Legal Issues In Policing
Legal Issues in Policing (LIIP) is the podcast blending the demands of the book with the rulings from the bench through the lens of the badge. Police Officers with a solid understanding of the law and their legal powers are more confident, competent and effective. Each episode will examine a legal issue in policing by reviewing current Canadian criminal case law from coast to coast to coast.
E157| One arrest, two offences & the scope of an incidental search.
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Ontario Court of Appeal decision R. v. Taylor, 2026 ONCA 832 where police arrested a man for dangerous driving following a collision. Police searched the cab of his semi tractor unit and found numerous drugs and paraphernalia, which led to an arrest for impaired operation. At trial in Ontario Superior Court, the judge found the search lawful as an incident to arrest and the man was convicted of several offences including dangerous driving CBH, impaired driving CBH and refusing to submit to a...
E156| Case law classic. A passenger, presence, & police power of arrest.
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the BC Court of Appeal decision R. v. Juan, 2007 BCCA 351 where police arrested a man who was a passenger in a car that arrived at a mall parking lot for a pre-arranged drug transaction. Police searched the man and found cocaine in his pocket. A trial judge excluded the evidence and acquitted the man of PPT — possession for the purpose of trafficking — because there were insufficient objective grounds to support his arrest. The judge found the only basis for arresting the...
E155| Form 5.2s & some good news (especially for BC cops).
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses Bill C-16's amendments to the Criminal Code provisions of s. 489.1 (report to a justice) and s. 490 (detention of things seized). Learn how these legislative changes affect the way police — especially those in BC — report (or not) the extraction of data from a seized electronic device and the time to request the extension of a detention order if proceedings are not commenced.
Criminal Code
s. 489.1(4) This section does not apply with respect to computer data...
E154| A ‘dropped’ cell phone, distorted evidence & deliberate deception.
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Ontario Superior Court of Justice decision R. v. Seymour, 2026 ONSC 6138, where police stopped a car and one of its passenger's fled on foot. On the passenger side floor, police found a 3D printed handgun. Police then applied for a search warrant to search the data of a cell phone located at the scene. In the ITO, police said the fleeing man "dropped" the phone as he fled. But that was not accurate. The police found the phone inside the car. Was...
E153| Invoked right to counsel, impaired investigation & interruption of the implementational duty.
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Newfoundland and Labrador Provincial Court decision R. v. Joe, 2026 NLPC 1024, where police arrested a man for dangerous driving. The man invoked his right to counsel but the officer did not facilitate contact with a lawyer. Instead, the officer demanded a roadside breath sample, which the man refused. Could the officer delay facilitating the man's access to a lawyer and proceed with roadside breath testing even though the man had already been arrested for another offence, advised of his right to counsel, a...
E152| One man’s trash is another’s evidentiary treasure? Cigarette butts, coffee cups & comparative DNA analysis.
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the P.E.I. Supreme Court decision R. v. Gallant, 2026 PESC 31, where police rummaged through a man's trash bin at the end of his driveway, removing cigarette butts and coffee cups. DNA was collected from these items and compared to DNA retrieved from a murder scene more than 30 years earlier, which proved a match. This match was then used to obtain further judicial authorizations. The man was subsequently charged with first degree murder and improperly interfering with human remains. The man sought...
E151| Impounds, inventories & incriminating finds.
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Court of Quebec decision R. v. Reddick, 2026 QCCQ 4237, where police conducted a warrantless inventory search of an impounded vehicle. An officer opened the trunk, lifted the floor covering to inspect the spare-tire compartment, and found a knotted bag. The officer untied the knotted bag and found two more knotted bags nested within one another, which he also untied to discover 500 grams of heroin. The accused attacked the officer's so called 'inventory search' in several ways, suggesting it was an investigatory search...
E150| An arrest, limitations & objective reasonableness.
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Ontario Court of Justice decision R. v. Nikocevic, 2026 ONCJ 429, where a police officer's arrest was challenged on the basis that he did not comply with the statutorily binding public interest and court appearance factors found in s. 495(2) of the Criminal Code when making an arrest under s. 495(1). In cross examination, the officer was questioned about the limitations on his power of arrest. However, he did not expressly refer to the public interest or court appearance considerations. Did the absence of evidence f...
E149| A stolen auto, an arrest, a search & multiple Charter breach allegations.
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Ontario Court of Justice decision R. v. Angelone, 2026 ONCJ 559, where a police officer relied on an Automated Licence Plate Reader (ALPR) hit that a vehicle was stolen as grounds for arrest. When the driver's satchel was searched, police found carfentanil. In court, the driver argued: (1) his arrest was arbitrary because the ALPR hit did not provide the necessary grounds to arrest him under s. 495(1) of the Criminal Code; (2) even if grounds existed under s. 495(1), the officer ought not to have arrested h...
E148| A pull over, plain view paraphernalia & a provincial police power to search.
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Ontario Court of Appeal decision R. v. Randall, 2026 ONCA 631, where a police officer stopped a driver for tinted windows and saw an unwrapped cannabis vape pen in plain sight near the gearshift. Thinking he had enough grounds under Ontario's Cannabis Control Act for a search of the driver and the vehicle, the officer ultimately discovered controlled substances, evidence of trafficking, cash and a loaded handgun. A trial judge found the police breached the driver's Charter rights because the observation of the c...
E147| Listener Question: Mixed motive searches — permitted or prohibited?
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike responds to a listener's question about whether a search would still be lawful if an officer had multiple, simultaneous reasons for searching, and the court found some — but not all of the reasons — were objectively unreasonable? Would having an invalid reason in mind when searching nullify a coexistent valid reason for a search?
References:
R. v. Spice, 2026 SKPC 14R. v. Annett, 17 C.C.C. (3d) 332 (Ont. C.A.) leave to appeal refused, [1985] 1 S.C.R. v.R. v. Dreyer, 2008 BCCA 89R. v...E146| Police misconduct, McNeil & McKee. Lasting effects of an ‘expunged’ discipline record.
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Supreme Court of Canada decision Edmonton Police Service v. McKee, 2026 SCC 24, where a police detective's expunged discipline record became an issue at trial. Did a provision in Alberta's Police Services Regulation removing a misconduct finding from an officer's disciplinary file also render the misconduct non-disclosable for criminal law purposes? Or did the expunged record still need to be disclosed by Crown to the accused because it may have been relevant to the detective's credibility, reliability or conduct during the investigation?
<...E145| A horrific crash, RGB & a two-for-one arrest.
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Ontario Court of Appeal decision R. v. Hayatibahar, 2026 ONCA 507, where police arrested two men for impaired driving following a fatal crash. The catch? There was only one driver. Was the arrest of both men for an offence that could only have been committed by one of them justified? And was a search of the accused's pockets at the hospital some two hours after his arrest reasonable? Or was the arrest unlawful resulting in s. 8 (unreasonable search) and s. 9 (arbitrary detention) Charter...
E144| Crown cannot create your "WHY".
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Saskatchewan Provincial Court decision R. v. Spice, 2026 SKPC 14, where a police officer searched a truck after arresting its driver for impaired. The officer testified he searched the truck — which was being impounded — as an incident to arrest to ensure there was nothing that would be dangerous to the tow truck driver. During the search, the officer saw a box of watermelon vodka. At trial, the accused wanted this observation, along with the certificate of analysis of his breath samples, excluded under s. 2...
E143| Does a “NO TRESPASSING” sign vitiate implied licence?
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses implied licence and the impact of a "NO TRESPASSING" sign. Does the posting of such a sign neuter the implied licence doctrine or does it merely state what the law already recognizes: a person entering onto another's property must have a legitimate reason for doing so? Doesn't implied licence provide members of the public, including police officers, the right to enter private property on legitimate business so long as they do not otherwise exceed the scope of the doctrine? What effect, if...
E142| An automobile, artificial illumination & an arrest. Adequate articulation or wishful thinking?
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Quebec Court of Appeal decision R. v. Paul, 2026 QCCA 552, where a police officer saw a known drug user acting suspiciously late at night. This person was nervous, evasive and appeared uncomfortable about police presence. After speaking with the man, police surreptitiously followed him, saw him approach a running vehicle with its headlights out, and watched as he appeared to interact with its driver. After noticing police, the man fled. Police then approached the vehicle and, using a flashlight, lit up its i...
E141| A tip, a trip & a takedown. Building RGB for a big bust.
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the BC Court of Appeal decision R. v. Dinh, 2026 BCCA 190, where police, acting on an anonymous Crime Stoppers' tip, followed a woman onto a ferry and later arrested her after she met with a man at a parking lot and exchanged bags. Police searched her car and found a kilogram of fentanyl hidden in the spare tire compartment of her trunk. The woman claimed her arrest was unlawful for lack of reasonable grounds and she wanted the evidence against her excluded. Was t...
E140| Update: A Singer, the sequel & solving an unresolved issue.
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Saskatchewan Court of Appeal decision R. v. Singer, 2026 SKCA 52, an update to Episode 138 (R. v. Singer, 2026 SCC 8). In this case, Saskatchewan’s top court had to determine the outstanding ground of appeal it refused to address: whether the accused’s right to a fair trial was prejudiced because the arresting officer — prior to testifying — allegedly overheard defence counsel’s submissions taking issue with the grounds to make a breath demand and whether it was made forthwith. The Court of Appeal initially found it u...
E139| CYA. Can you articulate?
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Manitoba Court of Appeal decision R. v. Francois, 2025 MBCA 93 where police, on routine patrol in a high crime area, saw a man in a back alley operating a grinder while leaning over a BMX bike. After briefly questioning the man about the bike, an officer — an avid biker himself — found things just didn't add up, so he arrested the man thinking the bike was stolen or being stolen. A search of the man and his back-pack resulted in the discovery of a sa...
E138| Knock & talk. Purpose, privacy & the police.
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Supreme Court of Canada decision R. v. Singer, 2026 SCC 8 where police, responding to a reported impaired driver, saw a truck matching the suspect vehicle description parked in a private driveway with its engine running and lights on. Officers walked up the driveway to the truck and saw a man sleeping or passed out in the driver's seat. The man was unresponsive to knocks at the window, so police opened the truck's door, woke the man up and observed signs of impairment. A...
E137| SCC — Data, decisions & division.
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Supreme Court's 2025 Year in Review. How do last year's numbers stack up against previous years? And how often does the court disagree on the outcome of a case?
Thanks for listening! Feedback welcome at [email protected]
E136| A man, a mall & a menacing machete. Assessing a stop, safety searches & the right to counsel.
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the BC Supreme Court decision R. v. Watroba, 2025 BCSC 815 where police saw a man, who they recognized as someone known to be involved in drug trafficking, standing outside a shopping mall with an easily accessible machete strapped across his back. This led to an investigative detention, a pat-down, the search of a satchel, the discovery of fentanyl and ultimately an arrest. The man was charged with possessing a weapon dangerous to the public peace and two counts of PPT. His lawyer, as...
E135| Public safety, parole & the power of arrest.
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the power to arrest, without warrant, an offender in breach of their conditional release — unescorted temporary absence, parole or statutory release — and how the authority under s. 137.1 of the Corrections and Conditional Release Act (CCRA) came to be.
CCRA definitions (s. 99(1)):
day parole means the authority granted to an offender by the Board or a provincial parole board to be at large during the offender’s sentence in order to prepare the offender for full pa...
E134| A Christmas message.
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike offers a Christmas message for all law enforcement officers.
Thanks for listening! Feedback welcome at [email protected]
E133| To arrest or not (2) arrest? That is the question.
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Supreme Court of Canada decision R. v. Carignan, 2025 SCC 43 where a police officer arrested a man under s. 495 of the Criminal Code. At trial, in the Court of Quebec, the man wanted a voir dire held to determine the lawfulness of his arrest because — he claimed — the police did not comply with s. 495(2) and he sought the exclusion of an incriminating statement he made to police under s. 24(2) of the Charter. But the judge refused to hold a voir dire, concluding s. 4...
E132| Patients, paramedics, privacy & passive police presence. Potted plant or probing participant?
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Alberta Court of Appeal decision R. v. Ouellette, 2025 ABCA 340 where a police officer accompanied an impaired driving suspect in the rear of an ambulance. While enroute to the hospital, the officer overheard the EMT ask the driver questions about drug and alcohol consumption and recorded her responses in his notebook. The officer then used this information in a warrant to seize the driver's medically taken blood samples. Did the police breach s. 8 of the Charter by riding in the ambulance and...
E131| s. 10(b) implementational delay & failure to communicate.
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Ontario Court of Appeal decision R. v. Dalia, 2025 ONCA 772 where police delayed providing an arrestee access to counsel until a house — the target of a search warrant — was secured. A sergeant expected an officer would learn via police radio when the home was secure and then facilitate access to a lawyer, while the officer was expecting further instruction from the sergeant before doing so. This miscommunication resulted in a s. 10(b) Charter breach. Listen and learn how you might avoid a simi...
E130| Suspected drug deal, no seatbelt & a traffic stop. Pretext or proper police purpose?
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Ontario Court of Appeal decision R. v. Jackson, 2025 ONCA 717 where police — after witnessing a suspected drug deal — stopped a vehicle, claiming a passenger was not wearing his seat belt. During the interaction, police saw cannabis shake (green specs and flakes) on the dashboard, smelled fresh marihuana and noticed an air freshener in the vehicle. When the man was about to be searched under Ontario's Cannabis Control Act, he fled, only to be chased down and arrested. A search incident to arrest turn...
E129| A raised shirt, an underwear waistband & a baggie of blow. When is a search a 'strip search'?
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Ontario Court of Appeal decision R. v. Samuels, 2025 ONCA 736 where police arrested a man for drug trafficking and searched him at the scene incident to arrest by lifting his shirt and removing a bag of drugs sticking out from his underwear waistband. The man's sweatpants were then lowered to his knees, exposing a pair of jeans underneath, so officer's could search his pockets. Police found a trove or drugs and drug-related evidence. Did these searches amount to a "strip search" such...
E128| Are you smarter than a Supreme Court judge? Some might expect you to be.
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Supreme Court of Canada decision R. v. Wilson, 2025 SCC 32 where police arrested people present at a drug overdose after someone called 9-1-1 for emergency medical assistance. A search incident to arrest revealed modified handguns, firearm parts and ammunition inside a nearby vehicle. Was the arrest lawful? Or did the amendments made to the CDSA under the Good Samaritan Drug Overdose Act exempt a person present at the overdose not only from a charge or conviction for simple possession — as the te...
E127| Why you do what you do matters!
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Saskatchewan Court of Appeal decision R. v. Brabant, 2025 SKCA 101 where police arrested a man without reasonable grounds to do so. When the man was searched, police found meth in his pocket and a sawed-off rifle under his sweater. Although the trial judge found Charter breaches — arbitrary detention and unreasonable search — the evidence was nevertheless admitted because the police could have detained the man and patted him down for safety and discovered the evidence anyway. Did the trial judge properly consider discoverability of th...
E126| To knock or not to knock?
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Ontario Court of Appeal decision R. v. Ngo, 2025 ONCA 685 where police conducted a no-knock entry when executing a search warrant? Was departing from the knock-and-announce rule justified in the circumstances? Or did police action render the manner of search unreasonable?
Lower court decision (R. v. Ngo, 2022 ONSC 3700)
Sentencing decision (R. v. Ngo, 2023 ONSC 282)
Thanks for listening! Feedback welcome at [email protected]
E125| A 'CLEW' to understanding search & seizure basics.
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike looks back to the basics of search and seizure law by using the acronym CLEW — Consent | Lawful Exception | Warrant — that you can use to think about this important investigative tool.
Thanks for listening! Feedback welcome at [email protected]
E124| A dropped 911, possible domestic & pocketed cocaine. Was safety search sensible?
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the BC Supreme Court decision R. v. Bateman, 2025 BCSC 1780 where police responded to an abandoned 911 call. Suspecting a possible domestic, an officer patted-down a man who answered the door at the residence. After feeling something “hard” and “firm” in the man’s hoodie pocket, the officer reached in and removed the object, subsequently discovering it to be cocaine wrapped in a Ziplock baggie. Was the initial pat down lawful and, if so, was reaching into the pocket and removing the object for its inspect...
E123| Did arrest of wrong man make it unlawful?
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Alberta Court of Appeal decision R. v. Araya, 2025 ABCA 61 where police mistakenly arrested the wrong man for robbery. When the man was searched, police found a loaded handgun in the satchel he was carrying. Did the mistaken identity render the arrest unlawful? Or did the officer still have reasonable grounds for arrest even though it turned out he arrested the wrong person? Find out what the appeal court ruled on this matter and other issues such as (1) whether an imminent threat...
E122| Test for arrest — cumulative, commonsensical & contextual.
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the New Brunswick Court of Appeal decision R. v. Breau, 2025 NBCA 95 where police arrested a woman for drug trafficking. When police searched the vehicle she was driving, drugs — including methamphetamine, MDMA, and cocaine — along with other evidence was discovered. The woman argued the police did not have sufficient grounds to arrest her, rendering her detention arbitrary — a s. 9 Charter breach. A trial judge upheld the arrest, but she appealed to the New Brunswick Court of Appeal. Find out what the appeal court ruled...
E121| Canada's overall crime down↓; assaults on officers up↑.
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses Statistics Canada's most recent crime data from 2024 and once again highlights the increase of assaults against peace officers.
Links
E120| A fenced yard, flight from arrest, a fight & Feeney.
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Saskatchewan Court of Appeal decision R. v. Hoffman, 2025 SKCA 75 where police opened the gate to a waist high, fenced yard and entered to arrest a man seen standing in it. When the officer advised the man that he was under arrest, the man turned and ran into the residence, followed by police. A physical altercation occurred leading to charges of assaulting a peace officer, resisting arrest and damaging a police vehicle. Was the entry into the fenced yard to arrest the...
E119| Does a strip search renew s. 10(b) Charter right to counsel?
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Ontario Court of Appeal decision R. v. Thompson, 2025 ONCA 500 where a man was arrested in relation to a serious drug investigation and later strip searched after being booked into cells. Police delayed advising the man of his s. 10(b) Charter right to counsel for 20 minutes following his arrest, and did not re-advise him of his right to a lawyer before conducting the strip search many hours later and after he had already spoken to duty counsel. Was the 20 minute delay justified...
E118| Independent civilian oversight. Cheers, jeers & years!
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
TRIGGER WARNING: This episode contains graphic content, including violence, suicide and death which may shock, offend or upset.
In this episode, Mike discusses examples of recently released reports from police civilian oversight agencies and the time it takes to conclude some of these investigations.
Cases referenced: