True Crime Case Files

Discover the shocking true crime story of Melissa Carver, a beloved Costa Mesa daycare owner brutally murdered in January 2022. This gripping episode of True Crime Case Files explores how Melissa’s husband, Brock Carver, and the family’s teenage babysitter, Kayla Jensen, conspired to kill her, staging the scene to look like suicide. Learn about the investigation, forensic evidence, and digital sleuthing that uncovered their secret affair, text messages, and photos revealing the chilling plot. Follow the Costa Mesa police, detectives, and courtroom drama as the trial unfolds, including murder, conspiracy charges, and life sentences. Hear how Melissa’s family, friend...

Discover the shocking true crime story of Deb Wertzel, a 59-year-old community college registrar from Bend, Oregon, who was kidnapped and murdered by her husband’s mistress, Katarina Novakova. In this gripping true crime case, investigators uncovered a secret affair, unethical psychiatric practices, and drug diversion that set the stage for jealousy-fueled murder. Follow the investigation, forensic evidence, cell phone tracking, and trial that led to Katarina’s life sentence without parole, while her husband, Dr. Michael Wertzel, faced ethics violations and loss of his medical license. This real-life murder mystery explores abduction, post-mortem mutilation, and betrayal in Bend, highlighting the...

Discover the shocking true crime story of Rachel Deakins, a beloved senior living activities coordinator in Vero Beach, Florida, whose life was tragically cut short in September 2021. Found drowned in the pool where she worked, Rachel’s death was first ruled a suicide before a thorough investigation revealed the horrifying truth: her husband, Jay Deakins, a private security contractor and Afghanistan veteran, murdered her after discovering her transgender past. This real-life murder case exposes domestic abuse, eldercare workplace conflicts, and the lengths someone would go to hide secrets and control. Follow the full investigation, police forensic evidence, cell phone tracking, an...

Eleanor “Ellie” McKay, a 71-year-old grandmother from North Scottsdale, mysteriously disappeared in June 2021 after leaving her gated community home for a “quick errand,” sparking one of Arizona’s most puzzling no-body true crime cases. Her personal items were later found in a remote desert, suggesting foul play. The investigation revealed shocking family secrets, including her son-in-law Marco Bellini’s hidden swinger lifestyle and digital evidence linking him to Ellie’s disappearance. The case drew massive online attention, with Christian true crime TikTok influencers spreading theories and amateur searchers crowding the Sonoran Desert, leading to tragic deaths. After months of investigation, Marco was arre...

A shocking true crime story from Muncie unfolds in this episode. In April 2018, beloved special-education teacher Sarah Whitaker, mother of six including two adopted children from Laos, was brutally murdered in her school cafeteria during lunch service. Investigators uncovered a twisted affair, cafeteria access logs, and surveillance footage revealing that Marlene Hix, 69, a school employee and Paul Whitaker’s secret lover, deliberately exploited Sarah’s visual impairment to stage the fatal incident as an accident. This true crime case shocked Muncie, prompted public outrage over initial “poor life choices” claims, and led to Marlene’s arrest and life-changing consequences for the Whitak...

Vanessa Leighton, a successful Tampa realtor, wife, and mother of four, led a secret double life documenting sexual encounters with clients in a private diary and laptop. In January 2022, she was brutally murdered in a vacant home she was showing, restrained and killed with repeated scalding water attacks. The shocking case revealed hidden affairs, a missing sex diary, and complex motives, culminating in her husband Daniel Leighton’s arrest. Using forensic evidence, phone data, and cutting-edge AI reconstruction, detectives pieced together the truth behind this Tampa real estate murder, leading to a controversial manslaughter verdict. This true crime story explores be...

Discover the shocking true crime story of Jonathan “Jon” Mercer, a dedicated Teach For America educator in Cleveland, Ohio, who was tragically murdered on his wedding day in Bay Village, June 2014. This jaw-dropping case involves a secret lesbian affair between Jon’s bride, Caroline Weiss, and his mother, Elaine Mercer, leading to a fatal shooting inside the wedding venue. Explore the investigation, including police interviews, forensic evidence, and the arrest of Elaine Mercer for second-degree murder. Follow the trial, shocking courtroom revelations, and sentencing of a mother who chose secrecy over family.


Become a supporter of this podcas...

Tragedy struck in Chandler, Arizona, when Kimberly “Kim” Rowley, a 43-year-old cybersecurity consultant and parenting blogger, was brutally murdered in her kitchen while preparing dessert in July 2022. This shocking true crime case revealed a dark family secret: her 14-year-old deaf daughter, Kayleigh Rowley, fired the fatal shots after being manipulated and drugged with amphetamines by her father, Mark Rowley, who had long resented Kim’s strict “security-first” parenting. The story captured national attention, drawing debates from child abuse experts, deaf advocacy groups, and “momfluencers” about extreme parenting, parental manipulation, and child exploitation. Mark was arrested, tried, and sentenced to life in prison with...

In this shocking true crime story from Delray Beach, Florida, millionaire Alexandra “Alex” Meir-Lassiter, 46, was brutally murdered in her own home by her husband, Richard Lassiter, in May 2021. Alex, a devoted mother and full-time caregiver to her severely disabled son Karl, trusted Richard completely, unaware of his secret affair with the family’s young pool boy, Mateo “Kiko” Bonetti. Richard’s calculated plot to kill his wife for her money, freedom from caregiving responsibilities, and to secure a life with his lover shocked the community. This true crime case reveals deceit, hidden relationships, financial exploitation, and the manipulation of family trusts. Foll...

Tragedy struck Katy, Texas in March 2024 when high school senior and varsity cheerleader Gabrielle “Gabby” Keller was brutally murdered in her own home. Stabbed repeatedly while asleep, her death shocked the community and sparked a high-profile investigation involving digital evidence, staged break-ins, and family secrets. Investigators uncovered a dark motive: Gabby had discovered her father, Daniel Keller, in a secret relationship with her best friend Zanna, and threatened to expose him. The case captured national attention, fueled by TikTok coverage, social media outrage, and online true crime discussions. Daniel Keller was ultimately arrested, tried, and sentenced to life in prison with...

In May 2023, Catalina Foothills, Arizona, became the site of a shocking true crime case when 23-year-old fitness instructor and former University of Arizona cheerleader Bretta Martin was brutally stabbed 72 times in her gated apartment. The murder shocked the community, revealing a twisted love triangle, secret affairs, and escalating harassment. Police investigation uncovered Bretta’s affair with wealthy snowbird Tom Avery and her harassment of his wife, Yelena Avery, who ultimately confronted Bretta in a deadly confrontation. Yelena Avery, a disciplined housewife and mother of three, was arrested, tried, and sentenced to death in January 2025. This true crime story covers domestic di...

Margaret “Maggie” Portland, a 49-year-old special-education aide and disability advocate from Grosse Pointe, Michigan, was tragically murdered in June 2021 in her own home. This shocking true crime case involves her son Drew Portland, best friend Lucas Marino, and her husband Richard Portland, uncovering a secret affair, hidden past in adult films, and a staged break-in that ended in a fatal gunshot. Follow the investigation as detectives uncover shocking twists, motives, and the chilling events leading to Lucas Marino’s arrest and conviction for second-degree murder. This real-life murder mystery is a true crime story of betrayal, fear, and tragedy in a quie...

In this shocking True Crime Case Files episode, we uncover the twisted story of Jade Moreland and Riley Knox, two 19-year-old Fort Worth teens whose online ‘sex competition’ on Twitch, YouTube, and OnlyFans ended in a brutal murder-suicide. Dive into the investigation as detectives examine corrosive chemical attacks at a Motel 6, review social media evidence, and interrogate suspects including Reverend Caleb Moreland, convicted murderer Walter Dennison, and YouTuber Lexi Vale. Explore the shocking motives, online harassment, inflated sexual partner claims, and the tragic aftermath that rocked families, the Fort Worth community, and the digital influencer world. Subscribe to True Crime Case...

In this shocking true crime case from Lenexa, Kansas, 15-year-old Ryan Halstedt brutally murdered his parents, Mark and Elaine Halstedt, after they confiscated his video game, Grand Theft Auto 5. Mark, a 45-year-old IT project manager, and Elaine, a former HR professional recently laid off, were found dead in their home in February 2019—Mark stabbed 25 times on the living room couch and Elaine beaten with a hammer. Police investigations uncovered disturbing digital evidence showing Ryan obsessively replaying violent in-game scenarios, ultimately revealing him as the murderer. This true crime story explores family tragedy, teenage violence, digital obsession, and shocking parental homicide, fo...

The shocking true crime story of Amara Kalkie-Hughes, an 18-year-old high school activist from Elgin, Illinois, whose secret affair with her principal, Dr. Gregory Hensley, ended in murder. In April 2021, Amara, known for her bold student activism and campaigns against her city’s controversial sister-city agreement with Matamoros, Mexico, was found dead in her car behind a local arts center. Investigators uncovered a months-long illegal relationship with a school principal, leading to a high-profile investigation, arrests, and a gripping murder trial in 2024. Follow the case of betrayal, abuse of power in schools, digital forensics breakthroughs, and the pursuit of justice in...

A shocking true crime case out of Fishers, Indiana: Housewife Marianne Ketterly admits to killing her husband Ross Ketterly after discovering he had an ongoing sexual relationship with her 21-year-old son Byron. This chilling Indiana murder story involves betrayal, family secrets, and a brutal stabbing in a quiet suburban neighborhood. Ross, a well-known wedding planner in central Indiana, was found dead in his master bedroom in July 2022, leading to a high-profile investigation, police interrogations, and a sensational trial. Watch as we uncover the twists, suspects, forensic evidence, and the courtroom drama surrounding one of the most disturbing domestic homicide cases...

In this True Crime Case Files episode, we investigate the shocking murder of Clara Whitfield, an 18-year-old high school senior in Little Rock, Arkansas, who was brutally beaten with a baseball bat by her therapist, Dr. Lionel Graves. Discover the chilling details of Clara’s secret prescription pill addiction, her illegal and abusive relationship with her Jungian analyst, and the deadly chain of events that led to her death in August 2021. Follow the police investigation, forensic evidence, and digital detective work that exposed the predator, the courtroom trial, and the life-changing verdict. This true crime story delves into sexual exploitation, th...

Discover the shocking true crime story of Madeline “Linny” Mandelbaum, a 21-year-old college student from Fort Lauderdale, Florida, who was blackmailed into a throuple and tragically found dead in a staged overdose. This true crime case exposes manipulation, coercion, and control by Elena Hale-Anton and Lukas Hale-Anton, revealing a twisted web of blackmail, sexual exploitation, and parental involvement. Learn how police investigations, forensic evidence, and digital messages uncovered the truth behind Linny’s death, leading to an international manhunt and the arrest of her murderer in France. Follow the trial, verdict, and sentencing in this real-life Fort Lauderdale murder mystery and ex...

In this shocking true crime story from Aiken, South Carolina, 18-year-old high school senior Michael Pondley, a straight-A student, debate team captain, and Applebee’s server, is brutally murdered after secretly selling sex to older women in town. Just after midnight, his body is found in a secluded area behind the restaurant, shot 28 times in a rage-driven attack. The investigation uncovers a web of lies, affairs, and hidden sexual encounters involving Marianne Whitlow, the pastor’s wife; Reverend Daniel Whitlow; and ultimately Loretta Mayfield, a recently widowed grandmother whose health and life were devastated by sexually transmitted infections from Michael. Foll...

In August 2023, Brownsville, Tennessee was rocked by the shocking murder of Denise Harper-Caldwell, a self-made entrepreneur and owner of Harper Auto Group. Found dead at the bottom of her staircase, Denise’s death was staged to look like an accident, but investigators uncovered a chilling truth. Her husband, Johnson Caldwell, embezzled thousands from her business to secretly support her teenage daughter, Benjamina ‘Bennie’ Harper, and groomed her over time. Motivated by financial greed and sexual obsession, Johnson killed Denise to cover his crimes and inherit her fortune. Follow this true crime story of murder, betrayal, and family secrets, including police invest...

In March 2021, 18-year-old Lennaline “Lena” Price, a runaway teen struggling for stability in Acworth, Georgia, was brutally murdered just weeks after marrying 88-year-old Harold “Hal” Whitcombe. Her headless body was discovered in a dumpster near Highway 92, sparking one of Cobb County’s most shocking homicide investigations. Detectives uncovered a twisted web of sexual obsession, betrayal, and manipulation involving Whitcombe, his lovers, and Dr. Evelyn Hartwell, his psychiatrist, who was later arrested and convicted for the killing. Follow the full true crime story as we detail the investigation, forensic evidence, shocking motives, trial, and life after the verdict. True crime fans, murder mys...

In this shocking true crime case, a Tampa bachelor party in January 2022 ended in the brutal dismemberment of two young strippers, Kelsey Rourke and Alyssa “Lissie” Maynard. The victims, 18-year-old drifters from Myrtle Beach, South Carolina, were last seen leaving Venus Mons strip club’s VIP room with the groom, Michael DeRosa. This true crime story follows the investigation, including dumpster discoveries, forensic evidence, cell phone tracking, and DNA analysis that led police to uncover the chilling motive: fear of exposure and reputation collapse. Follow the full investigation, arrest, trial, and conviction of DeRosa, as well as the lasting impact on vic...

Discover the shocking true crime story of Kimberley Hargreaves, a 29-year-old bride found murdered in Rochester, New York, on what was meant to be her midsummer wedding day in July 2022. This true crime case unravels the brutal killing with a power saw, a staged crime scene, and a chilling cover-up designed to implicate a suspected serial killer, Russell “Buddy” Morrow. Follow the investigation as police detectives, digital forensics, and GPS evidence reveal the horrifying truth: Kimberley’s fiancé, Harvey Hargreaves, killed her to hide a disturbing secret involving his sister. Explore the wedding day murder, the family drama, the police investi...

Discover the shocking true crime story of Paulette Whitaker, a 20-year-old Ohio State University psychology student whose promising life ended in tragedy in Columbus, Ohio, March 2019. Paulette was found dead in her campus dorm bathroom, initially ruled a suicide, but her parents’ persistence uncovered a horrifying college professor sex scandal. Investigators revealed a twisted plot of sexual coercion, blackmail, and murder involving Dr. Leonard Kline, a 76-year-old sociology professor, and Caleb Ross, a student and part-time IT aide. This gripping case exposes campus sexual exploitation, professor-student abuse of power, and a murder cover-up that shocked the nation. Follow the full in...

Discover the shocking true crime story of Elodie Martel, a 19-year-old international student and nanny in Tampa, Florida, whose life ended in a horrific family conspiracy. What began as a suspected overdose at an upscale golf club in January 2022 unfolded into a disturbing case of sexual exploitation, manipulation, and murder. Elodie had been secretly tracked and scored by her employers, the Hale family, including Gregory Hale, Lindsay Hale, and their son Jeremy, as part of a twisted “sex competition.” When she threatened to expose the abuse, all three conspired to strangle her and stage the scene to look like an acci...

A shocking true crime story unfolds in Scottsdale, Arizona, where a bitter custody battle ended in conspiracy, cover-ups, and murder. In July 2018, Marissa Lovell, a 42-year-old mother of three and former flight attendant, was found shot to death inside her million-dollar Gainey Ranch home. Investigators uncovered a chilling plot involving her husband, Daniel Lovell, and their teenage daughter, Auburn, who manipulated a hired killer, Raul Espinoza, to carry out the murder. This gripping case reveals family betrayal, emotional manipulation, and a meticulously planned crime, leading to arrests, a high-profile trial in 2022, and life-altering consequences for everyone involved.


...

In this shocking true crime case from Midwest City, Oklahoma, follow the tragic story of Janna Cole, an 18-year-old high school senior and lead cheerleader, whose life was cut short in April 2018 when she was brutally murdered and strangled behind a Waffle House off I-40. This episode of True Crime Case Files uncovers the twisted web of secrets, including Janna’s scholarship to LSU, her secret relationship with an elderly woman, and the jealousy and rage of her boyfriend, Tyler Grant, who ultimately confessed to the crime. Hear about the police investigation, shocking twists, forensic evidence, cell tower data, and th...

Briony Pierce, a 19-year-old nursing student from Gilbert, Arizona, was brutally murdered on her birthday during a family trip to Flagstaff in July 2023, in a shocking case of obsession and step-sibling violence. Stabbed 72 times with a hunting knife and hidden beneath a hotel bed, Briony’s murder stunned the community and triggered a high-profile investigation involving her mother Karen Pierce, stepfather Mark Pierce, and stepbrother Elridge Pierce. This true crime story exposes the dark side of blended families, teenage obsession, and family conflict, while highlighting forensic investigation, hotel surveillance, and criminal psychology. Follow the investigation, confession, trial, and life after th...

Discover the shocking true crime story of Eleanor Whitcombe, an 87-year-old wealthy Virginia Beach matriarch, whose life of control, coercion, and hidden family secrets ended in a brutal murder in April 2022. This gripping episode of True Crime Case Files explores the twisted family dynamics, a secret sexual competition between daughters-in-law, and the dark power of wealth and manipulation. Follow detectives as they uncover shocking evidence, including a detailed spreadsheet tracking performance, leading to the shocking confession of Lena Whitcombe. Dive into this real-life murder mystery, filled with shocking twists, psychological abuse, and a high-stakes inheritance drama that stunned even seasoned...

Tragic true crime in Pasadena, Texas: Teenager Brookfield Moreland, 15, was shot and killed in her own home in July 2019 in a shocking case of manipulation and murder. Her mother, Karol Moreland, orchestrated a secret plot, using family friend Evan Brooks, 18, to carry out the deadly plan, which resulted in the unintended death of her daughter. This true crime story explores family betrayal, shocking secrets, coercion, and a hidden affair that turned deadly. Follow the investigation, the shocking twists uncovered by police, the courtroom trial, and the sentencing of Karol Moreland and Evan Brooks. True crime fans will find this Pasadena...

In this shocking true crime episode of True Crime Case Files, we investigate the tragic South Bend, Indiana school shooting where a first-grade student tragically killed beloved teacher Taylor Shore in April 2022. Discover the full story behind this classroom murder, including the hidden family secrets, affair, and pregnancy that led to the unthinkable, the investigation by Detectives Maria Salgado and Ron Pretlow, and the shocking role of Danny Malley, the boy’s father, who orchestrated the crime. We explore child endangerment, solicitation of a minor to commit murder, and the courtroom drama that followed, including the trial, verdict, and sentencing.

In this shocking True Crime Case, we uncover the brutal murder of Lisa Armstrong, an eight-months-pregnant woman from Fairfax, Virginia, who was slashed to death in her own kitchen by her husband, Ethan Armstrong. Just six days after the killing, Ethan married his mistress, Saylor Whitmore, sparking national outrage and making headlines in Virginia crime news. This detailed investigation covers the police investigation, the discovery of Lisa’s body, the role of T.J. McClure, the biological father of her unborn baby, and the evidence that led to Ethan’s arrest, including cell tower data, bloody shoe prints, and incriminating text...

Discover the chilling true crime story of a teenager involved in a dangerous cult that led to the violent murder of his entire family in Omaha, Nebraska. In this episode of True Crime Case Files, we dive deep into the Hanigan family massacre, exploring the lives of victims Marla, Dan, and Claire Hanigan, the investigation by detectives Elena Morrow and Brian Lindell, and the shocking role of Rational Personality Management (RPM). Learn how teen cult indoctrination, online radicalization, and extremist pseudo-psychology groups can influence vulnerable youth. We follow the police hunt across the Midwest and West, the arrest of Joshua...

Explore the shocking true crime story of the racially charged revenge killing of Officer Bradley Mercer in North Myrtle Beach, South Carolina. In March 2021, Mercer, a 39-year-old traffic cop with a controversial record, was shot and killed in a Cracker Barrel restroom, sparking a nationwide investigation. This case exposes deep racial tensions, police misconduct claims, and the role of secret online forums in radicalizing a young man, Devin Mallory, who later confessed to the murder. Follow the full investigation, the high-profile trial, jury mistrials, and the life-altering aftermath for Mercer’s family, the police department, and the community. If you’re i...

Uncover the shocking true crime story of Tyler “Ty” Rollins, the 18-year-old high school lacrosse star from Olathe, Kansas, whose life ended in a brutal murder in July 2022. Ty, a Stanford-bound scholar, was found drugged and burned in his own backyard, revealing a secret affair with a 58-year-old housewife, Rebecca Kirwan. Follow the gripping investigation as detectives uncover deleted text messages, digital evidence, and cell tower data, track multiple suspects including family and classmates, and reconstruct the chilling events that led to Ty’s death. This true crime case explores jealousy, betrayal, and premeditated murder in a quiet suburban neighborhood, culmin...

Discover the shocking true crime story of Claire Milton, a devoted mother in Orinda, California, who was brutally murdered by her husband, Michael Milton, in April 2019. This chilling case involves blunt-force trauma, a staged accident, and an attempt to frame his mentally disabled daughter, Lysette Milton, for the crime. Explore the investigation led by Detectives Nora Bering and Calvin Rusk, the uncovering of Michael’s secret coercive relationship with the family gardener, and the critical role of home-security camera footage in solving the murder.


Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/true-crime-case-files--6127499/support.

In Lake Delton, Wisconsin, what was supposed to be a joyful wedding turned into one of the state’s most shocking true crime cases. On June 22, 2018, six members of the Fontaine family, including the bride Marissa Fontaine, were brutally murdered in a wedding massacre at the Lake Delton Community Lodge, executed by masked gunmen. Investigators uncovered a twisted plot orchestrated by the groom, Robert Laramie, enraged over infidelity, who hired career criminal Leon Mancuso and an unidentified accomplice to carry out the attack. The case involved execution-style killings, a bizarre post-mortem body dump, financial trails, and shocking courtroom testimony during th...

Discover the shocking true crime case of Roberta Krawiec, a 42-year-old Michigan mother brutally beaten to death by her husband, Derek Krawiec, in Big Rapids, Michigan. This domestic abuse murder shocked the quiet college town in March 2022, exposing a chilling world of coercive control, family secrets, and bribery to cover up violence. Follow the investigation as detectives uncover Derek’s hidden online fetish group, his payments to family members to lie, and the harrowing testimony of his son Evan Krawiec. From the crime scene investigation and police interrogation to the controversial murder trial and Derek’s eventual freedom, this true crim...

Discover the shocking true crime story of Marilynn Hartenstein-Harrington, a 38-year-old mother of four from Coral Gables, Florida, who was brutally murdered in November 2019 after uncovering a secret affair between her husband, Jonathan Harrington, and her father, Edward Hartenstein. In this gripping episode of True Crime Case Files, we detail the chilling investigation, the bloody murder in a Pollo Tropical drive-thru, the shocking family secrets, and the high-profile trial, confession, and 40-year prison sentence. Follow the full story of betrayal, hidden relationships, and a father-in-law’s shocking secret, including the psychological investigation, forensic evidence, and courtroom drama that captured the at...

In this gripping episode of True Crime Case Files, we explore the shocking murder of teenage girl Marley Kerr in Lexington, Kentucky, and the twisted obsession of her stepbrother Caleb Miller. Marley, an 18-year-old high school senior and aspiring nurse, was found strangled and trampled in a wooded clearing just days before her graduation in June 2020. The investigation uncovered a blended family full of tension, troubled stepbrothers, and chilling evidence, including candid photos and a journal detailing Caleb’s obsession. Follow along as Lexington police detectives piece together the timeline, interrogate suspects, and ultimately uncover the horrifying truth.