Crime Clueless
Crime Clueless dives into the world of true crime with a unique twist: a seasoned fan guides complete newbies through chilling cases, unraveling mysteries and unexpected twists together. Whether you're new to true crime or a seasoned sleuth, get ready to go from clueless to obsessed!
Phoebe Handsjuk Part 2: Truth, Twists, and Theories
In Part 2 of our deep dive into the baffling death of Phoebe Handsjuk, we’re pulling back the curtain on the investigation—and it’s not pretty. From missing security footage to bizarre crime scene oversights, this episode unpacks the behind-the-scenes missteps that left a grieving family with more questions than answers. We’ll break down the leading theories—accident, suicide, or something much darker—and explore the details that just don’t sit right. If you thought the garbage chute was the strangest part of this story... you haven’t heard anything yet.
Send us a text
Suppo...
She Didn’t Slip Into That Chute – Phoebe Handsjuk
When 24-year-old Phoebe Handsjuk was found dead at the bottom of a luxury apartment building’s garbage chute—missing a shoe, her foot nearly severed, and surrounded by trash—the official word was “accidental death.” But… excuse us, what now? In this head-scratching episode, we dive 12 stories deep into a case that makes zero sense the more you learn about it. Was Phoebe's death a tragic mix of wine, Ambien, and poor judgment? Or was something darker lurking behind the pristine walls of the Balencea apartments?
Join us as we untangle bizarre text messages, broken glass, a very questio...
Facebook Feud Murder – The Billie Jean and Billy Payne Case
It started with a friend request. Then a petty comment. Then a block. Then… murder.
In this jaw-dropping episode of Crime Clueless, we’re diving into one of the pettiest—and most tragic—double murders ever linked to a social media fight: the killings of Billie Jean Hayworth and Billy Payne, two young parents gunned down in their home in Mountain City, Tennessee, while their baby lay in Billie’s arms.
And behind it all? A wannabe-crime-boss grandma with a gun, a jealous ex-girlfriend with Wi-Fi rage, and a group of unhinged accomplices known as “The Crips”—a...
Murder at the Lil’ Champ – The Terry Paquette Case
On a quiet February morning in 1996, 31-year-old Terry Paquette showed up early to work at the Lil’ Champ convenience store in Orlando. Hours later, his coworkers walked into one of the most horrifying crime scenes the area had ever seen—Terry was found brutally murdered in the store’s bathroom. He had been stabbed 73 times, his throat was slashed, and blood covered the floor, the walls, even the stall doors. But despite DNA left at the scene… the case went cold.
For 26 years, Terry’s killer walked free.
In this episode of Crime Clueless, we dig into t...
Til Death (or a Suspicious Fall) Do Us Part
When ophthalmologist Toni Henthorn set off on a romantic anniversary hike with her husband, Harold, she had no idea she was about to take her last step. What should have been a scenic, love-filled getaway ended in tragedy when she mysteriously fell 140 feet to her death in Rocky Mountain National Park.
Harold, ever the devoted husband (cough), had an explanation—an unfortunate accident. Just like when his first wifedied in a freak accident. Just like when he waited 45 minutes to call for help. Just like when he took out nearly $5 million in life insurance on Toni before he...
Blood and Betrayal: The Haysom Case
In 1985, a quiet home in Bedford County, Virginia, became the scene of a brutal double murder. Derek and Nancy Haysom, a well-respected couple, were found savagely slain in their own home—a crime that shocked the community and left investigators searching for answers.
At first glance, the Haysoms seemed to have no enemies. Who could have wanted them dead? As detectives dug deeper, they uncovered a web of secrets, a tumultuous love affair, and a shocking betrayal that would take them across continents in search of the truth.
But was th...
Who Killed Pentagon Official Jack Wheeler?
A respected Pentagon insider. A cybersecurity expert with government ties. A man who helped shape U.S. military policy—found beaten to death, discarded in a landfill.
In the final days of 2010, John "Jack" Wheeler III was seen wandering the streets, confused and disoriented, claiming his briefcase had been stolen. Days later, his bruised and battered body was found in a Delaware landfill, his death ruled a homicide by blunt force trauma. But who killed him—and why?
Was his murder a professional hit? Did he stumble upon something classified that...
How to Survive Stalking – The Ultimate Safety Guide
Stalking isn’t a meet-cute. It’s a crime.
Imagine getting an anonymous text saying, “Nice dress today.” But you never told anyone where you’d be. Or noticing the same car outside your house… every night. It’s creepy, it’s unsettling, and for millions of people, it’s reality.
In this episode of How to Survive, Jenna and Shannon break down everything you need to know about stalking—how to spot the warning signs, protect yourself, and shut it down before it escalates.
Inside This Episode:
✔️ The red flags—early signs that s...
The Perfect Frame Job—Until It Wasn’t
 The Perfect Frame Job—Until It Wasn’t Â
The Twisted Truth Behind the Murder of Betsy Faria Â
What happens when the justice system gets it completely wrong? When an innocent man is sent to prison while the real killer walks free—living comfortably off the victim’s life insurance?
In this episode, we unravel the shocking twists and deadly deception behind the murder of Betsy Faria. At first glance, the case seemed open and shut—a husband accused of brutally killing his wife in their home. But as the evidence unra...
The Haunting of Winchester House
Step inside one of the most mysterious homes in America—the Winchester Mystery House. In this episode, we unravel the captivating story of Sarah Winchester, the grieving heiress who poured her fortune into building a sprawling, bizarre mansion. With its twisting hallways, staircases to nowhere, and doors that open into thin air, the house defies explanation. Was it designed to confuse vengeful spirits, or was it a reflection of Sarah’s haunted psyche?
Join us as we explore the history, the myths, and the ghostly encounters that make this house a legend. From the eerie séance room...
A Friend, A Lover, A Killer: The Murder of Betty Gore (part 3 of 3)
The trial of Candy Montgomery is underway, and the stakes couldn’t be higher. In the final chapter of our series on the Betty Gore case, we take you inside the courtroom as the prosecution argues this was a brutal, rage-fueled attack, while the defense presents a shocking claim of self-defense—bolstered by hypnosis. As jaw-dropping testimony unfolds, the jury must decide: was Candy pushed to the edge, or did she meticulously cover up a crime of passion? When the verdict is finally announced, the reaction is explosive. What happened to Candy after the trial? And decades later, does just...
A Friend, A Lover, A Killer: The Murder of Betty Gore (part 2 of 3)
With Betty Gore’s brutal murder sending shockwaves through Wylie, Texas, the case against Candy Montgomery begins to take shape. As investigators close in, Candy turns to an unlikely ally—Don Crowder, a defense attorney with no murder trial experience but a bold approach to the case. Meanwhile, she meets with psychiatrist Dr. Fason, a move that hints at a deeper strategy.
As the summer of 1980 turns to fall, Candy and her legal team work behind the scenes, preparing for what will become one of the most sensational trials in Texas history. What really happened that morning? And...
A Friend, A Lover, A Killer: The Murder of Betty Gore (part 1 of 3)
The peaceful town of Wylie, Texas, is the kind of place where neighbors are friends, church is the center of social life, and nothing truly bad ever happens—until it does.
Betty Gore, a schoolteacher and mother of two, is settling into life with a newborn, but something feels off. Her husband, Allan, is traveling for work more often, leaving her alone with the long, exhausting days of motherhood. The loneliness weighs on her. Friends say Betty has always been sensitive—prone to self-doubt, easily hurt by slights both real and imagined—but lately, something deeper seems to be...
Series - Exploring the Psychology of Serial Killers: In the Mind of a Serial Killer, The Making of a Monster (ep. 1)
What drives someone to kill—and keep killing? In the first episode of The Psychology of Serial Killers series, we take a deep dive into the minds of those who commit the most chilling crimes. From childhood warning signs to the dark triad of personality traits, we explore what makes a serial killer tick. Are they born with a predisposition to murder, or are they shaped by their environment? Using real-life case studies and psychological analysis, we begin unraveling the twisted psyche of those who kill again and again.
Sherri Rasmussen: A Life Stolen, Justice Long Fought For
Sherri Rasmussen was a bright and compassionate nurse with a promising future, tragically cut short in 1986. Her murder remained unsolved for over two decades until a shocking twist revealed the truth: a killer hiding in plain sight. Join us as we unravel Sherri's story, from her remarkable life and devastating loss to her family’s relentless pursuit of justice. This episode dives deep into the case, the groundbreaking DNA evidence, and the trial that shook the LAPD to its core. Remember: refuse to be clueless, careless, or caught off guard. Not today, murderers.
Exploring the Mystery and Legacy of Kurt Cobain (Part 2)
With Guest Shelley Markov, Host of the Shit Apple Podcast
In Part Two of our deep dive into the death of Kurt Cobain, we shift our focus to the unanswered questions, suspicious details, and the alternative theories that refuse to fade away. From the baffling lack of fingerprints on the shotgun to the inconsistencies in the official investigation, we examine the strange gaps in the case that still fuel speculation decades later. We’ll also dig into the work of private investigator Tom Grant, who was hired by Courtney Love but soon found himself questioning everything ab...
Exploring the Mystery and Legacy of Kurt Cobain - Part 1 with Guest Shelley Markov
Today we dive deep into the enigmatic life and untimely death of Kurt Cobain, the legendary frontman of Nirvana. In this episode, Jenna is joined by Shelley, host of “The Shit Apple Podcast” to dig into this wild case. We explore his meteoric rise to fame, the struggles behind the spotlight, and the unanswered questions surrounding his tragic end. Was it a case of personal demons, or is there more to the story? Join us as we celebrate his artistic genius, and reflect on the legacy he left behind. This is a story of fame, mystery, and the enduring power...
A One-Way Trip: The Unsolved Mystery of Patti Adkins
On June 29, 2001, Patricia “Patti” Adkins clocked out of her shift at the Honda plant in Marysville, Ohio, and stepped into what was supposed to be the beginning of a secret getaway with a man she thought she knew. But she was never seen again. With no body, no crime scene, and a web of lies surrounding her disappearance, investigators were left with a chilling mystery. Was Patti the victim of a calculated plan? What really happened that night? In this episode, we unravel the strange details of the case, the suspicious circumstances surrounding her last known moments, and the ling...
The Greed, Betrayal, and Ultimate Downfall of Robert Marshall
Join us in this Valentines Month Special. Host Jenna is joined by her husband Brandon to dive into the Marshall case from the 1980s.Â
Robert Marshall had it all—wealth, status, and a picture-perfect life in Toms River, New Jersey. But beneath the surface? He was drowning in debt, tangled in affairs, and desperate for a way out. When his wife, Maria, was gunned down in what looked like a random robbery, the cracks in his carefully curated life began to show. Investigators followed a trail of gambling debts, secret phone calls, and shady hitmen, uncovering a mur...
The Springfield Three: A 30 Year Mystery
In the early hours of June 7, 1992, three women—Sherrill Levitt, her daughter Suzie Streeter, and Suzie’s friend Stacy McCall—disappeared from a quiet home in Springfield, Missouri. Their cars were left in the driveway, their belongings untouched, and their house eerily undisturbed. Over 30 years later, this baffling case remains unsolved.
Join us as we dive into the mysterious details of that night, the haunting theories—from a mysterious green van to a possible serial killer—and the heart-wrenching efforts of the families who refuse to give up hope. Was this a calculated abduction, a crime of opportunit...
The Tylenol Murders: A Case That Shook America (part 2)
The nation is in shock. Extra-Strength Tylenol—trusted in millions of households—has been weaponized, and no one knows who is responsible. The recall has begun, but the damage is already done. Seven people have died, and investigators now face a daunting task: tracking down the killer before they strike again.
In this episode of Crime Clueless, we dive into the massive investigation that followed the Tylenol murders. Law enforcement scours stores, examines packaging, and interviews thousands of potential witnesses, all while racing against time. Theories begin to emerge, including the infamous extortion letter from...
The Tylenol Murders: A Case That Shook America (part 1)
On September 29, 1982, an ordinary morning turned into a nightmare when 12-year-old Mary Kellerman took an Extra-Strength Tylenol capsule and collapsed minutes later. Within hours, more lives were lost—including three members of the same family. What at first seemed like a string of medical emergencies soon revealed itself to be something far more sinister: poison.
In this episode of Crime Clueless, we unravel the early hours of the Tylenol murders, following investigators as they struggle to understand how and why seemingly healthy people are dying so suddenly. As more cases emerge, panic spreads, and the te...
Slipped into the Darkness: The Mystery of Brandon Swanson
A quiet rural road. A midnight phone call. A single exclamation—'Oh, shit'—before the line went silent. In this episode of Crime Clueless, we unravel the haunting disappearance of Brandon Swanson, a 19-year-old college student who seemingly vanished into thin air in the Minnesota countryside. Was it an accident, foul play, or something even stranger? Join us as we explore the chilling details, perplexing theories, and lasting impact of a case that remains unsolved to this day.
Send us a text
Find Crime Clueless Socials, blog, and website here...
The Mystery of Elisa Lam: Secrets of the Cecil Hotel (part 2)
In this episode of Crime Clueless, we dive deep into the unsettling mystery of Elisa Lam. From the eerie surveillance footage at the Cecil Hotel to the shocking details revealed in her autopsy, we explore every angle of this haunting case. We also break down the theories that have captivated true crime enthusiasts for years: Was it a tragic accident, a case of mental health struggles, or something far more sinister? Join us as we sift through the clues, speculate on the possibilities, and try to make sense of one of the most chilling cases of the decade. If...
The Mystery of Elisa Lam: Secrets of the Cecil Hotel (part 1)
In this episode, we unravel the haunting mystery of Elisa Lam, whose disappearance and tragic death at Los Angeles’ infamous Cecil Hotel captivated the world. From her last-known moments captured in the unsettling elevator footage to the grim discovery in a rooftop water tank, we delve into the investigation, the theories, and the unanswered questions that keep this case shrouded in intrigue. Join us as we honor Elisa’s life, explore the depths of her story, and confront the chilling legacy of the Cecil Hotel. A tale of mental health, urban legend, and humanity that defies explanation.
Cold Case Cracked: The Murder of Robin Lawrence
In this episode of Crime Clueless, we dive into the harrowing case of Robin Lawrence, a loving mother whose life was tragically cut short in her Springfield, Virginia, home in 1994. For nearly three decades, the brutal murder remained a cold case—until modern DNA technology and determined investigators unraveled the mystery. Join us as we explore Robin's story, the haunting details of the crime, and the breakthrough that finally led to justice. We’ll also discuss the chilling confession of the man responsible and the impact this resolution had on Robin’s family and community.
Send us a text...
Gone Without a Trace: The Unsolved Case of Bryce Laspisa
In this episode of Crime Clueless, we dive deep into the haunting case of Bryce Laspisa, a young man who disappeared without a trace in 2013. With his car found abandoned and his phone left behind, Bryce's sudden vanishing remains an unsettling mystery. We explore the timeline of events, the theories surrounding his disappearance, and the questions that still linger. Join us as we unravel the details of Bryce’s case, from his final moments to the ongoing search for answers.
Send us a text
Find Crime Clueless Socials, blog, and website here
Thank yo...
Honoring Nancy - An Interview with Jack Anderson
In this special episode of Crime Clueless, Jenna sits down with Jack Anderson, the brother of Nancy Anderson, to discuss his sister’s life, their family, and the shocking events that followed her tragic murder. Jack opens up about their childhood, sharing personal memories of Nancy and the impact she had on everyone around her. He also sheds light on his journey of seeking justice through his book, The Brittle Riddle, and how it ties into the larger fight for DNA justice. Along the way, we dive deep into never-before-heard stories, behind-the-scenes details, and fresh insights into the case th...
Nancy Anderson: Justice Revived (part 2)
In Part Two, we pick up Nancy Anderson's story in 2001, when her grieving family, still seeking answers after her 1972 murder, renewed contact with Hawaii detectives following her mother’s passing. Advances in DNA technology led to a breakthrough in 2019, identifying Tudor Chirila as the prime suspect through genealogical databases. Arrested in 2022, Chirila refused to admit he had committed this horrible crime. Further more, he passed away in custody before facing trial, leaving lingering questions. While justice in the legal sense was incomplete, Nancy’s family found solace in the resolution and focused on honoring her memory, ensuring her vibrant life...
The Murder of Nancy Anderson: A Case Gone Cold (part 1)
In 1972, 19-year-old Nancy Anderson was found stabbed to death in her Honolulu apartment in what appeared to be a senseless and brutal attack. Despite extensive efforts by investigators, leads quickly dried up, and the case grew cold, leaving a community haunted and a family without answers. Decades later, new developments would bring the case back to life. But what secrets had been hiding in plain sight all along? And could justice finally be served? Join us as we unravel the mystery of Nancy Anderson’s tragic murder and the startling revelations that would emerge years later.
Send us...
Christine Franke - Justice, Finally? (part 4)
With Benjamin Holmes behind bars, Christine’s family and friends face the emotional weight of the arrest. Benjamin's family reacts to the steps taken to connect him to this murder. As the case heads to trial, the pursuit of justice brings long-awaited answers—but not without its challenges. In this final chapter, we explore the courtroom drama, the family's reactions, and the lasting impact of the verdict on all those who loved Christine.
Send us a text
Find Crime Clueless Socials, blog, and website here
Thank you for listening - we are grateful for y...
Christine Franke - Cold Case Break and the Power of DNA (part 3)
After years of frustration and dead ends, Christine's case takes a dramatic turn in 2018 with the introduction of advanced DNA technology. Detectives revisit the evidence, leading to the shocking arrest of Benjamin Holmes. Who was he, and how did his DNA finally connect the dots? This episode unravels the science and determination that reignited the investigation and brought them closer to justice.
Send us a text
Find Crime Clueless Socials, blog, and website here
Thank you for listening - we are grateful for you!
Christine Franke - Friends, Secrets and Clues (part 2)
Detectives start to untangle Christine’s world by speaking with her friends and loved ones. What do they know about her life, her routine, and the days leading up to her murder? Could hidden secrets or overlooked details hold the key to solving the case? The investigation deepens as the search for answers intensifies.
Send us a text
Find Crime Clueless Socials, blog, and website here
Thank you for listening - we are grateful for you!
Christine Franke - A Life Interrupted (part 1)
In this episode, we meet Christine Franke, a vibrant college student with a bright future ahead of her. We explore her life, her aspirations, and the events leading up to the tragic night that would change everything. As detectives arrive at the scene, the search for answers begins.
Send us a text
Find Crime Clueless Socials, blog, and website here
Thank you for listening - we are grateful for you!
The Unsolvable Mystery of Rey Rivera - (Part 2)
The call that everyone feared came on May 24, 2006—Rey Rivera’s body had been found. In this episode, we dive into the shocking discovery at the Belvedere Hotel and the bizarre circumstances surrounding Rey’s death. From the peculiar state of the scene to the cryptic note taped behind Rey’s computer, every detail raises more questions than answers. Was this a tragic accident, or is something more sinister at play? We examine the police investigation, the unusual theories that emerged, and the eerie connections to Rey’s employer, Agora Publishing. As family and friends search for answers, we delve deep...
The Disappearance of Rey Rivera (Part 1)
Rey Rivera was a man on the cusp of fulfilling his dreams when he vanished without a trace on May 16, 2006. In this episode, we explore Rey’s life: his loving marriage to Allison, his move to Baltimore to pursue new opportunities, and his creative ambitions as a writer and filmmaker. Through interviews and first-hand accounts, we uncover the strange series of events leading up to his disappearance, including a frantic phone call that would be one of the last traces of Rey’s life. The story takes a chilling turn when his car is found abandoned near Baltimore’s histor...
The Vanishing of Brian Shaffer
In this episode of Crime Clueless, we dive into the mysterious disappearance of Brian Shaffer, a promising medical student who vanished without a trace from an Ohio bar in 2006. A night of celebration turned into a haunting puzzle when Brian was last seen entering the bar but never caught on camera leaving. Was it an elaborate escape, foul play, or something else entirely? Join us as we explore Brian’s life, the chilling details of that fateful night, and the theories that continue to baffle investigators and armchair detectives alike. Get ready to go from clueless to obsessed with th...
Crime Clueless Trailer
Send us a text
Find Crime Clueless Socials, blog, and website here
Thank you for listening - we are grateful for you!
