in the hills outside Florence, Italy were hunted by a killer who was never definitively identified.Known as the **Monster of Florence**, the killer targeted couples in secluded areas, murdered them with the same .22 caliber pistol, and in several cases mutilated the female victims. Depending on who you ask, the Monster may have been responsible for 14—or 16—murders.But the killings are only part of what makes this case so insane.In Part 1, Jamie and Peter dig into the culture of 1960s–1980s Italy that created the perfect hunting ground for the killer, the strange commun...

We talk Black Cat Kombucha, Halloween Horror Nights, the horror movies that got us hooked, and the childhood legend of the **Bush Narcs** before jumping into some major true crime updates — including the **D4vd case, Bryan Kohberger, and Lindsay Clancy**.Then we bring back **Drunk & Demonic** for some ridiculous drunk stories before diving into horror news and reviews, including **Ice Cream Man, Five Nights at Freddy’s 2, Backrooms, Barbarian, Psycho Killer, Skinamarink**, and what we want to see at Halloween Horror Nights.And somehow we end up discovering that today was apparently the day **Earth was supposed to lose...

What starts as a $2,700 self-improvement seminar eventually becomes one of the most disturbing cult stories in modern history.This week, Jamie and Peter dive into NXIVM — the organization built around Keith Raniere, a self-proclaimed genius who turned self-help seminars and multi-level marketing into a system of manipulation, control, and devotion.We follow Raniere from his early pyramid scheme, through the creation of Executive Success Programs and NXIVM, the arrival of Seagram heiress Clare Bronfman’s money, and the celebrity members who helped give the organization legitimacy.Then things get much darker.We get into Allison Mack, the secret group know...

Jamie and Peter are joined by Nick and Linds Love Horror for a very crowded and chaotic Haunted Happy Hour.The conversation begins with drinks, content creation and the surprisingly welcoming horror community before wandering into Cincinnati cryptids, the Loveland Frogman, Mothman festivals and the strange world of viral TikTok events.Then it is time for horror. The group discusses the movies that first turned them into horror fans, debates Freddy Krueger, Michael Myers and Jason Voorhees, and shares thoughts on the new Jason universe, Dead by Daylight and the future of A Nightmare on Elm Street.They also...

The Evil Dead franchise keeps finding new ways to get bloodier, meaner and completely unhinged.In this episode, Jamie and Peter break down the modern era of the franchise: Evil Dead (2013), Evil Dead Rise and Evil Dead Burn. We compare the Deadites, practical effects, most brutal kills, expanded Necronomicon lore and the endings of all three movies.Which movie has the strongest characters? Which Deadite is the most terrifying? And which modern Evil Dead film deserves the top spot?We also mix up a Dead by Dawn cocktail, discuss the future of the franchise and rank all six Evil...

A semi truck carrying a massive load of bourbon was stolen in Philadelphia—and somehow, that is only the beginning of this episode.Peter and Jamie break down the bizarre bourbon heist, revisit the anniversary of the mysterious Montauk Monster, and discuss recent developments surrounding the Luigi Mangione and d4vd cases.Then, things get strange with a fake Florida lawyer in Drunk or Dumb, the upcoming Sheep Detectives movie, the disturbing Maternal Instincts documentary, and the new teaser for the Friday the 13th prequel series Crystal Lake.They also discuss the possibility of a new Nightmare on Elm St...

The Evil Dead trilogy is one of the weirdest, bloodiest, funniest horror franchises ever made — and somehow it only gets stranger with each movie.In this episode of Horror Whiskey Company, we dig into The Evil Dead, Evil Dead II: Dead by Dawn, and Army of Darkness. We talk Sam Raimi, Bruce Campbell, the infamous cabin, the Necronomicon, the shift from brutal horror to full-blown horror comedy, and why Ash Williams became one of the most iconic characters in the genre.We’re also drinking through the chaos with a rum-fueled cocktail that may or may not taste like chai...

This conversation explores the detrimental effects of social media on mental health, particularly through the lens of the book 'The Sirens Call.' It transitions into a discussion about the Nancy Guthrie case, which has now been classified as a homicide, allowing for more resources to be allocated to the investigation. The conversation culminates in a wild New Year's Eve incident involving a woman who, after being exposed for infidelity, returns to a party with a gun, leading to a shooting and subsequent legal consequences. In this episode, the hosts explore the intersection of Hollywood and crime, discussing how...

This conversation delves into the mysterious disappearances documented in the Missing 411 series, focusing on the work of David Politis. The hosts discuss various cases of individuals who vanished under strange circumstances, the patterns identified by Politis, and the implications of these unexplained events. The case of Dior Kuntz Jr. serves as a focal point, raising questions about the nature of these disappearances and the investigation surrounding them. This conversation delves into the unsettling mysteries surrounding the disappearances of children in national parks and remote areas. The hosts explore several cases, including Dior, Sammy, Jared, Keith, and Stacy, highlighting the...

In this episode of the Horror Whiskey Podcast, hosts Pirate Pete and Jamie engage in a lively discussion that ranges from casual banter about their shirts and drinks to a serious conversation about the influence of media on high-profile criminal trials. They share personal anecdotes, discuss their summer drink preferences, and provide a true crime update regarding a teacher involved in a stabbing incident, exploring the implications of media coverage on the judicial process. In this episode, the hosts delve into the complexities of the legal system as it pertains to true crime cases, discussing recent developments in ongoing...

In this episode, Jamie and Pete explore the enigmatic Bermuda Triangle, discussing its history, famous disappearances, and the infamous USS Cyclops. They delve into the mysterious circumstances surrounding the area, including the strange occurrences reported by Christopher Columbus. The conversation also touches on the drinks they are enjoying, which are thematically linked to the episode's subject matter. This conversation delves into the mysterious disappearances of the USS Cyclops and Flight 19, exploring the red flags leading to their fates, the theories surrounding their vanishings, and the impact of media on the myths of the Bermuda Triangle. The hosts discuss the...

Join us as we delve into the latest true crime updates, including the Alex Murdaugh case, internet sleuths' role in missing persons cases, and a shocking case of a woman facing charges after a dangerous BDSM incident. We explore the complexities of legal proceedings, the influence of online communities, and the importance of understanding the nuances of criminal cases. In this episode, we explore a variety of topics including recent true crime cases, horror series, and the art of storytelling in documentaries. Join us as we dissect the latest in horror entertainment and real-life mysteries, offering insights and recommendations...

In this engaging conversation, Pete and Jamie explore the historical significance and haunting tales of Waverly Hills Sanatorium, while also sharing personal anecdotes and cocktail recipes. The discussion transitions from light-hearted banter about Philadelphia to a deep dive into the eerie history of one of America's most notorious tuberculosis hospitals, blending humor with chilling narratives. This conversation delves into the history and treatment of tuberculosis, particularly focusing on the infamous Waverly Hills Sanatorium. The hosts discuss the evolution of understanding tuberculosis, the historical context of its treatment, and the unconventional methods employed at Waverly Hills, including the chilling practices...

https://linktr.ee/drunkdemonicThis episode features an in-depth discussion on recent true crime cases, conspiracy theories, horror movie reviews, and the latest in horror entertainment. Hosted by Jamie Pete, it offers insights into criminal cases, government secrecy, and horror film analysis.Chapters00:00 Introduction and Welcome02:06 True Crime Update: The Case of Deforvid15:02 Conspiracy Theories and Mysterious Deaths25:00 Government Cover-Ups and Public Trust26:24 The Correspondence Dinner and Its Impact27:11 Distrust in Media and Current Events28:24 A Shocking Crime Story34:52 The Aftermath of a Tragic Incident36:55 Transition to Horror News37:05 Reviewing 'The Mummy' and Its Themes46:20 Exploring 'Dust Bunny' and Its...

This episode explores Colorado's dark history and legends, including vampires, haunted roads, underground spirits, shape-shifting witches, and the haunted Stanley Hotel, revealing the state's long-standing connection to the supernatural and mysterious.Chapters00:00 Introduction and Setup05:11 Exploring Colorado's Dark History09:51 The Legend of the Lafayette Vampire14:56 The Vampire's Grave and Local Folklore20:11 The Vampire Hunt and Community Response38:18 The Legend of T-Dor41:43 Riverdale Road: The Most Haunted Road46:45 The Haunting of Riverdale Road01:04:09 Tommy Knockers: Guardians or Harbingers?01:16:36 Stephen King's Connection to Colorado01:17:02 The Diamond Room and Culinary Delights01:18:48 The Terrifying Nature of the Mountain01:19:54 Understanding the Skinwalker01:21:43 The Nature...

Join us as we delve into recent true crime cases, movie reviews, and horror folklore, all while navigating a very hungover state. We discuss the Long Island serial killer, Matthew Perry's drug case, upcoming horror movies, and share some personal stories and movie recommendations.00:00 Introduction and Hangover Confessions02:09 True Crime Updates: Long Island Killer and Matthew Perry10:29 Legal Details and Confessions of Rex Heuerman20:51 Recent Horror Movie Releases and Reviews36:59 Horror Movie Settings and Special Effects45:39 Bigfoot and the California Mystery50:57 Upcoming Horror Films: Faces of Death, Hocum, The Mummy58:12 Questions from the Crypt: Best Horror Villain for Bar...

https://linktr.ee/drunkdemonicThis episode explores the chilling story of Scott Lee Kimball, an FBI informant turned serial killer, revealing how deception, manipulation, and systemic failures allowed his crimes to go unnoticed for years.Chapters00:00 Introduction to the Case05:50 The FBI's Trust in Kimball11:14 Becoming an Informant17:19 Freedom and New Relationships23:21 The Aftermath of Jennifer's Case29:22 Scott's Deception and Manipulation36:33 The Disappearances Begin42:58 Families Search for Answers50:32 The Pattern Emerges55:32 The Breakthrough01:03:42 Plea Deal and Sentencing#truecrimes #truestory #podcast #crime

summary

Join Party Time Pete as he dives into recent true crime stories, horror movie updates, and personal anecdotes, all with a humorous twist. This episode offers a mix of case analyses, industry insights, and entertainment, perfect for horror and true crime enthusiasts.

Explore the mysterious case of Travis Walton's UFO abduction, the investigation, and the enduring debate over extraterrestrial encounters. This episode delves into the details of the 1975 incident, law enforcement responses, and the cultural impact of UFO lore. Explore the mysterious case of Travis Walton's UFO encounter, the investigation, and its cultural impact. Delve into witness testimonies, scientific debates, and the influence of Hollywood dramatization.

Join us as we delve into the latest horror movies, true crime cases, and pop culture topics, featuring in-depth reviews and lively debates. Perfect for horror fans and true crime enthusiasts alike.#horrormovies, #truecrime, #moviereviews, #screamfranchise, #caseanalysis, #popculture, #horrordiscussion, #movieanalysis, #podcastChapters00:00 Introduction to Hockey and Family Life02:19 Transitioning to Podcasting and Drinks05:02 Discussing True Crime Updates10:09 The Lindsay Clancy Case: A Tragic Story15:50 Debating Mental Health and Responsibility19:02 The Ghost Arrest Incident: A Lighthearted Tale23:36 Franchise Reflections: Scream Series Evaluation26:20 Character Dynamics and Shifts in Scream28:56 Legacy Characters and Future of the Franchise32:17 Reveals and Plot Twists: A Critical...

In this episode, Jamie and Pete interview horror writer Eric Miller, exploring his motivations, writing process, and insights into the horror genre. They also discuss their favorite horror movies, documentaries, and the impact of setting in horror stories.In this engaging interview, horror and science fiction writer Eric Miller shares insights into his creative process, influences, and the fascinating world of horror, paranormal phenomena, and filmmaking. Discover how his passion for the strange and unknown shapes his stories and the industry.

summary

This episode explores the evolution of the Scream franchise from the original Wes Craven classics to the modern reboots and sequels. Hosts analyze themes, character development, and the franchise's commentary on horror culture, internet obsession, and legacy characters. In this in-depth discussion, Pete and Jamie analyze the latest Scream movies, exploring themes, character development, and franchise evolution. They compare Scream 5 and 6, predict future plotlines, and share their favorite kills and franchise rankings.

Summary

In this episode, the hosts discuss various topics ranging from their drinking habits to true crime updates, including the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie and conspiracy theories surrounding Jeffrey Epstein. They explore the implications of power dynamics in high-profile cases and delve into the complexities of public perception regarding celebrities like Michael Jackson. The conversation is lively and filled with humor, while also addressing serious issues in the true crime genre. In this engaging conversation, the hosts review a recent horror movie, discussing its emotional impact and tension. They share their experiences with modern...

In this episode of Horror Whiskey Company, hosts Jamie and Practical Pete discuss the Scream trilogy, focusing on the first three films. They explore the horror genre's landscape, the significance of self-awareness in the Scream movies, and the character dynamics, particularly the motivations behind Ghostface. The conversation also touches on the cultural impact of the franchise and the evolution of horror films. In this conversation, Jamie and Practical Pete delve into the nuances of the Scream franchise, comparing it to Halloween, discussing the challenges of sequels, and exploring character development. They highlight the...

Two young women. One historic mansion. A mystery that refuses to rest.In this episode, we dive into the unsolved murders of Kara and Marianne, two young women whose tragic deaths in the 1970s still haunt investigators, historians, and true-crime followers decades later.We explore the dark history surrounding the Lumber Baron Inn, the investigative challenges of the time, and the theories that have emerged as the case slipped further into cold-case territory. From missed opportunities and societal blind spots to the lingering questions that never received answers, this case highlights how justice can fade—but never fully disappear.We...

When real life feels scarier than the movies… you know it’s a wild episode.

In this episode of Horror Whiskey Company, we dive into the stories that blur the line between true crime and horror. From unsettling real-world cases — including a recently reopened investigation — to the latest horror films like Bone Lake and 28 Years Later, we break down why reality often feels more terrifying than fiction.

We also discuss:
🩸 The true crime cases that still don’t make sense
🎥 Upcoming horror movies we’re excited (and nervous) about
📺 How horror is evolving on streaming plat...

In this episode, the hosts delve into the eerie true crime story of the Watcher, a case that revolves around the Broadus family who received unsettling letters from an anonymous figure known as the Watcher after purchasing their new home. The conversation explores the psychological impact of fear, the community's response, and the ongoing mystery surrounding the identity of the Watcher. In this gripping conversation, the hosts delve into the chilling mystery of 'The Watcher,' a case involving a family who received threatening letters from an unknown individual after moving into their new home. The discussion explores various...

Summary

In this episode, the hosts discuss their personal experiences with alcohol, including the challenges of Dry January. They transition into a disturbing kidnapping story involving a young woman and her mother, who orchestrated the kidnapping to prevent her from communicating with an online predator. The conversation shifts to the legal implications of the case and the shortcomings of the justice system. The episode concludes with a shocking story about a grave robber, Jonathan Garlic, who was caught with human remains, leading to a discussion about the bizarre nature of his crimes and the...

Summary

In this engaging podcast episode, hosts Punctual Pete and Jamie reflect on the year 2025 in horror cinema, sharing their top 10 horror movie picks. They discuss the unique aspects of each film, from the heartwarming yet chilling 'Good Boy' to the graphic body horror of 'The Ugly Stepsister', and the campy slasher fun of 'The Monkey'. The conversation is filled with humor, insights, and a deep appreciation for the horror genre, making it a must-listen for fans. In this conversation, Punctual Pete and Jamie delve into various horror films, discussing unexpected plot twists, the...

Summary

In this conversation, the hosts delve into the Montauk Project, exploring its origins, the experiments conducted, and the emergence of Duncan Cameron's abilities. They discuss the escalating nature of the experiments, the physical anomalies observed, and the introduction of Al Beelick, linking the Montauk Project to the Philadelphia Experiment. The conversation is filled with humor and insights into the bizarre world of government conspiracies and psychic phenomena. This conversation delves into the Philadelphia Experiment and its alleged connection to the Montauk Project, exploring themes of time travel, government experiments, and the psychological manipulation...

Summary

In this episode, Jamie and Pete explore various themes ranging from personal updates to true crime discussions. They delve into the Gilgo Beach serial killer case, the Brian Walsh trial, and a disturbing story about a retired teacher turned Santa Claus facing serious charges. The conversation also touches on the latest horror news and reviews of a popular horror show, highlighting character development and impressive CGI. In this conversation, the hosts delve into various themes surrounding the series 'Stranger Things' and its connections to Stephen King's lore, particularly focusing on the character development...

Summary

In this episode, Jamie and Perfect Pete dive into the intriguing world of the Montauk Project, exploring its connections to the popular series Stranger Things. They engage in light-hearted banter about drinks and themed events, before delving into the conspiracy theories surrounding the Montauk Project and its alleged experiments. The conversation flows seamlessly from personal anecdotes to broader discussions about pop culture and the impact of streaming on viewership. In this episode, the hosts delve into the intriguing history of Camp Hero, a Cold War relic located at Montauk Point. They discuss the...

In this episode of Horror Whiskey Company, hosts Perfect Pete and Jamie dive into a variety of topics ranging from nostalgic reflections on the COVID era to true crime updates, including the case of Rex Heuerman and the tragic story of Celeste Rivas Hernandez. They also discuss a recent Bigfoot sighting and explore the themes of love and acceptance in the new Netflix adaptation of Frankenstein. The conversation is filled with humor, insights, and a deep appreciation for horror and true crime. In this engaging conversation, the hosts delve into the cinematic experience...

In this episode of Horror Whiskey Company, Jamie and PARTY HARD Pete delve into the haunting tale of Screaming Jenny, an urban legend from Harper's Ferry, West Virginia. The story explores themes of grief, folklore, and the significance of ghost stories in understanding human emotions. As they share the chilling narrative of Jenny's tragic fate, they also discuss the broader implications of ghost stories and their role in preserving cultural memories. In this conversation, Jamie and PARTY HARD Pete delve into the eerie and captivating world of true crime and folklore, particularly focusing on the haunting stories surrounding Austin...

Summary

In this conversation, the hosts delve into the controversial role of true crime influencers and the ethical implications of their influence on young audiences. They discuss the responsibility that comes with fame in the true crime genre and the potential consequences of glorifying violence.