Peanut Butter and Biscuits - A Ted Lasso/Shrinking Fancast
Peanut Butter and Biscuits is a fan-driven podcast dedicated to all things Ted Lasso and Shrinking. Hosted with warmth and humor, the show breaks down each episode of the series, explores its themes, celebrates the characters, and shares behind-the-scenes insights. It’s a joyful, uplifting listen for fans who want to dive deeper into the show’s heart, humor, and hopeful messages. Rated the top Ted Lasso podcast in 2025.
TED LASSO | Annette Badland returns to Peanut Butter and Biscuits
We are so fortunate to welcome back to the show for the second time this season, Annette Badland. We speak to her on a wild range of topics. Hope you enjoy!
FEATURING: Jeremy Goeckner & Craig McFarland
Named the best Ted Lasso Podcast:
https://podcast.feedspot.com/ted_lasso_podcasts/
Email the show at [email protected]
Join the Facebook group at https://www.facebook.com/groups/3161086474176010
TED LASSO Season 4 | Ep. 10 • Being Alive
Peanut Butter & Biscuits closes our recaps breaking down Ted Lasso Season 4, Episode 10: “Being Alive”
It's a time of goodbyes and a time of new beginnings as changes come in bunches in our Season 4 finale. We say a proper goodbye to our dear friend Mae as Ted must answer difficult questions from Henry and everyone must wonder what will become of the pub. Roy receives an exciting offer and must decide where his heart lies. Zelda's plot is brought into the light with large consequences for all involved. And Ted makes a fateful decision that will reshape the entir...
TED LASSO Editors A.J. Catoline & Melissa McCoy Talk Season 4
Jeremy and Craig are thrilled to welcome back to the show A.J. Catoline and Melissa McCoy!
The editors of our favorite show are back for more after you DEMANDED their return. Always one of our favorite conversations of a new season, they DO NOT DISAPPOINT yet again.
We ask them all about coming back, the pressure of delivering for the fans, what their favorite parts of Season 4 have been and TONS of behind-the-scenes stories about how the season came together. We ask them about the amazing opening episode in Kansas City, editing Annette Badland's l...
TED LASSO Season 4 | Ep. 9 • Mae Rides The Bus
Peanut Butter & Biscuits continues our recaps breaking down Ted Lasso Season 4, Episode 9: “Mae Rides The Bus”
It's do-or-die time for the Greyhounds. As they await Gemma to get cleared to play, the team finds themselves needing a win at Bristol City to clinch the final promotion spot to the Super League. To accomplish the goal the coaching staff devises a new plan for the twins to open up some offense. Keeley gets some very unexpected news that changes her outlook on the future. Ted invites Mae to join the team in their road trip to Bristol to give...
TED LASSO Season 4 | Ep. 8 • Follow the Anger
Peanut Butter & Biscuits continues our recaps breaking down Ted Lasso Season 4, Episode 8: “Follow the Anger”
TThe Lady Greyhounds face a tough challenge after a painful setback, forcing the team to process deeper frustrations rather than simply bouncing back with immediate optimism.
Jeremy is off working this week, so Zoey joins Craig to break all this down. We finally get some resolution to Roy and Keely, but we get nothing but questions on what lies ahead for Gemma. All of this and MORE lie ahead!
FEATURING: Craig McFarland & Zoey Zara McFarland
N...
TED LASSO Season 4 | Ep. 7 • Yes & Baby
Peanut Butter & Biscuits continues down the recap road breaking down Ted Lasso Season 4, Episode 7: “Yes & Baby”
The holiday break is over and it’s time for the team to get back to work. But it’s not all sunshine and rainbows for our Greyhounds. We get close and personal looks at the everyday struggles of our team as they attempt to find a new way forward. But it’s also a time of self-reflection and improvement as Alice and Ted must push themselves out of their comfort zones to grow. Roy and Erin arrive at a nexus point in th...
TED LASSO | Andrea Anders on Michelle Lasso and her career
Jeremy and Craig are thrilled to welcome Andrea Anders, who joins us for a special Peanut Butter & Biscuits conversation you won't want to miss!
Andrea gives us the inside scoop on playing Michelle Lasso in Ted Lasso — including all of the major revelations and emotional turns from Season 4, Episode 6. We dig into Michelle’s journey, her relationship with Ted, and what it was like stepping back into one of the most complicated relationships in the Ted Lasso universe.
But there’s plenty more beyond Richmond. Andrea takes us through her journey from the Midwest to Hollywood, her...
TED LASSO Season 4 | Ep. 6 • Don't Jump Around Much Anymore
Peanut Butter & Biscuits continues down the recap road breaking down Ted Lasso Season 4, Episode 6: “Don't Jump Around Much Anymore”
It's New Year's Eve and it's a night of reckoning for many. The Lady Greyhounds are invited to a lavish yacht party thrown in their honor by Zelda that proves to be too weird by far. Alice has a hard time convincing herself to go but tries to open herself up to the team. Rebecca, Keeley and Roy celebrate with an old friend which turns out requiring a trip to the hospital. Rebecca comes to grips with what she l...
TED LASSO Season 4 | Ep. 5 • Riches of Embarrassment
Peanut Butter & Biscuits continues down the recap road breaking down Ted Lasso Season 4, Episode 5: “Riches of Embarrassment”
The Lady Greyhounds are prepping fro their big FA Cup matchup with the mighty Chelsea. But when Margy and Mady see Ted eating alone it sparks a need for the whole team to learn more about their manager and Ted to confront exactly where he is in his life. This also sparks some kind of insecurity in Alice that quickly spirals out of hand. Not to be left out, Beard finally gives in and sees Jane's show and Rebecca is throw...
Annette Badland on Mae in Season 4 & Why The World Still Needs Lasso
We couldn't be happier to welcome Mae Green herself, Annette Badland to the podcast! She is literally the best freaking person alive and we had a wonderful conversation not just about Lasso but her entire career. We talk her roots at the Globe Theatre in the Royal Shakespeare Company, her favorite roles, how that warped her to the sci-fi world of Doctor Who and finally to our favorite bar in Richmond.
We also ask her all about Season 4! How she got the call that she was returning, what feels different about this season, what her new character...
TED LASSO Season 4 | Ep. 4 • Greyhounds’ Day Off
Peanut Butter & Biscuits continues down the recap road breaking down Ted Lasso Season 4, Episode 4: “Greyhounds’ Day Off”
Despite a run of success to start the season, all things are not clicking for the Lady Greyhounds as cliques have started to form based on positions and they are threatening to tear the team apart. The coaches have to come up with a way to break up the cliques to unlock the team’s true potential. Meanwhile, Roy and Keeley arrive at an ultimatum point as Keeley wants Roy to go on 10 dates to make sure he’s ready to get back...
TED LASSO Season 4 | Ep. 3 • Richmond's Got Talent
Peanut Butter & Biscuits continues down the recap road breaking down Ted Lasso Season 4, Episode 3: “Richmond's Got Talent”
An unexpected player "absence" leaves the lady Greyhounds without a striker with their first match approaching. As a result the coaches hold an open tryout looking to find some diamonds in the rough and give the team a boost all while Alice attempts to recruit her old teammate Gemma. At the annual shareholders meeting, Keeley must come to grips the obstacles facing the women's team and what it's going to take to make them a success.
This episode, like...
TED LASSO Season 4 | Ep. 2 • Curiouser and Curiouser
Peanut Butter & Biscuits continues down the recap road breaking down Ted Lasso Season 4, Episode 2: “Curiouser and Curiouser”
Ted has officially returned to Richmond to start his journey of coaching the lady Greyhounds. But while it all feels familiar, things have changed and so to must Ted. We meet the curmudgeonly Assistant Manager Alice Chilton, though Ted has his work cut out for himself in winning her over. We get to know the various characters that make up our new team and Rebecca is shook when her feminism credibility is questioned by Alice.
While the first episo...
TED LASSO Season 4 | Ep. 1 • Home
IT. IS. TIME!!!! Ted Lasso has returned and so to has your faithful recapers at Peanut Butter & Biscuits! It's been three years but man it feels like we never left because with Ted back it all feels like.... Home.
We head to the awesome Kansas City for the premiere of season 4 as we see what Ted has been up to since leaving Richmond. But even though time has passed, his old friends from across the pond have come to visit and to ask Ted to return to coach the new women's team. As Ted mulls, we explore K...
TED LASSO | The Countdown to Season Four!
Get your biscuits ready because Ted Lasso is finally back next week! This week on Peanut Butter & Biscuits, Jeremy and Craig celebrate the return of everyone's favorite AFC Richmond family by diving into your biggest hopes, dreams, and predictions for Season 4. From storylines we can't wait to see to characters we're hoping get their moment, it's a celebration of everything that makes Ted Lasso special. Plus, we break down the buzz surrounding the FIFA World Cup halftime show and recap the media blitz that's reunited the cast ahead of the highly anticipated premiere. Believe, and join us as we kick...
WELCOME TO WREXHAM Bonus Episode | Rich from Rob. Ryan. Red. Podcast
We are less than a month away from the return of Ted Lasso! In the meantime, we check in with Rich from the Rob. Ryan. Red. podcast to chat Wrexham. We both have fallen in love with the small town featured on the FX docu-series Welcome to Wrexham. Rich's podcast has been featured prominently in several episodes of the show. We chat the history or Wrexham, the World Cup and try to convince Rich to watch some Ted Lasso!
FEATURING: Craig McFarland and Jeremy Goeckner
Named the best Ted Lasso Podcast:
SHRINKING Bonus Episode | Sarah Lucky and James Renfroe Editors of Shrinking
Peanut Butter & Biscuits returns to Shrinking this week to speak with some of the editors of the show, Sarah Lucky and James Renfroe. They both share with Craig and Jeremy how they got their starts in editing as well as so many moments from the show we all love. This one is a blast and full of fun insights into the world of Shrinking.
FEATURING: Craig McFarland and Jeremy Goeckner
Named the best Ted Lasso Podcast:
https://podcast.feedspot.com/ted_lasso_podcasts/
Email the show at [email protected]
Join the Facebook group at https://www.facebook.co
TED LASSO Season 4 | Teaser Trailer Reactions
A day we've long awaited has arrived! Ted Lasso season four will premier August 5th on Apple TV. Jeremy and Craig break down the teaser trailer released by Apple as well as begin their speculation as to what we might be in for as we return to Richmond.
"In season four, Ted returns to Richmond, taking on his biggest challenge yet: coaching a second division women’s football team. Throughout the course of the season, Ted and the team learn to leap before they look, taking chances they never thought they would."
FE...
BONUS EPISODE: Emily Pendergast from Jury Duty: Company Retreat
Peanut Butter & Biscuits brings you a special one-on-one interview as Craig sits down with Emily Pendergast, who stars as Amy in Jury Duty: Company Retreat.
Emily talks about her journey through comedy, including her time performing with the legendary The Groundlings, and how that background helped shape her performance style and prepare her for the unique world of Jury Duty. She shares her love of comedy, what draws her to character-driven humor, and how improvisation continues to influence her work on screen.
The conversation also highlights her past roles, in...
TED LASSO Bonus Episode | Brendan Hunt talk "The Movement You Need"
Peanut Butter & Biscuits welcomes a very special guest this week—Brendan Hunt. That's right, Coach Beard himself!
A proud Chicago native, Brendan joins Craig and Jeremy to talk about bringing his one-man show, The Movement You Need, to Steppenwolf Theatre Company from April 19 through May 10. The show is a deeply personal, music-infused story that blends memoir, humor, and reflection—exploring Brendan’s journey growing up in Illinois and the moments that shaped him, all underscored by the enduring influence of The Beatles.
Craig and Jeremy dive into Brendan’s roots in the M...
SHRINKING Bonus Episode | Ted McGinley Shrinks!
Peanut Butter & Biscuits goes beyond the recap this week with a special interview featuring Ted McGinley, the man behind everyone’s favorite laid-back legend, Derek, from Shrinking.
Craig and Jeremy sit down with Ted to talk all things Season 3, including a deep dive into his standout episode “Dereks Don’t Die” and how Derek continues to quietly (and hilariously) steal the show. Ted reflects on the heart, humor, and unexpected depth that make the series so special—plus what it’s like being part of such a beloved ensemble.
The conversation also takes a turn through Ted’s...
SHRINKING Season 3 | Ep. 11 • And That's Our Time
Peanut Butter & Biscuits continues down the recap road breaking down Shrinking Season 3, Episode 11: “And That's Our Time”
As Alice is set to leave for college, the entire gang faces unknown horizons. Derek & Liz prepare for their trip, Brian and Charlie prep their move to Tennessee, Sean must tell Jimmy he's moving out, and Gaby and Derek make a HUGE decision. And in the midst of it all, Jimmy attempts to make amends before it's too late and finally find the strength to move forward.
Craig and Jeremy talk about Bill Lawrence's latest comments about season 4, the ef...
SHRINKING Season 3 | Ep. 10 • The Bodyguard of Sadness
Peanut Butter & Biscuits continues down the recap road breaking down Shrinking Season 3, Episode 10: “The Bodyguard of Sadness”
Alice's graduation has arrived and with it make-or-break moments for all. Jimmy's relationship with his father is pushed to the max. Derek & Liz are faced with shocking news that makes them contemplate the rest of their lives. Brian must make a sacrifice for his family. And Paul's impending move lead Jimmy to confront long-simmering feelings whose consequences may be too severe to fix.
Craig and Jeremy talk about their still-dancing Fighting Illini, if 3 month is just WAY TOO LONG f...
SHRINKING Season 3 | Ep. 9 • Daddy Issues
Peanut Butter & Biscuits continues down the recap road breaking down Shrinking Season 3, Episode 9: “Daddy Issues.”
Jimmy is forced to confront some long-buried truths as fatherhood, grief, and growth all collide in ways he can’t avoid. Paul finds himself navigating his own complicated legacy while trying (and sometimes failing) to give the right advice at the right time. Gabby continues to search for solid ground, while the ripple effects of past decisions start catching up with just about everyone.
Craig and Jeremy get through this one like lightning as they both recover from some illness...
SHRINKING Season 3 | Ep. 8 • Depression Diet
Peanut Butter & Biscuits continues down the recap road breaking down Shrinking Season 3, Episode 8: “Depression Diet”.
Gabby deals with the fallout of Maya's death as she has a crisis of confidence and uncertain about future. Paul tries to be there for Gabby through it all. Jimmy has his first "real date" with Sophie... though not really... and Brian & Charlie have been letting Ava stay with them and when Liz finds out, decisions must be made.
Craig and Jeremy read your comments from episode 6, talk about the epic discussion on tablets at the dinner table that emerged in the...
SHRINKING Season 3 | Ep. 7 • I Will Be Grape
Peanut Butter & Biscuits continues down the recap road breaking down Shrinking Season 3, Episode 7: “I Will Be Grape”.
Liz must summon all of her strength to deal with Derek's mother Constance as she visits following his surgery, Paul deals with his Parkinsons becoming bilateral and thinking about his legacy, and Jimmy, Alice & Brian embark on a fun quest on Tia's birthday that will bring Jimmy's long-simmering avoidance of moving forward to a make-or-break point.
Craig and Jeremy read your comments from episode 6, talk about their recent trek to Energizer Park, discuss why indeed is "Dick" short for "Rich...
SHRINKING Season 3 | Ep. 6 • Dereks Don't Die
Jeremy is back from his vacation as Peanut Butter & Biscuits continues down the recap road breaking down Shrinking Season 3, Episode 6: “Dereks Don't Die”.
Jimmy and Meg deal with the fallout of their hook-up; Gabby attempts to introduce Mya to new people; Sean receives a big opportunity; Brian tries to find a way to tell his dad about the baby; Derek has a health scare that makes everyone reexamine what's most important in their lives.
Craig and Jeremy read your comments from episode 5, talk about the strays improv groups are getting in this episode, how hard it is to...
SHRINKING Season 3 | Ep. 5 • Hold Your Horsies
Jeremy is back from his vacation as Peanut Butter & Biscuits continues down the recap road breaking down Shrinking Season 3, Episode 5: “Hold Your Horsies”.
Paul makes preparations for his retirement and Jimmy is being WAY TOO EAGER to help. Meg visits to look for family pictures but has bigger news as well. Sean and Alice deal with their seeming lameness. And a fateful slip of phrase from Derek makes Gabby have second thoughts about their relationship.
Craig and Jeremy read your comments from episode 4, talk about A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms for some reason, give you the...
SHRINKING Season 3 | Ep. 4 • The Field
Jeremy is back from his vacation as Peanut Butter & Biscuits continues down the recap road breaking down Shrinking Season 3, Episode 4: “The Field”.
Jimmy and Gabby must confront simmering emotions in their friendship when she invites him to lecture at her class, Derek winds up in the hospital and Liz reaches her limit with Matthew. Paul is cleared to go back to work but makes an important realization about his life.
Craig and Jeremy read your comments from episode 3, recap Jeremy's time at Epic Universe in Orlando, talk about the ethics of "Jimmying", whether or not 650mg of TH...
SHRINKING Season 3 | Ep. 3 • D-Day
It’s a milestone episode of Peanut Butter & Biscuits as Craig is joined by a very special guest — his lovely wife Zoey — making her official PB&B debut while Jeremy is away this week!
Together, Craig and Zoey break down Shrinking Season 3, Episode 3: “D-Day,” as emotions run high across the board. Jimmy and Liz show up for Brian and Charlie when Ava goes into labour, while Sean reconnects with his ex, Marisol,leading to some powerful moments of growth, vulnerability, and classic Shrinking heart.
Craig and Zoey share their full spoiler-filled reactions, explore what thes...
SHRINKING Season 3 | Ep. 2 • Happiness Mission
This week on Peanut Butter & Biscuits, Craig and Jeremy are back with a full spoiler breakdown of Shrinking Season 3, Episode 2 — an episode that brings the heart, the humor, and some genuinely tough moments.
“The gang unites to support Paul during a health setback; Jimmy and Alice help Louis take a big step; Liz and Derek make a tough choice.”
The guys dig into what this episode means for each character, how those storylines are starting to collide, and why Shrinking continues to balance emotional weight with laugh-out-loud moments better than just about anything on TV.
⚠️ Spo...
SHRINKING Season 3 | Ep. 1 • My Bad
This week on Peanut Butter & Biscuits, Craig and Jeremy dive headfirst into Shrinking Season 3, Episode 1: “My Bad.”
It’s a full spoiler breakdown of the season premiere — from character arcs and emotional beats to the moments that made us laugh, cringe, and immediately want the next episode.
⚠️ Spoiler warning! Make sure you’ve watched the Season 3 premiere before hitting play.
Plus, the boys tease and discuss the launch of their forthcoming Patreon, which will be unveiled next week!
Warm takes, sharp analysis, and the co...
We're back! Shrinking trailer react and life updates
We are back in 2026! Happy New Year! Jeremy and Craig sit down to give you updates on what has been going in their lives for the last six months. They also react to the official Shrinking season three trailer drop, and ponder when we will be getting more Ted Lasso season four news.
Donate to Craig's run charity:
https://basecampchildrenscancerfoundation-bloom.kindful.com/2025ddp4bc/beyond-the-mouse-podcast
FEATURING: Craig McFarland and Jeremy Goecker
Named the best Ted Lasso Podcast:
https://podcast.feedspot.com/ted_lasso_podcas...
Bonus Episode - Craig sits down with Kevin Smith
Craig had the incredible opportunity to sit down with director/podcaster Kevin Smith while he was in Chicago last week. Long time listeners to The Front Row Network know Kevin's impact on inspiring the creation of the network 10 years ago. The two chat about Kevin's impact on his fans, and his perspective on his career and future.
Back with more Lasso/Shrinking content soon! Enjoy this bonus interview.
FEATURING: Craig McFarland
Named the best Ted Lasso Podcast:
https://podcast.feedspot.com/ted_lasso_podcasts/
Email the...
Ted Lasso Season Four Roundtable
Jeremy takes the week off as Craig is joined by Lasso friends from around the world. Marc from The Richmond Way, Tori from They're Soulmates, Dr. Mark from MedLasso and Marita and Michaela from Coach Beard's Book Club all stop by to chat. We discuss our hopes and more hopes for the upcoming season.
FEATURING: Craig McFarland
Named the best Ted Lasso Podcast:
https://podcast.feedspot.com/ted_lasso_podcasts/
Email the show at [email protected]
Join the Facebook group at https://www.facebook.com/groups/3161086474176010
Ted Lasso is in Production for Season Four!
There is new Ted Lasso footage in the universe! Craig and Jeremy go through the recently released Apple press release about where season four is headed, including the new members of the cast that will be joining Ted, Rebecca, Higgins and Keeley. We are so excited!
FEATURING: Jeremy Goeckner & Craig McFarland
Named the best Ted Lasso Podcast:
https://podcast.feedspot.com/ted_lasso_podcasts/
Email the show at [email protected]
Join the Facebook group at https://www.facebook.com/groups/3161086474176010
TED LASSO SEASON FOUR CONFIRMED
Jason Sudeikis just officially confirmed on the New Heights podcast that Ted Lasso will return for season four. Details are limited at this time, but it doesn't mean we can't begin the speculation. Jeremy and Craig break down the comments from Jason, and the official press release put out by Apple. They also talk about the recent addition of Jeff Daniels to Shrinking season 3, as well as provide some updates on what's been going on the last three months in their own lives.
It is time to BELIEVE again!
<...
Luke Tennie Shrinks!
Happy New Year Shrinking fans! Have we got a great gift for you. We recently sat down with Luke Tennie. We spoke to him all about his character Sean, and the evolution he saw in season two. We also spoke to him about his career, and the continued opportunities he has had over the past year. Luke also provided us with some fun behind the scenes insights, including who was originally supposed to play Brett Goldstein's character Louis.
FEATURING: Jeremy Goeckner & Craig McFarland
BUY OUR TEA: https://www.whimsytea.shop/product/breakfast-with-the-boss/535?cp=true&sa=true&sbp=false&q=false...
SHRINKING Season 2 • Episode 12 - The Last Thanksgiving
Hey Lasso and Shrinking fans! We've made it to the end of another season as we're breaking down Episode 12 of Season 2: The Last Thanksgiving.
Jimmy and Paul start working on his road to true forgiveness as Paul pushes Jimmy to come fully clean to Alice about the REAL trauma he can't face. Brian and Charlie enlist Liz to help them find a nanny. Derek works to help Liz find the purpose she's been searching for. As Thanksgiving arrives, Gabby makes one last attempt to reconcile with Derek 2. Alice and Jimmy finally come clean to each other. Paul...
SHRINKING Season 2 • Episode 11 - The Drugs Don't Work
Hey Lasso and Shrinking fans! It's go time as we're breaking down Episode 11 of Season 2: The Drugs Don't Work.
Jimmy must deal with the fallout of Alice finding out about his ultimatum to Louis and it threatens to destroy all of the progress they've made. Brian and Charlie get very unexpected news on the baby front. Paul must confront his fear that his drugs are losing their effectiveness. Derek makes an offer to Sean after learning of a new relationship in his life. Gabby and Derek 2 reach a point of no return as Gabby lets some vital...
