Everything Scary
Everything Scary is a podcast that delves into all things spine-chilling. While it primarily focuses on true crime, it also covers anything else that falls under the umbrella of fear. For those listeners who HATE banter, this may not be the pod for you. We try to dial it back, since it does not appeal to everyone. But, it does still get away from us sometimes. The hosts approach these serious topics with a balance of levity, ensuring it’s never at the expense of the victims. If you enjoy true crime and appreciate a touch of humor, you’ll likel...
Kate Gosselin
Send us Fan Mail
From a.. somewhat charming reality show, about parents struggling with their 8 very young children, to a divorce, scandal and now one of the children becoming a New York Times best selling author, after publishing a book about the abuse he survived throughout his childhood at the hands of his own mother.
This is the story of Jon & Kate plus 8 star, Kate Gosselin
Support the show
If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early release dates, an everything scary sticker and ‘thank you’ as well as a shout...
Killer Mushrooms
Send us Fan Mail
Who would make 6 separate beef wellingtons for a lunch party with their ex husbands parents and aunt and uncle? Erin Patterson did! Sadly within 24 hours, four of the guest would be fighting for their lives! Was this an honest mistake, or malicious act?
This is the case of Erin Patterson and the death cap mushrooms
Support the show
If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early release dates, an everything scary sticker and ‘thank you’ as well as a shout out on our regular feed! Please j...
Megan Meier
Send us Fan Mail
Trigger warning- please be advised this episode deals with suicide and bullying.
When 13 year old Megan Meier received a friend request on MySpace from a 16 year old boy named Josh Evans, she was over the moon. For 6 weeks Josh used the online platform to court Megan and tell her joke beautiful she was, which was something that she had never felt before. But all that changed when Josh suddenly told Megan that he had heard that she is not very nice to her friends, and therefore was unsure if he w...
The Luby's Cafeteria Tragedy
Send us Fan Mail
On October 16th 1991 a blue 1987 Ford Ranger came crashing through the store front of Luby's Cafeteria. Sadly, this happened to be National Bosses Day, and the restaurant was much busier than normal. When Patrons rushed to the vehicle, believing that this all must have been some horrible accident due to a medical emergency, they would be met by George Hennard, a madman, brandishing 2 handguns. What would follow would be 12 minutes of pure devastation.
This is the case of the Luby's Cafeteria Tragedy.
Support the show
If you’re...
UPDATES!
Send us Fan Mail
We're back!! and there have been a ton of recent True Crime updates!
So today we will go into depth on the Lindsay Clancy trial, the break through in the murder of Tupac, a creepy Chris Watts update, what that loser Bryan Kohberger is trying now, AND Taylor Hanson being on DWTS!!!
Support the show
If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early release dates, an everything scary sticker and ‘thank you’ as well as a shout out on our regular feed! Please join at Patreon//everythi...
Bruce McArthur
Send us Fan Mail
One of the most high profile serial killers in Canada, was just simply the nice landscaper- who did beautiful work and actually, at one point worked for Barry and Honey Sherman -who we covered in a previous episode, and were billionaires who were found murdered by their indoor pool.
This is the case of Bruce McArthur
Support the show
If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early release dates, an everything scary sticker and ‘thank you’ as well as a shout out on our regular feed! Please...
Ian and Angela Diaz
Send us Fan Mail
When Ian Diaz met and married Angela Connel, things were looking great, Angela got pregnant quickly with twins, and the couple shared a beautiful condo that essentially backed right into Disneyland, and Ian was most certainly a Disney adult, so everything was perfect!
That was until Angela started receiving threats via email. And that was only the start of everything she was about to endure!
Ian and Angela could only assume, given the content of the emails, that these threats were coming from Ian's ex girlfriend, Michelle.......... but what i...
Nathan Carman
Send us Fan Mail
In 2016, Nathan Carman was rescued at sea after being lost for 7 days with his mother. Once Nathan was able to be questioned, there were certain parts of his story that were making it seem like it may have not been just a horrific accident. Which would also prompt a harder look into the murder of his grandfather that had happened only three years previous.
Support the show
If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early release dates, an everything scary sticker and ‘thank you’ as well as a shout o...
The Death of Mary Yoder
Send us Fan Mail
Mary Yoder was a healthy 60 year old chiropractor, when suddenly one afternoon she fell horribly ill and in less than 48 hours she had passed away, when the pathologist found Colchicine in her system, a potent medication used to treat gout, which Mary did not suffer from, it quickly became apparent that Mary had not died from natural causes and despite not having any enemies at all, 3 people quickly became suspicious, and all for very different reasons.
Support the show
If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early release da...
Kyle Bevan
Send us Fan Mail
Trigger Warning - involves the death of a child-
Kyle Bevan and Sinead James met and began dating in February of 2020- right before the whole world closed down- forcing them into cohabitation-sadly Sinead would trust the wrong person to be around her 3 daughters, and would ignore some glaring red flags and sadly this would end horribly for her middle daughter Lola.
Support the show
If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early release dates, an everything scary sticker and ‘thank you’ as well as a shout o...
Lucy Li & Oliver Karafa
Send us Fan Mail
Lucy and Oliver dated as teenagers, but would break up when she was not ready to be intimate so Oliver, did what he had to do, and slept with one of her friends.
One DUI causing a fatality, and a IG influencer career later, and the two would reconnect and marry.
This couple would do anything to come off as powerful and successful including scamming their friends. unfortunately, when it all ended up coming to a head, the results would be fatal.
Support the show
...
Lacey Spears
Send us Fan Mail
Trigger warning for child death, and muchausen by proxy.
Lacey Spears loved the attention that she would receive online from different groups when she would post pictures and captions describing the horrible medical journey her son Garnet was on. Only, Garnet didn't just fall sick naturally, it was his own mother who was keeping him sick for the attention.
Support the show
If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early release dates, an everything scary sticker and ‘thank you’ as well as a shout out on our regul...
Dr. Paolo Macchiarini
Send us Fan Mail
Dr Paolo Macchiarini was considered to be a superstar in the world of thoracic surgery. He was responsible for the ground breaking invention of a synthetic trachea, which would be bathed in the patients own cells, and had the potential to save so many lives.
Paolo would travel the world performing these surgeries, and while working with a 2 year old child who had been born without a windpipe, he would meet award winning journalist; Benita Alexander. The two fell madly in love, got engaged, Paolo was even able to secure Pope Fr...
Lindsay Clancy
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show
If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early release dates, an everything scary sticker and ‘thank you’ as well as a shout out on our regular feed! Please join at Patreon//everythingscarypod571
Geoffrey Paschel
Send us Fan Mail
Trigger Warning for Domestic Violence.
From 90 day fame- to behind bars. Geoffrey Paschel was one of the worst people alive- I went in to this case thinking that it would be interesting, given Matts undying obsession with 90 Day, and all of its branch offs. Turns out I could not be more wrong. This is a horrible case involving a malignant narcissist- who was a life long abuser of women and children.
This is the case of Geoffrey Paschel.
Support the show
If you’re interested in rec...
Barry and Honey Sherman
Send us Fan Mail
On December 15th of 2017, billionaire husband and wife team Barry and Honey Sherman were found hanging from men's belts along side of their indoor pool in their North York home. Barry was said to have no shortage of enemies, but could it have been someone that the Sherman's knew on a close, personal basis? There was no evidence of forced entry and the alarm that they were said to have been religious about setting, was not triggered. Was this someone who they had welcomed into their home?
This is the case...
Air King
Send us Fan Mail
You have probably seen the viral video of a ground service agent high jacking a plane, that had everyone questioning the story behind the video. Well, here it is!
Support the show
If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early release dates, an everything scary sticker and ‘thank you’ as well as a shout out on our regular feed! Please join at Patreon//everythingscarypod571
Kouri Richins
Send us Fan Mail
Kouri Richins has recently been convicted in the poisoning death of her 39 year old Eric Richins in March of 2022 while her children we home and asleep.
This is the case of Kouri Richins
Support the show
If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early release dates, an everything scary sticker and ‘thank you’ as well as a shout out on our regular feed! Please join at Patreon//everythingscarypod571
Afroman
Send us Fan Mail
Matts wonderful take on what happened when cops broke into the home of rapper/singer Afroman, caused a bunch of damage and forced him to write an entire album about the event, only then to turn around and sue him.
Support the show
If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early release dates, an everything scary sticker and ‘thank you’ as well as a shout out on our regular feed! Please join at Patreon//everythingscarypod571
The Harrison Family Murders
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show
If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early release dates, an everything scary sticker and ‘thank you’ as well as a shout out on our regular feed! Please join at Patreon//everythingscarypod571
Taylor Frankie Paul
Send us Fan Mail
As Per Matts request; if you haven't been living under a rock, you have probably seen some reporting on The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives star; Taylor Frankie Paul. Taylor sky rocketed to TikTok fame when she went Live with confessions of a lifestyle that no one would have believed she had been leading. This would lead to the conception of the Hulu show, in which Taylor would be the focus, in a group of young Mormon moms who enjoyed posting TikTok video. Quickly Taylor would become a fan favourite, which would lead t...
Beth Thomas
Send us Fan Mail
As an extremely young child, Beth was taken from her biological family, along with her little brother, and adopted by a family, who had desperately wanted children, but were unable to have any of their own. Beth would grow to display more and more disturbing behaviours, and her adoptive parents would explore every option they had in order to get her help.
What exactly had transpired in the short time that Beth had lived with her biological parents that had made her exhibit such strange and violent behaviours?
This i...
Murder in Collingwood
Send us Fan Mail
On the early morning hours of January 26th 2023, in Collingwood, Ontario Canada, an employee of the Alpine Ski Club was travelling to work before the sun had come up, and notice an orange hue in the sky just off the side of Arrowhead Road. Up on exiting his vehicle, he noticed that a car had veered down an embankment and was engulfed in flames. After firefighters arrived at the sight, and fought hard to extinguish the fire, they came to the sad realization, that on the passenger floor board were human remains. But, i...
Dr Phil
Send us Fan Mail
Despite my years long admiration for Dr Phil...we can stack this up with my Jacob Hoggard episode, of people I once loved who turned out to be pieces of Sh!t....
Support the show
If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early release dates, an everything scary sticker and ‘thank you’ as well as a shout out on our regular feed! Please join at Patreon//everythingscarypod571
Baby Jessica
Send us Fan Mail
In 1987 the world held its breath for 58 hours, after an 18 month old child had fallen down an 8 inch abandoned well, in her aunts back yard. To this day if you hear 'baby Jessica' most know what this is in reference to, and has even been sensationalized by such shows as The Simpsons.
But, these are the actual events that took place on that October afternoon in Midland Texas. This is the case of baby Jessica!
Support the show
If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early re...
The Disappearance of Morgan Nick
Send us Fan Mail
This episode is a mash up of a few topics- Matt answers a 'Whats the Matt'r' question, plus some Olympic women's hockey news, we also touch on the new studio and the reasoning behind it.
We also discuss the 1995 disappearance of 6 year old Morgan Nick, from a little league game, while her mother was in eye shot.
Support the show
If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early release dates, an everything scary sticker and ‘thank you’ as well as a shout out on our regular feed! P...
The Murder of Moriah Wilson
Send us Fan Mail
On May 11 2022, while in Texas, staying with a friend, as she awaited a 155 mile bike race. 23-year old Moriah Wilson was shot to death, in the home of her friend Caitlyn Cash. Originally, authorities suspected, the last person Mo was known to be with, fellow cyclist; Colin Strickland. But, soon suspicion started to shift to Colin's on and off again, live in girlfriend; Kaitlyn Armstrong.
This is the case of the Murder of Moriah Wilson.
Support the show
If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early re...
Valentines Day Special
Send us Fan Mail
On this special episode, Matt tells us all about the most romantic celebrity couples of all time (not really) and he also uses his expertise to answer a...very interesting What's The Matt'r question.
Support the show
If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early release dates, an everything scary sticker and ‘thank you’ as well as a shout out on our regular feed! Please join at Patreon//everythingscarypod571
Matt's True Criminal Case #7
Send us Fan Mail
In Matts Deepish Dive today, he will tell us about Paulina.... either the worst catfish of all time.... or accessory to murder...?
Support the show
If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early release dates, an everything scary sticker and ‘thank you’ as well as a shout out on our regular feed! Please join at Patreon//everythingscarypod571
The Poltergeist Curse
Send us Fan Mail
EARLY PATREON RELEASE- In 1982 the first of the Poltergeist trilogy movies was released. In a scene nearing the end of the movie, the mother of the Freeling family, Diane, is dragged into the in ground pool, where she is surrounded by skeletons floating to the surface. At this time, in Hollywood, it was said to have been cheaper to fly in ACTUAL human skeletons, instead of buying synthetic. And, that scene would be believed to be the catalyst to what some would deem The Poltergeist Curse, because what would follow would be a...
Amityville
Send us Fan Mail
Following the horrific killings of 6 members of the DaFeo family in 1974, a new family; The Lutz's would move into the same home at 112 Ocean Avenue in Amityville New York. What would follow would be 28 days of horror, according to the Lutz family.
Was everything that happened over that short period of time brought on because of the horrific murders of the DaFeo family, was there something dark about the house, long before- and did the house itself play a part in the murders? Or was this all just a house in w...
Matt's Stuff
Send us Fan Mail
Some Spotifeedback, Whats the Matt'r and a Deepish Dive!
Support the show
If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early release dates, an everything scary sticker and ‘thank you’ as well as a shout out on our regular feed! Please join at Patreon//everythingscarypod571
Tex McIver
Send us Fan Mail
In 2016 Tex McIver would claim that he had been holding his gun in the back seat of his Ford Expedition, due to his nerves of being in a bad part of Atlanta Georgia when he drifted off to sleep. After being jolted awake his gun would discharge, firing into the back of the passenger front seat, where his wife Diane was sitting.
Diane would later succumb to her injuries, and then the question would arise, did Tex intentionally shoot Diane, or was it all just a horrible (albeit, wildly irresponsible) accident?<...
Jacob Hoggard of Hedley
Send us Fan Mail
In 2018 Canadian pop rock band Hedley was at the height of their career, that was until a twitter user made a post asking for anyone who has had an inappropriate or uncomfortable experience with the band, to come forward and share their story, and with in a short period of time, she would already have over 60 people sharing their first hand stories, which ranged from, somewhat inappropriate to actual assault, the bands management team would drop the band instantly, almost as if they had been waiting for this day to come.
...
Steve Pladl
Send us Fan Mail
Older Patreon episode- Please listen with care, as episode includes sensitive topics, that can be triggering.
We will be returning after the holidays with all new episodes!
Support the show
If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early release dates, an everything scary sticker and ‘thank you’ as well as a shout out on our regular feed! Please join at Patreon//everythingscarypod571
Everything Scary Christmas Special
Send us Fan Mail
Happy Holidays to one and all! Please enjoy our true crime adjacent Christmas Special episode!
Support the show
If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early release dates, an everything scary sticker and ‘thank you’ as well as a shout out on our regular feed! Please join at Patreon//everythingscarypod571
Columbine Part 2
Send us Fan Mail
In Part 2 of our coverage, we will go over the events that led up to April 20th 1999, we will discuss, who the other 2 individual's were that were arrested, and served sentences due to their involvement.
As well as if this tragedy could have been stopped, and what were the signs? Also, how were two 17 year old boys, able to acquire the weapons that were used that awful day?
Support the show
If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early release dates, an everything scary sticker and ‘thank...
Columbine Part 1
Send us Fan Mail
TRIGGER WARNING; School Shooting. On April 20th 1999, twp students; Dylan Klebold, and Eric Harris would arrive at Columbine High School, just after 11am, with their plan being to take as many lives as possible. Within the first 2 hours, the media had already decided that this was the result of two kids who were bullied, who listened to Marilyn Mason, and who were apart of something called 'The Trench Coat Mafia' and in reality, none of that was true.
Support the show
If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, ea...
Jennifer and James Crumbley
Send us Fan Mail
TRIGGER WARNING FOR SCHOOL SHOOTING.
The Parents of school shooter Ethan Crumbley would go down in history as the first parents to be charged with Involuntary Manslaughter, following the devastation that was brought on by their son on November 30th, 2021, after Prosecutor; Karen McDonald would question, what, if anything they knew about what their son was planning. The gross negligence that she would discover would leave her without a choice but to charge them. But, she would have to find the first, because directly following the devastating shooting, both Jennifer and...
The Death of Matthew Golder
Send us Fan Mail
Trigger warning for, all of the things! child abuse, child death, domestic violence, suicide*
In 1971 it was determined that a 4 month old baby boy had lost his life in a horrible accident, that involved, his nearly 2 year old sister, Tracey, having thrown him from his crib resulting in a head injury.
As his sister grew up, she had never known the true cause of her little brothers death, and her mother Kathie had often given her conflicting stories. It was not until Tracey was older, with children...
