The Infamous Ex-Chief

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, host Scott Gardner reviews public records obtained from multiple Medina County, Ohio agencies concerning outside agency access to Flock Safety automated license plate reader systems. The central question posed to each agency was who approves an outside agency’s access, whether that approval is documented in writing, and whether the approval is ever reviewed.

Records discussed include agency license plate reader policies, Flock sharing lists, event logs, network audit reports, a user search log, a vendor contract, and written correspondence from agency personnel and counsel. The episode also op...

Send us Fan Mail

Send us Fan Mail

In this first episode of the series on Flock Safety automated license plate reader cameras, the host explains that he asked the East Cleveland city council to fund the technology while serving in law enforcement, and then reviews public records from Ohio law enforcement agencies concerning how officers' searches of the system are documented and audited.

The host notes that, in the contracts he has reviewed, data from the cameras is retained for thirty days, and states his opinion that this level of retention is overreach. He also references a reported...

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, Gregg Owen, a former Cook County homicide prosecutor and author of Convergence, discusses a 1976 double murder prosecution and the events surrounding it, as he recounts them. Owen describes an initial courtroom assignment he characterizes as irregular, a period during which physical evidence went missing from a Cook County Sheriff's Office inventory space, and an incident in which he says he was offered cash to alter the substance of his closing argument. These accounts reflect Owen's personal recollection of events from the late 1970s and early 1980s and have not been...

Send us Fan Mail

On September 3, 2026, Scott Gardner extended a settlement offer to the Village of Mantua in his pending mandamus action, which raises a question of first impression under Ohio law: whether an independent, multi-platform investigative journalist qualifies for the public records requester exception set out in Revised Code 149.43(B)(9)(c). The offer proposed to waive statutory damages, stipulate to undisputed facts, and allow the Eleventh District Court of Appeals to rule directly on the underlying legal question, without discovery or extended motion practice.

According to Gardner, counsel for the Village, Matt Markling, did...

Send us Fan Mail

Five episodes into the Rocky River investigation, this installment examines the special prosecutor's own investigative memoranda, obtained directly and reviewed in full for the first time on this platform.

The memoranda, addressed to Rocky River Law Director Michael O'Shea and dated August 17 and September 22, 2023, contain a legal analysis under six Ohio statutes: sexual battery (R.C. 2907.03), unlawful sexual conduct with a minor, gross sexual imposition, sexual imposition, importuning, and dereliction of duty. This episode focuses on the sexual battery analysis under R.C. 2907.03(A)(7), which addresses conduct by a person in...

Send us Fan Mail

One hundred twenty-seven days after a shooting at Valley Forge High School, Parma City School District still has not produced basic records about what happened before, during, and after that day. That case is now in mediation in the Ohio Court of Claims, four months after the original public records request was filed.

This episode is a comprehensive status update on every active public records fight currently underway, and a pattern emerges across all of them. Not one agency is contesting the substance of the request. Every one is arguing procedure...

Send us Fan Mail

A listener asked the question I get more than any other: does any of this reporting actually lead anywhere, or is it just content? So I answered it directly, using the Creston, Ohio fiscal officer case as the example.

Here's what's confirmed on the record. The Village of Creston has never given a public explanation for why their fiscal officer was disciplined or why she ultimately left. What exists is a written warning, a hearing process that raised real statutory questions, and a personnel file with a documented chain of custody...

Send us Fan Mail

A whistleblower complaint to the FAA. A membership revoked over a phone call. Five years of self-represented litigation, a $45,000 sanctions order, and now a petition to the United States Supreme Court built partly on an allegation that a court transcript was altered. Scott Gardner sits down with the man known online as "Chardon Pro Se" to walk through the entire paper trail, the USPA governance manual, the board meeting minutes, and the moment a magistrate allegedly said on the record that the court believed there was fraud in his case, right before ruling...

Send us Fan Mail

Jeffrey Deskovic was 16 years old when police put him through a six to seven hour polygraph session with no attorney and no parent in the room. The man running that session later testified in court, under oath, that his method had a name: GTC. Get The Confession.

The DNA from the crime scene excluded him. The hair comparison excluded him. The jury convicted him anyway, and Deskovic spent the next 16 years in prison for a crime he didn't commit.

In this episode, Deskovic walks through exactly how a wrongful...

Send us Fan Mail

Five episodes. One case. A question nobody in authority has answered.

In the finale of "The Worst Kept Secret in Rocky River," we trace what happened after former Rocky River police officer Michael Bernhardt's indictment — the third victim's attorney who called BCI the day the indictment dropped, the collapse from six warrants alleging rape and kidnapping down to three database misdemeanors, the sentencing where a judge told Bernhardt "you were basically living two lives," and the judicial release granted after less than 30 days served.

We go inside the BCI in...

Send us Fan Mail

She came forward on her own. Saw the news coverage, recognized what had happened to her, and made the call. What happened next is what this episode is about.

Case 2023-2700 is the second victim's case. A graduating senior at Rocky River High School. Michael Bernhardt was her SRO during her senior year. When BCI investigators asked him about his Snapchat username, he gave them ponch6514. The warrant return for this case documents a different account called Bernie that he never mentioned. In that same interview, he acknowledged managing that account...

Send us Fan Mail

Garrettsville PD billed me $225 for body camera footage. Their own 
CAD records show approximately 57 minutes of combined on-scene time 
across both incidents. Ohio Revised Code 149.43(B)(1) caps body 
camera fees at $75 per hour of video produced — not per hour of 
labor, not per hour of staff time. Per hour of video produced. At 
that rate, 57 minutes of footage has a maximum lawful fee of about 
$71.25. I was charged $225.

Before anything else: the officers who worked these calls did their 
jobs right. A noise complaint resolved...

Send us Fan Mail

Episode 3 of The Worst-Kept Secret, an ongoing investigation into Rocky River Police Department SRO Michael Bernhardt, covers what the department knew, when they knew it, and what everyone around Bernhardt did or failed to do with that information.

Bernhardt's second wife, a 30-year special education coordinator at Rocky River High School, describes going to the superintendent in person to report her husband. The official administrative leave letter signed by Chief Lichtman described her as an anonymous faculty member. She then drove to special prosecutor Michael Maloney's law office in Westlake with...

Send us Fan Mail

Episode 2 of The Worst-Kept Secret in Rocky River.

In June of 2024, the first victim's best friend sat down with BCI Special Agents Heather Karl and Stacy Pfeiffer at the Richfield Field Office. She had known the first victim since eighth grade. Twenty years later, she remembered every detail.

This episode is built from her recorded BCI statement, the first victim's own account, and the investigative file. What you hear is not commentary. It is documented.

Michael Bernhardt was the school resource officer at Rocky River High School...

Send us Fan Mail

Every legacy media outlet in Cleveland ran the press releases, aired the clips, and moved on. Nobody read the appellate record. Nobody stayed with the story. I did.

On May 2, 2025, I identified the exact legal problem that 7 judges on the Ohio Court of Appeals Eighth District just confirmed this morning was serious enough to stop everything and examine. Today, July 6, 2026, the full court granted en banc review in State v. McInnes — meaning the question of whether the burden of proof was on the wrong party in Ian McInnes's trial is now be...

Send us Fan Mail

They closed this case and called it "likely" self-infliction. But here's what the actual file says. 🔍

Bryon Macron was a Lafayette Township trustee in Medina County, Ohio. He was also a trained FAST Marine. On December 16, 2016, he texted a business contact at 12:36 AM to say he'd be there the next morning. Seventy-four minutes later, a vehicle matching his pulls into the township lot in the dark. He was never seen alive again. His cause of death is officially undetermined to this day.

I went through the file. Not the hea...

Send us Fan Mail

Six search warrants. Four agencies. One outcome nobody can explain on the record. 🔍

Michael Bernhardt was a Rocky River police officer for 29 years. For the last 12, he was the school resource officer with a badge, keys to every building in the district, and daily unsupervised access to students. He also spent 16 years on the Internet Crimes Against Children task force, where he posed as a 12-year-old girl to catch predators online.

On January 18th, 2024, BCI Special Agent Heather Karl obtained six search warrants in a single day, one for eve...

Send us Fan Mail

A progressive blogger named D.J. Byrnes, who runs the newsletter The Rooster, was sitting in a public hearing at the Ohio Statehouse when the State Highway Patrol walked up and arrested him. The charge was a first-degree misdemeanor for telecommunications harassment. The conduct behind it was an AI cartoon of Shrek and two text messages sent to State Senator Jerry Cirino, a Lake County Republican Byrnes has mocked in print for years.

The warrant came from Kirtland, up in Lake County, about 200 miles from where Byrnes was arrested in Franklin...

Send us Fan Mail

Christine Russo AKA the Big Sister: Unhinged has stayed quiet for four years. Not anymore. 🔍

On July 31st, 2022, her younger brother Dominic Russo and his friend Davion Flanagan died when Mackenzie Shirilla drove a Toyota Camry into a brick wall at nearly 100 miles an hour. A judge later found Shirilla guilty of murder. Two counts. 15 years to life. Then Netflix released The Crash, and the family realized the public was being shown a version of this story that left out the people who actually knew Dom.

In this interview, The...

Send us Fan Mail

Government Won't Release Records? Here's Why "Ongoing Investigation" is ILLEGAL

When you request public records, government agencies love hiding behind "ongoing investigation." But that's not how the law works.

In this video, I break down:
✓ What Ohio law ACTUALLY says about investigations
✓ Why agencies use this as a blanket excuse
✓ Real examples (Village of Hyrum, Valley Forge)
✓ How the Ohio Supreme Court already ruled on this
✓ What you can actually do about it

This isn't legal advice (I'm not a lawyer), but it's the l...

Send us Fan Mail

Bryan Malinowski ran the Little Rock Airport, had no criminal record, and sold coins and guns at weekend gun shows as a hobby. He never got a warning. Never got a letter. The ATF showed up at 6AM with 10 vehicles, breached his front door in 28 seconds, and shot him in the head.

Two years later, not one agent has faced any consequence. No press conference. No report. Nothing.

Attorney and former U.S. Attorney Bud Cummins represents the Malinowski family. He breaks down exactly what happened that morning — the ta...

Send us Fan Mail

I released a detailed investigative breakdown of the Parma Heights Police Department's incident report from April 20, 2026. This video covers critical details that haven't been widely reported, and I'm correcting a mistake I made early in my coverage.

CORRECTION: I repeatedly mispronounced Officer Christopher D. Rossman's name throughout my initial reporting. He deserves accuracy. His detailed narrative in this report is central to understanding what happened at Valley Forge High School that day.



www.theinfamousexchief.com


KEY DETAILS FROM THE POLICE REPORT:

Officer...

Send us Fan Mail

1If you're charged with a crime you didn't commit, you still might take the plea deal. That's not a bug in the system — it's a feature. 

Criminal defense attorney Edward F. Cohn has spent 23 years inside courtrooms in Arizona, Michigan, and Massachusetts watching this play out. In this episode of The Infamous Ex-Chief, we break down the trial penalty, why prosecutors make their move before you even step foot in a courtroom, and the hidden long-term consequences of a guilty plea that most defendants never see coming. 

Attorney Cohn hold...

Send us Fan Mail

She was two days from walking into that courtroom.

Dawn Pasela wasn't a random victim. She was the office manager of a federal mortgage fraud task force — handling evidence, organizing discovery, working alongside FBI agents and federal prosecutors every single day.

Then she started seeing what was really happening inside that office.
Fabricated cases. Destroyed computers. A prosecutor sleeping with the government's star witness. Exculpatory evidence buried under 45,000 pages of paperwork. Witnesses threatened. Careers destroyed.

Dawn made a choice. She was going to testify. She was go...

Send us Fan Mail

North Royalton police stop controversy involving Officer Lowe has raised serious questions about police accountability, internal affairs investigations, and DUI stop procedures.

In this interview, retired LAPD Internal Affairs Sergeant Marlon Marrache (Truth Behind the Badge) breaks down the North Royalton police stop and explains how internal affairs investigations actually work behind the scenes.

We cover key issues in the North Royalton case:
• Was the DUI stop valid?
• What happens during an internal affairs investigation?
• What it means when a police report is changed
• How police a...

Send us Fan Mail

Apple Creek’s former Police Chief Doug Miller is speaking out… and he’s not holding anything back.

In this exclusive sit-down with The Infamous Ex-Chief, Miller breaks down what really led to his resignation, the internal battles with council, and what was happening behind the scenes that the public never saw.

From budget fights and leadership philosophy to what he calls “personal” attacks… this conversation pulls back the curtain on how small-town politics and law enforcement leadership collide.

We also dive into the so-called “FlaskGate” incident, the anonymous co...

Send us Fan Mail

What if the biggest problem in media coverage isn’t what gets said — but what gets left out?

In this interview, I sit down with Rob Rosen, Emmy-winning television producer, investigative journalist, and author of Crimes of Omission: Distorted Justice, the Media’s War on Truth. We break down how major national stories involving police, crime, and public outrage can be shaped not just by falsehoods, but by missing facts, selective framing, and narrative steering.

We talk about:
What Rob means by “crimes of omission”
How media narratives...

Send us Fan Mail

All my lawyers in the house—this one’s for you. You already know what you’re about to see, because the moment you put body camera, the police report, and the law director’s letter side-by-side, the argument collapses. ⚖️📄🎥

Today we’re walking through North Royalton’s justification for altering a police report using the phrase everyone loves to throw around: “prosecutorial discretion.” The problem? The way it’s being used here has nothing to do with what prosecutorial discretion actually means.

Here’s what we’re covering:

The traffic stop and th...

Send us Fan Mail

What would happen in your town if the mayor just shut down the fire department—no reorganization, no restructure, no negotiation—just turned it off?

That’s essentially what residents in Hiram, Ohio woke up to: the Hiram Fire Department, including local EMS coverage, was suspended. And when emergency services disappear, even briefly, that’s not small-town drama. That’s a public safety issue.

I’m Scott Gardner, former cop, former homicide detective, and former chief of police. This platform is about accountability—especially when government decisions put the public at risk...

Send us Fan Mail

I’m going to talk about something I don’t normally cover—and I want to be clear up front: I’m split on this issue. I’m not a cannabis activist. I’ve never used marijuana. This isn’t “stoner politics.” This is an accountability conversation.

In 2023, Ohio voters passed Issue 2—legalizing recreational marijuana for adults 21+, setting possession limits, home grow rules, taxes, and a distribution structure. Whether you like marijuana or not, the key point is simple: the voters passed it. In a constitutional republic, that’s supposed to mean something.

Send us Fan Mail

The 8th District affirmed it: the testimony stands, the evidence stands, and the sentence stands. That’s the ruling.

On this 4th of 4 series:

Now here’s the bigger question—when courts and prosecutors make decisions that shape someone’s freedom, who holds them accountable?

I’m Scott Gardner—former cop, former homicide detective, and former chief of police. I’ve seen both sides of the courtroom. And here’s the structure most people never get shown: police officers operate under layers of exposure—internal affairs, civil liability, crimina...

Send us Fan Mail

The Eighth District Court of Appeals has affirmed the conviction in State of Ohio v. Larry McDonald.

The court held:

• Law enforcement officials testified as lay witnesses under Evid.R. 701
• The testimony was permissible
• The convictions were supported by sufficient evidence
• The verdict was not against the manifest weight
• The sentence was not contrary to law or excessive

This update is not about outrage.

It’s about process.

What does this affirmance mean for lay opinion testimony under Evid.R. 701?
...

Send us Fan Mail

When the court process keeps bending in the same direction, it stops being “mistake” and starts looking like system design. In this episode, I break down how Ohio court process can tilt outcomes through a burden shift, how “standard of review” becomes a shield, and why phrases like harmless error and “prove the prejudice” can protect bad procedure instead of correcting it. This is public accountability work—pro-cop, anti-corruption, and obsessed with the record. 🔍📄⚖️

I’m Scott Gardner—former cop, former homicide detective, former chief of police—and I’ve seen both sides of the courtroom. Thi...

Send us Fan Mail

Be decided by juries — not by prosecutors. That’s the line we’re supposed to defend. But in these cases, that line didn’t just blur… it got crossed.

I’m Scott Gardner — former homicide detective and former chief of police — and this is an accountability platform. I’m pro-cop, not pro-corruption. That means I’m not here to attack officers for doing their jobs, and I’m not here to protect misconduct. I’m here to call it straight, wherever it falls.

In this segment, we’re dealing with a problem that can po...

Send us Fan Mail

In Part 1 of this four-part series, I’m breaking down an East Cleveland, Ohio case that should matter to every police officer—and every citizen who still believes the government has to follow the rules. ⚖️🧾🚨

This isn’t about giving police “special treatment.” It’s about equal treatment under the law and the one rule criminal justice can’t survive without: the state proves guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. The accused does not prove innocence.

But in this case, the framework presented to the jury effectively flipped that burden. Instead of the state bei...

Send us Fan Mail

Former police chief reviews Rocky River SRO oversight using public records/court filings. Tips welcome (anonymous/confidential): https://www.theinfamousexchief.com

Support the show

Visit: https://www.liinks.co/the.infamous.exchief

Send us Fan Mail

Blue Collar Cop responded to my first question: What’s the biggest misconception civilians have about police use of force? He laid out four claims: “shoot to stop the threat,” no Hollywood shots (arms/legs, guns out of hands, warning shots), why Tasers fail more than people think, and what de-escalation can—and can’t—do.

In this video, I break down what’s accurate, what’s oversimplified, and what needs sources and standards—because “trust me” isn’t policy, and it sure isn’t accountability.

Drop your take in the comments: Which poi...

Send us Fan Mail

North Royalton residents noticed something change on the North Royalton Police Department Facebook page: comments restricted, unavailable, or gone. In this episode, Scott Gardner (former cop, former homicide detective, former chief of police) breaks down why Facebook comments on an official government page can carry First Amendment implications, why timing and viewpoint-neutral moderation policies matter, and why record preservation matters even more once a public records request is submitted.

Then we pivot into DUI/OVI arrests and why the paper trail—reports, CAD entries, and documentation—can reveal whether transparency is bein...

Send us Fan Mail

Welcome to The Infamous Ex-Chief, where we shake the system until the truth falls out. This isn’t your typical cop show, and we’re not anti-cop—we’re anti-corruption, pro-accountability, and all about real dialogue.

After 23 years in the trenches as a police chief and homicide detective, I know what it means to make the calls no one else wants to. That’s why we’re bringing in new voices—like Chief Miller. He’s a working cop who’s seen it all, and he’s not here to dodge the tough questions...