Evan & Tiki
Evan & Tiki brings balance, brains and edge to New York sports talk. Evan Roberts’ fan-first intensity pairs with Tiki Barber’s perspective from inside the game to create debate that’s informed, passionate and rarely predictable. Whether it’s Giants and Jets analysis, Yankees and Mets arguments, or Knicks, Nets and league-wide storylines, the conversation goes deeper than hot takes. Throw in Shaun Morash, who stirs the pot with unfiltered opinions and the raw pulse of the fanbase, and you have Evan & Tiki, a show where New York sports get talked through — not talked over.
Kickoff with Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti for Week 8 in the NFL | 'Kickoff with Boomer & Valenti'
Boomer and Mike breakdown the crazy NFL trades and project which may happen. They pick all the games in the NFL, and ask which of the current playoff teams can actually win the Super Bowl on a loaded Week 8 episode of Kickoff
Bo Bichette Opts Back In | 'Rico Brogna'
Bo Bichette has elected to opt in to his contract with the Mets. Let's take a look to see if it's worth it for the Mets to be spending 42 million dollars on an average third baseman. Visit TheRicoB.com for everything Rico Brogna Podcast P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Email [email protected]
Friday Full Show: Garrett Wilson Watch is on, Jets Prep for Raiders, Giants Rooting Guide
The Jets get set for yet another must win, but should they be more open to options at the trade deadline. A Football Friday with all the fix ins is here
Hour 1: Evan Blasts the Push to Trade Garrett Wilson
Evan Roberts is drawing a hard line: trading Garrett Wilson would be a massive mistake for the Jets, even if the return includes multiple first-round picks. Shaun Morash pushes back, warning that Wilson's frustration with losing could eventually force the Jets into a trade when they have far less leverage. Tiki Barber argues that New York needs more weapons, not fewer, especially with a rookie quarterback potentially on the way. Why gamble on draft picks when the Jets already have a proven star? The heated debate exposes a bigger problem with the Jets: coaching, not talent. Evan and Tiki insist...
Hour 2: Jalen Brunson’s Philly Award Is an Absolute Embarrassment
Jalen Brunson is Philadelphia’s Athlete of the Year, and the reaction is priceless! Evan and Tiki rip the Philadelphia sportswriters for honoring the Knicks superstar who helped embarrass the Sixers, questioning whether Philly has completely lost its pride. Does Brunson’s Villanova connection really justify this stunning decision? Plus, Boomer Esiason floats a surprising Giants trade target: Raiders running back Ashton Jeanty. Evan loves the potential upside of adding a former sixth overall pick, but Tiki strongly disagrees, arguing Jeanty isn't a significant upgrade over Cam Skattebo. Would the Giants be wasting valuable draft capital or buying low on a fu...
Hour 3: Ashton Jeanty Calls Out Jets Defense
Ashton Jeanty's comments about Jets defenders not wanting to tackle have Evan fired up, especially after the defensive coordinator's uninspiring response! Evan rips the lack of intensity and demands that the Jets use the criticism as motivation against the Raiders. Tiki explains the power of bulletin-board material, while concerns grow over David Bailey's injury and Aaron Glenn's future. Could an unlikely late-season surge actually save Glenn's job? Meanwhile, Evan predicts the Giants will add a running back before the trade deadline despite Cam Skattebo's emergence. Tiki weighs in on the cost of acquiring Ashton Jeanty and whether the Giants need...
Hour 4: Evan Roberts Slams Betting Odds for "Disrespecting" the Giants
Evan Roberts revisits a $100 bet he placed in February for the New York Giants to win the NFC, expressing frustration that the odds remain at 40-1 despite the team sitting in first place. Sean Morash provides a comprehensive rooting guide for fans during the bye week, while Tiki Barber prepares for his eighth New York City Marathon. The crew also makes their weekly NFL picks, including a unanimous selection for the Jets over the Raiders.
(00:01:50) NFL Cleat Issues
(00:04:20) Giants Rooting Guide
(00:11:45) Tiki's Marathon Prep
(00:16:20) NBA Cup Importance
(00:23:50) Evan's Longshot...
Shaun Has Had Enough of Halloween's Worst Traditions
Could Aaron Glenn actually save his job with the Jets? A frustrated caller fears Woody Johnson will bring Glenn back regardless of how the season ends, but Evan argues that a surprising late-season turnaround could completely change the conversation. Tiki weighs in on whether Glenn can still prove himself as a head coach, while serious questions emerge about Frank Reich's ability to develop the Jets' next young quarterback. Plus, Shaun Morash delivers his five worst things about Halloween, taking aim at candy corn, silly string, smashed pumpkins, and kids who refuse to say trick or treat! Evan and Tiki weigh...
Bad Tiki Returns and Unleashes Chaos on Evan and Shaun
Bad Tiki is back after nearly a year, and nobody at WFAN is safe! The outrageous AI character makes a Halloween return with relentless shots at Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, Shaun Morash, and the brand-new studio. From mocking the Mets and David Stearns to delivering an absolutely ridiculous Halloween costume reveal, Bad Tiki picks up right where he left off.
Evan Can't Believe Jets Coach's Response to Jeanty
Ashton Jeanty says some Jets defenders don't want to tackle, and Evan is stunned by the team's response! After hearing the defensive coordinator's lackluster comments, Evan questions whether the Jets have the leadership needed to fire up their defense. Tiki explains how powerful bulletin-board material can be and why Sunday's matchup with the Raiders is a chance for the Jets to prove their toughness. If they fail to respond, Evan believes it will only strengthen the argument that coaching is the team's biggest problem.
Evan Predicts Giants Will Trade for Another Running Back
Cam Skattebo has won over Giants fans, but Evan isn't convinced he's done enough to stop the team from upgrading at running back! Evan argues that Ashton Jeanty still offers greater upside and predicts the Giants will trade for another back before the deadline. Tiki pushes back on surrendering valuable draft picks and explains why bringing in competition could actually motivate Skattebo. Plus, Bo Bichette is staying with the Mets after exercising his $42 million option, but is that really good news? Evan and Tiki explain why the expensive short-term commitment makes sense despite Bichette's disappointing season. The guys also react...
Boomer Esiason’s Stunning Giants Trade Idea Has Evan Sold
The Giants trading for Ashton Jeanty might sound crazy, but Evan Roberts is all in! After Boomer Esiason floats the surprising idea of acquiring the Raiders’ former sixth overall pick, Evan argues the Giants could buy low on a potential star. Tiki Barber isn't buying it, insisting Jeanty hasn't proven he's a significant upgrade over Cam Skattebo and questioning why the Giants should sacrifice valuable draft capital for another unproven running back. The debate intensifies as Evan pushes back against accusations that he's trolling Giants fans, while Tiki warns that adding Jeanty could disrupt the running back room without actually im...
Jalen Brunson Has Officially Humiliated Philadelphia Again
Jalen Brunson is Philadelphia’s Athlete of the Year, and Evan Roberts is absolutely disgusted! The Philadelphia Sports Writers Association has decided to honor the Knicks superstar despite his role in ending the Sixers’ season and humiliating their fans. Evan calls the decision embarrassing and questions whether Philadelphia has any sports pride left, while Tiki Barber explores whether Brunson’s Villanova roots make the selection defensible. Has Brunson officially become the king of Philadelphia, too?
Trading Garrett Wilson Could Haunt the Jets for Years
Evan Roberts is furious with Amazon Prime after hearing what he believes was a fake sound effect during a missed extra point in the Packers-Panthers game. Evan insists the broadcast added an unnecessary crashing sound to the kick, calling it embarrassing and questioning why an NFL game needs cartoonish sound effects. Tiki Barber isn't nearly as bothered, sparking a hilarious debate over whether Evan is making too much of it.
Tiki Blasts Jets Coaching as the Real Problem
Evan Roberts is fed up with Jets fans dreaming about first-round picks instead of appreciating Garrett Wilson. Evan and Tiki Barber argue that trading a proven star would be a massive gamble, especially when the Jets are preparing to develop their next franchise quarterback. Tiki points to how the Bengals surrounded Joe Burrow with weapons, while Evan insists the Jets already have enough draft capital and need to stop creating more holes on their roster. The debate intensifies as Shaun Morash continues warning that Wilson could eventually want out, but Evan calls out the contradiction between worrying about losing players...
Evan Blasts Shaun's Garrett Wilson Trade Argument
Evan Roberts refuses to budge on Garrett Wilson, but Shaun Morash believes the Jets are making a massive mistake by keeping their star receiver. Shaun warns that Wilson's growing frustration with losing could eventually force his way out, leaving the Jets with far less trade leverage. With multiple first-round picks potentially on the table, is now the time to cash in before it's too late?
Thursday Full Show: Pat Murphy Takes a Shot at the Yankees, Garrett Wilson Wants to Stay
Pat Murphy is a World Series Champ but a mic catches him take a shot at Yankee culture, Joe Beningo stops by In Studio, Connor Hughes talks Trade Deadline, and much more
Hour 1: Pat Murphy's Yankees Jab Exposes an Ugly Reputation
Pat Murphy takes a shot at the Yankees after leading the Brewers to a World Series championship, and New York fans are furious! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber dissect Murphy's viral exchange with former Yankee Jake Bauers and debate whether his comments expose a much bigger problem in the Bronx. Has the Yankees' reputation for big spending, selfish play, and a lack of accountability become impossible to ignore? Tiki questions Aaron Boone's ability to hold his stars accountable, while Evan argues that Milwaukee's winning formula isn't so easy to replicate with a roster full of highly paid players. Plus, Evan...
Hour 2: Joe Benigno Blasts David Stearns for Betraying Pete Alonso
Joe Benigno storms into the WFAN studio and unloads on David Stearns, declaring he'll never forgive the Mets executive for letting Pete Alonso walk. Even with Milwaukee celebrating a championship, Joe has zero confidence in the Mets' direction, questions Juan Soto's impact, and makes his feelings clear about what the team needs this offseason. The conversation turns explosive when the Jets come up. Joe is running out of patience with the coaching staff, Evan refuses to entertain trading Garrett Wilson, and the possibility of a quarterback change looms if the losing continues. Plus, Garrett Wilson addresses speculation about wanting out...
Hour 3: Ashton Jeanty Calls Out Jets Defense as Quitters
Ashton Jeanty just gave the Jets the ultimate bulletin-board material! The Raiders running back claims some Jets defenders don't want to tackle, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber believe Aaron Glenn must use those comments to fire up his team. With Glenn's future increasingly uncertain, Connor Hughes joins the show to reveal just how much trouble the Jets head coach could be in, why Garrett Wilson isn't likely to be traded, and why bringing back Rex Ryan would be a massive mistake. Across town, the first-place Giants are exploring potential trade deadline upgrades. Hughes reveals their interest in Jonathan Taylor...
Hour 4: Debating an Eight-Year Deal for Tarik Skubal and the Mets
Evan and Tiki analyze whether the New York Mets should gamble on an eight-year, $320 million contract for Tarik Skubal despite his injury history. They also discuss the New York Jets' quarterback future involving Cade Klubnik and engage in a heated debate about the merits of living in New York versus Florida.
(00:01:50) NFC East Division Race
(00:03:15) Tarik Skubal Mets Rumors
(00:08:40) Yankees Roster Construction
(00:13:28) Cade Klubnik Draft Discussion
(00:22:30) New York Vs Florida
(00:31:54) NFL Trade Deadline Moves
(00:40:40) Historic Sports Droughts
(00:43:35) Packers Vs Panthers Preview
Evan Wants Mets to Gamble $320 Million on Tarik Skubal
The Mets need a legitimate ace, and Evan Roberts is ready to take a massive risk! Evan makes the case for giving Tarik Skubal an eight-year, $320 million contract despite his injury history. Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash weigh in on whether the Mets should go all-in on one of baseball's best pitchers. Plus, the Yankees face their own offseason decisions, including protecting young talent and potentially pursuing Japanese slugger Sato. Meanwhile, Tiki boldly picks the Giants to win the NFC East, as the crew debates whether New York can hold off the Cowboys. Evan also considers trading multiple Jets first-round...
Mets' Halloween World Series Collapse Still Haunts Fans
Derek Jeter's unforgettable Mr. November home run, the Mets' heartbreaking World Series collapse, and the night Mike White stunned the Bengals! Shaun Morash delivers his five most memorable Halloween moments in New York sports history, sparking plenty of nostalgia and painful memories for Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber. From the Jets beating the Giants in a rare Halloween showdown between Boomer Esiason and Phil Simms to Alex Rodriguez's historic reviewed home run in the 2009 World Series, the countdown is packed with unforgettable moments. Evan relives the agony of the Mets' 2015 World Series loss, while Shaun reveals why Halloween 2001 stands above...
Ashton Jeanty Rips Jets Defenders for Avoiding Tackles
Ashton Jeanty just called out the Jets defense, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber believe Aaron Glenn better make his players pay attention! The Raiders running back claims some Jets defenders don't want to tackle, sparking a heated conversation about effort, toughness, and accountability. Tiki examines the potential culprits, while Evan argues that failing to respond with their best defensive performance of the season would be another damning indictment of Glenn's leadership.
Connor Hughes Reveals Aaron Glenn's Jets Job Is in Serious Danger
Aaron Glenn's future with the Jets is looking increasingly bleak, and Connor Hughes delivers a troubling outlook for the head coach. Hughes joins Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber to explain why Glenn could be coaching for his job, how the Jets' repeated game-management failures are costing them victories, and why bringing back Rex Ryan would be a terrible idea. Plus, could Garrett Wilson eventually demand a trade if the losing continues? Across town, the Giants are eyeing a potential trade deadline splash. Hughes reveals their interest in Jonathan Taylor and Tony Pollard, but warns against sacrificing too much draft capital...
Garrett Wilson Reveals His True Feelings About the Jets
Garrett Wilson is shutting down the trade speculation, but his frustration with the Jets' constant losing is impossible to ignore! Evan Roberts blasts the New York media for fueling rumors that Wilson wants out, arguing that Jets fans overwhelmingly want their star receiver to stay. After Wilson declares his love for New York while admitting the losses hurt more every week, Evan and Tiki debate how much longer his patience can last.
Joe Benigno Rips Jets for Wasting Their Talent
Joe Benigno has had enough of the Jets' dysfunction! With another disappointing season unfolding, Joe blasts the coaching staff, questions Geno Smith's reluctance to take chances, and warns that a loss to the Raiders could push his frustration over the edge. Could a coaching change be coming, and when should the Jets turn to Cade Klubnik? The debate heats up over Garrett Wilson as Joe admits he's considered trading the star receiver for a massive draft haul, while Evan argues the Jets can't afford to strip weapons away from their next quarterback. Plus, Joe celebrates the Knicks' championship, praises Mike...
Joe Benigno Erupts Over David Stearns Letting Pete Alonso Walk
Joe Benigno is back in the WFAN studio, and he's absolutely furious with David Stearns! Joe declares he'll never forgive the Mets executive for letting Pete Alonso walk, predicts Alonso could reach the Hall of Fame as an Oriole, and questions whether Stearns deserves any credit for Milwaukee's championship success. But Joe isn't stopping there. He calls out Juan Soto for failing to carry the Mets when they need him most, blasts the team's disastrous replacement for Alonso at first base, and explains why he has zero confidence in the organization's direction. Plus, Evan and Tiki explore the possibility of...
Aaron Boone's Yankees Have a Massive Accountability Problem
The Yankees are getting mocked by World Series champions, and the criticism of their culture is getting harder to ignore! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber revisit Pat Murphy's viral comments and debate whether Aaron Boone's unwillingness to hold his highly paid stars accountable is holding the franchise back. Evan also questions why Hal Steinbrenner's desire to win should mean anything when Brian Cashman continues running a team that repeatedly falls short. Meanwhile, Milwaukee's championship has Evan wondering whether the Giants could pull off their own miracle Super Bowl run, even if Tiki insists he's been preaching that possibility for months...
Jeffrey Simmons' Massive Trade Price Scares Off the Giants
The Brewers are World Series champions for the first time, but Evan Roberts is furious with how they celebrated! Where was the massive dogpile, the emotion, and the pure chaos that should come with winning a championship? Evan and Tiki Barber react to Milwaukee's surprisingly subdued celebration before debating whether Pat Murphy's demanding managerial style could ever work with the Yankees and their highly paid stars. Is Aaron Boone's lack of accountability part of the problem? Plus, a blockbuster NFL trade sends Jeffrey Simmons from the Titans to the Bears for a massive haul of draft picks! Should the Giants...
Yankees' Losing Culture Is Becoming a League-Wide Punchline
Pat Murphy takes a shot at the Yankees moments after the Brewers win the World Series, and his viral comments have New York fans fired up! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate what Murphy actually meant when he suggested Yankees players only care about themselves. Is Milwaukee's championship-winning manager exposing a harsh truth about the Yankees' culture, or simply taking an easy shot at a big-spending franchise that hasn't delivered?
What If Brett Baty Isn't Here Anymore | 'Rico Brogna'
That's right. Is there someone who can fill in for Brett Baty and his super utility role?
Wednesday Full Show: Joe Schoen Speaks on the Trade Deadline, Knicks Finally Win
The Giants may be active at the trade deadline after listening to Joe Schoen, The Jets own the Colts pick, The Knicks win, and much more
Hour 1: Giants Must Get Aggressive With NFC East at Stake
The Giants are sitting atop the NFC East, and the NFL trade deadline presents a massive opportunity. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate how aggressive Joe Schoen should be with limited draft capital and a legitimate chance to win the division. Could Tony Pollard provide the boost the Giants need after Tyrone Tracy's injury, or would Jonathan Taylor be worth a blockbuster move? Plus, J.J. McCarthy's impressive Giants debut raises a fascinating question: Have the Giants already made the best move of the deadline? Meanwhile, Evan fires back at the idea of trading Garrett Wilson, arguing the Jets would...
Hour 2: Jorge Posada Exposes Growing Tension With the Yankees
Jorge Posada says he doesn't feel welcome around the Yankees, and Shaun Morash is putting Brian Cashman on blast! With CC Sabathia questioning the absence of former players and Derek Jeter's complicated history with Cashman, Shaun believes the Yankees have lost the championship culture that once made them special. Evan Roberts pushes back, arguing Posada's bitterness over how his career ended could explain the tension, while Tiki Barber explains why keeping franchise legends involved matters. Meanwhile, the Jets face massive decisions ahead of the NFL trade deadline. Would dealing Garrett Wilson or Breece Hall be a disastrous mistake for their...
Hour 3: Aaron Glenn's Game Management Failures Are Killing the Jets
Wink Martindale unloads on the Jets, questioning Aaron Glenn's ability to handle defensive play-calling and head coaching duties while taking a direct shot at Woody Johnson for not paying for a defensive coordinator. Shaun Morash sees Martindale's comments as validation of his earlier reporting, while Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Glenn is simply overwhelmed or the Jets have a much bigger coaching problem. Tiki also breaks down the disastrous goal-line sequence against Miami and explains how one small formation mistake can cost an NFL team a game. Plus, could J.J. McCarthy actually threaten Jaxson Dart's future as...
Hour 4: Would Sean McDermott's Winning Culture Work for the Jets?
Evan and Tiki discuss the intense accountability culture Jim Harbaugh brings to the Giants and wonder if the Jets should target Sean McDermott to fix their organization. They examine the historical rarity of 3-0 comebacks in the World Series and debate the merits of trading Garrett Wilson. The conversation also covers the recent string of major NBA injuries and the aesthetic changes to the WFAN studio.
(00:01:50) Harbaugh's Leadership Tactic
(00:06:00) New York Hockey Rivalries
(00:09:10) Sean McDermott Jets Fit
(00:15:15) Trading William Contreras
(00:20:30) Station Internal Debates
(00:27:45) Trading Garrett Wilson
<...Justin Herbert Could Be the Jets' Ultimate Trade Target
Could Justin Herbert actually become the Jets' next franchise quarterback? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explore a potential blockbuster trade, the massive draft capital New York could offer, and whether Jim Harbaugh might ever consider moving on from his star quarterback. Evan admits he'd be interested despite Herbert's flaws, but questions whether the Chargers would ever make him available. Plus, Shaun Morash gets confronted with his own brutal old tweets about Jorge Posada while defending the former Yankees catcher amid his criticism of Brian Cashman. A caller floats a wild conspiracy theory involving Darren Mougey deliberately pushing Garrett Wilson toward...
Wink Martindale Blasts Woody Johnson Over Jets Coaching Mess
Wink Martindale takes aim at the Jets, blasting Aaron Glenn for trying to handle defensive play-calling and head coaching duties while suggesting Woody Johnson refused to pay for a legitimate defensive coordinator. Shaun Morash sees Martindale's comments as vindication of his earlier reporting, but Evan Roberts questions whether the former Giants defensive coordinator is telling the whole story. Tiki Barber argues that Glenn's defense has largely performed well, but his struggles managing critical game situations are becoming impossible to ignore. Plus, Tiki breaks down the Jets' disastrous goal-line sequence against Miami, revealing how a subtle formation mistake involving Mason Taylor...
Tiki Barber Defends Kayvon Thibodeaux Against Giants Critics
Could J.J. McCarthy actually steal Jaxson Dart's job as the Giants' starting quarterback? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate what it would take for McCarthy to force a legitimate quarterback competition in 2027, with a Super Bowl victory emerging as the ultimate measuring stick. Even a deep playoff run might not be enough if McCarthy isn't the driving force behind it. Plus, Tiki pushes back against Giants fans frustrated with Kayvon Thibodeaux, explaining why his impact goes far beyond sacks and missed opportunities. The conversation also turns to the Giants' running backs, Cam Skattebo's response to John Harbaugh's challenge, and...