Books vs. Movies

Send us a text

That age-old question haunts every book lover who's watched their favorite novel get adapted to film: "Is the book really better?" For Shirley Jackson's masterpiece "The Haunting of Hill House" and its 1999 film adaptation "The Haunting," the answer is complicated by fascinating behind-the-scenes copyright issues that forced filmmakers to create something almost entirely different from both the source novel and the beloved 1963 film adaptation.

Orlando and I dive into this strange case study, exploring how a psychologically complex novel about a lonely woman named Eleanor finding belonging in a subtly unsettling...

Send us a text

Lawrence Wright's "Going Clear: Scientology, Hollywood and the Prison of Belief" pulls back the curtain on Scientology's most guarded secrets, revealing a world where science fiction becomes religious doctrine and Hollywood celebrities become powerful pawns in a global organization.

The journey begins with Lafayette Ronald Hubbard—a charismatic science fiction writer whose creation of Dianetics evolved into a belief system involving alien spirits called Thetans and promises of supernatural abilities through "going clear." What makes this investigation so compelling is the meticulous research behind every shocking revelation. Wright's book and its do...

Send us a text

Margaret Atwood's chilling vision of a dystopian America transformed into the theocratic Republic of Gilead has captivated readers since 1985, but how does this haunting story translate from page to screen? Diving deep into both the original novel and its acclaimed Hulu adaptation, this episode explores the fascinating creative choices that shape our understanding of Offred's nightmare.

From the stunning watercolor imagery of Renee Nault's graphic novel adaptation to the controversial casting of younger actors as the Commander and Serena Joy, each artistic decision fundamentally alters our perception of Gilead's power dynamics...

Send us a text

In a snow-covered suburb of 1981 Sweden, a bullied boy finds an unlikely ally in the mysterious girl next door who only appears after dark. This seemingly simple premise launches us into the haunting world of "Let the Right One In," a vampire tale unlike any other.

John Ajvide Lindqvist's 2004 novel and its acclaimed 2008 Swedish film adaptation both weave an unforgettable story of childhood loneliness, predation, and the desperate human need for connection. While most vampire narratives glamorize immortality, this story presents it as a tragic, isolated existence—where a centuries-old being tr...

Send us a text

Candice Carty-Williams' acclaimed novel Queenie takes on new life in its 2024 television adaptation, offering viewers and readers two complementary visions of one powerful story. Following a 25-year-old Jamaican-British woman navigating the complexities of modern life in London, both versions capture the raw emotional journey of finding yourself when caught between cultures.

What makes this adaptation particularly fascinating is how thoughtfully it re imagines key aspects of Queenie's story. From the timing of her breakup with Tom to how she processes childhood abandonment by her mother, the television series takes a more...

Send us a text

The age-old question of whether books truly outshine their film adaptations takes an intriguing turn with "Our Towns," a fascinating exploration of America's overlooked communities. Unlike traditional adaptations, this HBO Max documentary serves as a complementary companion to James and Deborah Fallows' non-fiction journey across the United States.

For five years, the Fallows traveled to dozens of small cities and towns that rarely make national headlines, documenting how these communities tackle their unique challenges. What began as a simple blog post asking readers to share stories about their hometowns blossomed into...

Send us a text

What makes a horror story truly terrifying? Is it supernatural elements like Satan and witchcraft, or the painfully realistic portrayal of psychological manipulation? In this special guest-hosted episode of Books vs Movies, Orlando delivers a compelling breakdown of Rosemary's Baby that might forever change how you view this classic horror tale.

The 1967 novel by Ira Levin and its 1968 film adaptation directed by Roman Polanski tell essentially the same story—a young woman becomes pregnant under mysterious circumstances while surrounded by strange neighbors with sinister intentions. Yet despite following the same plot be...

Send us a text

Discover the spine-chilling world of Stephen King's "Doctor Sleep" in my latest episode, where I delve into the rich narrative of trauma, redemption, and supernatural terror. As I compare the novel to the critically acclaimed 2019 film adaptation, directed by Mike Flanagan, I unpack the complex character dynamics and haunting experiences that shape the journey of Danny Torrance and Abra Stone. Both narratives uncover the pain of addiction and the shadows of the past while weaving a tale of good vs evil against the backdrop of King's unique style.

Explore how Flanagan...

Send us a text

Join me for a riveting journey through Colson Whitehead’s poignant narrative of “The Underground Railroad.” As we peel back the layers of this complex story, listeners will discover the stark contrasts between the original novel and its breathtaking miniseries adaptation. Reflecting on the harrowing experience of Cora, a slave escaping from a Georgia plantation, we unpack how Whitehead transforms the metaphor of freedom into a literal Underground Railroad. The transformative journey sheds light on resilience, hope, and the unyielding spirit of those who fought for liberty.

In this episode, I guides...

Send us a text

What if your favorite movie could turn into a slightly disappointing experience just because of a trailer that gave away too much? Join me, Lluvia, as I bring you on a cinematic journey through my top 10 films of 2024, kicking off with the suspense-filled "Speak No Evil." While James McAvoy’s performance was nothing short of captivating, the movie stumbled due to spoilers and frustrating character flaws. And what happens when nostalgia meets comedy? "Sonic the Hedgehog 3" races in with beloved characters like Sonic, Knuckles, and Tails, but the film leans heavily on Jim Ca...