Broadway Unexpected : Chronicles of their journey

40 Episodes
Subscribe

By: Maya Callaghan

A historical review of everything on Broadway that nobody saw coming.  We explore the unforeseen trials and tribulations of a Broadway production and what happened along their way to curtains up!

✂️ Clip this podcast
Exploring the Heart of Theater with Kermit MaFrog
#37
Yesterday at 7:00 PM

In my chat with Kermit MaFrog, we talk musical theatre, Muppets, and why he makes these videos: to help someone smile and make the world a little gentler, a little kinder. Because stories and songs can bring people together—and there’s room for all of us onstage.


Nerine Skinner: From Ballet Dreams to Comedy Stages
#36
Last Tuesday at 11:00 PM

What if not having it all figured out is part of the show? 

Actor and comedian Nerine Skinner joins Broadway Unexpected to talk about her unconventional route into performing—from ballet and musical theatre to comedy, political satire, and creating Decisions Decisions.

She opens up about the pressure to be perfect and the freedom that came from treating her show as a work in progress. Trying things, changing what didn’t land, and letting the audience bring their own energy made room for the unexpected—and, sometimes, the funniest moments.

Her reminder for anyone...


Harry F. Brown's journey from Let it Shine to The Band
#35
11/08/2026

One missed lyric. One big regret. A career that kept unfolding.

In this interview, we sat down with songwriter and actor Harry F. Brown who shares how a childhood moment in a school production of We Will Rock You made him realize he wanted to be onstage. Years later, an audition on a whim led to Let It Shine—and a path into musicals, touring, and the West End.

The journey wasn’t perfectly mapped out. Harry talks candidly about imposter syndrome, learning the ropes on the job, and finding his own route without drama scho...


From Musical Theater to Stand-Up: Dylan Adler's Journey
#34
11/06/2026

The algorithm may help you get noticed. But the room is where the magic happens. 

In this episode, we talk with comedian and performer Dylan Adler about the winding path from seeing Wicked with his mom to pursuing comedy—and the strange balancing act of building a career online while missing the energy of being in person.

For Dylan, social media can open doors, but it doesn’t replace the work: sharpening your craft, collaborating, and letting the audience change the moment. That same live-wire energy carries into his new parody-musical role, where camp and comed...


Jared Goldsmith's journey from Dear Evan Hansen to creating original works
#33
11/04/2026

A theater camp turned a hobby into a lifestyle. 

Jared Goldsmith (Jared in Dear Evan Hansen on Broadway and the first national tour, and nearly a million TikTok followers for his theater satire) joins us today. 

Jared's story shows that community can matter as much as talent. At camp he met other kids who loved this too, and he says many of those friendships have lasted. The fast, professional pace of a three-week camp show also prepared him for summer stock, college and the pace of the real industry. A new Broadway show might have fo...


Matt Juniosa's journey from Idol to Got Talent to Jesus Christ Superstar
#32
11/04/2026

"If you can't say it, you have to sing it." 

On this episode, we sit down with Matty Juniosa. He went from Idol Philippines and a boy group to finishing fourth on Britain's Got Talent, and now plays alternate Judas and Annas in Jesus Christ Superstar at the London Palladium. The show is transferring to Drury Lane.

Matty calls himself a former "pop girly." He says pop leans toward entertainment and spectacle, while musical theatre is story-based and about human experience. His turning point was watching Cynthia Erivo perform The Color Purple at the Tonys. F...


The journey of Andrew Fox as he introduces the world to Slam Frank
#31
11/01/2026

"A play is a dream or a nightmare that you have that now you get other people to pay you to see."  

That is a great line that Andrew Fox shared with us as we sat down with him to talk about Slam Frank, a new off-Broadway show that he composed.

His idea of what art is for: to "break your brain a little" so you have to put the puzzle back together is just one of the amazing topics that we discussed in depth.


Matthew Harvey's journey from detention to the West End
#30
11/01/2026

He got a detention, and it changed his whole life. 

In this interview, we sit down with actor, composer and musician Matthew Harvey. He's the Jesus standby in Jesus Christ Superstar on the West End, a composer on season one of SNL UK, and the creator of Musical Theatre House Party.


From Fight Choreographer to Solo Performer: Chloe Baldwin's wild journey
#29
10/30/2026

"I never feel more alive than when I'm in a show."

That's a quote from Chloe Baldwin when we sat down with her.  She's an actress, filmmaker and fight choreographer. She's performed at theaters across the country and toured The Woman in Black. Now she's bringing her solo Renaissance Fair show to audiences.

Chloe is our first fight choreographer on the show so we do a deep dive into understanding all of the aspects of how that role fits into the production.


Ross Baum's journey to WANTED
#28
10/27/2026

Two outlaw sisters. One family legend. A Broadway musical that almost started as a joke.

Ross Baum, the composer of Wanted shares how a freezing Syracuse winter, a Disney Cruise Line contract and one surprise email led to a new original Western musical.

The message at the heart of the show: embrace all of who you are, and don't hide.  You will learn how the show's big song changed over time through the creative process.

New and original stories are essential to the evolution of the industry and WANTED is the perfect example o...


BALLS: The Monster-Catchin' Musical with Stuart Zagnit
#27
10/26/2026

Stuart Zagnit thought musicals were just people singing. Then one musical changed everything for him.  Today, we sit down with Stuart to discuss his latest project, BALLS: The Monster-Catchin' Musical.

Stuart started in theater, then anime opened up a whole new world—and now he gets to bring both together in ways he never expected.

The best part? Staying curious enough to say yes before you feel ready. You might discover a side of yourself you didn’t know was there.


BALLS: The Monster-Catchin' Musical with Harrison Bryan
#26
10/26/2026

Harrison Bryan said it best - theater gets way more interesting when you stop picking one lane.  Today, we are sitting down with him to discuss his latest project, BALLS: The Monster-Catchin' Musical.

Harrison Bryan is proof that acting, writing, puppeteering, and producing don’t cancel each other out - they make the work bigger, weirder, and way more alive.

What I loved most was this:
multi-hyphenate artists aren’t unfocused - they’re usually building the future before everyone else catches up. The best creative rooms make space for multiple skills, not just one nea...


Hannah LeBeau's journey through dance
#25
10/24/2026

Hannah LeBeau became a therapist after a life that looked like pure performance - NFL cheerleader, theater kid, perfectionist, stutter and all.
Watch this interview if you’ve ever felt like your “extra” parts were a problem.

They might be the reason you’re good at what you do.
Hannah said dance didn’t just teach her how to move - it taught her how to adapt, problem solve, and keep going when life gets messy.
And honestly? That hit.
Because sometimes the thing you thought made you “too much” is actually what makes you resi


Q Lim's journey from South Korea to Broadway
#24
10/23/2026

Q Lim was told she didn’t belong in the room—and that rejection changed everything.

If you’ve ever been told you’re “not enough,” watch this interview and send it to someone who needs the reminder. Q Lim went from being called tone-deaf and kicked out of a class to performing on Broadway and coaching the next generation.

What hit me most:
Her mom took her to theater because she never got to chase art herself.
She started ballet at 3, pointe at 7 or 8, then had to rebuild after injury.
One brutal “you...


Charlotte Hanna-William's journey from the Middle East to the West End
#22
10/21/2026

Charlotte Hanna-Williams said the most relatable thing about getting into theater: it was never one big moment. It was just tiny yeses that kept adding up.

Have you ever had a slow-burn path to something you love? In this conversation, Charlotte talks about growing up in the Middle East and slowly finding her way into musical theater.

She discusses how one real acting teacher changed everything by treating her like an adult.  Why her foundation year at Mountview was scary, risky, and still one of the best decisions she made.  That part about learning before au...


From architecture to MJ: Bryson Jacobi Kai's broadway journey
#23
10/21/2026

Bryson Jacobi Kai thought he was going to be an architect.  All he could think about was building structures for anyone who would listen to him but one middle school role changed everything.  The first time people reacted to him, he knew he wanted the feeling again.

What I love most in this conversation, he's not chasing applause now, he's chasing proof.

Proof to himself.

Proof that the risk was worth it.

Proof that the “weird route” can still lead somewhere beautiful.
And honestly? His whole story feels like a remind...


Buna McCreery-Njie's journey from roller hockey to Hamilton
#20
10/18/2026

We had a great conversation with Buna McCreery-Njie.  He was not a sports kid - unless you count roller hockey, and gymnastics.

What actually made him stick with theatre was getting handed a sheet of colleges at 12 and realizing - oh, this can be a real career.
Before that, He just knew he loved performing.

It felt like a safe space when life at school was messy, and that mattered more than being “good” at sports.

Honestly, the biggest shift was when someone finally showed him the route in.  Sometimes that’s all it t...


Timothy H. Lee's theater journey from South Korea to Broadway
#21
10/18/2026

Timothy H. Lee said the thing a lot of us need to hear:
Your joy cannot depend on booking, applause, or being “enough.” If other people can take it away, it was never fully yours.

He talked about coming to theater as a survival space, not a spotlight chase—and honestly, that changes everything. When joy comes from your craft, your people, and being better than yesterday, it gets harder for the world to steal it.

That line about casting loving people with joy? Worth saving if you need a reminder before your next auditi...


The skill of humor on stage with Martin Callaghan
#18
10/16/2026

In this conversation with Martin Callaghan, a renowned actor whose career spans more than 30 years on the stage, he said something very interesting to me.  Theatre should mean something, not just be a gimmick. When a revival like Glengarry Glen Ross flips the casting, it can change the meaning of the whole thing.

That’s the difference: a casting choice that makes you think—or one that only makes money.

He also called Shakespeare what it really is: filthy, funny, and far more human than people sometimes give it credit for.
That kind of hones...


Lucy Ireland's journey of balancing acting and content creation
#19
10/16/2026

She sang the wrong song for drama school and still got in.  This is your reminder that “perfect” is not the point.

Lucy Ireland opens up about applying to GSA thinking the worst that could happen was a no.

What changed everything wasn’t a flawless rep list or trying to look “right” for the room.  It was showing up, being honest, and proving she had potential.

That’s the bit people forget.

Drama schools are not just looking for polish—they’re looking for you.
The voice, the story, the spark, the thi...


From the Bronx to Wendy, Hawa Kamara's Broadway journey
#17
10/14/2026

Hawa Kamara just said the thing most actors are thinking but don’t say out loud: comedy is all about the shock factor.

She broke down why the funniest moments usually come from contrast—expecting one thing, getting the complete opposite.
And honestly? That’s why her take on physical comedy hits so hard.

A classic fall or trip works because the body goes one way and the moment flips fast. Playing calm in a chaotic scene makes the chaos even funnier.  Sometimes the best joke is just truth told in the most unexpected way.


Melissa Cabey's global journey with A Chorus Line
#16
10/13/2026

She didn’t even know Broadway existed until she was 12 - then one YouTube video changed everything.

Do you love a full-circle theater story like that?  If so, you're in for a treat with this conversation with Melissa Cabey.  She said Idina Menzel's Defying Gravity was her gateway into the industry.  

Then came Rent.

Then voice lessons.

Then acting lessons.

Then a whole life built around the stage.

What I love most is that her path wasn’t “perfect” - it was obsessed, determined, and real.
And honestl...


The finesse of being a vocal coach with Hannah Bayles
#15
10/11/2026

In this interview, Hannah Bayles talked about how how she didn’t need a degree to become a better teacher—she needed the right way to learn.  Have you ever felt more seen by hands-on learning than lectures?

For years, she thought the answer was more school, more rules, more proving herself.  But the real shift happened when she found a teacher who was kind, technical, and actually made her voice feel safer to use.

That changed everything.  She stopped chasing "perfect" and started understanding what her voice was doing.  She realized safety matters just as much...


Understanding vocal technique with Christina Licatalosi
#14
10/11/2026

The biggest lie in singing?  That you’re either “a singer” or you’re not.
Has anyone ever made you believe that?

Christina Licatalosi said the thing so many performers need to hear - most people are not tone deaf, they just need the right tools, the right coaching, and a little patience.  And honestly, that changes everything.
Good teaching should make you feel safe enough to try. Technique matters, but confidence changes the sound too.

The goal is not to sound like someone else - it’s to sound like you.
That’s why I...


Moving from Australia to Broadway, Daniel Assetta's journey
#13
10/09/2026

Daniel Assetta moved from Australia to Broadway — and said the hardest part wasn’t the dance calls, it was starting over in a city where nobody knew his work.

Daniel talked about what it really feels like to build a career from scratch in New York after already being established back home.  The industry is way bigger in the U.S., but that also means more ways to get lost in it.

His first Broadway audition was West Side Story, and it felt like the start of a whole new life. & Juliet became the perfect fit b...


The journey to the creation of SIX with Lucy Moss
#12
10/09/2026

It was fascinating to listen to Lucy Moss and her journey to co-creating Six.  She explores how the hardest thing isn't writing songs but it's making stories that actually work. Have you ever loved a show, movie, or book and couldn’t explain why it landed so hard?

What I loved about this interview:
Big ideas only work when the characters’ choices keep colliding in the right order.  Autobiography is useful, but it’s not the same thing as a story. Sometimes the “simple” version of a thing is secretly the most difficult to build.


Broadway through the eyes of a historian: Jennifer Tepper's Journey
#10
10/06/2026

“Theater is timing, alchemy, and a million things you can’t predict.”

That line hit me hard.  Jennifer Tepper breaks down why Merrily We Roll Along and Chess hit differently when they came back—and why star casting is only one piece of the puzzle.

What really makes a show land?

The right book revision
The right director
The right moment in culture
And sometimes, just the right audience

That’s the part people miss. A show isn’t only about how it did the first time around.

It’s...


The Secret Circus comes to town with Chanel Samson
#11
10/06/2026

Failure is beautiful.

That’s the whole Secret Circus philosophy—and honestly, it changed the way I think about performing, creating, and even living.

Have you ever had a “messy” moment turn into the best part?

Chanel Samson said something that stuck with me:
On stage, failure isn’t the end—it’s where the real magic shows up.
If the audience feels safe, they stop protecting you and start playing with you. Kids get this instantly. Adults just need a reminder.
That’s why Secret Circus works—it’s not trying to be per...


Exploring all aspects of theater touring with Clair Rachel Howell
#9
10/04/2026

"I thought a Broadway credit would make the hustle easier. It didn’t."

if you’ve ever thought the next milestone would finally make things feel “stable.”, Clair Rachel Howell said it best - even after booking Wicked, the grind never really stops.

Swing life means you’re always learning, adjusting, and making peace with imperfection.  Self-tapes are brutal when you’re a perfectionist and can hear every tiny thing back. The real win isn’t “having it figured out” - it’s staying ready when the call comes.

And honestly? That’s such a real reminder fo...


Theater marketing: Insights from Arthur Jones
#8
10/04/2026

Welcome to this week’s edition of Broadway Unexpected, where we dive into the fascinating world of theater marketing with Arthur Jones, head of marketing at the Royal Shakespeare Company. Arthur shares his journey from a childhood filled with theater magic to navigating the complexities of marketing in this vibrant industry.


Introducing Ayla, A New Musical
#6
10/02/2026

In this heartfelt conversation, we delve into the creative processes of composer Gianluca Cucchiara and choreographer Eleesha Drennan, who are collaborating on the new musical "Ayla". They share personal stories that illuminate their paths into the world of theater, highlighting the impact of music and family on their artistic journeys.

Ayla is a new musical that Gianluca, Eleesha and Academy Award winning producer Giovanna Romagnoli are ready to take the next step and present it to the world.  Yesterday, they announced a one-night only concert at The Other Palace in London on November 30th.  Among those scheduled to...


Creating complex songs that are viewed as "simple" with Tobi LaCroix
#7
10/02/2026

Tobi LaCroix, a remarkable young talent in the world of pop music, joins us this week to share his journey into songwriting and composition. Starting at the tender age of four, Tobi has quickly risen in the indie pop scene, captivating audiences with relatable lyrics and catchy melodies.

Pop music is not brain dead.

Tobi LaCroix said the quiet part out loud: simple is harder than complex, and derivative doesn’t mean lazy.

Have you ever loved a song because it just hits. Save this for the next time someone acts like pop is...


Douglas Waterbury-Tieman introduces New Musical Theater Nashville
#5
09/29/2026

Douglas Waterbury-Tieman said something I can’t stop thinking about:
He busked in New York and got his next big connection because he showed up with a fiddle and no plan.

He didn’t “start” New Musical Theater Nashville by waiting for permission — he built the room first.

The work grows when the community does. That’s the part people miss.

Talent matters, but consistency and connection move things forward.
If you’re building anything creative, this is your sign to keep showing up.


Jake Pedersen's journey from Pittsburgh to Broadway
#4
09/29/2026

Jake Pedersen knows the highs of Broadway—and the uncertainty between gigs.

After Parade, Wicked, and Ragtime, Jake still had moments of wondering, “Is this gonna be for me?” In our conversation, he opens up about the auditions, the in-between periods, and what keeps drawing him back to the stage.

Because an acting career isn’t only the spotlight. It’s also the waiting, the uncertainty, and choosing to keep going because you love the work.


The art of writing lyrics for musicals with Rebekah Greer Melocik
#3
09/28/2026

In this episode, we sit down with Rebekah Greer Melocik, a talented composer, librettist, and lyricist known for her work on the Broadway musical "How to Dance in Ohio". Rebekah shares her journey into musical theater, revealing the pivotal moments that shaped her career and her passion for lyric writing.

In today's conversation, Rebekah shares about her latest project, "It Comes With The Building", an original musical with music by Jacob Yandura and book by Harrison David Rivers.


The Journey of Jodie Steele: From Basingstoke to the West End
#2
09/28/2026

Jodie Steele, a West End star, shares her transformative journey from Basingstoke to the bright lights of theatre.  Jodie reflects on the moment that ignited her passion for acting—a trip to see Wicked at 17, thanks to her mother's sacrifice. "I just remember thinking, wow, this is the best thing ever... seven years down the line, I would have been doing my Elphaba dress fitting," she recalls. Her journey into musicals wasn’t immediate; instead, her teenage years were filled with challenges, including bullying and a rough upbringing.

Jodie is well-known for her role as Heather Chandler in th...


Exploring songwriting and Les Misérables with Jess Folley
#1
09/27/2026

In the first episode of season 3 of Broadway Unexpected, we sit down with Jess Folley, a talented actress and songwriter currently featured in "Les Misérables" on the West End. Jess shares her journey into the world of theatre, revealing how her passion for performance began at a tender age and how songwriting became her voice in moments of emotional depth.

Before joining the cast of Les Mis, Jess won the first series of The Voice Kids UK.  With her band, RLY, they won X-Factor: The Band.  She ultimately combined all of that experience to compose and sta...


From Manchester to the West End: Astrid Harris' Journey as Celine Dion
#107
09/26/2026

Discover how Astrid Harris' early experiences in a musical family shaped her career in theatre. Learn about her journey, passion for accents, and insights on performing arts.

As a child, Astrid Harris was surrounded by creativity and the performing arts. Growing up in a family steeped in music and visual arts, she found her passion early on. In this interview, we’ll explore Astrid’s journey into theatre, her love for accents, and what aspiring performers can learn from her experiences.

You can catch her playing Céline Dion in Titanique at the Criterion Theatre in Lo...


Inside Jennifer Glatzhofer's Musical Journey and Songwriting
#106
09/22/2026

Discover insights from actress Jennifer Glatzhofer on her journey in musical theatre. Learn about influences, experiences, and the unique aspects of both American and British theatre.

As a passionate advocate for the arts, I had the pleasure of sitting down with actress, singer, and songwriter Jennifer Glatzhofer. Throughout our conversation, we explored her journey into the world of musical theatre, her inspirations, and the cultural nuances between American and British theatre. In this interview, I’ll share key insights from our discussion that aspiring performers and theatre enthusiasts will find valuable.

Jennifer Glatzhofer is an ac...


From the Fringe to West-End: Allie Dart-Munro's incredible journey
#105
09/22/2026

Discover the inspiring journey of actress Allie Dart-Munro from her childhood passion for theater to her success in West End productions. Learn about her experiences and insights into acting.

In this interview we delve into the fascinating journey of Allie Dart-Munro, a talented actress who has made a name for herself in the competitive world of theater. From her early dramatic performances as a child to her notable roles on the West End, Allie shares her experiences, challenges, and the joy she finds in acting.

You can currently see her in The Comedy about Spies...