The Creep Off
Congratulations, you have discovered the greatest and only comedy true crime competition on the internet! Every week our hosts Karl and Vinnie go head-to-head and each make their nominations for the biggest creep in any given category. Then You the listener get to decide the points, and the loser spins the dreaded wheel of consequences.
A Brother Is A Brother
This week on The Creep Off, Karl & Vinnie nominate their picks for the creepiest conman. These scammers did more than steal a few bucks, and now it’s up to you to decide which one deserves the title. Plus, another round of terrible people in the Scum Parade and a new edition of Karl’s Cop Cam.
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
The score is currently Vinnie 1- Karl 1 – Guest 0
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here...
Cigarettes & Perfume
It’s Wildcard Round on The Creep-Off! Karl & Vinnie can nominate a creep from ANY category. Plus, we’ve got a brand-new Cop Cam, another Scum Parade, and the main event: Karl spins the Wheel of Consequences! Listen and learn his fate.
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
The score is currently Vinnie 1 - Karl 0 – Guest 0
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
‘Done for the day’: US ambulance driver abandons patient and takes Uber home | Cleveland...
Karl Obama
Who is the creepiest candidate? Karl and Vinnie make their nominations for the biggest creeps in the most important election of our lifetime. Plus, this week on Karl’s Cop Cam which watch the police remove a human bowling ball from a short bus and on the Scum Parade we meet another Joker wannabe, and a perverted Jeopardy champion get sentenced.
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
The score is currently Vinnie 0 - Karl 0 – Guest 0
Check out this week’s...
Meth Math 101 (Halloween Creeps)
Halloween is here, and the creeps are already out. Karl’s Cop Cam is back, and the Scum Parade is marching through a TJ Maxx dressing room and a lawsuit-prone, STD-ridden nail salon.
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
The score is currently Vinnie 4 - Karl 3 – Guest 0
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
Woman went to salon for manicure, left with herpes: Lawsuit
TJ Maxx manager allegedly hid video...
Ain't I a Stinker? (Who is the Creepiest Fireman?)
Who is the creepiest firefighter? Karl and Vinnie bring you two firefighters who made headlines for all the wrong reasons. You decide who gets the title. Plus, Karl’s Cop Cam and the Scum Parade!
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
Bus driver 'farted so badly' it led to sacking after colleagues 'needed a shower' - Daily Star
Long Island bar patron admits to setting place abl...
A Mother’s Lament
Karl & Vinnie are back to find out who is the creepiest couple. Plus, a brand-new edition of Karl’s Cop Cam and a fresh Scum Parade featuring a creepy pediatrician and a woman who went to great lengths to become a male nurse. Join us live and let us know who you think deserves the point!
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
Sheriff: Improperly-equipped vehicle driven by double amputee kills pe...
A Mother’s Lament
Karl & Vinnie are back to find out who is the creepiest couple. Plus, a brand-new edition of Karl’s Cop Cam and a fresh Scum Parade featuring a creepy pediatrician and a woman who went to great lengths to become a male nurse. Join us live and let us know who you think deserves the point!
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
Sheriff: Improperly-equipped vehicle driven by double amputee kills pe...
Copyright Strike Transplant
Karl & Vinnie are back in the studio for an episode that’s anything but normal. Things get a little real and the boys clear the air, and the “will they or won’t they?” energy returns. For the first time ever, they both bring the same creep: Tom Myers. Tom has hit The Creep Off’s YouTube channel with a copyright strike over a video from more than two years ago, and now he’s sent a proposal. Karl & Vinnie respond. There’s no Cop Cam or Scum Parade; this one is more of a YouTube stream than a traditional...
The One Where Vinnie loses his Shit
Who Is the Creepiest Neighbor? Karl and Vinnie each bring a neighbor from hell, and you decide who deserves the point.
Plus, Karl’s Cop Cam, the Scum Parade, and more people you’ll be glad don’t live next door.
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
Mother accused of giving away baby to stranger at bus stop
School employee allegedly stabbed delivery driver with a pen 6 times becaus...
Lonely in St. Petersburg
Karl & Vinnie welcome another competitor into the contest: Jerry Banfield, an expert in this week’s category... Creeps on Dating Apps. Jerry enters the competition with a chance to flip the guest score to 5 if he can take down Karl & Vinnie! Will he single-handedly force them to spin the dreaded Tandem Wheel of Consequences?
Plus, Karl’s Cop Cam, the Scum Parade, and all the usual insensitive comedy you’ve come to expect!
Become a Patron or a YouTube member for Friday’s Scum Stream and other bonus content. Vote for this week’s winner at Patreon...
A Headless Flock of Seagulls
Karl & Vinnie celebrate Grandparents Day by nominating grandparents who prove that getting older doesn’t mean getting kinder or wiser, turns out some of them are pretty shitty! Who is the Creepiest Grandparent? You decide!
Become a Patron or a YouTube member for Friday’s Scum Stream and other bonus content. Vote for this week’s winner at Patreon.com/TheCreepOff
Voicemail: 585-371-8108
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
Where's Waldo? She Is Lying Naked Atop A Wooden Pallet | The Smoking...
Stop Mething Around
Join Karl, Vinnie, and the unmistakable voice of Syracuse, Brian McBride, as they celebrate Labor Day the only way they know how, with a special Scum Parade! The guys are clocking in to cover some of societies biggest wastes of space! Plus, Karl’s Cop Cam, your voicemails, and more!
Check out the stories here:
Glamorous TV host weeps as she’s sentenced to death by hanging for involvement in drug trafficking gang
She does that every morning': Brentwood residents say woman defecating on sidewalk is threatening them | FOX 11 Los Angeles
"...
Down to Clown
WHOOP WHOOP! Karl & Vinnie are heading to the Dark Carnival to find out which Juggalo deserves the title of Biggest Creep!
PLUS: Karl’s Cop Cam, The Scum Parade, your voicemails and more!
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
57326209 | Wayne County Sheriff's Office, NY
Tulsa cops hunting 'serial defecator' who terrorized local businesses
Fast food worker 'trying to serve...
Join Karl & Vinnie for another wild card showdown. There is no category, and they can pick whoever they want! plus Karls Cop Cam, The Scum Parade and Vinnie spin’s the wheel
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
Iowa Woman Busted On Lawn Mower OUI Rap | The Smoking Gun
Man allegedly killed father and kept corpse in the garage
Heavily pregnant Australia...
The Pig That Ate St. Louis
This week, Karl and Vinnie are diving into the world of OnlyFans to find out who can uncover the Creepiest OnlyFans Model. We’ll also check in on Karl’s Cop Cam, march some fresh scumbags through the Scum Parade, and find out if Vinnie will be spinning the wheel.
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
Naked woman arrested after driving stolen Pleasant Prairie fire vehicle - WISN
...
Steel Shark
Karl and Vinnie head into the garage to find the creepiest grease monkey! We’ll also fire up another edition of Karl’s Cop Cam, march some fresh scumbags through the Scum Parade, and make several arguments that probably won’t hold up under even the slightest scrutiny!
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
https://nypost.com/2026/07/30/us-news/naked-man-found-hiding-in-fresno-plasma-center-ceiling-resists-arrest/
https://nypost.com/2026/08/01/us-news/florida-dad-allegedly-murdered-infant-with-leaf-blower/
ht...
Meowschwitz
Karl and Vinnie head north of the border to answer one question: Who is the Biggest Creep in British Columbia? We'll also bring you a brand-new Karl's Cop Cam, another edition of the Scum Parade, and all the arguments, bad decisions, and questionable judgment you've come to expect from us at the Creep Off.
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
https://cnycentral.com/news/local/ex-doordash-driver-accused-of-filming-naked-customer-gets-trial-date
http...
Here's The Thing
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
This week, Karl and Vinnie head to the Iberian Peninsula to answer one very important question: Who is the Biggest Creep in Spain? They may have won the world cup, but we will knock them down a peg or two! We'll also bring you a brand-new Karl's Cop Cam, another packed Scum Parade full of humanity's worst behavior, and all the usual nonsense you've come to expect from The Creep Off.
Check out this week’s scum...
The Strike Zone
Join Karl & Vinnie as they slide tackle one of the world's biggest sports, soccer. We will also have Karl's Cop Cam, The Scum Parade, and your voicemails!
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
TJ Maxx & Walmart Voyeur In Irving And Dallas Arrested
'Helicoptering his g*******' | Repeat flasher charged for alleged public indecency, trespassing in Indianapolis
New Jersey woman with ‘boobs’ tattoo acc...
It’s 3 O’clock Somewhere
There is nothing more patriotic than the Scum Parade! Join Karl, Vinnie, and Tell 'Em Steve-Dave!'s Bryan Johnson for a stripped-down episode dedicated to the kind of scum only America can produce!
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-15867943/Moment-family-plant-hair-childs-meal-pub.html?utm_source=fark&utm_medium=website&utm_content=link&utm_campaign=fark&ICID=ref_fark
https://www.courthousenews.com/ca...
Old Habits Die Hard
After a month of Pride-themed creep categories, we're throwing out the rules. One final wildcard matchup will decide who earns the dubious honor of being crowned the creepiest of them all. Karl and Vinnie will also bring you another edition of Karl's Cop Cam, a fresh Scum Parade packed with the internet's latest degenerates, and your voicemails.
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Anthrocon marks 20 years of bringing furries to Pittsburgh
'Poodunnit' solved after swimmer admits to defecating in...
Who Da Man? Who Da Man?
#258 Who Da Man?
This week on The Creep Off, Karl & Vinnie continue their Pride Month celebration by tackling the biggest category of them all: Who Is the Creepiest "+"?
In this installment of Karl’s Cop Cam, we meet a non-binary indigenousness, anxiety and generational traumatized drunk driver! Oh Boy! Plus a brand-new scum parade, and most importantly Danni asks us to judge her bikini!
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum pa...
Hey! I Recognize that Blanket!
This week on The Creep Off, Karl & Vinnie continue their Pride Month celebration by asking one very important question Who Is the Creepiest "T"? Which "T" will pass and claim the title? We're joined by Mahalia to go over our new consequences before Vinnie spins the Wheel! We'll also watch a brand-new edition of Karl's Cop Cam and learn how the Lord works in mysterious ways in this week's Scum Parade.
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum...
A Long Trip Down a Dirt Road
Pride Month rolls on, and this week Karl & Vinnie are celebrating by nominating the Creepiest "G"! Who will earn this prestigious and completely unwanted title? We'll be digging through another collection of all-around pieces of garbage to determine which "G" is the worst of them all! In this installment of Karl’s Cop Cam, we meet a teacher/wine enthusiast who needed more booze! In the Scum Parade, we meet an office hero who took a stand, an amateur magician and a reminder to keep your pets on a leash
Don’t forget to vote for w...
Leggo My Preggo
Pride Month is here, and Karl & Vinnie are celebrating the only way they know how—by asking one very important question: Who Is the Creepiest "L"? In this installment of Karl’s Cop Cam, we meet an expectant mother who terrorizes sex shops with her child in tow, and appears to have built quite an impressive collection of drugs and alcohol: In the Scum Parade, we learn why you should never cheap out on a casket, discover that cats don't fly, and find out that sometimes it's better to end a situation before it gets even worse.
...
That's All We Had Karen!
Join Karl & Vinnie for the Annual Memorial Day Scum Parade, a holiday tradition unlike any other. We’re digging through some of the biggest degenerates, scumbags, predators, weirdos, and absolute disasters so you don’t have to! Plus, we check out Brittany Spears arrest video.
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
Police: Montgomery County man shows up drunk to pick up friend from DWI arrest - WNYT.com NewsChannel 13
Notorious 'Pee Pee Poo Poo Man' busted for 2 alleged sexual assaults
Man had...
Intercepted by Warlords
Karl & Vinnie scrub in for a brand-new episode of The Creep Off to answer one important question: Who is the Creepiest Nursing? Plus a fresh edition of Karl’s Cop Cam, featuring guns, car chases and a good boy named Danger. This week’s Scum Parade features a negligent OnlyFans model, a man who liked shopping at Walgreens way too much, and a woman who ate all the food!
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum parade stories h...
See you in St. Louis!
This week, Karl & Vinnie head to the Gateway City to answer one important question: Who is the Biggest Creep in St. Louis? Plus, a brand-new edition of Karl’s Cop Cam asks what happens when a man’s coworker is caught red-handed with his 14-year-old daughter. And in the Scum Parade, we meet a strict grandmother, an amateur chef, and learn exactly how old you need to be to get a tattoo.
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum pa...
Lonely Fans
This week on The Creep Off, Karl & Vinnie head south of the border to answer one question: Who is the Biggest Creep in Mexico? Expect wild stories, a brand-new Karl’s Cop Cam, and a Scum Parade where we witness the first shots of the pedo hunter civil war!
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
The score is currently Vinnie 2 - Karl 2 – Guest 4
Want more of the madness? Support the show on Patreon, Supercast to snag exclusive merch and get an...
There is No Vape, Only Rasul!
The Creep Off goes back to court as Karl and Vinnie tackle one of the sleaziest professions on earth to answer one question: Who is the Creepiest Lawyer? Plus: Karl’s Cop Cam features a woman with a bit of a drinking problem, followed by a police problem. In the Scum Parade we meet Jersey Mikes new spokesperson, A Mothers worst mistake and we ruin everyone’s favorite holiday movie Home Alone
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum pa...
THE JOKER SUCKS
In this episode of The Creep Off, Karl and Vinnie head into the dark, sticky world of the movies to answer one simple question: Who is the biggest creep in the movie theater? We’ve also got a fresh batch of degeneracy in the Scum Parade, and another installment of Karl’s Cop Cam, where we learn why public transportations is always a bad idea
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
Man allegedly...
Live From Las Vegas 3: Why So Blue?
In this episode, Karl & Vinnie are live at Hackamania from the Plaza Hotel in Las Vegas for an unforgettable Creep-Off! They’re joined by special guest referee Dr. Steve and the keeper of the consequences, Mahalia, for a high-stakes competition where the loser has to ride the zipline over Fremont Street in a kilt. Lucy Tightboxxx and Anthony Cumia join the show to break down the addition of a new character, “Polish Joe,” in the Janel Grant v. Vince McMahon lawsuit. Ant, Karl & Vinnie breakdown a wild cop cam featuring one of the worst cops of all time. Finally, they’r...
Everybody Loves Karl
This week's episode is no holds are barred, and Karl & Vinnie are free to nominate whoever they want as this week's biggest creep!
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
Man caught cooking dog meat at Udon Thani home | Thaiger
Ind. Teen Found Guilty of Raping Non-Verbal Boy with Autism on School Bus
Man clawed at woman's new tattoo, ripped skin from her throat...
Two Birds, One Exhaust Pipe...
This week on The Creep Off, Karl & Vinnie head into unfamiliar territory… the dentist’s office. Plus, we welcome Dr. Steve, who announces he’ll be serving as special guest referee for our competition at Hackamania.
We’ve also got a fresh batch of degeneracy in the Scum Parade, and another installment of Karl’s Cop Cam, where cops discover a woman with a fresh haircut chained up in a bedroom.
And finally, Vinnie spins the Wheel of Consequences.
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest c...
A Genuine Karl Foot
Join Karl & Vinnie as they celebrate "Pakistan Day" by nominating the country's biggest creep! Plus the usual chaos and side tangents—we watch Justin Timberlake's DUI arrest and break down whatever fresh scumbaggery the universe served up this week.. Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
Pervert sent penis pics in pink chastity belt and begged woman to treat him like a pony - Daily Star
From Healer to Offender: Six Year...
Lucky Charms & Woodchippers
Today on The Creep-Off, Karl & Vinnie celebrate the least necessary holiday of all time St. Patrick’s Day by searching for the biggest creep in Ireland. Plus, one of the scariest cop cams we’ve seen yet, featuring two children on their way to commit murder, and the latest updates from the world of scumbags.
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
Head priest of Trinity Episcopal Church in Pittsburgh accused of...
One Noisy Floater
Join us for a special celebration in honor of International Women’s Day! Karl & Vinnie want to celebrate you women with an episode dedicated to the worst of you! we’ll listen to your voicemails, watch a woman enjoy a marital aide in the privacy of the front seat of her car, and bring you the latest in scum stories from creepy women around the world!
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
Police: W...
I need a Demon Like I Need a Hole in the Head
Everything’s bigger in Texas…especially the creeps. This week on The Creep Off, Karl & Vinnie head to the Lone Star State to answer one question: Who is the Biggest Creep in Texas?
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
https://www.yahoo.com/entertainment/celebrity/articles/maury-povich-wants-no-part-152931919.html
NHS doctor who spied on men in toilets said he only wanted to compare penis size | News UK | Metro...
Africa's Funniest Home Videos
Lock up the good silver, this week Karl & Vinnie will be making nominations for the creepiest house cleaner! Plus, We are joined by Lucy Tightboxxx to give us last week’s results, we’ll listen to your voicemails, watch a truly wild cop cam video, and bring you the latest in scum stories from around the world!
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff.
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
Clarksburg Banana Republic peeping tom arrested, police sea...
The Continuing Adventures of Brandon & Kayla
This week, Karl & Vinnie celebrate Presidents Day by nominating their picks for the biggest creep in our nation’s capital. We also check back in with the King and Queen of Cop Cam videos making their third appearance Brandon & Kayla! Plus your voicemails and a brand-new Scum Parade.
Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at Patreon.com/Thecreepoff
Check out this week’s scum parade stories here:
https://www.jsonline.com/story/news/crime/2026/02/05/stoughton-police-use-drone-to-catch-serial-defecator-park/88528813007/
https://www.dailystar.co.uk/news...