Around with Randall
Listen to the weekly podcast “Around with Randall” as he discusses, in just a few minutes, a topic surrounding non-profit philanthropy. Included each week are tactical suggestions listeners can use immediately to make their non-profit, and their job activities, more effective.Email Randall with a topic for a show: [email protected] Randall with a thought regarding specific a show: [email protected]
Episode 306: What is the Real Purpose of a Nonprofit? Finding Discomfort in the Right Answer
What is the true purpose of a nonprofit and why do budgets, AI, and generational change make the answer urgent now? Take a look at six practical steps, from measuring impact instead of activity to hiring leaders who challenge convention, and learn how comfort can quietly keep an organization from the very difference it exists to make. It is a candid invitation to lean into discomfort and imagine what you would build if you started from scratch tomorrow.
Episode 305: Reading the Room: When Behaviors Don't Match the Words
When someone says everything is fine but starts questioning every decision, what deserves your attention: the reassurance or the change in behavior? How does fear, uncertainty, and a need for control sit beneath the words people choose? Learn six practical ways to notice those shifts, ask more thoughtful questions, and leave room for an honest answer. For nonprofit leaders and anyone navigating a difficult conversation, the starting point is not decoding another person, it’s being willing to listen.
Episode 304: Are We, You, Ready for the Fundraising Office of the Future?
The fundraising office of the future may depend a lot less on adding people than rethinking the work already being done. Economics, donor expectations, prospect intelligence, and thoughtful technology use can reshape an office around meaningful relationships rather than familiar routines. At the center is a deceptively simple question: are our resources helping us connect what donors care about with what our organizations need? Preparing for change begins not with predicting tomorrow, but with examining what we are willing to do differently today.
Episode 303: Realizing the Requirements of the Role You Want, i.e. CDO, vs the One You Have
Moving into nonprofit leadership requires more than excelling at fundraising. It demands fluency in how the entire organization works. Chief development and philanthropy officers must understand finance, strategy, governance, technology, reputation, and the external forces shaping their mission. The central challenge is not becoming an expert in everything, but learning enough to ask better questions, seek trusted guidance, and make decisions through an organization-wide lens. It is a thoughtful invitation to reconsider what genuine readiness for leadership looks like.
Episode 302: The Why and How to Say NO to a Philanthropic Gift
When should a nonprofit say no to a gift? Financial pressure, donor relationships, reputational risk, and long-term obligations can complicate what first appears to be an easy yes. Thoughtful gift acceptance is not an obstacle to philanthropy; it is a safeguard for the organization, donor, and mission. A disciplined process can turn a difficult decision into an act of responsible leadership.
Episode 301: Integrating Program Staff Into Donor Relationships Without Diluting the Philanthropic Process
Major donor conversations are strongest when fundraisers stop treating program experts as an afterthought and start building the relationship together. Shared planning, a unified case for support, clear roles, rehearsal, training, and accountability can turn technical expertise into donor trust. It confronts what can go wrong when teams make promises they cannot keep. The result is a practical look at how nonprofits can connect relationships, mission expertise, and measurable impact without losing sight of the donor.
Episode 300: Communication and Outreach By Generational Need
Donor communication is not a one-size-fits-all. Each generation brings distinct expectations about trust, impact, access, and ease. Let’s explore how nonprofits can use generational tendencies as a starting point and still pay attention to individual preferences and relationships. The real challenge is to stop communicating in the way that is easiest and begin meeting supporters where they are. That shift can turn routine outreach into a more meaningful and lasting connection.
Special 20: The Great Philanthropists - Dolly Parton: Making a Difference Directly
Philanthropy is typically measured by the size of a foundation or the scale of a public gift, but some of its deepest impact happens quietly. Through education, disaster relief, scholarships, and personal opportunity, Dolly Parton’s example reveals how generosity can change the course of individual lives without waiting for an institution to intervene.
Episode 299: Looking to Create Accountability for the Team: Here is how to do it
Accountability is often mistaken for control, but its real power comes from alignment, clarity, and mutual commitment. This episode explores why realistic goals, regular conversations, and early intervention help teams move from mere activity to meaningful accomplishment. It also reframes accountability as a form of development to strengthen individuals, build trust, and improve organizational performance. For leaders navigating a new role or trying to elevate an existing team, there are practical ways to turn expectations into shared progress.
Episode 298: Qualification: The Difference Between Interest and Philanthropic Interest
Qualification isn't just about finding out what a donor is interested in, it's about discovering what they want to change, improve, or accomplish through philanthropy. In this episode, Randall breaks down the difference between general interest and genuine philanthropic intent and offers six practical ways to uncover it. The goal isn't simply to move prospects through a pipeline; it's to understand what moves them and become the “sherpa” who helps them get there.
Episode 297: Creating a Quantifiable Risk Assessment for that Significant Solicitation
How much should you actually ask a donor for? Don’t be the fundraiser that lets capacity scores, intuition, or organizational need determine the answer. Take a more disciplined approach: quantify the risk by looking at donor readiness, purpose alignment, amount confidence, relationship strength, and timing. The goal isn't to slow down, it's to reduce uncertainty of asks, increase confidence, and ultimately create more meaningful gifts.
Episode 296: Getting Naming Opportunities Correct
Naming opportunities can be one of the most valuable and most easily mishandled tools in philanthropy. But, before putting a donor's name on a building, you need a process that protects the donor relationship and the organization's future. This episode explores six practical ways to build that process, from valuation and naming tiers to morality clauses and flexibility. The goal isn't only to recognize today's donors; it's to make decisions that will still make sense 30, 40, or 50 years from now.
Episode 295: The Need for Internal Collaboration with Donor Strategy
Gift officers can easily become isolated in the very work that requires the most strategic thinking. Moves management meetings often become reporting sessions instead of collaborative problem-solving opportunities. However, leaning into vulnerability, smaller portfolios, and a simple “bounce-off” approach can change that. The goal isn’t better metrics; its helping donors discover the next step to making an impact on the things they deeply care about.
Episode 294: Fighting the Familiarity Paradigm to Lead Change
Great leaders are often hired to create change but organizations want transformation without the discomfort that comes with it. In this episode, Randall explores the “familiarity trap” and why boards, teams, and leaders unintentionally pull change agents back toward the status quo. Learn six practical ways to stay focused on transformation, build trust, distinguish resistance from wisdom, and accept that meaningful leadership rarely comes without some discomfort.
Episode 293: Do we realize that women are the key to the next 25-50 years of philanthropy?
The next great shift in philanthropy may not be about younger donors. It may be about who makes the decisions. Women increasingly influence financial decisions and are positioned to inherit (and ultimately direct) enormous amounts of wealth. Fundraisers need to rethink how they build relationships with couples, surviving spouses, and families.
Episode 292: Are We Giving Donors All the Options, Vehicles, to Give?
The difference between a good gift and a transformative one is not a donor’s generosity, it is the way we help them see what is possible. This episode explores how a fundraiser helped a donor move beyond a narrow view of giving and consider a broader funding strategy rooted in values, timing, business identity, and community impact. When we present thoughtful options instead of assumptions, we may unlock a better path for the donor and a deeper outcome for the mission. It is a reminder that meaningful philanthropy often begins with better questions.
Episode 291: Taking Over A GO’s Portfolio: Easier Than You Might Think
What happens when a trusted gift officer leaves and someone new inherits the portfolio? Too often, new fundraisers worry they're replacing a beloved relationship when, in reality, they're continuing a donor's commitment to a mission they already believe in. Why are donors more connected to organizations than individuals? Understanding these five practical strategies will make portfolio transitions seamless, donor-centered, and successful.
Episode 290: When Absolutely Necessary – The Why and How of Changing the Nonprofit Mission
There is a tension many nonprofit leaders feel but rarely name: when a mission statement remains sacred, even after the organization’s work has evolved. Mission change should be rare, careful, and rooted in identity rather than opportunity. It’s not about finding new language. The most important statement should accurately reflect who they are, what they do, and why their work matters now. For leaders navigating strategy, donor trust, and community need, consider this thoughtful framework for knowing when a mission is still guiding the work and when it may be holding the organization back.
Episode 289: The Seven Deadly Sins and the Relationship to Philanthropy
What do the Seven Deadly Sins have to do with fundraising? More than you might think. Pride, greed, envy, wrath, sloth, and the others quietly find their way into nonprofit leadership, donor relationships, and fundraising strategy. This limits an organization's ability to fulfill its mission. Let’s dive in and find out how these timeless human tendencies show up in philanthropy and look at a practical framework for recognizing and overcoming them.
Episode 288: The Donor Wants to Give: Why Aren't We Asking?
Most fundraising challenges don't stem from a lack of generous donors. They stem from never extending the right invitation. Organizations stay trapped in endless cultivation meetings, updates, and tours because they haven't uncovered what truly motivates a donor to give. The best solicitations are never surprises. Discovery should replace persuasion and six practical strategies can help donors accomplish the impact they already want to make.
Episode 287: Happy Birthday America: Celebrating Freedom Around the World and with Philanthropy
As America celebrates its 250th birthday, it's worth reflecting on something even bigger than our nation's history: the enduring value of freedom. In this special episode we explore how freedom has shaped civilizations, why it requires constant stewardship, and how philanthropy is one of its greatest expressions. From the Declaration of Independence to today's nonprofit leaders, choosing to serve others is one of the highest forms of freedom.
Episode 286: The Use of Data and Removing Bias - Known and Unknown
Artificial intelligence and predictive analytics are transforming fundraising, but better technology does not automatically create better decisions. Let’s look at how bias, incomplete records, flawed assumptions, and overreliance on data models can lead organizations to overlook promising donors and opportunities. Fundraisers need to think critically about the information feeding their systems. Data should inform decisions, not replace human judgment, relationships and thoughtful strategy.
Episode 285: Mapping Donor Networks: Influencer Dynamics
Many fundraising conversations focus on the donor sitting across the table, but rarely are major philanthropic decisions made by one person alone. Spouses, children, attorneys, financial advisors, and trusted friends often shape the timing, confidence, and ultimate outcome of a gift. This episode explores how understanding those influence networks can remove hidden obstacles, strengthen donor relationships, and help donors make the decisions they already want to make. The best fundraisers aren't asking for gifts, they're helping donors navigate the people and dynamics that surround every significant decision.
Episode 284: The Donor Waltz Three Conversation Sequencing that Builds Momentum
Fundraising is relationship building, but too many donor conversations feel disconnected, repetitive, and transactional. Enter the “Donor Waltz”. A three-step sequence of conversations designed to move donors from discovery to alignment, to meaningful commitment. Donors experience philanthropy emotionally, not operationally, and organizations that fail to find the emotional journey risk losing momentum, trust, and transformational opportunities. When fundraisers learn to sequence conversations, donor relationships begin to feel less like a checklist and more like a partnership.
Special 19: The Great Philanthropists - Andrew Carnegie: The Starting Point of Modern Philanthropy
Andrew Carnegie did not believe philanthropy was simply about relieving immediate need. He believed it was about creating opportunities that could create generational change. In this special episode, we look at how Carnegie’s philosophy shaped modern giving through libraries, education, research, and long-term investment in human potential. Challenging nonprofits to think beyond short-term charity and ask a harder question. Are we only responding to problems, or are we helping people escape them? A reflection on wealth, responsibility, and the deeper purpose of philanthropy.
Episode 283: Qualification Calls – Meetings: Getting to the Point and Not Wasting Time or Resources
Fundraisers often spend enormous amounts of time pursuing prospects who will never make a gift. Not because they lack capacity, but because nobody properly qualified their intent. In this episode, we look at one of the biggest hidden problems in fundraising: confusing wealth with philanthropic interest. Let’s explore how better qualification questions, smaller portfolios, and clearer disqualification standards can improve donor relationships and fundraising outcomes. Effective fundraising is not about collecting more names, it’s about identifying alignment and moving the right relationships forward.
Episode 282: A Physical Stewardship Matrix: Creating, Having, and Using One
Most nonprofits talk about stewardship, but few can actually show you a structured plan for how it happens. In this episode, we explore the idea of a donor stewardship matrix. A simple but powerful framework that brings clarity, accountability, and consistency to donor relationships. Stewardship is no longer just about thank-you letters; it’s about creating intentional systems that deepen trust, improve retention, and ensure donors feel connected to the impact they make possible. A practical reminder that meaningful philanthropy often depends less on grand gestures and more on disciplined follow-through.
Episode 281: Podcast 300 - Fighting a Failure of Imagination
A tragedy in the Apollo program revealed a powerful truth: the greatest failures aren’t always technical; they’re failures of imagination. In this milestone 300th episode, Randall challenges nonprofit leaders to rethink how they see risk, innovation, and the future itself. Drawing lessons from NASA and the space race, he outlines five practical ways to break free from limiting assumptions and uncover new possibilities. Because in a rapidly changing world, the organizations that thrive won’t just react, they’ll imagine what others never considered.
Episode 280: Truly Fighting the Term Overhead in our Nonprofit Work
Nonprofits don’t have an overhead problem, they have a narrative problem. When organizations obsess over keeping costs low, they often starve the very investments that drive growth, impact, and long-term sustainability. The truth is simple: low cost does not equal high impact. The organizations that truly move the needle are the ones willing to reframe overhead as strategic investment and communicate that clearly to donors, boards, and stakeholders.
Episode 279: Succession Planning at All Levels: How to Not Get Caught in Bad Transition
Succession planning isn’t just a CEO issue. It’s a frontline necessity in a nonprofit sector where turnover is constant and stability is fragile. When organizations fail to plan, they risk revenue disruption, donor attrition, and cultural erosion that can take years to rebuild. The strongest nonprofits don’t react to transitions. They prepare for them by developing internal talent, protecting relationships, and creating clear operational frameworks. Done right, succession planning isn’t about replacing people. It’s about strengthening the entire organization before change ever happens.
Episode 278: Fractional Work: How to Make It Work
Fractional employees are quickly becoming a practical solution for nonprofits facing talent shortages and budget constraints, but they’re not a simple fix. This episode explores how fractional roles can unlock high-level expertise without full-time costs, while also exposing the hidden risks to continuity, culture, and donor relationships. The key insight: success isn’t about whether you use fractional talent, but how intentionally you design and manage it.
Episode 277: Where Advocacy Ends - Good and Lobbying Begins - Bad
Nonprofits often hesitate to engage in public policy, fearing they might cross into prohibited territory. But the real risk may be staying silent. Missing opportunities to shape the very systems that define their impact. This episode reframes advocacy as a strategic, mission-aligned responsibility, showing how organizations can influence policy through education, data, and relationships without engaging in direct lobbying. When done thoughtfully, policy engagement becomes not a distraction, but a powerful extension of a nonprofit’s mission.
Episode 276: Shooters Keep Shooting: How to Overcome that Fundraising Drought
Every fundraiser eventually hits a drought. Calls go unanswered, meetings stall, and momentum disappears. In those moments, the instinct is to hesitate, to overthink, or to pull back entirely. But the most successful fundraisers operate like great shooters: they keep showing up, trusting that consistent effort, not short-term results, drives long-term success. This episode explores the psychology behind those slumps and offers practical ways to stay confident, consistent, and moving forward when nothing seems to be working.
Episode 275: Emotional Quotient-Intelligence in Philanthropy – the Office, Donors, and Teamwork
Emotional intelligence isn’t a “soft skill” in nonprofit work. It’s the foundation of everything that works. In a field built entirely on relationships, the ability to read the room, manage your own reactions, and understand others often determines success more than strategy or data. The challenge is that most organizations talk about it, but few build it intentionally. This episode breaks down how developing emotional intelligence (personally and organizationally) can quietly transform performance, culture, and long-term impact.
Episode 274: The Importance of Culture: How to Ensure the Right One to Drive Results
Talent alone doesn’t determine success – culture does. The same individual can struggle in one environment and thrive in another, not because their ability changed, but because the system around them did. Over time, what’s tolerated becomes the norm, and those patterns quietly shape performance, trust, and retention. The real question isn’t whether culture matters, it’s whether you’re shaping it intentionally or letting it shape you.
Episode 273: Has Fundraising Work Really Changed much in 50 Years: A Question to be Answered
Episode 272: The Fundraisers Bill of Rights - What we Should be Looking for to Achieve Success
Most fundraisers know the Donor Bill of Rights – but what about the Fundraiser’s Bill of Rights? It’s about the organization behind them. Leadership engagement, board functionality, strategic clarity, data systems, realistic expectations, and culture all shape whether philanthropy can thrive. The real question isn’t simply “Can this fundraiser raise money?” but “Is this organization built to support fundraising success?” When those pieces align, philanthropy becomes a shared responsibility — and the mission moves forward.
Episode 271: Communication Fatigue in a Hyperconnected World - Better mass communication tactics
In a world of overflowing inboxes and nonstop notifications, nonprofits risk becoming part of the noise. Tackle donor fatigue head-on. Most organizations don’t have a generosity problem. They have an attention and trust problem. With six practical tactics, Randall outlines how to audit communications, segment by motivation (not wealth), rebalance ask-to-impact ratios, create quiet periods, clarify priorities, and even let donors choose their preferences. The solution isn’t more creativity or more volume – it’s more discipline. Do less, do it better, and build relationships that last.
Episode 270: Using Faith Based Fundraising Lessons in Secular Organizations
Faith-based giving and secular nonprofits aren’t opposites. They share a powerful common thread: values. Today, we explore how nonprofits can learn from faith-driven philanthropy without becoming religious organizations. The key is aligning with a donor’s core motivations (identity, legacy, duty, compassion) and designing language, stories, and discovery questions that tap into that deeper connection. When you move beyond transactions and speak to values, you unlock loyalty, retention, and transformational giving. Done well, this approach strengthens relationships today and opens the door to long-term legacy support tomorrow.
Episode 269: Peer to Peer Fundraising: Expectations and Getting It Right
Peer-to-peer fundraising isn’t a magic fix for struggling nonprofits. It’s a strategy that requires discipline, clarity, and real support. In this episode, Randall breaks down what peer-to-peer fundraising is, where organizations overestimate its impact, and why it often underperforms. From building the right case to stewarding volunteers like donors, he outlines seven tactical steps that separate sustainable pipeline growth from volunteer fatigue. Done poorly, it creates frustration and distrust. Done well, it expands reach, deepens relationships, and strengthens long-term donor development.