Mums Mysteries & Murder
We're two Mums living in Edinburgh who are obsessed with true crime and mysterious happenings, so obsessed we decided to start a podcast! Each month we take turns to tell stories from our homelands - Cheryl Scottish born and bred where haggis is NOT actually an animal and Marti from the land down under where no prawns have ever been thrown on a barbie, it needs to be said! So, if you want polished, professional true crime then this is not for you, maybe try Casefile. But if you love true crime and mystery like us & you can't stop talking...
Scotland's Dumbest Criminals!
This week we're back with something a little lighter, as we've told a lot of quite heavy stories of late on the pod, so Cheryl brings a little light - as much as you can with a true crime podcast anyway and tells us 3 stories about Scotland's Dumbest Criminals!
Featuring the stories of David Macgregor with his broken hip and suspicious arm through a window.
Garry Ruff - a 28-year-old who robbed a bookie with a questionable weapon?
John Paul Lynch - who just walked out of prison in 2022 but, spoiler, got caught b...
The death of Jayden Penno Tompsett
We resume normal service, and it's Marti's turn this time to tell the story of 22-year-old Jayden, who, on the 29th of December 2017, went on a road trip with friends to celebrate New Year's Eve and the beginning of a new year, but he never made it.
We also talk about the millennium, why sticking pink flamingos on your face is always a good idea and big things on the side of the road. Send us your pics!
Sources for this episode:
Outback murder Highway documentary
Inquest do...
Halloween Special Part 4 with Ishbel Benzie
This week, we welcome Ishbel Benzie, a physiotherapist turned transformational coach, to chat about the world of science and spiritual healing and whether they really need to be kept in separate corners. There's also a lot of "witchy talk!"
Ishbel shares how Reiki, hypnosis, and past-life work became part of her practice, and talks about heart healing, creating a sense of safety, and helping people work through what they’ve been carrying. We also get into ancestral trauma and the idea that some patterns might echo across generations. Big topic for a chat that starts with “so, t...
Halloween Special Part 3 with John Tantalon from North Edinburgh Nightmares
*There is a slight sound issue at the beginning of this ep but it only lasts 30 seconds, so don't worry - we had a bit of a recording issue.
In our third Halloween special, we welcome back friend of the podcast, John from NorthEdinburgh Nightmares, for the third time!
We talk all ghosty things that go bump in the night, along with chat about John's new upcoming book - it's his 6th book. If you'd like to find out more about his books, head to the link at the bottom of our notes
We...
Halloween Special Part 2 with Scotland's Shanty Queen Joss Cameron
In our second Halloween special, we talk to Joss Camerson - also known as the Sea Shanty Queen about the origins of sea shanties, whether Robson Green is actually a dick in real life and her stint on Neighbours!
But it wouldn't be a Halloween special without some creepiness, so we also talk about Spirit Guides, a Banshee story that left us both pretty much speechless and Joss's first book called The Callbearers.
She has got to be one of the most fascinating guests we've ever had on the podcast - we might have to g...
Halloween Special with Wayne from Eerie Edinburgh
Welcome to our first spooky season episode & who better to kick off with than one of our good friends and podcast favourite, Wayne from Eerie Edinburgh, talking all things ghosty in the run up to his new book out in time for Halloween called
The Night Shift - the title is creepy enough for me.
Of course Wayne brings the usual creep - the sleep paralysis demon story is enough to make you sleep with the light on for pretty much forever... and lots of other ghosty, lighthearted chat that you've come to expect from...
The Murder of Margaret Fleming
Trigger warning: This episode contains discussion of the neglect, abuse and murder of a vulnerable young adult.
If you're not in the right place to listen to this episode, please give this one a miss.
In this episode, Cheryl tells the sad story of the murder of Margaret Fleming in the village of Inverkip in Scotland. Margaret was just 19 years old and a vulnerable adult in need of support when she was last seen publicly in December 1999, her body has never been found.
Sources for this episode are:
BBC 1 Programme - M...
The Westfield Shopping Centre Murders - Joel Cauchi
In this episode, Marti takes us to Australia and the devastating 2024 Bondi Junction shopping centre attack.
We look at the story of Joel Cauchi, the 40-year-old man who killed six people and injured ten others in just a matter of minutes, and the questions that followed about his deteriorating mental health, missed opportunities for intervention and why the majority of his victims were women.
We also head down the very dark rabbit hole of incel culture — where it came from, how online communities became increasingly misogynistic, and the violence that has been linked to the id...
Robert Black
Trigger Warning - This episode contains themes of child sexual abuse and the murder of children.
In our SECOND episode of the month!
Cheryl tells the story of Robert Black, the Scottish serial killer and paedophile whose horrifying murderous reign began in the 70s and continued throughout the 1980s.
We also chat about the Edinburgh Fringe, what our Mastermind Subject would be- you'll never guess! And why one of us won't be swimming in the ocean at Portobello anytime soon!
Sources for this episode are:
The Book: Fe...
The Marree Man | Australia's Giant Desert Geoglyph, Our 5th Birthday Episode & A Big Announcement
There's a lot going on in this episode so strap yourself in!
Today - if you're listening on the day this drops we're celebrating five years of Mums Mysteries & Murder... with our 70th episode and we've got a big announcement!
Before we get into the mystery, we're sharing some exciting news about the future of the podcast!
Then we're heading deep into the Australian Outback to investigate one of Australia's strangest unsolved mysteries: The Marree Man.
Stretching over 4 kilometres (2.5 miles) across a remote desert plateau, t...
The First Modern Murder - The Jigsaw Murders
Trigger warning: dismemberment is mentioned in this episode
In 1935, in the town of Moffat, a young woman was out on a walk with her Mother and noticed a bundle wrapped in cloth, which on first glance looked like nothing much, but on further investigation, there were over 70 different body parts wrapped in cloth and newspaper scattered all around the area.
Many historians describe it as one of the first truly modern forensic investigations.
We also talk about what were watching - SO MUCH!
The problem with changing your nam...
The Mysterious Deaths of Dr Bogle & Mrs Chandler
* This episode has a few audio issues, but we know you dont listen to MM&M for perfection so we know you'll love it regardless. This is down to the fact probably that it was not edited by our beloved editor Erin.
Early on the morning of New Year's Day in the Sydney suburb of Chatswood in 1963 2 young boys out looking for golf balls got more than they bargained for when they discovered the half-naked body of a man partially covered by his clothes which had been thrown over the top of him alongside a sq...
The Rabbit Wars Of St Andrews
Come down a rabbit hole with us and listen to the intriguing tale of the Rabbit Wars of St Andrews as told by Cheryl! This story takes us all the way back to 1797 and includes no less than 900 rabbits and the selling of the famous St Andrews Golf Course. Trigger warning - Rabbits will get hurt in this episode
You might have guessed, but this is a slightly lighter episode than our recent episodes. In the words of Cheryl
"It's Downton Abbey with significantly more rabbits!"
We also talk about what makes a great...
The Luna Park Ghost Train Fire
This month, Marti is covering the Luna Park Ghost Train fire in Sydney in 1979, it's one we've wanted to cover for so long because it's not covered by many podcasts, and it's such a sad, interesting story with so many layers..
We also talk about theme park disasters and rollercoasters, Cheryl's disastrous note-taking in the dark, how we're such babies when it comes to scary shit and horror & childrens tv in the 80s - and yes we talk commercials again!
Sources for this episode are:
2021 Documentary - Exposed 3-part documentary The...
The disappearance and death of Corrie Mckeague
It's Cheryl's first story on the podcast, and she goes in hard, covering the horrible disappearance and death of Corrie McKeague in 2016 in Dunfermline, Scotland.
Sources for this episode:
BBC News
FindCorrie.co.uk
The Guardian newspaper website
Wikipedia
We also cover vintage commercials, what we've been watching ( as always! Some things never change! ), the history of Dunfermline, Pokémon adventures, the wrong pronunciation of words, in our opinion, and what was going on in the world in 2016. Quite a big year as it turns out!
Hoste...
The Catfishing Murder of Carly Ryan
We're back!!
Thank you for your patience whilst we took a break and rejigged a little, and now we're back, and Cheryl is joining the Mums Mysteries & Murder team - this is our first episode together, and it's a cracker!
In this episode, we get to know our new co-host Cheryl a little better, and we cover the incredibly sad catfishing murder of Carly Ryan back in 2006, who changed the laws in Australia around online intent.
Sources for this episode include:
The Carly Ryan Foundation - http://www.carlyryanfoundation.com...
Bonus - an alternative sign off - Announcement Part 2
We love Erin's choice of sad music - please don't listen to this until youve listened to our announcement episode
If you're not based in the UK, you might not find it as funny as us, but we had to share.
Send us a text - we'd love to hear your thoughts about this episode & if there are any cases youd like us to cover please get in touch
Hosted by & Researched & written by Marti Jeremiah-Shelley & Effie McDonald
Edited & Produced by Erin Fe...
An Announcement
It's still Christmas, and we have an announcement to make....
Hosted by & Researched & written by Marti Jeremiah-Shelley & Effie McDonald
Edited & Produced by Erin Ferguson https://www.instagram.com/erinfaudio/
Since 2023 ( earlier episodes are badly edited by us!)
Theme Music Vampire Strut by Joybean @AudioJungle
Follow us on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/mumsmysteriesandmurder/
You can also support the pod and buy us a coffee at
https://ko-fi.com/mumsmysteriesandmurder
And we would love it if y...
Christmas Special with Kerrie from North Edinburgh Nightmares
In our Christmas episode, we are absolutely delighted and terrified to be joined by Kerrie, one-half of North Edinburgh Nightmares.
We chat about historical Scotland, ghostly haunts and stories, the Edinburgh dungeon and faeries, a darker type of Christmas, creepy dolls and mannequins and folklore in Scotland, amongst other things.
You can find out more about North Edinburgh Nightmares and Kerrie's work at
https://northedinburghnightmares.wordpress.com/home/
Follow Kerrie on Instagram at https://www.instagram.com/taibhsetales/
And North Edinburgh Nightmares at https://www.instagram.com/north_edinburgh_ni...
The Murder of Barry Wallace & Barry Oldham - live episode with Dawn from Scottish Murders
This is our live episode recorded at Cumbernauld Library as a part of their Killers & Coffee sessions with Dawn from Scottish Murders
And we are covering the tragic case of the murder of Barry Oldham & Barry Wallace in December of 1999.
Trigger warning for this episode: we do touch on decapitation, and if you're Scottish, you might not want to hear me pronounce so many Scottish names wrong!
Sources for this ep are:
Sources - limbs in the loch - catching a killer - can be found on BBC I pla...
Halloween Special with Wayne from Eerie Edinburgh
It's our Halloween Special
And we're absolutely delighted to have Wayne back from Eerie Edinburgh to talk all things ghostly happenings, banshees, witches and Scotland - all of our favourite subjects.
And the best bit - Wayne answers listeners' questions....
Wayne also covers the story of the Haunted Bathroom...
To hear more from Wayne, head to https://eerieedinburgh.com/
Check out his YouTube channel - which we highly recommend, they are like mini films at https://eerieedinburgh.com/youtube-episodes
Follow him on Instagram at https://www.instagram.com...
The Trial of Erin Patterson - Collab Episode with Tam from True Crime Bookcase
We know so many of you have been intrigued by the Erin Patterson case in Australia and have been chatting with us about your thoughts, so when we approached Tam from True Crime Bookcase who attended the trial in Australia recently and is an Erin Patterson guru we were delighted she was up for chatting with us on the podcast.
Tam runs the Instagram account True Crime Bookcase - If you love reading about True Crime, you need to start following her - we've gotten so many brilliant recommendations from her, and she will give you the h...
The Murder of Aileen Printie - Collab with Dawn from Scottish Murders
This was a special live recording at Airdrie Library for their Killers & Coffee series back in July with Dawn from Scottish Murders.
Trigger warning: We do discuss suicide in this episode.
In this episode, Dawn tells the heartbreaking story of the murder of Aileen Printie in Edinburgh back in 1981.
Aileen was found murdered in her bedroom, discovered by her Mum and sister in August of 1981 in the Longstone area of Edinburgh. She was only 31 years old.
We also talk about the 80's, sunbeds and what to do when you're bored...
The Murder of Scott Johnston
Trigger warning: In this episode, we talk a lot about suicide. Please skip this episode if you're not in the right place to listen. Discussions of homophobia in Australia in the 80s is also heavily featured, so please take note.
We are covering the murder of Scott Johnston - Born in California on the 27th of November 1961 - he had such a promising future ahead of him, until he moved to Australia in the 80s.
We also talk about what we're watching to lighten the mood,
Australia in the 80s and how...
The Unusual Experiences of Sir Robert Victor Goddard
This month, Effie tells the story of British Military Hero Sir Robert Victor Goddard and the unusual events that plagued his very dramatic life.
Sources for this episode are: the book
Flight Towards Reality by Sir Robert Goddard.
We also talk time slips, Daniel Radcliffe's time travelling, the unbelievable responsibility of teenage boys in wartime, health and safety - don't worry, it's more exciting than it sounds, Effie's "gift" and disappearing ghost cars!
Oh yes, it's a very mysterious episode!
We also feature a promo for Murder Mile UK...
The Legend of Fishers Ghost
This month Marti is covering a request from our good friend Wayne over at Eerie Edinburgh whose advert you will have heard at the top of the episode.
It's a slightly different one for Marti, its a very vintage story based in 1826, in Campbelltown, a small city located on the outskirts of Sydney where a young man sees a ghost, but the ghost isn't just any ordinary ghost....
We'd love to hear your thoughts on this one..
We also talk about what we've been reading:
I Found A Body - we coul...
The Life & Almost Death of Maggie Dickson
In this month's episode, Effie takes us through the extraordinary life and almost death of Maggie Dickson born in 1702, a fishhawker living in Musselburgh, abandoned by her husband Maggie had a difficult life, but that's nothing compared to her ( almost death.)
Sources for this episode are:
Edinburgh Reporter
Beheaded podcast
The Hanging of Maggie Dickson - Book
Clan Broonfield - on YouTube
The Scotsman
The National Library of Scotland
Shows we talked about - Christopher Wilder - The Beauty Queen Killer
Forrest Fenn's Treasure Hunt...
The Wanda Beach Murders
Trigger warning This episode contains themes of sexual abuse, child murder & suicide.
This month Marti covers the Wanda Beach murders which happened in 1965 in Cronulla Sydney, when two young teenage girls caught the train to the beach with their siblings and never came home.
The murders of Christine Sharrock & Marianne Schmidt.
We also talk about one of Australia's most prolific serial killers.
We of course also talk about what we are watching, his Highness Micheal Sheen, lone shoes & weird things found on beaches!
Were going...
The Murder of Elaine Doyle
We're back for 2025!!!!
Did you miss us?
We're kicking off the year with the devastating murder of 16-year-old Elaine Doyle who lived with her Mum, Dad and brother - a very normal Scottish family, living in Greenock on the west coast of Scotland.
Until, in 1986 when their lives were turned upside down when Elaine was brutally murdered.
Sources for this episode are:
BBC
Scottish Murders Podcast
Crimepod
Guardian Newspaper
Greenock Telegraph
Sky Murdertown doc
We also talk about knife crime *trigger warn...
The Tromp Family Mystery
For our final episode of 2024 and our 50th episode!!!!
We're bringing you an intriguing mystery from Australia which is all about shared psychosis so this episode might not be for everyone, if you don't feel in a place to listen to this episode right now please give this one a miss.
On Monday 29 August 2016 Mark Tromp and his wife Jacoba got into a car for a “tech-free road trip” with their three adult children Riana, 29, Mitchell, 25, and Ella 22.
They headed north in Ella's car only to turn up one by one a week later having...
The Falkirk Triangle
For our November episode, Effie is covering a Scottish mystery, something we've never touched on before but glossed over. UFO's!!
Bonniebridge is a little town, it's a small town, that just looks like your average British town about 4 miles west of Falkirk in central Scotland but its harbouring a very strange secret....
It has had the largest number of UFO sightings in the world!
Just sit back and take that in!
So much so that since 1992 there have been 300 incidents reported every single year!
36% of locals have seen something unusual in th...
The Murder of Julie-Anne Leahy & Vicky Arnold
Trigger warning* There is a lot of chat in this episode around suicide so if this episode is not for you, or you're not able to listen just now please give this episode a miss.
Sources for this episode are:
ABC News
Office of the state coroner inquest report Brisbane 2013
Daily mail interview with Robert Reid investigative journalist
Australian true crime podcast Episode A convenient murder-suicide https://open.spotify.com/episode/4yhwWkmlqIXHKTS8KUrk4Y?si=6wg6C2NxQnOUfy17GyvtUw&t=1769
<...
The Murder of George Murdoch
This month Effie is covering an Aberdeen case from back in 1983.
George Murdoch, also known as Dodd, a taxi driver in the area, a family man, much loved by the community who was brutally murdered at the age of 58.
Sources for this episode are:
BBC News
The Scottish Sun
Sky News
STV documentary Unsolved
Who is the cheese wire killer - podcast
We also chat random bus stop altercations, road rage cone throwing, which weapon we would choose if we had to murder someone, what we...
Special Guest Episode- In coversation with Author N Leigh Hunt - School Shootings
* Warning *
In this episode, we talk about school shootings in Dunblane Scotland and in the US, we also talk about violence against young children and gun laws.
If this episode is not for you, please give this episode a miss.
The sound is not fantastic on this episode, we were having a few issues with Effie's microphone, so please bear with us.
We were lucky enough to meet N Leigh Hunt at Crimecon in Glasgow and he had a huge effect on us both, so we felt so honoured when he agr...
The Murder of Dianne Brimble
It's our 3rd Birthday!!!!!
Thank you for listening to us talk a lot about random things!
And to "celebrate" Marti is covering the tragic and horrendous death of Dianne Brimble onboard the cruise ship P & O Pacific Sky in 2002.
Dianne Brimble aged 42 and her 12-year-old daughter Tahlia boarded the ship, along with Dianne’s sister, Alma Wood, and Alma’s daughter, Kari Ann. All four girls shared a cabin for the 10-day cruise. A cruise they had saved for 2 years for, it was supposed to be the trip of a lifetime with family!
Dianne didn't...
The Scottish Witch Trials
In this episode Effie is covering the Scottish Witch Trials and we cover myths and lots of other witchy stuff! The Scottish Witchcraft Act was introduced in 1563 and followed on from trials that had taken place across Europe.
We are delighted to be bringing you this episode as we've had so many requests for the witch trials!
We also talk about tarring people and putting them in barrels, Jeremy Clarkson, annoying Tik Tokers and what we've been watching!
Sources for this episode are:
BBC News
BBC Documentary – Lucy Worsely
Hist...
The murder of Graeme Thorne
This month we are doubling up on the Australian stories with Marti covering the devastatingly sad story of the murder of Graeme Thorne
We also talk a lot about the amazing Penny Farmer and the tragic murder of her brother Chris and his girlfriend Peta in Belize- we highly recommend listening to her podcast Paradise listen here: https://open.spotify.com/episode/4FPAufGAWaKEy6fwTbtVqK?si=OXmJ99iVQtCQVdCTiPSsiw
We also talk a LOT about the building of the Sydney Opera House - which is entangled heavily in this story, Paul Robinson from Neighbours and lottery winners.
The tragic death of Caroline Byrne
Trigger warning for this episode, dealing with suicide.
This month Marti is covering the tragic death of Caroline Byrne in NSW Australia in 1995 and it might ring some familiar bells with the Melissa Caddick case we covered recently.
Caroline Byrne was a normal 24-year-old living a normal life with a boyfriend she had just moved in with, started a new job she loved and had a relatively happy family life, why then on the 7th of June would she suddenly take her own life, or was she murdered?
We also ta...
The Ardlamont Mystery
In this episode, (this is a listener request from our amazing friend Wayne over at Eerie Edinburgh) - go check out his podcast and youtube channel.
Effie covers the 1893 Ardlamont Estate Mystery in Argyll & Bute - a peninsula off the West Coast Of Scotland and a horrible murder/accident that occurred?
This one is a brilliant ep for our historical pod fans!
We also talk about Saltburn for way too long!!!! ( spoilers if you haven't seen it!)
Sources for this episode:
The book Ardlamont Mystery the real-life mystery behind Sher...
Scottish Murders Collab - Jason Downie
We were recently asked to be guests on one of our favourite podcasts with one of our favourite podcasters - Dawn from the Scottish Murders podcast ( go check it out and give it a binge listen if you don't know it!)
Where Effie tells the horrifying story of Jason Downie who in November 2010 brutally murdered his 16 year old girlfriend Chantelle Rowe and both of her parents in a horrific killing spree.
There are a lot of Scottish accents in this episode, so you're in for a treat!
Hosted by & Researched & written by <...