Private Dicks

40 Episodes
Subscribe

By: Richard Steudle, RJ McCarthy and Rick Getz

Three Richards Solve the Worlds Greatest Mysteries 100% of the Time

PD Side Quests – The Knights of the Round Table – Sir Meliant – E16
Last Wednesday at 4:08 AM

I love this dorky shit. Another knight guys.

Another short one, but a goodie.

We learn some stuff.

Enjoy


PD Side Quests – The Knights of the Round Table – Sir Brandelis – E15
05/15/2026

Another Knight! This time Sir Brandelis. I told you he probably hated Sir Gawain. Let’s see if he did.

Knights for a couple weeks

Sorry I’m a day late

Love ya dickheads. I really do.


PD Side Quests – The Knights of the Round Table – Sir Lovel, Bard of Camelot – E14
05/07/2026

Another knight for you!

I know it’s a short episode, but we are releasing one knight a week for the next 2 weeks (2 more weeks)

Love ya dick heads


Not See or Not See Hunter? – The Isdal Woman – PD 95
04/22/2026

Today we go to Norway to solve a big one.

One that has been around since the 70s

You might know it, but we solved it.

And it was easy.

All we had to do to solve this case was investigate the following websites;

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isdal_Woman

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-39369429

https://www.heartstartspounding.com/episodes/isdalwoman

https://binreminded.medium.com/the-isdal-woman-a-new-perspective-77d89dff7103

https://www.jahernandez.com/posts/the-isdal-woman-of-norway

https://www.nzz...


The Siberian Wakanda – The Tunguska Event – PD94
04/08/2026

Today we solve the mystery of what really happened in the Siberian Tiaga in the early parts of the 1900s.

Let me tell you. Of course, aliens are a theory

All we had to do to solve this case was investigate the following websites;

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tunguska_event

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meteoric_iron

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leonid_Kulik

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_I

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evenki_people

https://www.nasa...


PD Side Quests – The Knights of the Round Table – Sir Florence – E13
03/25/2026

Little Ears for your ears. God I love learning about the knights.

Love
Richard


Cow Vigilantes – The Bhiwani Killings (feat. Sumit Swami) – PD93
03/11/2026

Dickheads,

We are back with another episode! Sumit is back as guest and Richard wanted to bring us to India, to make him feel at home.

We had a lot of laughs in this and we learnt a lot about India, its religion and politics and how they ally together in many ways.

All we had to do to solve this case was investigate the following websites;

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2023_Bhiwani_killings

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-64701344

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-65229522

<...


These Guys are Dirtbags – Escape From Alcatraz – PD92
02/25/2026

DICKHEADS! Nice to know you read these!

Richard brings RJ a story about the three men that supposedly escaped from Alcatraz in the 60’s.

It involves fake dummies, popular mechanics, 133 IQs and Clint Eastwood.

You’ll love it. Our solve is a little benign, but isn’t that life sometimes?

All we had to do to solve this case was investigate the following websites;

https://www.fbi.gov/history/famous-cases/alcatraz-escape

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/June_1962_Alcatraz_escape

https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20240607-it-wa...


PD Side Quests – The Knights of the Round Table – Sir Guinglain – E12
02/11/2026

Another Knight! Sir Guinglain! Son of a faerie!

Enjoy!

Another Full Episode in 2 weeks!


The Heavy Weight Champion of the ABA – John Brisker (feat. Rob Pue) – PD 91
02/04/2026

Hello Dickheads

We have a great episode today and we have guest Rob Pue. Rob is a comedian from Canada who is every Canadian Comics favourite comic. Go check out his new album here

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bxw74gwwau0

Richard brings Pue and RJ an episode about ABA Legend, John Brisker.

You’re gonna love this guy, we did

Well, he went missing in the 70s and no one knows what happened to him.

Except us. It was easy to figure out

Al...


Three Piles of Two – The Be-Lo Supermarket Shooting – PD90
01/22/2026

We’re back with full episodes! This one is a short one, but its still a real episode!!

Today, we cover one that Richard thought was crazy. Not really well known, but a wild story none the less.

Who shot up the BeLo in Kingston, NC in 1993?

Someone knows

Its us.

All we had to do to solve this case was investigate the following websites;

https://www.reddit.com/r/TrueCrimeDiscussion/comments/1fyej74/on_the_evening_of_june_6_1993_a_man_walked_into/

https://www.reddit.co...


PD Side Quests – The Knights of the Round Table – Sir Gawain the True – E11
01/07/2026

The last of the Orkney Boys.

The oldest and most well known.

Loved by Arthur and his most loyal knight

Sir Gawain.

Have fun!


2025 Christmas Special – Patty Vaughan – PD89
12/26/2025

Merry Christmas Dickheads,
The dicks only recorded this a few days ago, so Richard didn’t get a chance to do a huge edit, just preliminary stuff.
So it’s pretty raw.
As raw as RJ likes to get.
Today we talk about a woman that went missing on Christmas in 1996, the same year as JonBenets murder.
Her name was Patty Vaughan
She never got the attention that JonBenet got so her case was never solved
Because I think this is very solvable.
But we solved it and it was easy.


PD Side Quests – The Knights of the Round Table – Sir Agrevain – E10
12/17/2025

Dickheads – It’s another knight – You’re welcome.

This guy has hard hands and is constantly agrevated.

Sir Agrevain.

Enjoy


PD Side Quests – The Knights of the Round Table – Sir Gaheris – E09
12/03/2025

Yo Dickheads!

Another Knight.

Another Brother of the Orkney Clan – Sir Gaheris!

Spoiler alert. He killed his own mom

Enjoy


Outer Worlds 2 Special Investigative Series – E05 – Starfield Sucks
11/19/2025

Hey Dickheads,

Been taking a break from writing to play video games. Rj did too.

We talked about it.

It was loose and fun!

Full episodes will be back soon enough!

Enjoy


PD Side Quests – The Knights of the Round Table – Sir Gareth (feat. Kristy Janssen) – E08
11/05/2025

Well Dickheads, another knight

Today you get to learn about soft hands the kitchen knight and his rainbow coloured enemies.

Oh yeah, Kristy is here!! YES

Enjoy!


The Whaley House – HALLOWEEN SPECIAL – PD 88
10/31/2025

Do you believe in ghosts?

Can places become haunted?

Especially in a place where there was many violent deaths?

Let us answer these questions and more in our Halloween Special about the Whaley house.

All we had to do to solve this case was investigate the following websites;

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whaley_House_(San_Diego,_California)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Whaley

https://www.trolleytours.com/san-diego/whaley-house

https://thelittlehouseofhorrors.com/the-whaley-house/

https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/69953452/thomas-whaley<...


Beware of Dark Water – Natalie Wood (feat. Nick Beaton) – PD 87
10/22/2025

Today we had Comedian Nick Beaton come and discuss one of the biggest Hollywood mysteries of modern time

Did Natalie Wood fall off her yacht and die by accident, or did someone throw her in?

What did Christopher Walken see?

Robert Wagner seems suspicious. Prince Valiant my butt.

All we had to do to solve this case was investigate the following websites;

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natalie_Wood

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natasha_Gregson_Wagner

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natalie_Wood_filmography<...


Circumstantial Evidence Only – Is Scott Peterson Guilty? – PD 86
10/07/2025

We dive deep into a famous case. That of the murder of Laci Peterson.

Was the right man convicted? Was justice served. Most people think yes. But was it?

Come listen to the episode and figure out if it is.

All we had to do to solve this case was investigate the following websites;

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Laci_Peterson

https://web.archive.org/web/20131215011233/https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/A-PORTRAIT-OF-THE-ACCUSED-In-a-rare-interview-2812780.php

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phil_Mickelson

https://www...


The Bandit Queen – Belle Starr – PD 85
09/24/2025

Howdy Dickheads,

This episode we go to the wild west!

We learn about someone who was known back then as the Bandit Queen or the Female Jesse James

She was badass. A grumpy bad ass, but a bad ass none the less.

Now we may not agree with everything she did, we do agree that she was quite interesting

Who killed this lady? Her murder is unsolved to this day

Listen to find out.

All we had to do to solve this case was investigate...


The German’s, A Coal Fire, A Murder Plot, A Cursed Mummy or many more… – Titanic Mysteries – PD 84
09/10/2025

DICKHEADS!

Did you know that there are some tin foil hat wearing assholes that don’t think the Titanic sinking was a tragic accident but a murder plot? Or an insurance scam? Some people even think it was the curse of a mummy that brought down the old beast.

Whatever it was, we now know what happened for sure, cause RJ was really super into this and so was Richard and they figured the shit out of it

All we had to do to solve this case was investigate the following websites;

...


BONUS – Missy Bevers Supplemental – PD 83.5
08/28/2025

We were supposed to post this last week!!

Sorry everyone

Here is that bonus episode Richard promised you with all the audio that he went through when writing the episode.

I know you can find this yourself, but here it is with Richard.

We will be back in two weeks with a proper episode!


Sometimes Dead is Better – Missy Bevers (feat. Courtney Racicot) – PD 83
08/13/2025

Richard was trying to find unknown cases and in his arrogance he found one that he thought was not famous.

Wrong, very famous case

Who killed Missy Bevers? There is video, there is evidence how can there still be a mystery?

Could it be cause no one actually cares?

Find out.

All we had to do to solve this case was investigate the following websites;

https://www.reddit.com/r/MissyBevers/comments/1ljtm3v/smartphone/

https://www.wfaa.com/article/news/crime/missy-bevers-murder-investigation-midlothian-texas-police-suspects-leads/287-9de8...


Too Many Services for Homeless Youth – Where is Justin Pollari? (feat. Odi Mane) – PD 82
07/30/2025

Dickheads

Its summer and listenership is down. That means I’m covering lesser known cases.

Please listen and enjoy, Justin could use some coverage.

We solved this one easy though.

All we needed to solve this case was investigate the following websites;

https://www.cyc-net.org/today2003/today031210.html

https://www.sootoday.com/local-news/opp-re-open-justin-pollari-investigation-97289

https://www.canadaunsolved.com/cases/justin-pollari

https://www.sootoday.com/local-news/police-statement-on-justin-pollari-investigation-97343

https://www.reddit.com/r/UnresolvedMysteries/comments/7y42rf/where_is_justin_pollari_the_te...


PD Side Quests – The Knights of the Round Table – Sir Bleoberis – E07
07/25/2025

Another knight

2 days late

Sir Bleoberis or Blueberries as Richard knew him as a kid

Enjoy!


PD Side Quests – The Knights of the Round Table – Sir Accolon – E06
07/16/2025

Another knight!

Sir Accolon is the man, you’re gonna love him!

I love doing these!

Leave us a rating will ya!


Alexander Hamilton – Not Throwin’ Away My Shot – PD 81 (Uncut for your pleasure)
07/02/2025

Hey we recorded this way too late and Richard wanted this episode to be a July 4th special. So he didn’t do any editing this week. You’re welcome.

America’s youngest founding father. First secretary of the Treasury. George Washington’s little bitch. Star of a broadway musical. Most ambitious person you’ll ever read about. Very interesting history

And there was even a mystery to solve. No spoilers.

All we had to do to solve this case was investigate the following websites;

https://www.britannica.com/biography/Alexander-Hamilton-United-States-statesman/Hamiltons...


BONUS – Micheal Owes RJ a Microphone (feat. MJSYPod) – PD 79.5
06/25/2025

Micheal was hammered.

Richard kept the microphone recording.

It was funny.

Micheal owes RJ a microphone.


The Many Lies of Casey Anthony pt 2 – (feat. Micheal and Jeremy Steal Your Podcast) – PD 80
06/17/2025

Here is the final episode of the Casey Anthony Saga. God she is crazy. Micheal, Jeremy and RJ were all hilarious in this.

Thanks for listening.

All we had to do to solve this case was investigate the following websites;

https://www.cnn.com/2013/11/04/us/casey-anthony-trial-fast-facts/index.html

https://www.biography.com/crime/casey-anthony-muder-trial-timeline-facts

https://abcnews.go.com/TheLaw/story?id=5620249&page=1

https://people.com/casey-anthony-case-complete-timeline-8422805

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Caylee_Anthony

https://www.oxygen.com/crime-news/the-casey-anthony-case-a-timeline

...


The Many Lies of Casey Anthony (feat. Micheal and Jeremy Steal Your Podcast) – PD 79
06/04/2025

Dickhead – Micheal and Jeremy are here from Micheal and Jeremy Steal Your Podcast

Richard went a little nuts and did way too much research on Casey Anthony.

So now you get two episodes.

I promise you’ll enjoy, even though Micheal and RJ get bored and talk about Magic Cards.

All we had to do to solve this case was investigate the following websites;

https://www.cnn.com/2013/11/04/us/casey-anthony-trial-fast-facts/index.html

https://www.biography.com/crime/casey-anthony-muder-trial-timeline-facts

https://abcnews.go.com/TheLaw/story?id=5620249&page...


Werewolves! – Peter Stump and other notables – PD 78
05/21/2025

Hello Dickheads,

This week RJ talks to us about Werewolves.

And we have a client.

Darron Wood, producer of such shows as Defence Diaries and True Crime Bullshit.

He is hilarious, this episode is hilarious and we had fun all round

If you had fun listening, please go give us a rating on Spotify or Apple Podcasts and leave us a review.

We are on YouTube too, so please come join us there if that is your platform. One of us will even interact with you there...


The Smiley Face Killer Conspiracy – Global Death Investigations – PD 77
05/07/2025

Today, our episode is very fun

It’s a conspiracy and I love that stuff.

A conspiracy that involves a GANG of serial killers working off the dark net to waterboard young men to death across the midwest.

Seems pretty specific

Well it is.

All we had to do to solve this case was investigate the following websites;

https://biosocal.com/what-is-skin-slippage

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smiley_face_murder_theory

https://www.nbc.com/smiley-face-killers-the-hunt-for-justice

https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/cu...


The Disappearance and Death of Henry McCabe – The Sasquatch Theory – PD 76
04/23/2025

DICKHEADS

Richard’s brother, Kyle, hires the Dicks to solve a mystery for him

This one is a doozy

It’s got a disappearance, a maybe murder, a creepy voicemail, refugee camps and a Karen with two e’s

It was an easy one to solve.

Richard Solved it months ago.

All we had to do to solve this case was investigate the following websites;

https://vocal.media/criminal/the-mysterious-dealth-of-henry-mc-cabe-2015

https://www.reddit.com/r/UnresolvedMysteries/comments/1ipohud/henry_mccabe_revisited_some_misunderstandings/

...


BONUS – Did Dr. Sam Sheppard Murder his wife Marilyn? pt. 2 – The Theories – PD 75.5
04/09/2025

Hey Dickheads

Here is a little bonus episode for ya about Sam Sheppard.

We didn’t go into the theories with everyone because they already had their minds made up.

I feel like this needed to happen

Back in 2 weeks for a new episode!


Did Dr. Sam Sheppard murder his wife Marilyn? – The Funeral of Rick Getz – PD 75
03/26/2025

This week Richard solved a case in honour of the Death of Rick Getz.

It was his eulogy

This is an Unethical and Private Dicks episode!

The case is the death of Marilyn Sheppard.

Who killed her? Was it her husband? Probably.

Listen to the episode to find out.

All we had to do to solve this case was investigate the following websites;

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sam_Sheppard
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/F._Lee_Bailey
https://www.cleveland.com/metro/2012/09...


The Mothman – Did he just work for CPS? – PD 74
03/12/2025

Hello Dickheads!

Today Richard wanted to solve a mystery on the side. So he did.

Good thing Gil came. He wanted to know about Mothman too!

From John Keel, Indrid Cold and the Silver Bridge, this episode will give you most everything you want in a Mothman Episode.

All we had to do to solve this case was investigate the following websites;

https://cryptozoologycryptids.fandom.com/wiki/Mothman

https://allthatsinteresting.com/mothman

https://uwm.edu/letters-science/in-focus-2021/history-student-tells-the-story-of-the-mothman/

https://sites.uwm.edu/undergrad-research-symposium-2021/2021/04/09...


The Disappearance of Chipley Sanders and James Bess (feat. Lesbian Detectives) – PD 73
02/26/2025

Well Dickheads,

Bad news. Rick is dead. Not quite sure how that happened, but I’m sure we will find out.

Maybe we can call him on a Ouiji Board one day. But for now, we will have to settle with Richard and RJ.

But Richard is scared, so he hires a few detectives to help him solve the case he was currently working

The Disappearance of Chipley Sanders and James Bess.

Super sad case.

I think we solved it though

We learned all about gr...


PD Side Quests – The Knights of the Round Table – Esclabor, the Unknown – E05
02/12/2025

Time for another knight… well not technically a knight this time. It’s the dad of the last 3 knights we just did. Former king, current lord, Esclabor the Unknown.

Kristy from Unethical joins Richard for this one and it was awesome to see her all the way from down under

If you had fun listening, please go give us a rating on Spotify or Apple Podcasts and leave us a review.
We are on YouTube too, so please come join us there if that is your platform. One of us will even interact with you...


BONUS – The Murder of Jeanette DePalma Pt. 2 – The Other Theories – PD 72.5
02/05/2025

Here is a little part 2. Richard and RJ had had enough the other day.

Love ya.