Match Made in Manhattan

Katy’s ENGAGED!!! This week, we’re getting into the full engagement story, including the big GGNO the night before, the TikTok “leak,” and how Colbie and Adam kept the big secret. Plus, is everyone smoking again?! Meanwhile, college students are apparently trading traditional darties for wellness darties (WHAT?!), and we’re sharing our thoughts on Earle Meets World and Sterling Point.

Advice segment: If you need advice on a situation, or have a wild story to share - email matchmadepodcast@gmail.com with subject line “ADVICE SEGMENT” where we will pick stories to answer each week (anonymously...

Are we buying diamonds on Tiktok?! In this episode, Harry Styles is out-walking us all, Katy is officially in her "hoe phase" ?! and Colbie’s Nintendogs are… famished. The girls debate TikTok diamonds and lab-grown vs. natural, offer some unsolicited feedback for Ms. Hailey Bieber, and prepare Colbie for her upcoming face scan. Plus, the question on everyone’s mind: will we ever actually see Taylor swift's wedding photos?

Advice segment: If you need advice on a situation, or have a wild story to share - email matchmadepodcast@gmail.com with subject line “ADVICE SEGMENT” where we will pick...

Montauk Coffee Guy is back… or is he? This week on the pod, Adam recaps his latest Hamptons excursion, including somehow getting a deal on his ticket, and we debate whether Surf Lodge is actually overrated. Colbie may or may not completely ruin Adam’s birthday surprise, Adam takes what he believes is the best photo of his life and immediately clocks the gays in the background as potential new love interests, and we get into the trials and tribulations of waxing. Adam then considers getting waxed exactly where you think… and we debate whether anyone should ever put themse...

Colbie has a new man… maybe. This week on the pod, Adam admits he loves a fake soft launch, Katy gives us her thoughts on Sterling Point, and Colbie recaps her 30th birthday banger. Adam lowers his age range on Hinge and somehow ends up twerking at Taco Bell Cantina, and we close things out by diving into the internet rabbit hole that is Pizzagate. All of that and more on this week’s episode of Match Made in Manhattan.

Advice segment: If you need advice on a situation, or have a wild story to share - emai...

Colbie’s cheeks are out and Ms. New Booty has officially arrived. This week on the pod, Katy reflects on a very celeb-filled movie premiere featuring Callum Turner and company, Adam makes the case that maybe we all need to protect our peace a little less and simply say yes, and we unpack why the Surf Lodge becomes increasingly humiliating the more you think about it. We also debate one of dating’s most important logistical questions: is it better to plan a date weeks in advance or keep things spontaneous? All of that and more on this week’s epis...

The giggles have taken over. This week on the pod, Katy receives a truly unforgettable Band-Aid bouquet, Colbie’s trips to brooklyn are cursed, and Adam recaps a full rodeo of a night at Flaming Saddles that involved a DJ who was simply just… bravo. We also tackle the hard-hitting question of the week: chest hair y or n? All of that and more on this week’s episode of Match Made in Manhattan.

Advice segment: If you need advice on a situation, or have a wild story to share - email matchmadepodcast@gmail.com with subject line “...

It's the Colbie and Adam special! This week on the pod, Colbie and Adam unpack the mass hysteria over lettuce in NYC, Adam recounts ~the love seat~, and we determine that the love doctor was, unfortunately, not doctoring. Adam also gets an unexpected text from one of Colbie’s old flames, and Colbie and Adam celebrate re-signing their lease by debating whether they should finally redecorate, or leave everything exactly as it is. All of that and more on this week’s episode of Match Made in Manhattan.

Advice segment: If you need advice on a situation, or h...

Are facelifts our future hobby? This week on the pod, we map out our eventual cosmetic procedures, Adam gives a dating update, and we revisit the ever-expanding lore of Montauk Coffee Guy. We also ask ourselves a surprisingly difficult question: do any of us actually have hobbies? Colbie recounts getting a chemical burn, and a listener writes in wondering whether she should be offering to pay on dates. All of that and more on this week’s episode of Match Made in Manhattan

Advice segment: If you need advice on a situation, or have a wild story to s...

Wedding bells or just good PR? This week on the pod, we debate what a Taylor and Travis wedding at MSG would actually look like, crown the most problematic Kardashian/Jenner, and wonder whether Adam accidentally agreed to go on a date with someone in a cult. We also take relationship notes from Paige Lorenze, discuss the Hinge epidemic of guys who never actually ask you on a date, and help a listener navigate the impossible situation of being in love with her best friend. All of that and more on this week’s episode of Match Made in Ma...

You know what they say about boys with J-names… This week on the pod, Colbie spills the tea after hanging out with the cast of Off Campus (including Mika and Josh), Adam recaps his Pride weekend—including getting whacked in the face before making an Irish exit—and we take a trip down memory lane as Colbie and Katy revisit their teenage ombré hair eras while Adam comes to terms with going gray. Katy also shares everything from her Japan adventure, from showing up way too early at the airport (Adam was right), to designer handbag purchases, red wine mishaps...

Take out the TRASH! This week on the pod, Colbie and Adam have a garbage problem, Katy prepares for her trip to Japan with an extra suitcase, a willingness to try fish, and a deep fear of accidentally offending someone. Adam somehow ends up bringing everyone to the basement, we debate whether a recent outing was a Knicks game or a chair convention, and get into the proper etiquette of the Irish exit. Plus, a listener writes in wondering whether she should attend her friend’s wedding ceremony at all, and we help her think through the dilemma. All of...

It’s wine o’clock! This week on the pod, Katy returns from England after what can only be described as a pie crawl and is now casually considering a wedding in the Cotswolds. Colbie is on a mission for the perfect gas station iced coffee, we unpack the absolutely baffling Surf Lodge x Popeyes collaboration, and Adam shares a run-in with someone who may—or may not—have been a Tinder Swindler. Plus, after years of struggle, Adam finally gets his skin fixed and has never been more powerful. All of that and more on this week’s episode of...

You’re cute jeans! This week on the pod, we break down all the chaos from the Summer House reunion, including the drama between West and Amanda vs. Ciara and Kyle, while Adam shares a bold decision involving his trip to Mexico. We also relive his travel disasters, dive into a spirited debate about wedding culture and whether destination weddings are actually selfish, and hear how Colbie somehow managed to lose a fight with a golf cart. Plus, she spots Eli Manning out in the wild, and we help a listener decode what it really means when a guy su...

This week on the pod, Adam is being terrorized by Colbie’s possessed hatch sound machine, meanwhile, Katy is preparing to cosplay as a bat on her next flight. The trio helps one listener decide whether it’s time to break up with her boyfriend… and another listener decide if the dreaded triple-text is ever worth it.

Advice segment: If you need advice on a situation, or have a wild story to share - email matchmadepodcast@gmail.com with subject line “ADVICE SEGMENT” where we will pick stories to answer each week (anonymously - always). And don’t forget to...

We’ve officially reached the point where we know way too much about each other… while somehow still learning alarming new information every week. This week on the pod, Adam is feeling suspiciously confident, Colbie gives a life and job update, and Adam makes a horrifying discovery about his “chapstick.” Katy and Jack enter a heated dispute over a horse, Colbie recaps a Williamsburg date, and we discuss the concept of increasing your “surface area of luck” when it comes to dating and life. We also unpack Blake Lively at the Met Gala and all the discourse surrounding it. All of that...

This week on the pod, Katy proves she’s shockingly skilled with a plunger, Colbie announces her new job (and her rise as a LinkedIn influencer), and Adam debates whether it’s time to finally do something about his eyebrows. We decide it might be time to find new bars in NYC, talk dating lives, and what it actually feels like to date when you’re both so busy you’re basically ships in the night. All of that and more on this week’s episode of Match Made in Manhattan.

Advice segment: If you need advice on a situa...

Wedding crashers but make it NYC dating. This week on the pod, Colbie and Adam go on a Chelsea adventure while the trio unpacks the sudden rise of posture correctors. We recap Colbies prom party, reflect on some very questionable high school spirit week themes, and talk the most elite songs on our lists these days. We also break down the Sean Kingston family fraud situation, and a listener writes in about feeling uneasy on what should be the best day of her sister’s life. All of that and more on this week’s episode of Match Made in M...

Coachella chaos, Bieber takes, and influencer sightings in the wild. Colbie lands at LAX (cardigan included) and gives the unfiltered Coachella recap - what people don’t tell you, plus a borderline spiritual Bieber moment. We debate whether his “chill” set would be praised if he were a woman, get into Alix Earle vs. Alex Cooper (real beef or PR stunt?), and end with our excitement for prom weekend. All this and more on this weeks match made!

Advice segment: If you need advice on a situation, or have a wild story to share - emai...

Five years (almost). This week on the pod, we celebrate Match Made in Manhattan’s 5-year anniversary (5 months early) mourn the tragic theft of Adam’s bagel, and lay out our very strong opinions on the do’s and don’ts of bridal parties and bachelorettes. Adam recaps a recent date and raises some controversial questions. We also break down the eternal debate of paid vs. unpaid Hinge and which one actually gets the people goin. All of that and more on this week’s episode of Match Made in Manhattan!

Advice segment: If you need advice on a situa...

Are we sweating for wellness or for attention? This week on the pod, we debate performative saunas and heated workouts, Katy threatens to remove Adam from her close friends story, and we unpack the bizarre but very real concept of “step friends.” We’re gearing up for a full NYC bachelorette weekend, praising The RealReal while Adam spirals over the dragonfly blazer he returned and will never emotionally recover from, and of course, he runs into an ex flame at a bar with Colbie because the universe loves to give you chaos when you're in Williamsburg. We take a detour...

Today’s theme: ghosting. Katy is reflecting on the anti-ghost text she’d use with men, Adam is MIA in the 'land down under' and Colbie is avoiding her taxes. Katy reveals the truth about her vacation and how it affected her relationship. The girls relive their run-in with Aly and AJ, the Hannah Montana 20th anniversary special, and a discussion about whether a ‘reboot’ is always (or ever) necessary. Colbie remembers her DIY ring-back tone. The girls also help a listener figure out what to do about a friend who may or may not be ghosting her. 

Advice...

Something feels… off this week. On the pod, we investigate the suspicious behavior happening on people’s close friends stories, give our thoughts on a certain rumored celebrity relationship, and Colbie brings up the male loneliness epidemic which takes us in several unexpected directions. We play a round of fruit love island (punch the monkey makes an appearance), relive our college glory days of Tour de Franzia, and unpack the absolute chokehold one specific Free People bralette had on our overall era. Adam shares a controversial take, and a listener writes in about an Airbnb situation involving a very ques...

Reunited and it feels so good. This week on the pod, Colbie returns after two weeks away and Adam confirms life is simply better when she’s back, which naturally leads us to planning an overdue Admin Night (taxes, life logistics, and… Botox). We unpack the horrors of lymphatic drainage, Colbie reveals she’s hosting a full-blown prom, and the promposals are slated to get out of hand with the inclusion of the infamous balloon saloon. We dish out advice to a listener who writes in after catching the guy she’s seeing kissing another girl. All of this and more...

A DRAG PATHHHH. This week on the pod, Adam and Katy dive into drag paths, Adam decides he’s purchasing a Hamptons house, and the Hillstone closing rumors send him into a full crash out. We talk paying for Hinge, which naturally leads us into a deep dive on dating older men and a nostalgic stroll down memory lane to our League era. We also ask the hard-hitting question: are first dates actually enjoyable, or are we all pretending? Plus, we weigh in on a listener’s wedding dilemma that has us surprisingly divided. All of that and more on t...

Have you ever wondered if men’s underwear can actually change your life… This week on the pod: we investigate the lore of men’s underwear and the mystical powers of Skims, Adam streaks during the blizzard, and he and Katy unpack the psychological damage of elementary school fitness tests (why were they grading us like Olympians?). Adam introduces us to the concept of “Circuit Gays” while questioning what kind of gay he even is, and Katy learns what “chopped” means, live, in real time. We close it out by helping a listener get a deeply embarrassing moment off her chest, bec...

Have you ever hit it off with someone at a party… and then realized you introduced them as the wrong name to everyone with a pulse at the party all night? No? Just Adam? Okay. This week on the pod: Adam has a meet-cute moment at a NYFW party that turns into a social identity crisis, and the trio debates whether it’s ever acceptable to lie at a party (and how far is too far). We get into a very honest conversation about Plan B, Adam decides he’s going to learn a new language, and Colbie admits she ne...

Do you wash your new clothes before wearing them… or are you living on the edge? This week on the pod: Dr. Dennis Gross tells Adam he needs botox, Katy channels her inner homesteader with a parsnip stew era, and Colbie and Adam nearly end their friendship over the correct pronunciation of “missile.” Adam forgot to pay his electric bill and prepares to be cheeks-out in Miami, while Colbie has a full-blown Super Bowl revelation that absolutely no one saw coming. Meanwhile, Adam unpacks the complicated dynamic of having a Barry’s stalker who may or may not know his name...

Nothing strikes fear like a silence that lasts one beat too long. This week on the pod, we break down how to survive awkward pauses, what to do when you forget someone’s name mid-conversation, and how Katy’s very large tonsils caused her to choke and leave Adam stranded socially. We unpack Katy’s Bridezilla tendencies, Adam dragging his feet on booking flights (but not feelings), and debate whether Colbie wearing butter yellow to a wedding is chic or a crime.

We confirm Colbie and Adam are in a lavender marriage, admit Katy’s deep in her Zill...

If you’re spiraling this winter, welcome. This week on the pod, Adam has a funny run-in with a listener in the wild, Katy commits to the “winter special”, and Adam talks Speedos and his baby tee sweater collection. Colbie catches Adam picking up someone up at a bar (or did she...)

We also hear from a listener who has a divine realization while listening to last week’s episode, and help another listener decide which of two same-day weddings deserves her presence. Fashion mishaps, faith-adjacent moments, and friend-group wisdom – all this and more on this week’s episode of...

Bring your own bible. This week, Katy puts us onto a new mystery show, we spiral into who’s actually profiting off Bible sales, and Colbie declares BYOB now stands for “Buy Your Own Bible.” Adam recaps his non-date date in SF, Colbie defends Spirit Airlines, and Katy gives flowers to a TikTok parody queen. With a blizzard on the way, we're getting Botox, the secret upper-bleph pipeline, and why ponytails deserve legal protection. Plus, a listener says our podcast caused her breakup, and another needs advice about a boyfriend who should not be behind the wheel. All this and mo...

Men want parties and we’re here to deliver. This week on the pod, we share our Traitors thoughts (relax, no spoilers), Katy gears up to throw a party for Jack, and Adam and Colbie declare war on Hinge. We unpack why Tinder’s UI/UX is elite, break down Adam’s ongoing, wordless flirtation with a guy at Barry’s (it’s all in the head nods), and report back that the grapes have, in fact, been working for Adam.

Plus, a listener writes in to tell us she’s now a full-on fiancée after taking our ad...

Rack city bish rack rack city bish. This week on the pod, Colbie casually drops that she flew to Puerto Rico on a whim, Adam admits he’s going through a phase, and we reveal our official words of the year (with varying levels of commitment). We break down a heated rivalry Adam is desperate for straight men to witness, confirm once and for all that Colbie is an ice queen who simply does not cry, and block a full creep live on air. Katy pleads for more time to enjoy her grandma hobbies, we unpack why people are st...

New year, same chaos. This week on the pod, we spiral over our so-called New Year’s resolutions (or lack thereof) and the absolute TRASH we’re already dragging into 2025. We mourn the existence of 2-in-1 washer-dryers, comfort Katy through a social-anxiety spiral, and cheer on Colbie’s undying love for Dance Dance Revolution. Adam reflects on Japan and the norovirus saga he can finally laugh about – while Katy confesses she will absolutely not be participating in Dry Jan, especially after letting an NYU student clean her teeth. We also learn that Colbie once had a full shrine to Teen Vog...

"This is the craziest tea that I've had happen on the podcast". On the pod, we dive into the ...hockey... show Adam and Colbie can't stop watching, attempt to decode the mystery that is “Chungus,” and let Katy break down the solidcore drama that somehow ends with Adam fully blocked on socials. Colbie accidentally sleeps through half her life, Adam delivers a fresh John update, and we unpack the wild DM that slid into his inbox from a listener. Chaos, confusion, and questionable choices… all waiting for you on this week’s episode of Match Made in Manhattan.

Advice...

Adam is on his death bed! This week on the pod, Adam walks us through the saga of his mud coffee and the black plague it summoned, Colbie recounts surviving a horseback riding mishap, and Katy steps fully into her Ina Garten fantasy while dealing with a very inconvenient ceiling leak. We discuss opening a wine bar and drag John for being a smelly-A, process the shocking return of the OG Hillstone man, and share our thoughts on the Turkey Trot Family Prank taking over the internet. Plus, a listener writes in wondering if texting after a second date...

Everyone is gay. This week on the pod: Katy is fresh off her dreamy stay at the Pendry Natirar, Adam recaps a date, and we somehow end up unpacking why he insists on calling literally everyone gay (with love). We debate the all-important question: which date number is the elite date – 1, 2, or 3? Adam cooks for the first time in years and… it did not simmer peacefully. Colbie goes bowling with some bros, and a listener writes in asking if she should worry about her friend copying her vibe a little too closely. All of this and more on this week’s e...

I'm burnin up, for you babyyy. This week on the pod, Colbie and Katy hit the Jonas Brothers Christmas movie world premiere (and Katy meets her favorite TikTok star...). Colbie shoots her shot with the hot DJ, and Adam is now into yodeling music.The group debates dating red flags, and Adam gets his dates mixed up. All of this and more on this week’s episode of Match Made in Manhattan!

Advice segment: If you need advice on a situation, or have a wild story to share - email matchmadepodcast@gmail.com with subject line “ADVICE SEGM...

It’s beginning to look a lot like Christmas… at least in Katy’s apartment?! This week on the pod – We recap the murder mystery party of the season and debate the age-old question: real or fake tree? Adam doubles down on “bring back hanging out at people’s apartments,” and he and Colbie face the now infamous Bug-gate. Plus, which decade will be our peak? Katy’s betting on her 60s, while Adam and Colbie are claiming their 30s and 40s. Finally, a Capricorn listener writes in asking for some business advice. All of this and more on this week’s epis...

Would you date your ex’s best friend?! Colbie and Katy talk about ‘forbidden fruit,’ turning 30 & Colbie’s recent FIRST DATE!! Daylight savings is upon us & Dancing With the Stars is all anyone is talking about. Katy recaps her new decade (so far) and upcoming murder mystery party plans and Colbie loves dancing on tables in Cabo. The girls answer three listener questions, one about getting ghosted, another about a friendship breakup and finally: A listener has a crush on her ex-boyfriend’s best friend. Let’s discuss all of this and more on this episode of Match Made! 

Advice se...

Delia*s graphic tees walked so the Parke sweatshirt could run… Colbie and Katy discuss: which 'group' are you in? Katy is turning 30 and Colbie went back to college. The girls chat King Kylie + Kim K’s bush thongs, and answer two listener questions - one about a lying friend and another about what to do after a crush follows you back on instagram. All of this and more on this episode of Match Made!

Advice segment: If you need advice on a situation, or have a wild story to share - email matchmadepodcast@gmail.com with subje...