MonsterTalk

40 Episodes
Subscribe

By: Blake Smith

MonsterTalk: The Science Show About Monsters is a free audio podcast that critically examines the science behind cryptozoological (and legendary) creatures, such as Bigfoot, the Loch Ness Monster, or werewolves. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support.

S05E04 Haunting America Revisited
#4
Today at 2:04 AM

This week on MonsterTalk, Blake and Karen are joined by Matthew Baxter to revisit Karen’s classic investigation book Haunting America — newly re-released in paperback just in time for Halloween 🎃. Together they discuss how the book began as a project for the James Randi Educational Foundation (JREF), the fieldwork behind its famous cases, and the updated edition’s new conclusion and color photos.👻 Topics discussed:

• Origins of Haunting America — conceived at the JREF as a skeptical investigation anthology.
• Behind-the-scenes stories from Karen and Matt’s fieldwork across the U.S.

• Visits to legendary “haunted” sites including:
  🏠 The Myrtles P...


S05E03 So Much for the Show Me State
#3
Last Tuesday at 2:07 AM

UAPs, “Disclosure,” and the Influence Machine 🔦🛰️
This episode looks at the latest UAP theater around Rep. Eric Burlison’s congressional presentation of the “Hellfire vs. orb” video, how it intersects with long-running media and funding networks (Skinwalker Ranch/NIDS/Las Vegas circle), and why skepticism and provenance still matter. We discuss the hearing, witness line-up, and the ecosystem that amplifies these claims—along with grounded, testable explanations where available.
With Matt Baxter.

🎥 Primary Items from the Episode
• Eric Burlison’s Congressional Presentation of Video (with George Knapp testimony)
• Eric Burlison’s UAP DISCLOSURE ACT

🧪 Skeptical Takes...


S05E02 Autocannibalism Is Not The Answer
#2
10/13/2025

This week Blake Smith and Karen Stollznow are joined by clinical psychologist Dr. Brian A. Sharpless, author of Monsters on the Couch, to discuss cannibalism—what it is, why humans have done it, and how the taboo shows up in archaeology, medicine, psychology, and horror cinema. They cover definitions (endocannibalism vs. survival cannibalism), prion diseases such as Kuru, criminal and paraphilic cases, and pop-culture touchpoints from Ravenous to The Texas Chain Saw Massacre, plus legend-tripping at Lovelock Cave and the “giants” folklore around the Mound Builder myth.

Don't forget to grab Karen's latest: Bitch: The Journey of a Word


S05E01 - Think of the Children!
#1
10/06/2025

🎙 MonsterTalk — The Cult of Moloch
Show Notes ¡ Hosts: Blake Smith & Karen Stollznow

In this episode, Blake Smith and Karen Stollznow explore the history, mythology, and propaganda surrounding the idea of the Cult of Moloch—a figure long associated with child sacrifice and moral panic. They trace Moloch’s biblical origins in Leviticus and Kings, the contested archaeological claims from Carthage’s Tophet, and Roman accusations against rivals such as the Celts and Druids. The discussion moves through how child-sacrifice narratives have been weaponized across history—from Rome’s propaganda and medieval blood libel to the Satanic Panic and modern consp...


S04E46 - SciCom and Science Comedy with Brian Malow
#46
09/29/2025

We finish up Season 4 of MonsterTalk, not with a bang - but a chuckle, as we welcome Science Comedian Brian Malow to talk about using humor and science to entertain. 

https://sciencecomedian.com/

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support.

Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon revenue sharing.


S04E45 - Resurrecting Dire Wolves and Moa Bad Ideas
#45
09/22/2025

We discuss the sketchy "science by press release" of Colossal Biosciences and the controversies lurking in the history of its lead scientist. Have they resurrected dire wolves? No. Definitely not. If only overblown celebrity endorsed hype was the only problem…

Did they make a Dire Wolf? (Spoiler: NOT EVEN REMOTELY CLOSE)


George Church's explanation of Epstein ties


James Arthur Ray - Guru of Death?


Tony Robbins (more from Quora and Reddit)


Peter Jackson and the Moa


S04E44 Ghost Hunting 1975
#44
09/15/2025

We take a look at a fascinating slice of paranormal history in the form of a 1975 BBC documentary The Ghost Hunters. How much has changed in paranormal research since 1975? Not much, after a fashion… 

Anybody know something about these plastic pub barrels from the 1970s?

Show Notes:
Benson Herbert - ghost hunter
Andrew Green - the Spectre Inspector

John Cutten (SPR, Inventor)
Watch this masterpiece on YouTube here.
Yes - the Ion Gun is, in fact, a device for cleaning vinyl records.
Hugh’s other paranormal doco - "Out of th...


S04E43 - Big Foot and Van Meter
#43
09/08/2025

Blake catches Karen up on his current research projects: The four-wall tour dates of the PGF, and a contextual look at the Van Meter Visitor. Neither of these projects are finished but he is excited to share what he's been working on.

Dolemite is mentioned favorably.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support.

Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon revenue sharing.


S04E42 You Don't Know Jackalopes
#43
09/01/2025

Blake is joined by regular contributor Matt Baxter, and special guest Kara Van Hoose from the Colorado Department of Parks and Wildlife to discuss the (not that mysterious) outbreak of "tentacle bunnies" in Colorado this summer.  

News reports of "rabbits with tentacles"

Deer wasting disease (zombie deer)

"Colorado Cannibal" Alfred Packer

Colorado Parks & Wildlife 

Colorado Parks & Wildlife Karl Shuker's blog about Jackalope

99% Invisible episode on Jackalope

Wall Drug

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support.

Some prod...


S04E41 Karen and Matt in Scotland
08/25/2025

Karen and Matt are back from their book tour in the UK and they got to have some real MonsterTalk moments! Loch Ness, Boleskine House and more plus Blake wrestles with gremlins!

More photos will be available on Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/posts/137274189?pr=true&cr=true 

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support.

Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon revenue sharing.


Flashback: Shaver Mystery Super-cut
08/18/2025

It's Hollow Earth, UFOs, the birth of Sci-Fi, and more wierdshit than you can believe as we present a super-cut of our 2-part interview with Jerry Drake and Jeb Card about one of the foundational stories of "weirdshitology" in a new ginormous single episode. 

And there's a little bit of reading if you want to follow us down the rabbit hole... 

EXTENSIVE show notes freely viewable at Patreon.




Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support.

Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon re...


S04E40 - Catching Up: UK Edition
#40
08/11/2025

Karen and Matt check in from the UK! Karen is on tour promoting her new book Bitch: The Journey of a Word.  (affiliate link)

Islands are engines of language diversity

Borley Rectory

Mentioned for future coverage (but touched on before):

The Black Monk of Pontefract

Episodes covering Enfield and Poltergeists

Boleskine House

Some Nessie & Scotland coverage

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support.

Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon revenue s...


S04E39 - Are Magpies Monsters?
#39
08/04/2025

A fascinating chat about Australian Magpies (Gymnorhina tibicen) with Dr. Grainne Cleary in which we talk about the role of stories in creating monsters, the role of citizen science, and lots of cool biology facts about these birds. Not everything about Magpies is black and white, it turns out.

Why do birds do that? (affiliate link)

Your Backyard Birds (booktopia - Australian bookshop)

And remember:
Why do Birds Sing? will be dropping into stores September 2nd, 2025!

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support.

...


S04E38 - Revisiting Robert the Doll
#38
07/28/2025

Blake recounts his recent visit to see Robert the Doll, and his findings after a deep dive into newspapers and other literature.   Patrons get follow-up info from the girl who was the subject of the "true doll haunting" from episode #114! 


Karen's latest book:  Bitch: The Journey of a Word

Recent death "associated" with demonic doll Annabelle

Official website of the museum hosting Robert the Doll

Call for Papers: Of Gods and Monsters II (July 15, 2025 - November 1, 2025)


Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/sup...


Flashback: Demon Dolls
#114
07/21/2025

Flashback to October 2016! Updated content on Robert coming soon.In this week’s episode of MonsterTalk, we talk about demonic or evil dolls, and look into the history of one of America’s most famous creepy playthings: Robert the Doll. Our interview is with Dr. Cori Convertito, Curator of the Key West Art and Historical Society, which oversees the Fort East Martello Museum, home of Robert the Doll.Robert the Doll links
dramatized film (now "Films" as of 2025)authorized history booknovelFacebook pageTwitter accountofficial websiteStories about Robert — Lore podcastVideos
Child’s Play (not based on Robert the Doll. See episode for de...


Flashback: Alien Intrusion and the UTH
07/13/2025

Flashback to January 2018:
In this episode of MonsterTalk, we return to discussion of the Ultraterrestrial Hypothesis (UTH) and what seems to be its growing influence in paranormal circles. It’s been used to explain UFOs, mothman, bigfoot, fairies, dogman, ghosts and many other phenomena which defy scientific demonstrability. Now it crops up again in a new film event titled Alien Intrusion which turned out to be a stealth evangelical creationist film which suggests that aliens and UFOs are actually demonic. We are joined by MonsterTalk alum Joe Laycock, Natasha Mikles and Jeb Card to discuss the UTH and Jeb’s Paranor...


Flashback: Zombies, Cults & Demons
07/07/2025

FLASHBACK to December 2013:
A FAMILIAR VOICE returns to MonsterTalk as Dr. Karen Stollznow joins us to discuss her (then new) book, God Bless America.

Items of Interest
Haunting America on Amazon

More information on the case of Anneliese Michel

Wade Davis’s book on Haitian zombies — The Serpent and the Rainbow

More reading on the Satanic Panic — In Pursuit of Satan: The Police and the Occult

Music
Monstertalk Theme: Monster by Peach Stealing Monkeys

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/mo...


Flashback: Doctor Atlantis - with Ken Feder
#98
06/30/2025

Flashback to May 2015:
IS THERE A LOST CITY somewhere that formed the basis of the legend of Atlantis? Dr. Kenny Feder returns, not to praise Atlantis, but to bury it.

Kenny Feder: Selected Works

The Past in Perspective
Frauds, Myths and Mysteries
Linking to the Past

Related Links
Atlantis by Donovan
Podcast — Archeology Fantasies
In Search Of… Atlantis

Music
Monstertalk Theme: Monster by Peach Stealing Monkeys

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com...


Flashback: The Warren Omission
#72
06/23/2025

We will be playing some episodes from our archives for a few weeks this Summer - let's kick it off with this classic from October 2013! THE WARREN OMISSION.WAS THE STORY OF The Conjuring the true story of how Ed and Lorraine Warren fought demonic forces in Rhode Island? In this special episode of MonsterTalk, we hear a different side to the story of America’s first family of ghost hunting. Features interviews with investigators Joe Nickell and Steven Novella.

Full Notes

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support.

...


S04E37 High Weirdness with Erik Davis
#37
06/16/2025

We're joined by Erik Davis to discuss his book High Weirdness - a history of psychedelics and counterculture as a triptych embodied with three prominent figures: Terrence McKenna, Philip K. Dick, and Robert Anton Wilson. From Blade Runner to the Illuminati to Magic Mushrooms these three laid down foundational blocks decades ago that underpin (or perhaps undermine?) our present. 

Terrence McKenna
Philip K. Dick
Robert Anton Wilson

Pyrrho - ancient Greek skeptic

Our coverage of Operation Mindf*ck (part 1 and part 2)

Erik Davis links:
Burning Shore (Substack)


S04E36 – Nefarious Stealth Evangelicalism?
06/09/2025

We’re joined by Matt Baxter to discuss what we thought was a horror film but turned out to be something quite different.Warning: This film and episode deal with suicide, murder, abortion, politics, religion, and pretty much most of the hot potato topics we generally try to eschew. Hopefully we do a decent job of discussing it.

Nefarious (streaming) – Affiliate Link

More on Blaze Media

Some reviews:
7th Day Adventist review

A Christian review with interesting comments

Reddit tackles Nefarious

Horror Obsessive – really didn’t care for the “b...


S04E35 - Dread Bothy and Beyond
#35
06/02/2025

Matt Baxter returns to join Karen and Blake in a discussion of allegedly haunted “bothies” in the remote hiking regions of the UK. This episode contains some discussion of guns, suicide, and cannibalism.

Links to further reading/listening:

What is a “bothy?”

Mountain Bothy Association

BBC’s Uncanny episodes we mention:

Don’t Sleep in this House – December 2021

Return to Luibeilt Christmas Special 2024

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support.

Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon revenue sharin


S04E34 - The Murder that Inspired Twin Peaks
#34
05/26/2025

Jerry Drake returns to discuss his new book:
Hazel was a Good Girl: The Murder that Inspired Twin Peaks

Jerry has been with quite a few times to discuss Grimoires, Jack Parsons, The Hollow Earth, Internet Mysteries and Ghost Lights and we're excited to see what he makes of this real life unsolved murder with ties to one of the most influential shows to ever air on TV.

This episode does discuss murder, sexual assault, and other sensitive topics. It's not really explicit but it might not be suitable for children, hence the tag.
<...


S04E33 - BigFootage: The Secret of Bigfoot pt 2
#33
05/19/2025

We're back with part two of our 2-part coverage of the 1976 episode of The Six Million Dollar Man that introduced a generation of kids to Bigfoot, and the idea that the creature might be interconnected with space aliens living inside a California mountain.Related
Links:

The Bionic Book by Herbie Pilato (affiliate link)

Operation Plowshare

The Six Million Dollar Man series (DVD)

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support.

Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon revenue sharing.


S04E32 - BigFootage: The Secret of Bigfoot pt 1
#32
05/12/2025

Karen joins Blake to discuss the influential 2-part episodes of The Six Million Dollar Man that introduced a generation of kids to Bigfoot, and the idea that the creature might be interconnected with space aliens living inside a California mountain.

This is part one of a two-part special edition.

The patron edition has extended footage and no modern commercials.

Extensive show notes available here:
https://www.patreon.com/posts/128686370?forSale=true 

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support.

Some product links may be a...


S04E31 - Catching Up May 2025
#31
05/05/2025

Blake and Karen take a minute to catch their breath and talk about where things are in their lives and what's up next in MonsterTalk news.

Links:
Bitch: The Journey of a Word

Adhesive Capsulitis 

Idiopathic Illnesses

Mechanical Turk

Speaking Machine

Replica of Speaking Machine (YouTube)

Wolfgang von Kempelen

Deep Mind

Deep Blue

Marvin Minsky

John McCarthy

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support.

Some product links m...


S04E30 Dinos & Dragons - Part 2
#30
04/28/2025

This is part two of our two part look at Dragons and how these mythical beasts are being used to promote Creationism. Our guest is Dr. Philip Senter and he's the author of a new book about this topic.  We use the word bullsh!t a lot in this episode so I slapped an explicit tag on - but I don't think it's too explicit otherwise. 

Get Dr. Senter's book here: The Real Story of Dinosaurs and Dragons

News story about Mokele Mbembe being compromised by Creationists

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://ww...


S04E29 - Dinos & Dragons - Part 1
#29
04/21/2025

This is part one of our two part look at Dragons and how these mythical beasts are being used to promote Creationism. Our guest is Dr. Philip Senter and he's the author of a new book about this topic.

Get Dr. Senter's book here: The Real Story of Dinosaurs and Dragons

Read more about "The Dragon of Bologna"

Another Book about fake historical zoological specimens 

The National Center for Science Education has long been a source for how to take action to combat the injection of Creationist material into public education.


S04E28 The Victor Hotel Ghost
#28
04/14/2025

Matt & Karen went out for a little getaway weekend to Victor, Colorado and ended up investigating the allegedly haunted Victor Hotel. Did Eddie die in the hotel elevator? Was Matt caught in embarrassing circumstances? Find out inside!




The show notes here won't show the images so you'll need to hop over to our episode webpage to see them.
https://www.monstertalk.org/s04e28-the-victor-hotel-ghost/

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support.

Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon revenue sharing.


S04E27 - Jewish Mysticism and Dybbuks with Peter Bebergal
#27
04/07/2025

We're excited to welcome back Peter Bebergal. This time we're talking about mysticism and dybbuks. Be sure and check out the links below including the upcoming talk Peter is giving April 14th for The Last Tuesday Society.

Peter on Jewish Boston podcast

All the Haunts Be Ours (affiliate link) 15-Disk Horror Collection

The Ibbur from Jewish mysticism

Peter will be talking monster culture for The Last Tuesday Society on April 14th at 3 pm ET - check it out

Grab all of Peter's Books at Amazon and support this show!


S04E26 - A Natural History of Sea Serpents with Adrian Shine
#25
03/31/2025

We're delighted to get to talk with Adrian Shine, who has worked for decades to raise awareness about Loch Ness and investigated the legendary creature said to inhabit the dark waters of that deep Scottish lake.  He's written a new book about Sea Monsters and their connection to the Loch Ness Mystery which releases April 1st, 2025. 

A Natural History of Sea Monsters (affiliate link)

The Loch Ness Centre

In the intro you hear a clip of IN SEARCH OF from S01E20 - which features a young Adrian. Check out In Research Of's coverage wi...


S04E25 - Demon Sex in Medieval Times PT 2
#25
03/24/2025

We're back with part 2 of our interview with Dr. Eleanor Janega to discuss Demons in Medieval Europe - and a lot of that has to do with sexy sex.  So… another EXPLICIT tag! 

Eleanor's Blog Going-Medieval

Eleanor's book The Once and Future Sex

The Apocalypse Tapestry of Angers (The Guardian)

The Apocalypse Tapestry (Wikipedia)

YouTube videos with Eleanor 

Monty Summers translation of the Malleus Maleficarum  (AMZ affiliate link)








Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monsterta...


S04E24 Demon Sex in Medieval Times
#24
03/16/2025

We're joined by the engaging historian Dr. Eleanor Janega to talk about how the people of Europe considered demonic sex during the medieval period of history. This episode is in two parts, and both are explicit. 

Presenter on the History Hit channel - https://www.historyhit.com/ 

Blog - https://going-medieval.com/ 

Medievalist, author, blogs about medieval history, pop culture, and swearing 

Author of: The Once and Future Sex: Going Medieval on Women's Roles in Society

Article: “On sex with demons” - https://going-medieval.com/2020/07/30/on-sex-with-demons/

Become a supporte...


S04E23 Remembering Joe Nickell
#23
03/10/2025

A brief remembrance of our friend, Joe Nickell. (December 1, 1944 – March 4, 2025)

Joe Nickell's extraordinary life came to an end on Tuesday, March 4th and we're posting this brief remembrance this week instead of our regular episode.

Check out Joe's many "personas."

The Science of Monsters: Tracking the Real-Life Creatures

Archive episodes with Joe

The sourtoe cocktail

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support.

Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon revenue sharing.


S04E22 Women in the Paranormal
#22
03/03/2025

We're joined by Allison Jornlin (paranormalwomen.com) to talk about the footprint of women in the field of parapsychology and paranormal investigation. 

We most recently talked with Allison during "the dark times" on our COVID-era MonsterTalk Live series.

She also covered the Chicago Mothman flap with us back in 2018!


Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support.

Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon revenue sharing.


S04E21 The Cave of the Winds
#21
02/24/2025

Is the cave of the winds near Manitou Springs, CO HAUNTED!? Matt Baxter has investigated and he joins us to talk about what he found.

Related Links:
Spooky Science Sisters - Roanoke episode with Karen

In Research Of… The Lost Colony - Blake & Jeb Card discuss the In Search Of… episode about Roanoke.

Eclectic Shopping options in Manitou Springs

The history of Manitou Springs

The Cave of the Winds (Official Site)

The Manitou (1978 film)

Manitou - the spirit



Become a suppor...


S04E20 - Understand Japan's Dan Da Dan [Explicit]
#20
02/17/2025

We're joined by Dr. Justin Mullis to get a better understanding of the incredibly lore-dense anime series Dan Da Dan.

Justin's academia profile

Legend of Momotaro

Some links recommended by Justin:
This is a really good video about the history of the Flatwoods Monster in Japanese video games. Highly recommended.

This is the Religious Dispatches article about koro.

Here's the Japan Today interview with the current editor of MU magazine.And here's the MU magazine article I mentioned about Turbo Granny (in Japanese).

The book on Japanes...


S04E19 - Monsters of the Heart
#19
02/10/2025

As Valentine's day bears down upon us, we turn to the monsters whose origins lie in passion, betrayal, and tragedy. If love is the strongest human emotion, surely rage at betrayal is its nightmarish mirror - and such emotions are embodied in a variety of creatures around the world and throughout history.

Content Warning - this episode contains stories of child death, suicide, murder, and other unplesantness. And also some discussion of candy. So there's that.

Don't forget to pick up Karen's latest Book: Bitch: The Journey of a Word

Become a supporter of...


S04E18 - Grave Rubbers from CyberSpace!
#18
02/03/2025

Cemeteries Cleaning and Grave Rubbing - Karen and Blake are joined by Matt Baxter to discuss the ethics and best practices around maintaining and preserving graveyards. 

Links for Grave Rubbers from CyberSpace:
The article that inspired this conversation (via The Conversation)

Ken Feder (friend of the show and emeritus professor of archaeology) sent along this helpful article about grave preservation.

The woman with the pink foam (Kaeli Mae McEwen - aka "Clean Girl") has a site where she sells the stuff.

In Atlanta - at historic Oakland Cemetery - the...


S04E17 The Ghost of Ticonderoga with Joseph Gagne
#17
01/27/2025

This week we're welcoming back historian Dr Joseph Gagne to tell us about a ghost story that straddles North America and Scotland.  He was last with us to tell us about the legend of La Corriveau in episode 181. 

Appearances of the Dead: A Cultural History of Ghosts by Ronald C. Finucane - mentioned by Joseph as his introduction to this story. This is an affiliate link and the book is out of print, so be advised it's PRICEY.

But wait!  You can read it for free at Archive.org.
Joseph asked me to be sure and...