Canadian Creepies
Welcome to Canadian Creepies—the podcast that digs into the dark corners of Canada’s past and present. Your hosts Valerie, Ali, Amanda Joy ( host of Down the Crooked Path), and sometimes Kyle explore the true crime cases that haunt us, the paranormal encounters that make us question what’s real, and the unsettling folklore that lingers just out of sight.From cults to cold cases, ghosts to government cover-ups, we don’t just tell the stories—we ask why they still matter.It’s creepy. It’s Canadian. And it’s probably going to keep you up at night.
049 No One's Interested In Something You Didn't Do
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
In this powerful episode of Canadian Creepies, Valerie and Amanda take a deep, unflinching look at one of Canada’s most haunting true stories — the wrongful conviction of David Milgaard.
At just 17 years old, Milgaard was sentenced to life in prison for the murder of Gail Miller, a crime he did not commit. For 23 years, he fought to be heard while the real perpetrator, Larry Fisher, continued to prey on women across the Prairies. Through pressure, tunnel vision, and...
DTCP - The Bell Witch: Truth, Terror & Folklore
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
Step into the shadows of history and uncover one of America’s most chilling paranormal legends—the Bell Witch. In this episode of Down the Crooked Path, we dive deep into the eerie events that haunted the Bell family in early 19th-century Tennessee. Was it a vengeful spirit? A curse? Or something even more sinister?
From unexplained voices to violent attacks, the Bell Witch tormented a family and left behind a legacy of fear that still lingers today. Amanda Joy explore the terrifying accounts, the historical reco...
048 The Disappearance of Kenley Matheson
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
In September of 1992, twenty-year-old Acadia University student Kenley Matheson vanished from the small university town of Wolfville, Nova Scotia. His last confirmed sighting was on Main Street on the morning of September 21st. He was never seen again.
No remains.
No belongings.
No activity on his bank account.
And more than thirty years later, still no answers.
In this episode, we trace the verified timeline of Kenley’s disappearance, examine the early RCMP investigation, and explore the priva...
Bonus Episode: Interview with Brian Baker, Author of Eerie Whispers
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
In this special bonus episode of Canadian Creepies, we sit down with journalist and author Brian Baker to explore the question at the heart of his new book, Eerie Whispers:
Why are Canadians so afraid to talk about ghosts?
From campfire tales and immigrant folklore to the ancestral stories of Indigenous Nations, Canada is overflowing with supernatural lore—yet we often shy away from embracing it. Brian dives into the cultural forces that keep our paranormal experiences in the shadows, the st...
DTCP - Christopher Case: Fear and Fate
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
Did fear itself seal Christopher Case’s fate? In this gripping episode of Down the Crooked Path, host Amanda Joy unravels the eerie mystery surrounding Case’s tragic death—a story tangled in paranoia, ancient curses, and unexplained phenomena. When Christopher began receiving chilling warnings of impending doom, his life took a dark and terrifying turn.
As his fear escalated, so did the bizarre circumstances surrounding his final days. Was he the victim of supernatural forces beyond comprehension, or did his own mind betray him? We explor...
047 Creep of the Week: John A MacDonald
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
On this week’s Creep of the Week, we turn our attention to a figure often wrapped in myth, nostalgia, and carefully curated national memory. John A. Macdonald is remembered as Canada’s first Prime Minister — but beneath the statues and the schoolbook stories lies a far more unsettling legacy.
In this episode, we peel back the polished image to examine the darker foundations of the country he helped build. From the expansionist policies that fueled the construction of the Canadian Pacific Railway to the creation and en...
DTCP - Mercy Lena Brown's Story: The Last American Vampire
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
In 1892, the small town of Exeter, Rhode Island, became home to one of the most infamous vampire cases in American history. Mercy Brown, a young woman who succumbed to tuberculosis, became the center of a desperate and chilling ritual—one designed to stop what her family believed was a supernatural force draining their lives.
But was Mercy truly a vampire? Or was her story a tragic intersection of outdated medical practices and deep-rooted folklore? In this episode, we explore how tuberculosis fueled vampire legends, the shocking ex...
046 The Mulligan Affair
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
On this episode of Canadian Creepies, Valerie and Amanda head west to uncover one of the most shocking corruption scandals in Canadian history — The Mulligan Affair.
In 1950s Vancouver, Police Chief Walter Mulligan stood as the face of law and order… until a series of leaks exposed a tangled web of bribery, vice, and backroom deals that reached from the city’s underbelly to the highest ranks of power. What followed was a public scandal that shattered trust and left Vancouver haunted by its own hy...
DTCP - The Fox Sisters: Spirits, Secrets & Scandal
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
While Down the Crooked Path episodes on Canadian Creepies usually explores mysteries and hauntings from across Canada, this special episode takes us beyond our borders. Some stories are simply too strange — and too fascinating — to leave untold.
In this episode, we explore the fascinating story of the Fox Sisters, the women who ignited the Spiritualist movement in the 19th century. From their humble beginnings in Hydesville, New York, to their rise as celebrated mediums, their mysterious spirit rappings captivated audiences—but was it all a hoax?
T...
045 The Black Donnellys
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
On this episode of Canadian Creepies, Valerie and Kyle return to one of the most infamous stories in Canadian folklore — the tale of the Black Donnellys.
In the small town of Lucan, Ontario, a simmering feud between neighbours exploded into one of the bloodiest nights in Canadian history. Arson, vigilante justice, and deep-rooted grudges would turn a family’s name into legend — and leave behind a haunting that still lingers more than a century later.
Join us as we unravel the myths, the mob, and th...
DTCP 027 - The Prime Minister and the Spirits
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
On this episode of Down the Crooked Path, we uncover the hidden spiritual life of one of Canada’s most powerful figures — Prime Minister William Lyon Mackenzie King.
Behind the formal portraits and wartime speeches was a man who believed the dead could offer guidance to the living. Through séances, crystal readings, and long nights with mediums, King sought counsel from ghosts, angels, and even his departed mother — shaping not only his private world, but, perhaps, the course of a nation.
Join Amanda Joy as...
044 Unsolved Mysteries: Part 02
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
On this episode of Canadian Creepies, Valerie and Amanda return to the strange and the unsolved — where truth slips through the cracks of history.
From the mysterious death of painter Tom Thomson, to the daring Montreal Museum of Fine Arts heist, and the eerie story of a village that vanished, these are the enigmas that continue to haunt Canada’s collective memory.
Were they accidents, crimes, or something far more inexplicable?
Some mysteries don’t fade wi...
DTCP 026 - The Five Fishermen: Haunted by the Tide
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
On this episode of Down the Crooked Path, we head to Halifax, Nova Scotia—where the sea isn’t the only thing that refuses to rest.
Once a funeral home, now a fine dining landmark, the Five Fishermen Restaurant has served generations of guests… both living and otherwise. From flickering lights and moving cutlery to ghostly reflections in the mirrors, this historic building carries the weight of Halifax’s most tragic days.
Some say the spirits of Titanic victims still linger...
043 Unsolved Mysteries: Part 01
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
This week on Canadian Creepies, Valerie and Amanda dive deep into the strange and the unexplained — stories that have haunted Canada for decades.
From mysterious lights in the northern skies to a theatre magnate who disappeared without a trace, these cases blur the line between fact and folklore. Were they victims of foul play, cosmic encounters, or something even stranger?
Join us as we sift through clues, theories, and chilling coincidences that still leave investigators — and believers — searching for answers.
🎧 Some mysteries fade with...
DTCP 025 - Beneath the Escarpment: The Haunted Tunnels of the Niagara Region
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
On this episode of Down the Crooked Path, we venture deep beneath the Niagara Region—where the earth hides its secrets in stone and shadow.
From the eerie depths of the Merritton Tunnel to the forgotten bunkers near Decew Falls, these underground passages have long been home to whispers, footsteps, and unexplained lights. Some were built for war, others for industry—but all seem to have inherited something darker.
Join us as we uncover the ghostly legends buried beneath Niagara’s peaceful surface: the tunnel...
042 Creep of the Week: John Robinson
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
This week's episode is chaos. From Valerie being sick and struggling her way through the insanely wrong information to Daisy barking this one is one for the books.
Canadian Creepies presents it's first ever full length Creep of the Week with returning season 1 co-host Kyle!
Please note that the victim and timeline in this case discussed in the beginning is completely wrong and Valerie does clarify by the end of the episode all the correct information.
✨ This episode also highlights the work of...
DTCP 024 - Skeleton Park
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
Beneath the quiet grass of a neighbourhood park in Kingston, Ontario, thousands of bodies still lie just below the surface. Once a cemetery for the poor, the unknown, and the forgotten, the land was converted into a public park—without removing most of the dead.
Locals nicknamed it Skeleton Park, and for good reason.
For decades, residents have reported bones surfacing after rain, children digging up skull fragments, and apparitions wandering between the trees. Some hear ...
041 Shadows Over the St. Lawrence: Haunted Quebec 01
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
From the mist rising over the St. Lawrence to the echoing corridors of centuries-old fortresses, Quebec is a province built on history—and haunted by it.
In this episode of Canadian Creepies, Valerie and Amanda wander through three of Quebec’s most chilling sites:
🕯️ The Château Frontenac, where the ghost of the Count of Frontenac still walks the halls, searching for the love he lost.
⚔️ The Plains of Abraham, where phantom soldiers march through fog and cannon fire long after the batt...
DTCP 023 - The Dagg Poltergeist: When the Walls Spoke
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
In the fall of 1899, a quiet farmhouse near Shawville, Quebec became the center of one of Canada’s strangest hauntings. The Dagg family claimed their home was plagued by a mischievous—and sometimes malevolent—presence that threw stones, moved objects, and spoke in ghostly voices.
Neighbors witnessed it. Clergy tried to bless it away. Reporters documented it. Yet no one could explain what truly haunted the Daggs’ home.
Was it a spirit tormenting the living, a case of trickery and hysteria, or something else entirely...
040 Blood and Brotherhood: The White Boy Posse Part 02
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
In the shadows of Canada’s prairies, the White Boy Posse’s violent brotherhood reached its breaking point. What began as loyalty and blood spilled in silence erupted into betrayal, chaos, and murder—leaving communities scarred by the trail they left behind.
In Part Two of Blood and Brotherhood, we follow the group’s downfall, the bloody violence that marked its end, and how the echoes of white supremacy stretch far beyond the Prairies—reaching into Niagara and beyond.
🕯️ A tale of hate, power, an...
DTCP 022 - The Eternal Cry of the Dungarvon Whooper
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
In the late 1800s, deep in the Miramichi woods of New Brunswick, a young cook was said to have met a violent end in a remote lumber camp. Soon after, the stillness of the forest was shattered by terrifying, unearthly cries that echoed through the night. The men called it the Dungarvon Whooper, and the legend was born.
But were these chilling screams the restless spirit of a murdered man, a tale spun by lonely lumberjacks, or something older that has always haunted the...
039 Blood and Brotherhood: The White Boy Posse Part 01
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
In the shadows of Canada’s prairies, a violent brotherhood began to take shape. Calling themselves the White Boy Posse, this group bound its members with loyalty, intimidation, and blood. What started as a small, tightly knit crew would soon spiral into something far darker—leaving fear, chaos, and death in its wake.
In Part One of Blood and Brotherhood, we trace the origins of this ruthless organization: how it emerged, what fueled its rise, and the dangerous ideals that held it together. From back...
DTCP 021 - The Curious Case of Jacko the Ape
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
In the summer of 1884, a strange creature was said to have been captured near Yale, British Columbia—a being caught somewhere between man and beast. Reporters called it Jacko the Ape, and for a brief moment, the story gripped the imagination of a young nation.
But was Jacko a living relic of a lost species, an early Bigfoot encounter, or simply a case of tall tales and sensational headlines?
In this episode of Down the Crooked Path, we unravel the mystery of Jacko: the ca...
038 The Mystery of Justin Evans
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
In this unsettling installment of Canadian Creepies, we turn to Simcoe, Ontario, where the disappearance of 22-year-old Justin Evans in 2021 left a community shaken. Days of searching turned into weeks of questions, until his body was discovered and the story shifted from a missing-person case to something far darker.
Why was Justin targeted, and how did a small-town tragedy spiral into an unresolved mystery that continues to haunt those who knew him? Was it a crime of opportunity, a betrayal close to home, or something even...
DTCP 020 - The Haunting of Goblin Hollow
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
In this haunting installment of Down the Crooked Path, we revisit one of Prince Edward Island’s darkest unsolved crimes: the murder of Ann Beaton in 1859. Struck down on her walk home, Ann’s story blurred almost immediately into legend—her death investigated with a strange ritual, her memory carried in whispered ballads, and her spirit said to linger still.
Who killed Ann Beaton, and why has the truth remained buried for over 160 years? Was she the victim of a jealous hand, a random act of violen...
037 Shadows in Burlington: The Murder of Joseph Fritch
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
In this episode of Canadian Creepies, we revisit the tragic murder of Joseph Fritch, a Burlington man whose ordinary stop for gas turned into a nightmare. Ambushed by two teenagers, Fritch’s death shattered the illusion of “safe suburbia” and left a community reeling. We trace the crime from the night of the ambush to the swift arrests of Steven Olah and James Ruston, the courtroom outcomes, and the lasting questions about juvenile justice and accountability.
But this story isn’t only about legal proceedings—it’s about Jose...
DTCP 019 - Deerman: Folklore, Fear, and the Forest
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
In this eerie installment of Down the Crooked Path, we explore the unsettling legend of Deerman—a figure that straddles the line between man and beast in Canadian folklore. Part cryptid, part cautionary tale, Deerman has been whispered about in forested communities for generations: glowing eyes in the treeline, antlers silhouetted against the moon, and a body that seems almost—but not quite—human.
Where did this legend begin, and what does it reveal about our fears of the wilderness and the unknown? Is Deerma...
DTCP 018 - What Mr.Christie Hid
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
This Down the Crooked Path episode, hosted by Amanda Joy, uncovers a hidden chapter behind one of Canada’s most familiar names. Mr. Christie may have made good cookies, but his legacy carries with it a shadowed tale — one that begins with whispers of a room never meant to be found.
In this episode, Amanda slips past the ordinary history to explore the strange, the secretive, and the unsettling. What was concealed, and why? Some doors are closed for a reason… and once opened, they change how we...
DTCP 017 - The Silent Sister
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
On this journey Down the Crooked Path, we step into the fog of legend to unravel one of Canada’s most enduring ghost stories. Known to some as the Headless Nun, she is more than a campfire tale — her shadow lingers in whispered folklore, haunting landscapes, and uneasy imaginations.
In this episode, we peel back the layers of history and superstition, exploring the origins of the story, its ties to the land, and why her silence has echoed for centuries. Is she a warning, a memory, or s...
DTCP 016 - Whispers on the Frequency
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
In the shadow of the Cold War, one Canadian engineer found himself staring not at the ground, but at the skies. Wilbert Smith (1910–1962), a respected radio engineer, began his career tuning into the science of sound and signal—but soon found himself listening for something far stranger.
This week, Down the Crooked Path uncovers the curious story of Smith’s work, his secret government files, and the questions that followed him into history. Was he chasing nothing more than static… or had he stumbled onto transmissions from bey...
Season 02: New chills, same thrills.
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
A little ghostly pause in our schedule… 👻
Valerie here, taking a short break from my episodes so I can stir the cauldron and brew up something extra creepy. I’ll be back September 11th with a partner-in-crime to dig into true crime, haunted history, and the kinds of stories that keep you up at night.
But don’t wander too far—Amanda’s Down the Crooked Path episodes will still haunt your Tuesdays right here on Canadian Creepies. And while you wait for my return, ex...
DTCP 015 - The Mugwump Monster
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
In the shadowy waters of Ontario's Lake Timiskaming lurks a legend—one with scales, a serpentine body, and a reputation that’s as slippery as it is strange. Locals call it the Mugwump Monster, and its story winds through decades of eyewitness accounts, folklore, and just enough mystery to keep you looking twice at the water’s surface.
Hosted by Amanda Joy, this episode dives deep into the tangled mix of history, myth, and possibility surrounding Canada’s own lake monster. From chilling tales told aro...
Residential Schools: Part 06 Beyond Apologies - Paths to Justice and Reparations
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
In the final chapter of our six-part series, we look ahead—beyond the government apologies and symbolic gestures—to the deeper truths and ongoing demands for justice.
Valerie and Amanda explore the limitations of official apologies and what Indigenous communities have repeatedly stated is needed for real change: full reparations, land return, and systemic accountability. We highlight the urgent call for Indigenous-led education, cultural revitalization, and the re-centering of Indigenous knowledge, languages, and leadership in shaping a better future.
We also...
DTCP 014 - Demon Island
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
In the shadowy heart of the Canadian wilderness lies a remote, forested island with a name that echoes with warning: Demon Island.
In this episode, Amanda Joy explores the chilling folklore, unsettling disappearances, and whispered curses surrounding this little-known place. What began as campfire stories and cautionary tales has morphed into something far more unnerving—a legacy of dread that continues to haunt locals and curious visitors alike.
Why do some who visit return shaken? Why do others not return at all?
Fr...
Residential Schools: Part 05 The Unmarked Graves & Ongoing Impact
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
In May 2021, the world was forced to reckon with what Indigenous communities in Canada had known for generations: children never came home from residential schools. This episode begins with the discovery of unmarked graves at the former Kamloops Indian Residential School and continues with similar findings across the country—each one a painful confirmation of long-told truths.
We explore the emotional, cultural, and political impact of these discoveries, and how they’ve reignited conversations around truth, justice, and accountability. We also highlight how Indigenous communities are recl...
DTCP 013 - The Vampires of Wilno
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
In the quiet hills of Wilno, Ontario—the oldest Polish-Kashub settlement in Canada—whispers of something ancient still linger. Tales of the undead, of graves disturbed, of iron stakes and midnight rituals have passed through generations like warnings carried on the wind.
In this episode, Amanda ventures into the strange and shadowy folklore of Wilno’s so-called vampires. Blending Old World superstition with New World fear, these stories speak to the tension between tradition and survival, between myth and memory.
What happens when belief follow...
Residential Schools: Part 04 The Road to Reckoning
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
Co-hosted by Valerie & Amanda Joy (Down the Crooked Path)
What happened after the dormitories began to close? This episode traces the long, uneven path from the physical shutdown of Canada’s residential schools to the national reckoning still unfolding today.
Valerie and Amanda explore:
Closing the Schools (1960s–1990s): Why it took decades, and what “closure” actually looked like on the ground.The Sixties Scoop: How the removal of Indigenous children into non-Indigenous foster and adoptive homes continued the project...DTCP 012 - The Northern Triangle
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
Deep in the rugged wilderness of northern British Columbia lies a region with a chilling reputation: dozens of people have vanished here without a trace—planes, hikers, hunters, and entire search parties swallowed by the land.
In this episode, Amanda Joy ventures into the eerie mystery of what's become known as Canada’s Bermuda Triangle—a vast stretch of untamed terrain between Vanderhoof, Terrace, and the Yukon border where the disappearances are as frequent as they are unexplained.
Is it just u...
Residential Schools: Part 03 Resistance and Survival
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
Residential Schools: Erasure, Resistance, Reckoning — Part 03 of 06: Resistance & Survival
Co-hosted by Valerie and Amanda Joy (Down the Crooked Path).
This episode turns to the often-overlooked stories of resistance within the residential school system—a system designed to erase Indigenous identities and cultures. Valerie and Amanda Joy honour the courage of those who fought back in ways both large and small:
Students who risked everything to rebel, run away, and reclaim their freedomFamilies and leaders who refused to be silenced and...DTCP 011 - Werewolves of La Belle Province
Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy!
In this episode, Amanda Joy ventures deep into the misty forests and old villages of Quebec to uncover the chilling legends of the loup-garou—the werewolves of La Belle Province.
These tales aren’t just campfire stories. They’re part of a rich French-Canadian folklore that reveals the fears, beliefs, and moral lessons woven through generations. From medieval European roots to the uniquely Québécois twists that transformed them, we’ll explore why these shapeshifting creatures haunted imaginations for centuries.
Join us as we trace t...
