Crime, Wine & Chaos
Crime, Wine & Chaos is a true crime and chaos, comedy podcast hosted by sisters, Amber Rae and Naomi Lackaff. Join us for a drink as we dive deep into these harrowing stories. Cheers! - EXPLICIT CONTENT - 18 years and older listener advised
Episode 295 - The Murder of Cynthia Baumgartner Roth & The Survival of Kennedy Littledike
This week Naomi covers the death of a young mom married to a man with a pattern of losing wives in tragic accidents.
Then Amber covers the story of Kennedy Littledike. An Idaho teenager who miraculously survived a horrific 2021 car crash.
Naomi's Sources:
Randy Roth: How Many of His 4 Wives Did He Murder? | A&E
Randy Roth - Wikipedia
Randy Roth | Murderpedia, the encyclopedia of murderers
Amber's Sources:
https://nypost.com/2024/02/16/us-news/idaho-teen-kennedy-littledike-hung-from-power-line-with-broken-leg-for-an-hour/
Teen H...
Episode 294 - The Murder of Reagan Simmons-Hancock & Live Aid
**THIS EPISODE STARTS WITH AN UPDATE ON THE OSCAR URIAS MURDER TRIAL. THIS CASE WAS ORIGINALLY COVERED ON EPISODE 198. THANK YOU TO THE LOVED ONES OF ELIZABETH AND HATTIE WHO REACHED OUT****
This week Amber covers the murder of Reagan Simmons-Hancock, committed by Taylor Parker who faked a pregnancy for months and violently attached Reagan.
Then, Naomi covers one of the most iconic concerts of all time, and the money it raised that wound up as weapons instead of food.
Amber's Sources:
Murder of Reagan Simmons-Hancock - Wikipedia
Episode 293 - The Murders of Christine Banfield and Joseph Ryan & Missing in Panama
This week, Naomi covers a double homicide that at first glance looked like bedroom role play gone horribly wrong.
Then Amber covers Kris Kremers and Lisanne Froon 2 Dutch students who went missing on April 1, 2014 while hiking in Panama.
Naomi's sources:
Temptation - Dateline NBC - Apple Podcasts
Where Is Brendan Banfield Now? His Life After Stabbing Wife with Au Pair Lover
https://www.nbcnews.com/au-pair-murders-brendan-banfield-juliana-peres-magalhaes
US man who plotted with au pair to murder wife given life sentence | Virginia | The...
Episode 292 - GPO Girl & Sarma Melngailis a.k.a. Bad Vegan
In this episode, Amber tells the story of a young girl found in distress near the Dublin General Post Office.
Then, Naomi tries to make sense of a chaotic story of eternal life, raw food, celebrities, and coercive control.
Amber's Sources:
Operation Shepard - Identification of female found by Gardai on O’Connell Street on the 10/10/13
Four years after 'GPO girl' mystery, the woman behind it appeals jail sentence in Australia
Mystery GPO girl makes similar claims in Canada
‘GPO Girl’ to...
Episode 291 - The Murder of Ron Whitehead & The Death of Hedviga Golik
This week, Naomi covers the murder or a husband and a father in what was first believed to be a tragic and random act of violence.
Then Amber covers Hedviga Golik, a Croatian nurse who died of natural causes alone in her Zagreb apartment in the mid-1960s. Due to deep social isolation, her mummified body remained completely undiscovered in her armchair for 42 years.
Naomi's Sources:
2 sentenced for roles in murder-for-hire
https://komonews.com/news/local/accused-teen-goes-on-trial-in-murder-for-hire-case
https://cases.justia.com/washington/files/62407-5...
Episode 290 - The Pillowcase Bandit & Cindy Bi
This week, Amber tells the story of Matthew Davies who robbed a bank in Scotland with a meat cleaver and a pillow case.
Then, Naomi tells the story of a woman out to destroy the life of the surrogate she blames for the death of her son.
Amber's Sources:
Bungling Dunfermline pillow case disguise bank robber jailed
And finally… blind stupidity | Irish Legal News
Brain of Scotland - Man who robbed bank wearing pillow case without eye holes arrested after fleeing 'very slowly' then sto...
Episode 289 - The Murder of Stanford White & The Tragic Death of Kyle Plush
This week, Naomi covers the very public murder of a high-society architect at the hands of a playboy millionaire.
Then Amber tells the story of the preventable and tragic death of Kyle Plush.
Naomi's Sources:
Harry Thaw | Murderpedia, the encyclopedia of murderers
Stanford White - Wikipedia
The Trials of Harry Thaw for the Murder of Stanford White
Harry Kendall Thaw - Wikipedia
Amber's Sources:
Death of Kyle Plush - Wikipedia
Episode 288 - The Murder of Liz Reiser and The Survival of Brandi Hicks & The Bombing of the L.A. Times Building
This week, Amber covers the murder of Liz Reiser and the survival of Brandi Hicks that started as an act of kindness and generosity,
Then, Naomi covers another “crime of the century” and another explosive moment in the labor movement.
Amber's Sources:
Murder of Elizabeth Reiser - Wikipedia
Elizabeth Reiser Murder: Where Is Matthew Vaca Now?
Brandi Hicks Now: Where is Elizabeth Reiser's Friend Today? Update
Teen 'played dead' after being thrown off bridge when friend was 'almost decapitated' - The Mirro...
Episode 287 - Leopold and Loeb & The Jack-in-the-Box E. Coli Outbreak
This week, Naomi covers the story of two young men who committed a shocking murder, believing they were too smart to get caught.
Then Amber tells the story of the E. Coli outbreak that swept across the Pacific Northwest in the early 90's.
Naomi's Sources:
Leopold and Loeb - Wikipedia
Übermensch - Wikipedia
https://home.heinonline.org/crime-of-the-century-leopold-and-loebs-perfect-crime/
The Loeb-Leopold case : with excerpts from the evidence of the alienists and including the arguments to the court by counsel for
Episode 286 - The Abduction of Natascha Kampusch & Rana Plaza Collapse
This week, Amber tells the remarkable survival story of Natascha Kampusch who was abducted and held captive for 8 years.
Then, Naomi covers one of the deadliest structural failures in modern history.
Amber's Sources:
Natascha Kampusch - Wikipedia
Natascha Kampusch New Book "3,096 Days": Austrian Kidnap Victim Details 8 1/2 Years of Horror, Abuse - CBS News
Kidnapped girl reveals new details of her life as a 'domestic slave' - CNN.com
Natascha Kampusch Survived Abduction and 8 Years of Torment | A&E
Episode 285 - The Stalking and Murder of Rebecca Schaeffer & The Story of Sonny Graham and Terry Cottle
This week, Naomi covers the murder of a rising Hollywood star whose case was a turning point in anti-stalking legislation.
Then Amber covers the story of two suicide victims who shared the same heart.
For this episode, Amber was drinking Casa Santos Lima Colossal Reserva.
Naomi's Sources:
20/20 Special - Your Biggest Fan
Robert John Bardo - Wikipedia
Rebecca Schaeffer - Wikipedia
Robert John Bardo | Murderpedia, the encyclopedia of murderers
Amber's Sources:
2 Suicide V...
Episode 284 - The Attempted Murder of Lonnie Feather & Jonathan Hoang: Missing
This week, Amber covers the attempted murder of Lonnie Feathers. Lonnie was attacked by her boyfriend whom she had known for many years.
Then, Naomi covers the disappearance of an at-risk young man, whose family is certain was abducted.
If you think you’ve seen Jonathan stay with him or in sight of him. Ask if he is Jonathan. Call 911. Then call Crime Stoppers - (800) 222-TIPS (8477).
For the most current information and public material regarding Jonathan, please visit findjonathanhoang.com.
Amber's Sources:
Lonnie...
Episode 283 - Mary Kay Letourneau & The Survival Story of Katie Piper
This week, Naomi covers one of the most notorious child predators of the 90’s.
Then Amber covers Katie Piper who survived an acid attack by an abusive ex-partner.
Naomi's Sources:
Mary Kay Letourneau - Wikipedia
Mary Kay Letourneau: Notes on a Scandal
Amber's Sources:
Katie Piper Foundation: www.katiepiperfoundation.org.uk
Katie Piper - Wikipedia
'Resilience is in all of us' – Katie Piper on how surviving an acid attack has s...
Episode 282 - The Murder of Samantha Heller & Christian Gerhartsreiter
In this episode, Amber covers the murder of Samantha Heller who was killed by an abusive boyfriend.
Then, Naomi covers the story of a notorious con man who also became a murderer.
For this episode, Amber was drinking Ruffino Prosecco Rose
Amber's Sources:
Man suffocated girlfriend after she survived 100 mph crash - ABC7 Chicago
Judge rules Lancaster County man cannot take back his guilty plea for murder of girlfriend in 2012 | fox43.com
Plea Stands for Man Serving Decades for Killing Girlfriend in Highway Crash
Ben...
Episode 281 - The Murder of Nadine Ann Taylor & The Rosenhan Experiment
This week, Naomi covers the disappearance and murder of a mother of two in Halifax, who’s justice came at the hands of a very brave woman, and her unlikely escape from the hands of a serial killer in the making.
Then Amber covers the Rosenhan Experiment. The 1973 article "On Being Sane in Insane Places," was a study by psychologist David Rosenhan that exposed flaws in psychiatric diagnosis.
Naomi's Sources:
Steven Laffin | Murderpedia, the encyclopedia of murderers
https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/nova-scotia/fears-grow-for-missing-halifax-woman
Da...
Episode 280 - The Murder of Aleta Diane Ray & The Zanesville Zoo Massacre
This week, Amber shares the murder of Aleta Diane Ray, a devoted mother who was senselessly killed by her partner's scorned ex-wife.
Then, Naomi tells the true events of the time a private zoo in Ohio was set loose on an unsuspecting town.
For this episode, Amber was drinking Menage a Trois Red Blend
Amber's Sources:
Idaho man recalls how ‘evil’ estranged wife, a former nurse, committed murder in doc: ‘I felt disgusted’ | Fox News
Investigation Discovery
Aleta Diane Ray Murder: Where Are Autumn P...
Episode 279 - The Murder of Ronni Chasen & The Story of Terry Wallis
This week, Naomi covers the murder of a successful Hollywood publicist that many believe still remains unsolved.
Then Amber covers the miraculous survival story of Terry Wallis.
Naomi's Sources:
https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/what-happened-night-publicist-ronni-chasen-was-killed
Hollywood Mystery
https://abcnews.com/US/ronni-chasen-murder-person-interest-publicist-slaying-fatally
The Murder of Ronni Chasen
Ronni Chasen - Wikipedia
Amber's Sources:
Terry Wallis - Wikipedia
Terry Wallis, 57, Dies; Awoke 19 Years After a Traumatic Brain Injury...
Episode 278 - The Stalking and Murder of Kristil Krug & D.A.R.E.
This week, Amber covers the stalking and murder of Kristil Krug who was failed by law enforcement.
Then, Naomi takes us back to the 80’s and the origin story of D.A.R.E., a police-run program to keep kids off drugs, or so they told us.
For this episode, Amber was drinking an iced coffee.
Amber's Sources:
Who killed Kristil Krug? Slain Colorado mom received menacing threats weeks before her murder. - CBS News
She was stalked and harassed and blamed her ex. Evidence about the tr...
Episode 277 - The Sycamore Gap Mystery & Rattlesnake Kate
This week, Naomi covers the story of the tragic felling of the Sycamore Gap Tree.
Then Amber covers Katherine McHale Slaughterback AKA Rattlesnake Kate who encountered a rattlesnake migration and took matters into her own hands.
Amber was drinking coffee for this episode.
Naomi's Sources:
The Sycamore Gap Mystery
Sycamore Gap tree - Wikipedia
Amber's Sources:
Katherine McHale Slaughterback
Katherine Slaughterback (Rattlesnake Kate)
Stories of a Legend <...
Episode 276 - The Murders of Geraldine Jackson and Nancy Phelps & The Disappearance of Melissa Caddick
This week, Amber covers the murders of two elderly women, Geraldine Jackson and Nancy Phelps, in Buffalo New York.
Then, Naomi covers the disappearance of a con woman in Australia.
Amber's Sources:
Grand Jury Indicts Henchen in Murders of Two Elderly Women | Buffalo Toronto Public Media
Henchen Indicted in Southtowns Murders | Buffalo Toronto Public Media
MISSING WOMEN’S BODIES FOUND - The Herald-Courier
Henchen's widow sues sheriff over his death
<...Episode 275 - The Murder of Jennifer Levin & The Secret Mall Apartment
This week Naomi covers another notorious murder from the 80’s that was dubbed The Preppy Murder.
Then Amber covers the secret mall apartment where 8 artists built a hidden 750-square-foot living space inside the Providence Place Mall in Rhode Island.
For this episode, Amber was drinking a pomegranate Sanpellegrino.
Naomi's Sources:
The Preppy Murder: Death in Central Park
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Chambers_(criminal)
Amber's Sources:
Secret Mall Apartment Documentary Film (2024) - Netflix; Directed by Jeremy Workman<...
Episode 274 - The Kiss and Kill Murder & David Reimer
This week Amber covers the story of Elizabeth "Betty" Jean Williams, who was shot to death in Odessa, Texas, by her ex-boyfriend, John Mack Herring
Then, Naomi covers the tragic story of the medical experimentation inflicted on David Reimer.
Amber's Sources:
Kiss and Kill - Wikipedia
A Kiss Before Dying – Texas Monthly
Killer Claims Girl Begged Him To Shoot Her | by Cat Leigh | Of Misdeeds and Mysteries | Medium
A Crime to Remember S3 E13
Naomi's Sources:
...
Episode 273 - The Murder of Darcey Freeman & American Apparel
This week, Naomi covers the horrifying public murder of a little girl in Australia.
Then Amber covers the story of American Apparel and the abusive founder, Dov Charney.
This week, Amber was drinking Maison Perrier Peach Spritzer
Naomi's sources:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Darcey_Freeman
https://www.theguardian.com/fgirl-thrown-from-bridge-by-father
https://murderpedia.org/male.F/f/freeman-arthur.htm
https://www.heraldsun.com.au/arthur-freeman-jailed-for-a-32year-minimum
https://www.abc.net.au/doctors-knew-freeman-was-violent-before-bridge-murder
Amber's Sources:
Trainwreck “The Cult of A...
Episode 272 - The Murder of Helena Greenwood & Mike Diana
This week, Amber covers the murder of Helena Greenwood. Helena was murdered in her home just weeks before she was scheduled to testify at trial for her sexual assault case.
Then Naomi covers the case of the first and only artist to be tried and found guilty of obscenity.
Amber's Sources:
Forensic Files S8 E24 “Nailed”
Life sentence without parole for slaying of exec | Local News | smdailyjournal.com
DNA traps scientist's killer 15 years on | World news | The Guardian
Naomi's Sources:
Mike Diana - Wikipedia
A C...
Episode 271 - Gisèle Pelicot & A Plane Crash In The Alaskan Wilderness
This week, Naomi covers the mass rape trial in France that shook the world.
Then Amber tells the story of two friends out for a brief sight-seeing flight that left them stranded in the Alaskan wilderness.
For this episode, Amber was drinking 100 Nails Ranch Pinot Noir Central Coast
Naomi's Sources:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gis%C3%A8le_Pelicot
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pelicot_rape_case
https://time.com/collections/women-of-the-year/7216401/gisele-pelicot-rape-case/
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cvg4l80gz7eo
https...
Episode 270 - Benjamin and Meghan Elliot & The Life and Death of Princess Diana
This week, Amber covers the story of twins, Benjamin and Meghan Elliot. 17-year old Benjamin Elliot stabbed his twin sister Meghan, but he claimed he was sleepwalking.
Then, Naomi tells the story of the short and surreal life and tragic death of The People’s Princess.
Amber was just drinking water for this episode.
Amber's Sources:
48 Hours S 38 E 1 The Boy Who Killed His Twin
A Texas teen stabbed his twin sister to death. It's a mystery why. - CBS News
Benjamin Elli...
Episode 269 - The Murder of Lindsay Hawker & The Disappearance of Patricia Meehan
This week, Naomi covers the murder of a young British teacher, working abroad, who was murdered by an obsessed would-be student.
Then Amber covers the strange disappearance of Patricia Meehan. Patricia vanished after walking away from a car crash on Montana Highway 200 in April 1989.
Anyone with information on Patricia Meehan is asked to call the McCone County Sheriff’s Office at 406-485-3405.
This week, Amber was drinking a mocktail of Ginger Ale and Black Cherry San Pellegrino
Naomi's Sources:
Murder of Lindsay Hawker - Wikipedia
Li...
Episode 268 - The Murder of Debbie Dorian & The Mysterious Death of Casey Kasem
In this episode Amber covers the murder of Debbie Dorian. Debbie was killed in her Fresno apartment in 1996. It would take 30 years for justice to be served.
Then, Naomi tells the winding tale of the life and death of one of America’s most iconic radio DJ’s.
For this episode, Amber was drinking American Vintage Red Blend from CA
Amber's Sources:
DNA breakthrough solves 1996 murder of California woman, revealing serial predator - ABC News
How Debbie Dorian's Killer Escaped Police for Over 20 Years | 20/20: The After Show<...
Episode 267 - The Murder of Sonia Blount & The Kidnapping of Denise Lee
This week, Naomi covers the tragic murder of a devoted mom by yet another man who couldn’t handle rejection.
Then Amber cover the kidnapping of Denise Amber Lee. Denise and several others made 911 calls but because of a broken system, first responders arrived too late.
Naomi's Sources:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UTWSAttcV5w
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-40002220
https://www.irishtimes.com/news/sonia-blount-s-killer-revealed-during-trial-
https://www.irishexaminer.com/news/arid-30790050.html
htt...
Chaotic Break: The Unsolved Murder of Arpana Jinaga & The Exxon Valdez Oil Spill
Don't worry, Chaos Kids...we're not taking a whole month off. Unforeseen circumstances have us taking an unexpected break this week, but we will be back with a brand new episode next week! In the meantime, enjoy a classic and one of our personal favorites.
This week, Amber covers the unsolved murder of Arpana Jinaga who was found dead in her apartment after a community Halloween party. Thank you to Jennifer B. for the story suggestion!
Amber pulled her sources from:
Podcast – True Crime All The Time – Unsolved, Episode 140
Arpana Jinag...
Episode 266 - The Murder of Farah Swaleh Noor & The Iroquois Theater Fire
This week Naomi covers one of the most gruesome and notorious murders in Ireland, the killers dubbed the “Scissor Sisters” for their horrific crime.
Then Amber covers the Iroquois Theater Fire, the deadliest single-building fire, killing over 600 people.
For this episode, Amber was drinking Chardonnay – Blue Jean
Naomi's Sources:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MEBfO3MHpwM
https://murderpedia.org/female.M/m/mulhall-sisters.htm
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scissor_Sisters_(convicted_killers)
https://www.independent.ie/regionals...
Episode 265 - The Murder of Melissa Lamesch & The Bogle-Chandler Mystery
This week, Amber covers the devastating murder of Melissa Lamesch and her unborn son Barrett.
Then, Naomi tells the story of one of Australia’s most persistent and fascinating mysteries: who killed Gilbert Bogle and Margaret Chandler?
For this episode, Amber was drinking a blood orange San Pellegrino
Amber's Sources:
People Magazine Investigates S E 8 “Inferno of Lies”
Illinois firefighter accused of staging a house fire to cover up a murder — and a secret - CBS News
‘48 Hours’ episode details 2020 murder of Mt. Morris woman<...
Episode 264 - The Murder of Felix Polk & The Strange Story of Mary Louise Day
This week, Naomi covers a bitter divorce that turned into murder, and a family divided.
Then Amber tells the story of the disappearance of Mary Louise Day. A 13-year old girl who disappeared in 1981 and then re-appeared 22 years later. Or did she?
For this episode, Amber was drinking Cabernet Sauvignon From F. Stephen Miller Cellars
Naomi's Sources:
https://murderpedia.org/female.P/p/polk-susan.htm
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Susan_Polk
https://web.archive.org/web/20080907143641/http://today.msnbc.msn.c...
Episode 263 - The Hazing of Danny Santulli & Frederic Bourdin: Serial Imposter
This week, Amber covers the near fatal hazing of Danny Santulli at University of Missouri's Phi Gamma Delta fraternity.
Then, Naomi covers the incredulous true story of a man who spent decades pretending to be other people, in an attempt to stay young forever?
For this episode, Amber was drinking Hearsay – Red Blend from Santa Barbara County
Amber's Sources:
House of Horrors: Secrets of College Greek Life Episode 1
Parents of freshman permanently impaired in hazing incident praise new law holding colleges accountable
Fam...
Episode 262 - The Murder of Daniel & Linda Broderick & Sarah Lawrence College Cult
This week, Naomi covers the double homicide of a man and his wife killed by what the press described as “a woman scorned”.
Then Amber tells the story of a dad-turned-cult leader to a group of college friends in Yonkers, New York.
Amber was drinking a pinot from Johan Vineyards in Willamette Valley.
Naomi's sources:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betty_Broderick
https://murderpedia.org/female.B/b/broderick-betty.htm
https://murderpedia.org/female.B/b/broderick-betty.htm
Ambe...
Episode 261 - The High School Catfishing Story & Tham Luang Cave Rescue
In this episode, Amber covers a high school catfishing story where a teen and her boyfriend face persistent harassment from an unknown number.
Then, Naomi covers the harrowing rescue of 12 boys and their coach from the depths of a dangerous cave, that captivated the entire world.
For this episode, Amber was drinking a lime San Pellegrino.
Amber's Sources:
Unknown Number Documentary
10 Jaw-Dropping Details 'Unknown Number' Didn't Include About Owen and Lauryn's Cyberbullying Case
‘Unknown Number: The High School Catfish’ Director on Doc’s Bizar...
Episode 260 - The Murder of Kirsten Costas & The Making of the Movie, "Roar"
This week, Naomi covers another notorious murder from the 80’s that inspired a made for tv movie: the murder of a beloved daughter whose death shook an entire community.
Then Amber covers the making of the 1981 movie, Roar which was one of Hollywood's most dangerous and chaotic projects.
For this episode, Amber was drinking Bebame Red from El Dorando County CA
Naomi's Sources:
https://murderpedia.org/female.P/p/protti-bernadette.htm
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Kirsten_Costas
https://moviedelic.com...
Episode 259 - The Attempted Murder of Ashley Freeman and Michael Grinnan & The Hoddle Street Massacre
This week, Amber covers the attempted murder of Ashley Freeman and Michael Grinnan. Ashley and Michael were college sweethearts and out for a night drive, when things went horribly wrong.
Then, Naomi covers a mass killing in Melbourne, Australia that shocked the whole nation.
For this episode, Amber was drinking Ben Ami, a red blend from California.
Amber's Sources:
Massillon murder suspect has decades-long criminal history
Massillon man admits to killing two women, gets life term
Ashley Freeman and Michael G...
Episode 258 - Pamela Smart & Stranded On A Volcano
This week, Naomi covers one of the most infamous murder trials in modern history, one of the first to be televised in real time.
Then, Amber tells the story of a newly divorced dad, on his first vacation without his family, and a sight seeing excursion gone horribly wrong.
Amber was drinking Sleight of Hand Cellars, a Columbia Valley Red.
Naomi's sources:
https://www.cbsnews.com/pamela-smart-accepts-responsibility-husbands-murder-first-time
https://www.governor.nh.gov/governor-ayotte-pardon-request-pamela-smart
https://abcnews.go.com/pamela-smart-teen-lover-murdered-husband-decades-ago
...
Chaotic Break: The Murder of Nikki Kuhnhausen & Harvey's Casino Bombing
Amber and Naomi are taking a much needed and unprecedented hiatus. Don't worry! We'll be back in no time! In the meantime, here's another old favorite of ours, Episode 146, originally published on July 30th, 2023.
This week, Naomi covers the tragic murder that led to the Nikki Kuhnhausen Act, removing the “gay & trans panic defense” in Washington State as justification for murder.
Then Amber covers The Harvey's Resort Hotel bombing. In August of 1980, what appeared to be a delivery from IBM was dropped off at Harvey's Hotel Resort. The package was actually 1,000 pounds of dynam...
