The Show: A NY Post baseball podcast with Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman

40 Episodes
Subscribe

By: NYPost

On the New York Post's baseball podcast "The Show with Joel Sherman and Jon Heyman," the veteran MLB insiders and longtime friends and combatants go toe-to-toe on the latest MLB news and issues of the week.The Post columnists have been arguing about baseball since competing as New York Yankees beat writers in their 20s (Yes, a while ago!). Now, finally on the same team, they get to take their three decades of baseball debates public, showing off their knowledge and revealing rumors and inside info from around Major League Baseball. "The Show", the best baseball podcast around, is released...

David Stearns reveals what it would take to call up Brandon Sproat or Jonah Tong
#166
Last Tuesday at 5:41 PM

On a new episode of "The Show," Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman are joined by Mets President of Baseball Operations David Stearns. David talks about two top pitching prospects Brandon Sproat & Jonah Tong and what he needs to see before calling them up to the majors. Plus, what the main issue was during their rough stretch of play and evaluates Juan Soto's first year in Queens.


Before that, Joel & Jon discuss the Yankees embarrassing weekend vs. Boston and the messaging around Anthony Volpe's inconsistent play.

Learn more about your ad choices...


Nolan McLean reminds Ron Darling of a former teammate + Cal Raleigh is the AL MVP over Aaron Judge
#165
08/19/2025

On a new episode of "The Show," Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman are joined by Mets broadcaster (and birthday boy) Ron Darling. Ron discusses why Mets young pitcher Nolan McLean reminds him of a former teammate and Cy Young winner, if the Mets season is salvageable and how much longer he has in one of the best booths in baseball.


Plus, Joel and Jon explain why they would vote for Cal Raleigh for AL MVP if the season ended today and discuss Rob Manfred's comments on realignment.

Learn more about your...


Chris Mad Dog Russo reacts to the crisis going on with NY Baseball | The Show - Ep. 164
08/12/2025

On today's episode of The Show with Joel Sherman and Jon Heyman, the guys are joined by Sirius XM and radio legend Chris 'Mad Dog' Russo. Mad Dog discusses the crisis going on with the Yankees and Mets as both teams are struggling to get through the regular season and try and make the playoffs.


Timecodes

00:00 Intro

00:47 Mets are swept

8:08 Yankees issues

18:58 Chris 'Mad Dog' Russo

57:24 Hit or Error

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices


Yankees Playoff Hopes Are in Peril as Fundamentals Somehow Get Worse + Chris Antonetti on Decision to Not Trade Steven Kwan
#163
08/04/2025

On a new episode of "The Show," Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman discuss the Yankees lack of accountability as the fundamentals find a way to get even worse while being swept by the Marlins. Plus, Mets starting pitching is a concern as some are hitting a wall and others aren't giving length.


Later, Cleveland Guardians President of Baseball Operations Chris Antonetti joins Joel & Jon to breakdown his moves at the trade deadline, why he decided to not move Steven Kwan & the sports gambling investigation of pitchers Emmanuel Clase & Luis Ortiz.


0:00...


Everything We're Hearing Ahead of the MLB Trade Deadline!
#162
07/28/2025

On a new episode of The Show, Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman react to the Yankees trades for Ryan McMahon, Amed Rosario & what they expect them to do before the trade deadline on Thursday. Plus, Mets trade for Gregory Soto and their targets to improve the bullpen and possibly center field.


Later, Joel & Jon look at the rest of the league and reveal some of the best players they're hearing that could get traded.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices


Yankees Are Playing Terrible Baseball + Pat Murphy on the Little Things Leading Brewers to Best Record in MLB
#161
07/24/2025

On a new episode of "The Show," Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman are joined by Milwaukee Brewers manager, Pat Murphy. Murph talks about how he's ingrained the importance of the little things into his ball club, the rise of Jacob Misiorowski to stardom & his role as the trade deadline approaches.


Plus, Joel & Jon discuss how the issues that cost the Yankees the World Series last season are rearing its ugly head once again & the Mets needing bullpen help at the deadline.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices<...


Who Will Your Team Get at the Trade Deadline?
#160
07/24/2025

On a special episode of The Show with Joel Sherman and Jon Heyman. The guys preview all of the biggest names and superstars that can be traded at this year's MLB Deadline. Plus the guys discuss what the local NY teams will do, including how aggressive Brian Cashman and the Yankees will be and what will David Stearns do to strengthen this year's team to make another deep playoff run.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices


Derek Falvey on Crucial Two Weeks For Twins Ahead of Trade Deadline + State of Mets, Yankees at the All-Star Break
#159
07/15/2025

On a new episode of "The Show," Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman are joined by Minnesota Twins President of Baseball Operations Derek Falvey. Derek discusses the crucial two weeks coming up for his club ahead of the trade deadline, the trade availability on a few of his stars and the rise of the Detroit Tigers becoming the team to beat in the AL Central.


Plus, Joel & Jon on the state of the Mets, Yankees at the All-Star Break, what they need to do at the trade deadline and debate the controversial addition of Brewers pitcher...


Theory on Yankees Annual Summer Skid + Michael Kay Addresses the Blue Jays Drama
#158
07/07/2025

On a new episode of "The Show," Joel Sherman and Jon Heyman are joined by Yankees broadcaster Michael Kay. Kay discusses why Aaron Boone is not the Yankees issue, what the team needs at the trade deadline and addresses his drama with Blue Jays broadcaster Jamie Campbell.


Plus, Joel and Jon come up with a theory as to why NYY has had a skid like this, around the same time, each of the last three seasons & discuss the Mets turning a corner with pitching help on the way.

Learn more...


Mets Skid is Bordering on Panic + D-backs GM Mike Hazen Want to be a Buyer at the Trade Deadline
#157
07/01/2025

On a new episode of "The Show," Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman discuss the Mets continuing to slide and why it is starting to border on panic time in Queens. Plus, Yankees offense continues to struggle but the pitching is keeping them afloat.


Later, Diamondbacks GM Mike Hazen talks about his team being one of the most interesting as the trade deadline approaches, addresses the recent Ketel Marte situation with a fan & provides an update to the injuries to Corbin Carroll, Gabriel Moreno.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone...


Why Mets Skid is More Concerning Than Yankees + A.J. Hinch on Tigers Development into MLB's Best Team
#156
06/25/2025

On a new episode of The Show, Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman discuss what has happened to the Mets and Yankees over the last two weeks. Both teams are going through a June Swoon but they break down why they're more concerned with the Mets struggles.


Later, manager of the Detroit Tigers, A.J. Hinch joins The Show to talk about his team's development into the best record in MLB, the impact from former Yankees Gleyber Torres and Tommy Kahnle & what his role is when it comes to trade deadline talks.

...


Francisco Lindor opens up to The Show about his father's influence on his career
#155
06/17/2025

New York Mets SS Francisco Lindor joins Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman this week on The Show. Lindor discusses being on track to make his first All-Star Game as a Met, where he gets his high baseball IQ from and what it would mean to him to be named captain.


Plus, Joel & Jon react to the shocking Rafael Devers trade, Yankees bats going quiet & Mets pitching regression.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices


Yankees Clearly Need Pitching + Jed Hoyer on Pete Crow-Armstrong's Development into MVP Candidate
#154
06/09/2025

On a new episode of "The Show," Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman discuss the Yankees pitching being exposed in series loss vs. Red Sox some options that could be available at the trade deadline. Plus, a left-handed reliever that could make sense for the Mets.


Later, Cubs President of Baseball Operations discusses the trade with the Mets for Pete Crow-Armstrong, what his team needs to add at the deadline & the biggest difference in the sports from 5-10 years ago.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices


Carlos Rodon Discusses How He Adjusted After Disastrous 2023 Season + Mets Trade Deadline Needs
#153
06/03/2025

On a new episode of "The Show," Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman are joined by Yankees starting pitcher Carlos Rodon. Carlos discusses stepping up in the absence of Gerrit Cole, how he dealt with his disastrous 2023 season & how this team compares to last year's World Series team.


Plus, Joel & Jon share their takeaways from Yankees series loss vs Dodgers and what the Mets may need at the trade deadline.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices


Mets Have Some Lineup Decisions to Make + Dave Dombrowski on Battling With Mets & Braves For NL East Title
#152
05/28/2025

On a new episode of "The Show," Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman discuss why the Mets should start thinking about making a change at third base and catcher. Plus, Yankees pitching continues to be a strength as they build the largest division lead in baseball.


Later, Phillies President Dave Dombrowski joins Joel and Jon to discuss Zack Wheeler's dominance, the trade for Jesus Luzardo and the upcoming free agency for Kyle Schwarber.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices


Yankees Pivot Outshines Juan Soto in Subway Series + Alex Anthopoulos on Braves Bounce Back After Slow Start
#151
05/20/2025

On a new episode, Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman share their takeaways from Yankees Subway Series win over Mets. Plus, Juan Soto does not look like himself as Yankees pivot of Fried, Bellinger and Goldschmidt have big part in winning the series.


Later, Atlanta Braves President of Baseball Operations Alex Anthopoulos discusses the Braves bounce back after a slow start to the season, Ronald Acuna Jr. close to returning from injury & why he didn't re-sign Max Fried.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices


What to Expect in Juan Soto's Return to The Bronx
#150
05/15/2025

On a special edition of the "The Show," Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman breakdown the clash in styles in this year's edition of the Subway Series. Plus, what to expect in Juan Soto's first time back to Yankee Stadium.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices


Aaron Judge is a Hall of Famer Playing At His Best & Scott Harris on Building Tigers into Legit Contender
#149
05/13/2025

On a new episode of "The Show" with Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman, they breakdown Aaron Judge's incredible start to the season. Plus, with the Subway Series less than a week away the discuss how the Juan Soto decision has looked like a win-win for both teams so far.


Later, Detroit Tigers President of Baseball Operations Scott Harris joins Joel & Jon to discuss how they're no longer just on a "good run," Javy Baez's bounce back and if signing an extension with ace Tarik Skubal is something they are working on and have the means...


Yankees May Need to Consider Trading Devin Williams + Orioles GM Mike Elias Addresses Rough Start to Season
#148
05/07/2025

On a new episode of "The Show," with Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman, they question if the Yankees might have to consider trading Devin Williams at the deadline. Plus, the Mets are starting to get some injuries but are playing well despite them.


Later, Orioles GM Mike Elias joins Joel & Jon to breakdown Baltimore's tough start to the season, crucial injuries to the pitching staff and his vote of confidence in manager Brandon Hyde.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices


Steve Cohen Isn't Worried About Juan Soto's Slow Start + Yankees remove Devin Williams From Closer Role
#147
04/28/2025

On a new episode of "The Show," Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman are joined by Mets owner Steve Cohen. Cohen shares his thoughts on the strong start to the season, if he has any concern about Juan Soto's struggles to begin his Mets career & if he's thought about naming Francisco Lindor the captain.


Plus, Joel & Jon breakdown the Yankees to remove Devin Williams from the closer role & Mets bullpen issues showing up over the weekend.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices


A.J. Preller Shows Off the Japanese he Learned to Recruit Shohei Ohtani + Pitching Has Mets Off To Hot Start
#146
04/22/2025

On a new episode of "The Show," Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman are joined by Padres President of Baseball Operations A.J. Preller to discuss how he's been able to reload the organization with talent after losing so much in recent years, his fearlessness to trade prospects & shares a story about playing basketball against Carmelo Anthony's son, Kiyan.


Plus, Joel & Jon discuss the Mets pitching carrying them to start the season and David Stearns' philosophy when it comes to acquiring pitching looking to be right again.

Learn more about your ad...


Reacting to Juan Soto's Comments + Alex Cora Admits This Red Sox Season Feels Different
#145
04/15/2025

On a new episode of "The Show," Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman are joined by Red Sox manager Alex Cora. Cora breaks down the recent poor play, prospect Kristian Campbell's strong start to the season & if he regrets how the Rafael Devers situation in spring training was handled.


Plus, Joel & Jon share their thoughts on Juan Soto commenting on being pitched differently this season without having Aaron Judge as protection and the Yankees offense continuing to rake.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices


How Vladimir Guerrero Jr’s Extension Impacts Pete Alonso + Buster Posey Talks Giants Hot Start
#144
04/08/2025

On a new episode of “The Show” with Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman, Giants legend and President of Baseball Operations Buster Posey joins to discuss his transition to the front office, San Francisco’s strong start to the season & changing the perception of the organization.


Plus, Joel & Jon discuss how Vladimir Guerrero Jr’s extension with the Blue Jays impacts Pete Alonso and an issue with the Yankees that’s already being exposed.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices


Torpedo Bats Explained by Official Bat of MLB CEO
#143
04/02/2025

On a new episode of "The Show" with Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman, they are joined by the co-founder & CEO of Marucci Sports, the official bats of Major League Baseball, Kurt Ainsworth to discuss the creation and purpose of the torpedo bats. He breaks down what makes them different than the average bat, how many are currently being used across the major leagues & if he's concerned MLB could ban them.


Plus, Joel & Jon give their thoughts on the torpedo bats, the Yankees historic weekend mashing against Milwaukee & why Garrett Crochet's extension is a gamble by...


Keith Hernandez Shares Expectations for Mets + Filling Out MLB Bingo Card
#142
03/24/2025

On a new episode of "The Show," Mets broadcaster and legend Keith Hernandez joins Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman to discuss his expectations for NYM this season, what makes the Mets broadcast booth as good as it is & if the '86 team was as crazy as its reputation.


Plus, Joel & Jon fill out a bingo card full of interesting things they believe could happen this MLB season. If they say in shock "I didn't have that on my bingo card!" at some point this season, they'll actually mean it.

Learn more...


Yankees Likely Leadoff Hitter Austin Wells Joins! + Dodgers Start With Sweep In Tokyo
#141
03/19/2025

On a new episode of "The Show," Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman are joined by Yankees catcher Austin Wells. He shares how he feels about hitting leadoff this season, his confidence in the starting rotation despite injuries and the loss of Gerrit Cole for the season as well as how he's becoming more of a leader in the clubhouse.


To open "The Show," Joel & Jon breakdown the Dodgers 2-game sweep of the Cubs in Tokyo to open the season and where this team ranks, at least on paper, of best they've ever seen. Plus, what...


Clay Holmes on His Transition to the Starting Rotation + Can Yankees Survive Without Gerrit Cole?
#140
03/12/2025

On a new episode of "The Show," Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman discuss the Yankees injury-riddled spring continuing with Gerrit Cole needing Tommy John surgery. They discuss how expectations for NYY have changed and if they can survive without their ace. Plus, they breakdown the ongoing negotiations between the Toronto Blue Jays, Vladimir Guerrero Jr.


Later, Mets starting pitcher Clay Holmes talks about what sparked his transition to the rotation, the pressure of being the Yankees closer & his close relationship with Juan Soto.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone...


Michael Kay on Biggest Yankees Questions Heading Into the Season + Will MLB Reinstate Pete Rose?
#139
03/07/2025

On a new episode of "The Show," Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman discuss the possible reinstatement of Pete Rose and if he were to be on the Hall of Fame ballot, would they vote for him.


Later, voice of the New York Yankees Michael Kay joins Joel & Jon to discuss NYY's hole at third base, his thoughts on the relaxation of the facial hair policy and examine exactly why Juan Soto signed with the crosstown Mets.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices


Mets Rotation is Banged Up, Finding a Marcus Stroman Trade + NYM Outfielder Brandon Nimmo
#138
02/25/2025

On a new episode of "The Show" with Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman, they discuss Sean Manaea's injury and the Mets now being down 1/3 of their starting rotation. Plus, they explain why a crosstown trade for Marcus Stroman makes sense on paper.


Later, NYM outfielder Brandon Nimmo joins Joel & Jon to discuss what makes Juan Soto's swing "perfect", how he feels about hitting cleanup & why winning the World Series is the expectation.


Click here for more information (https://truefantravel.com/trip/new-york-spring-training/?utm_source=nyp&utm_medium=theshowpodcast&utm_campaign...


Early Observations of Mets, Yankees Spring Training + NYM Pitching Coach Jeremy Hefner
#137
02/20/2025

On a new episode of "The Show" with Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman, the guys discuss Vladimir Guerrero Jr. not coming to terms with the Blue Jays on a long-term extension, the saga going on in Boston with Rafael Devers refusing to play anywhere but third base after signing Gold Glove winner Alex Bregman & some observations from the first week of Mets, Yankees spring training.


Later, Joel & Jon are joined by NYM pitching coach Jeremy Hefner to breakdown moving to a 6-man rotation, Clay Holmes' transition to a starter & Carlos Mendoza's first year as manager.<...


Yankees, Mets Final Offseason Grades + NYY Manager Aaron Boone
#136
02/11/2025

On a new episode of “The Show,” Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman share their final thoughts on the Yankees and Mets offseason as spring training is underway.


Later, NYY manager Aaron Boone joins Joel & Jon to discuss if he believes the 2025 Yankees are better than 2024, breaks down the competitions at third base and leadoff hitter & expectations for Anthony Volpe and Austin Wells.


Click here for more information (https://truefantravel.com/trip/new-york-spring-training/?utm_source=nyp&utm_medium=theshowpodcast&utm_campaign=ny-spring-training) about TrueFan Travel’s 5-night Spring Training package in Tampa...


Pete Alonso is Back in Queens + Former Mets DH J.D. Martinez Joins!
#135
02/06/2025

On a new episode of "The Show," Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman react to the Pete Alonso free agency saga coming to an end with him re-signing with the Mets and where it puts them now in the National League.


Later, former NYM DH and World Series champion J.D. Martinez joins Joel & Jon to discuss his offseason, the Mets magical postseason run, how Jose Iglesias changed the clubhouse culture and his love for pickleball.


Click here for more information (https://truefantravel.com/trip/new-york-spring-training/?utm_source=nyp&utm_medium...


Feels Like Pete Alonso Wants Mets More Than Mets Want Alonso + Dodgers GM Brandon Gomes
#134
01/28/2025

On a new episode of "The Show," Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman break down the current market for Pete Alonso and why it seems like he wants the Mets more than they want him. Plus, Jon shares his takeaways on the Hall of Fame results.


Later, Los Angeles Dodgers GM Brandon Gomes joins "The Show" to discuss their mega offseason and if it's bad for baseball, winning the Roki Sasaki sweepstakes & having an even bigger bullseye on their back this season.


Click here for more information (https://truefantravel.com/trip...


Pete Alonso Is A Victim Of His Time, One Real Issue With The Dodgers + Hall of Fame w/ Jayson Stark
#133
01/28/2025

On a new episode of the "The Show," Joel Sherman is flying solo. He breaks down why Pete Alonso is a victim of his time and the one real issue he has with all of the spending that the Dodgers are doing.


Later, baseball writer for The Athletic Jayson Stark joins "The Show" to discuss the results of the Hall of Fame voting, they each champion for a guy they'd like to see get in the HOF very soon and look ahead to next year's ballot.


Click here for...


Where Things Stand with Pete Alonso, What's Next for Yankees + Mets Legend David Wright
#132
01/14/2025

On a new episode of "The Show," Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman break down where things stand between Pete Alonso, Mets and what his market looks like besides NYM. Plus, they discuss what's next for the Yankees this offseason and provide an update on the Roki Sasaki sweepstakes.


Later on "The Show," Mets legend David Wright joins Joel & Jon to discuss his #5 getting retired during the 2025 season, if he thinks about what his career may have looked like without the nagging back injury and which NYM he believes was the best he played on.

<...


Offseason as a free agent, active A's & becoming a foodie w/ Mark Canha
#131
01/09/2025

Free agent IF/OF Mark Canha joins Jon Heyman to discuss his offseason as a free agent, how he became such a foodie and why he gets hit by so many pitches.


Later, Mark talks about Juan Soto's massive contract, the A's active offseason and if he was surprised by the Tigers run to the postseason after being traded by them at the deadline.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices


Juan Soto Signs with Mets & Yankees Start Pivot with Max Fried
#130
12/12/2024

On a new episode of "The Show," Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman are live from the Winter Meetings in Dallas. They break down Juan Soto signing with the Mets and how the negotiation process went down. Also, what's next for NYM after the $765M commitment?


Later, Joel & Jon discuss the Yankees pivoting to sign Max Fried & what might be next for them.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices


Is Signing Juan Soto Actually in Yankees Best Interest, Mets Interested in Clay Holmes as a Starting Pitcher + Hall of Fame Ballot w/ Dan O'Dowd & Brian Kenny
#129
12/03/2024

On a new episode of "The Show," Joel Sherman is joined by former Rockies GM and MLB Network's Dan O'Dowd who questions if it's even in the Yankees best interest to go all-in to sign Juan Soto. Plus, they break down the Mets starting pitching philosophy coming off the signing of Frankie Montas and the report they're interested in signing Clay Holmes as a starter.


Later, MLB Network's Brian Kenny joins Joel to break down this year's Hall of Fame ballot and plays Hit or Error.

Learn more about your...


Juan Soto Decision Getting Closer & Hall of Fame Ballot with Chris "Mad Dog" Russo
#128
11/26/2024

Chris "Mad Dog" Russo joins Jon Heyman as a special guest co-host on "The Show" to discuss Juan Soto narrowing in on his decision and where Mad Dog believes he'll end up. Plus, Jon and Mad Dog break down the new names on the Baseball Hall of Fame ballot. Later, Mad Dog has a rant about a bad look for baseball and Jon discusses one team that he doesn't understand what they're doing this offseason.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices


Juan Soto Sweepstakes Update, Roki Sasaki is Coming to MLB + Yankees P Luke Weaver
#127
11/13/2024

On a new episode of "The Show," Joel Sherman and Jon Heyman break down where things stand in Juan Soto's free agency and the Blue Jays entering the mix to sign him. Plus, is the chase for Roki Sasaki a fair fight? Who are some trade candidates that could be on the market this offseason?


Later, Yankees breakout star pitcher Luke Weaver joins "The Show" to share his journey of becoming the closer, favorite memories from the postseason run and how changing windups made such an impact.

Learn more about...