John Brown Today

40 Episodes
Subscribe

By: Louis DeCaro Jr.

John Brown Today is a podcast devoted to historical and contemporary themes relating to the abolitionist John Brown (1800-59), the controversial antislavery and antiracist freedom fighter. John Brown Today is hosted by Louis A. DeCaro Jr., a Brown biographer and researcher, the most prolific author on the John Brown theme since the abolitionist's death in 1859. John Brown Today engages a range of themes from history and biography to popular culture and other contemporary themes.

✂️ Clip this podcast
John Brown Unchained: A Counterfactual Historical Experiment
Yesterday at 6:00 PM

Send us Fan Mail

In this special counterfactual episode of John Brown Today, historian and biographer Louis A. DeCaro Jr. challenges the conventional textbook portrayal of Harpers Ferry as a doomed, suicidal gesture. Drawing directly on primary archival evidence, Lou traces what would have unfolded had Brown avoided his fatal pre-dawn hesitation on October 17, 1859, and escaped into the Blue Ridge and Allegheny mountains with his raiders, planter hostages, and roughly two hundred liberated local enslaved recruits.

Special music: Michael Kiwanuka, "Love & Hate" (title song from Love & Hate album ) 

Support the show


The Harper's Ferry Raid: Interview with Jim Silvia, Part 1
10/09/2026

Send us Fan Mail

In the first of two parts, Lou talks with Jim Silvia, the vice president of the nonprofit Harpers Ferry Park Association and a 13-year veteran certified park guide at Harpers Ferry National Historical Park. Jim's newly published work, The Raid Minute By Minute, is a milestone in John Brown studies, being a comprehensive look, not only at the raid, but also the four years leading up to the raid. 

To support the HF Park Association, please follow this link to purchase The Raid Minute by Minute (https://www.harpersferryhistory.org/product/r...


The Harper's Ferry Raid: Interview with Jim Silvia, Part 2
10/09/2026

Send us Fan Mail

In the second of two parts, Lou talks with Jim Silvia, the vice president of the nonprofit Harpers Ferry Park Association and a 13-year veteran certified park guide at Harpers Ferry National Historical Park. Jim's newly published work, The Raid Minute By Minute, is a milestone in John Brown studies, being a comprehensive look, not only at the raid, but also the four years leading up to the raid. 

To support the HF Park Association, please follow this link to purchase The Raid Minute by Minute (https://www.harpersferryhistory.org/product/r...


How Teddy Roosevelt Screwed Over John Brown's Legacy
09/12/2026

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, Lou examines how Theodore Roosevelt appropriated—and ultimately undermined—the historical legacy of John Brown. Focus centers on Roosevelt’s August 1910 "New Nationalism" address at the dedication of the John Brown Memorial Park in Osawatomie, Kansas, followed by his September 1910 essay in The Outlook, "The Progressives of the Past and the Present."

Key topics explored include:

The Osawatomie Address: How TR used the backdrop of Osawatomie to launch his progressive political platform while barely mentioning John Brown, subordinating Brown's abolitionist conviction to the political centrism of Abr...


Covenant of Blood: John Brown and His Jewish Associates in Kansas, Part 2
06/14/2026

Send us Fan Mail

In Part 2 of this gripping exploration into John Brown and his Jewish associates in Kansas, Lou revisits the infamous Pottawatomie Creek killings. Grounding the narrative in the vital testimony of August Bondi alongside other primary and secondary sources, the episode reframes the violence not as random slaughter but as a preemptive strike. Lou demonstrates how Theodore Wiener became a crucial actor in this lethal counter-offensive, as Brown, his sons, and his son-in-law moved to thwart a hostile, pro-slavery plot by executing five local pro-slavery collaborators: the Doyles, William Wilkinson, and William Sherman.

<...


Covenant of Blood: John Brown and His Jewish Associates in Kansas, Part 1
06/14/2026

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, Lou introduces us to the fascinating and unlikely alliance between John Brown’s family and local Jewish immigrants in the violent, war-torn landscape of Territorial Kansas. To set the stage, Lou explores how Brown—a self-conscious heir to the rigid Puritan Protestant tradition—deeply conceptualized and viewed the Jewish people.

We are then introduced to three of Brown’s Jewish associates: August Bondi, Jacob Benjamin, and Theodore Wiener. Drawing from the richest available historical records, the episode focuses primarily on Bondi and Wiener, charting their paths as they converge...


Experiment: "John Brown Speaks" Meets Google's Notebook LM
05/04/2026

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, Lou uploads the transcript of the extended introduction of his book, John Brown Speaks (Rowman & Littlefield, 2015) to one of Google's AI programs, Notebook LM.  Notebook LM "reads" the introduction and then produces a faux podcast featuring two human-like voices discussing the content of the article. As this experiment shows, AI is a very useful and interesting tool, but it is not without its flaws and biases based on the source and content of its knowledge. Overall, despite some problematic points, this AI podcast episode does a fairly good job of di...


2011 Throwback: Should John Brown Be Posthumously Pardoned?
03/14/2026

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, Lou introduces the question of whether John Brown should be posthumously pardoned. The theme begins with biographer David S. Reynold's Op-Ed in the New York Times on December 1, 2009 entitled, "Freedom's Martyr," in which  he suggested the symbolic value of a posthumous pardon for Brown, either by the State of Virginia or even by then President Barack Obama.  Two years later, this question was revisited by a John Brown birthday meeting, "Five Nine 2011" (commemorating the 211th birthday of Brown), held at the Brecht Forum in New York City.  Among the other gue...


The Terrible Parable of the Dumbass Doyles
03/02/2026

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, Lou revisits the story of James and Maehala Doyle of Tennessee, who devoted themselves and their family to supporting slavery and opposing antislavery and abolitionist settlers in the Kansas Territory. In the Pottawatomie incident of May 1856, Doyle and his two oldest sons, William and Drury, were killed by John Brown's men, under the leadership of the old man, because of their role in spreading and supporting proslavery terrorism in the territory, and for posing a direct threat to the lives and well-being of the Browns.  The Doyles are dumbasses--ignorant people c...


John Brown, Accomplices, and the Struggle Against Systemic Racism: A Conversation with Dan Morrison
11/04/2025

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, Lou speaks with Dan Morrison, the founder of the John Brown Project and a documentary filmmaker from Torrington, Connecticut, John Brown’s birthplace. Morrison details his work, including a community arts project that produced a 21st-century remix of the Civil War era song, "John Brown's Body" and his current musical documentary, "Pushing the Rock," which examines systemic racism in America and features interviews with historical figures’ descendants and scholars. The conversation heavily focuses on rehabilitating the historical reputation of abolitionist John Brown, countering common misconceptions that portray him as a...


The John Brown Lens: What would Brown Say About Contemporary Zionist Israel, the Charlie Kirk Tragedy, & Trump's War on the History of Slavery
09/19/2025

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, Lou breaks with the regular approach of this podcast to put a John Brown lens on pressing contemporary issues. He specifically addresses three main topics, arguing why John Brown would be an anti-Zionist due to the movement's oppressive colonial practices and its perceived anti-biblical, racialized nature; critiquing the notion that the recently murdered Charlie Kirk was a Christian martyr because of his white nationalist views and opposition to the Black civil rights tradition; and finally, condemning the Trump administration's attempts to revise history and...


Echoes of Abolition: An Interview with Biographer and Cultural Historian David S. Reynolds
09/05/2025

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, Lou interviews the preeminent cultural historian of the 19th-century USA, David S. Reynolds. This year marks the twentieth anniversary of the publication of Reynolds' landmark biography, John Brown Abolitionist. Reynolds opens by describing his most recent project, the forthcoming Two Ships (Penguin), and then revisits the writing of John Brown Abolitionist, rehearsing some key themes from the book as well as reflecting on his  background and methodology as a cultural historian. The interview finishes with a shift to Reynolds' 2020 opus, Abe, a cultural biography of Abraham Lincoln. 

There is...


A "Secret Six" Tour: Discovering the Contemporary Origin of the Term
07/24/2025

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, I am inviting you on a peculiar historical tour of the term, "Secret Six." While John Brown students are accustomed to seeing this term used to speak of Brown's key supporters, this episode is about the origin of the term and its significance in the literature about Brown.  As you'll discover, while the "tour" of "Secret Six" is full of trivial and interesting cases where the term has been used since the nineteenth century, it was not really applied to Brown's story until the twentieth century.  While the term has it...


Malcolm X on John Brown: A Centennial Remembrance
05/19/2025

Send us a text

In this episode, Lou shares an extended reflection on Malcolm X that is attuned to the memory and legacy of John Brown. Going beyond easy, almost cliché use of Malcolm's words, Lou draws on his background as a Malcolm X biographer to reflect upon both the strategic and personal approach of the memorable black leader to John Brown's legacy.

This May 19, 2025 is the centennial of Malcolm X's birth.  With one foot in the antebellum era and another foot in the Civil Rights era, the stretch may be challenging, but it's well wo...


LD's Sucky "Secret Six" Tour
05/16/2025

Send us a text

In this episode, Lou explores the appellation, "Secret Six," which is often associated with the so-called inner circle of John Brown's supporters. Taking you on this imaginary tour, Lou travels through time to find references to the "Secret Six," finding a lot of interesting and sometimes musing flotsam and jetsam and a couple of high-profile associations with "Secret Six." But what he doesn't find is a term that has any real association with John Brown, his followers, or their stories. Join Lou as he gets to the bottom of "Secret Six"--which, it...


Misusing John Brown: From Luigi Mangione to Christian Nationalism
02/04/2025

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, Lou discusses two recent online articles to illustrate how John Brown is often appropriated and misused by writers in discussing contemporary issues.  The first article discussed is an effort to draw a parallel between John Brown and Luigi Mangione, who allegedly murdered a healthcare executive in cold blood last year. The second article presents John Brown as a Christian Nationalist. In both cases, Lou objects to the misuse of John Brown, showing how inaccurate these appropriations tend to be. 

Links to the articles, fyi:

Will Shetterly, "Wh...


The Cat Who Went to Kansas (and Other John Brown Animals)
12/17/2024

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, Lou discusses the animals--pets, livestock, and others who are part of the John Brown story, from the dogs of Harper's Ferry to a cat who went to Kansas.  Just when you thought you'd heard everything about John Brown, huh?

Guest music: "Story of a Toy" by Freedom Trail Studio (Youtube)

Also available on the John Brown Today YouTube station

Support the show


Sick of Bonhoeffer? Why the USA Can Celebrate a German Martyr, But Not John Brown
#2
12/03/2024

Send us Fan Mail

Dietrich Bonhoeffer was born in 1906, and was a German Lutheran pastor, a figure noted in the theological world for his neo-orthodox views, and his most popular book, The Cost of Discipleship.  Bonhoeffer is more widely remembered as an anti-Nazi dissident who was a key founding member of the Confessing Church which opposed the Nazis.  In the 1940s, Bonhoeffer joined the German underground, but was arrested and incarcerated at Tegel Prison, where he remained for over a year. However, In 1945, documents were discovered that named Bonhoeffer among the dissidents and orders for his execution we...


Back Again!
#1
12/03/2024

Send us Fan Mail

After the better of two years, John Brown Today is going back in production. This is just a brief message to greet listeners and to update them a bit, and thank them for maintaining an interest in this podcast. John Brown Today is coming back and I'm looking forward to what lies ahead.  So stay tuned.  

Please note that two episodes will be uploaded for December 2024.

Music: "Burden Laid Down" by The Westerlies (YouTube)

Support the show


The Legend of John Brown's Baby Kiss Revisited
#3
04/12/2023

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, Lou does a deep dive evaluation of the legend of John Brown kissing a black baby on the day of his execution,  a story that has been enshrined in poetry and paintings.  Sharing his research on the topic, Lou considers the evidence and draws some interesting conclusions suggesting that this legend may have more than a core of truth.

Check out the video version on my YouTube channel here.

Guest music (closing): Aaron Lieberman, "Move Up to the Mountains" (YouTube)

Support the show


"From John Brown to James Brown": A Conversation with Ed Maliskas
#2
02/05/2023

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, Lou shares a conversation with author Ed Maliskas, a musician, clergyman, and researcher, the author of John Brown to James Brown: The Little Farm Where Liberty Budded, Blossomed, and Boogied (2016).  In this fascinating discussion, Ed talks about coming to learn about the old Kennedy Farm in Maryland where John Brown and his raiders lived prior to the Harper's Ferry raid in the summer and early fall of 1859.  However, as Ed learned, the farm, often referred to as the "John Brown farm" (not to be confused with John Brown's own home an...


The Sellout of Harper's Ferry Station: The Difficult Case of Heyward Shepherd
#1
01/17/2023

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, Lou takes on the difficult theme of Heyward Shepherd, the black porter who was mortally wounded by John Brown's men during the Harper's Ferry raid, on the night of October 16, 1859.  Reviewing the initial incidents of the raid, Lou considers the conventional narrative of Shepherd's demise, but then takes a sharp left turn: was Heyward Shepherd really a victim, or did his own actions instigate his shooting? And what was Heyward Shepherd trying to do when he was shot by one of Brown's raiders? The conclusion drawn from looking at the e...


Reaction & Reflection: David Blight on John Brown - - "John Brown Terrorist or Hero?"
#10
12/29/2022

Send us Fan Mail

After an extended hiatus, Lou returns with a reaction & reflection upon the YouTube video, "John Brown: Terrorist or Hero?" which features a short lecture by the eminent historian David Blight.  John Brown Today features the audio version here, and listeners can also view the reaction & reflection video here (or copy this link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OV6GOH8Pslc)

Support the show


What Did Blacks Really Think of John Brown? Kudos & Conflicts (Part 1)
#8
10/24/2022

Send us Fan Mail

In Part 1 of "What Did Blacks Really Think of John Brown?" Lou reflects upon the question of white allies, particularly in the case of John Brown's story. What did black leaders and other associates really think of John Brown?  Recalling Brown's devotion to black liberation and notable devotion to human equality, Lou suggests nevertheless that human interaction is by nature complex and even Brown might grate upon his black associates. How should these tensions be understood? Was he a paternalistic racist as some have charged in recent times? Did he presume too much d...


What Did Blacks Really Think of John Brown? The Question of "Sambo Mistakes" (Part 2)
#9
10/24/2022

Send us Fan Mail

In Part 2 of this two-part episode, Lou reflects upon the question of white allies, particularly in the case of John Brown's story. What did black leaders and other associates really think of John Brown?  Recalling Brown's devotion to black liberation and notable devotion to human equality, Lou suggests nevertheless that human interaction is by nature complex and even Brown might grate upon his black associates. How should these tensions be understood? Was he a paternalistic racist as some have charged in recent times? Did he presume too much despite being a notable and r...


Questioning John Brown’s Sanity: A Historical Thread Considered
#7
09/09/2022

Send us Fan Mail

Many people in the United States, especially (but not exclusively) white people, tend to think of John Brown as someone who was "crazy." In this episode, Lou surveys what he calls a historical "thread" regarding the alleged insanity of Brown.  Beginning with affidavits filed in Virginia in 1859 in an attempt by friends and relatives in Ohio to spare Brown's life, as well as Republican insanity rhetoric designed to dissociate Brown from their party, it is clear there is otherwise no historical evidence for the insanity notion. In the twentieth century, however, academics promoted B...


John Brown’s Trial: The “Lost” Narrative of George H. Hoyt
#6
07/25/2022

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, Lou presents a narrative written by John Brown's young lawyer, George H. Hoyt, written only a few years after the abolitionist's hanging.  Hoyt went to join John Brown in Charlestown, Virginia (today West Va.) and support his lawyers, but really went as a spy for Brown's supporters in the North who wanted to launch a rescue. But not only was the rescue impossible by the time that Hoyt arrived in Virginia, but Brown did not want to escape.  Hoyt thus became part of the drama of Brown's trial and last da...


Why John Brown? A Biographer's Reflections in Response to a Thoughtful Critic
#5
06/30/2022

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, Lou responds to the comments of a thoughtful but critical podcast listener who has well-stated reasons for asking, "why John Brown?"  The question is a good one and Lou starts with personal and scholarly reflections on a range of views of Brown that range from anti-Brown to non-admirer.  Then, Lou shares the podcast listener's comments and attempts to make a response that hopefully is helpful to this friendly critic as well as others with similar thoughts on the abolitionist and his legacy. 

Guest music:

"Climbing" by Ree...


Good Boy with a Gun: The Tragic Story of Will Leeman, A Harper’s Ferry Raider
#4
05/26/2022

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, Lou does a deep dive into the story of William Leeman, the youngest of John Brown's Harper's Ferry raiders.  From his origins in Maine to Kansas and his enlistment in John Brown's army, we look at the story of a young man with feet of iron and clay, whose death in Virginia in 1859 resonates with the racist gun violence and mass killings that grip our nation today.   

A special note of thanks is due H. Scott Wolfe, for providing his extensive research on Leeman, the work of many yea...


"John Brown Has Been Lost to His Own Church": An Interview with Louis DeCaro Jr. by Dr. Chris Dost, July 10, 2021
#3
04/30/2022

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, Lou is interviewed by Dr. Chris Dost, biblical scholar and pastor of the Northville Baptist Church in New Milford, Connecticut.  This audio is excerpted from an interview recorded on July 10, 2021.

Closing tune: "Amazing Grace" by Cooper Cannell

Hey friends, click on this link to get your JOHN BROWN TODAY Podcast Mug!

Feedback?
https://www.speakpipe.com/JOHNBROWNTODAY

Support the show


Biography: The Ups and Downs of Mr. Brown, 1835-1851
#2
04/04/2022

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, Lou provides a slice of biography, zooming in on John Brown's personal and economic challenges as a frontier entrepreneur and his often forgotten comeback in the early 1840s. While overlooked by unstudied and prejudiced scholars, Brown actually bounced back in the mid-1840s and distinguished himself as one of the leading experts on fine sheep and wool. Looking at Brown's attempt to intervene on behalf of wool growers in the 1840s, we get further insight into Brown's inclination to defend the underdog.  This observation provides a way to revisit the b...


A Disparate Legacy: Oswald Garrison Villard and the John Brown Biography
#1
03/16/2022

Send us Fan Mail

To begin the fourth cycle of John Brown Today, Lou reflects upon the life and contribution of Brown biographer, Oswald Garrison Villard, whose life of John Brown was first published in 1910. As Lou argues, Villard did a great favor to historical study and John Brown students by commissioning extensive research for his work--research that he could not even utilize to the fullest extent himself. On the other hand, Villard depreciated John Brown as a restless and principled murderer, used his economic clout to the disadvantage of W.E.B. DuBois, another biographer of...


Interrogating History: The Mayflower, “America,” and John Brown
#10
01/31/2022

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, Lou reflects upon the critical thesis of the late Gabriel Moran (1935-2021), who indefatigably pointed out  the distinction between "America" as a dream (and as a vast continental land mass) and The United States of America as a nation. Following Gabriel's lead, Lou reflects upon the linguistic and political challenges of confusing the two, something that is done as much by rightwingers as by critics of racism, including such eminent voices as Malcolm X and Martin Luther King Jr. What is the significance of confusing the USA with "America"? Lou e...


Light vs. Lies: The Real History of the Harper's Ferry Raid (with a Jan. 6th epilogue!)
#9
01/16/2022

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, Lou revisits the Harper's Ferry raid of October 16, 1859, presents some preliminary thoughts on the contemporary perspective and then addresses a number of key points, along with a "January 6th" epilogue.  The key points addressed in this extended episode are:

1. What basically characterized John Brown’s earlier Virginia plan and how it was changed in the 1850s, and why it was changed?

2. Why did John Brown choose to capture the federal armory and what did he intend when he did so?

3. To what degree did Joh...


My John Brown Holiday Notes
#8
12/24/2021

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode Lou tries to answer the question, "Did John Brown celebrate Christmas?"  This leads us to consider both Thanksgiving and Christmas in the antebellum era, what they represented to the North and South, respectively, and their social significance. Then, taking a quick tour of the archives, Lou pulls some different vignettes relating John Brown to Christmas.

Merry Christmas to those who observe the day, and happy holidays and happy new year to all!

Hey friends, click on this link to get your JOHN BROWN TODAY Podcast M...


A Text For the Nation: John Brown Beyond Biography
#7
12/13/2021

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, Lou reflects upon the 1859 words of abolitionist orator Wendell Phillips, that the hanged John Brown had "given this nation a text."  Lou considers how W.E.B. DuBois used the abolitionist as a text in writing his biography John Brown in 1909. Almost seventy years later, the leftist historian Albert Fried  likewise did so in the writing of his historiographic memoir, John Brown's Journey (1978). Both writers demonstrated that Wendell Phillips was correct:  Brown has given this nation a text, a fact that will not lessen in time.

Hey fri...


John Brown, Abraham Lincoln, and the Moral Core: A Juxtaposition for December 2
#6
11/30/2021

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, Lou reflects upon the "moral core" of Brown and Lincoln in juxtaposition. Mainly considering how these men are viewed in terms of religion and in regard to their roles in human liberation, Lou argues that Lincoln is neither a prophet nor a martyr, and that he is bested in both categories by Brown. 

This episode is dedicated to the annual remembrance of John Brown's hanging on December 2, 1859. 

Hey friends, click on this link to get your JOHN BROWN TODAY Podcast Mug!

Support th...


Explaining John Brown Correctly: A Conversation with Dan Morrison
#5
11/17/2021

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode Lou talks with Dan Morrison, a journalist and artist who lives in Torrington, Connecticut, the birthplace of John Brown.  The basis of the conversation is Dan's recent explainer video, "Was John Brown a Terrorist?" an Explainer Video which succinctly and effectively addresses a theme that so many have distorted and skewed.  Dan is a listener of John Brown Today but he does a lot of thinking about the Old Man on his own, and he's working on a project that will interest JBT listeners for sure.  This episode clo...


Mary Ellen Pleasant and "The Rule of Credible Evidence"
#4
10/17/2021

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, Lou discusses the story of Mary Ellen Pleasant, an African American woman who has been lauded for her civil rights activities in 19th century San Francisco, but--more important to this podcast--claimed to have been a confidant and supporter of John Brown. Along the way, Lou shares a number of examples of stories and reports that connected claimants to the John Brown story, some of them obviously false, others arguably true, and some in-between, with a mix of the credible and interesting with fabrications and farce.  This is especially the case w...


The Voices of the Past: A Conversation with Ian Barford (Part 2)
#3
09/27/2021

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, Lou continues his conversation with friend Ian Barford, the actor and  Brown-Douglass researcher. In this episode we discuss Ian's project on John Brown's relationship with Frederick Douglass and other black leaders of that period, including the impact that black nationalist archetypes had on Brown's thinking, and in turn how he responded in support of black self-determination. There is also some musing in regard to a trip to Kansas this past summer which they shared, both doing archive work as well as visiting historic sites.

If you're interested, you c...