Heretic Happy Hour

40 Episodes
Subscribe

By: Quoir

Heretic Happy Hour is an unapologetically irreverent, crass, and sometimes profound conversation about the intersection of culture and the Christian faith. Hosts Keith Giles and Matthew J. Distefano, alongside a rotating panel of guest hosts that include theologians and therapists, professors and prophets, mystics and misfits, pull no punches and leave no stones unturned. For some serious sacred cow-tipping, there’s nothing better than spending an hour of your time with us. New shows every Tuesday, with bonus episodes on Fridays and Sundays.

#268: Jesus and Marx with Roger Wolsey and Michael Burns
#443
Last Tuesday at 10:00 AM

In this week's main episode, Keith and Matthew chat with Roger Wolsey and Michael Burns about the similarities and differences between Jesus Christ and Karl Marx.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today! Use code "heretic" to save 10% off a yearly subscription.

Pick up the new book, Quantum Theology today, as well as The UnChristian Truth About White Christian Nationalism.

...


BONUS SHOW: WAR!
#442
Last Friday at 12:40 PM

In this week's bonus show, Keith and Matthew talk about what's on everyone's mind: the war.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today, and use Promo Code "heretic" to save an additional 10% off a yearly subscription (which is already 10% off a monthly subscription).

Join Matthew's Launch Team for Saints, Sinners, and Clickers now!

Pick up Keith and Matt's book, Reading...


#267: Jung and Jesus with Mo Thomas, Brandy Anderson, and Roger Wolsey
#441
03/03/2026

In this week's main episode, Keith and Matthew sit down with Mo Thomas, Brandy Anderson, and Roger Wolsey to talk about psychologist Carl Jung and how his contributions can impact how we view Jesus Christ.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today! Use code "heretic" to save 10% off a yearly subscription.

Pick up the new book, Quantum Theology today, as well as...


BONUS SHOW: Thou Shalt Not Touch Poison Oak
#440
02/27/2026

In this week's bonus show, Keith and Matthew take a multitude of calls and texts into the hotline. Plus, a cautionary tale about being careful around poison oak.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today, and use Promo Code "heretic" to save an additional 10% off a yearly subscription (which is already 10% off a monthly subscription).

Pick up Keith and Matt's book, Reading...


#266: Quantum Theology with Zac Cannon, Mo Thomas, and Brandy Anderson
#438
02/24/2026

In this week's main episode, Keith chats with fellow contributors to Quoir's latest book, Quantum Theology, to talk about the intersection of quantum physics and spirituality.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today! Use code "heretic" to save 10% off a yearly subscription.

Pick up the new book, Quantum Theology today, as well as The UnChristian Truth About White Christian Nationalism.

...


BONUS SHOW: Epstein Fallout and the Nature of Evil
#439
02/20/2026

In this week's bonus show, Keith and Matthew read the very first hotline poem, plus a discussion about how evil falls in upon itself and how that should give us hope.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today, and use Promo Code "heretic" to save an additional 10% off a yearly subscription (which is already 10% off a monthly subscription).

Pick up Keith and...


#265: How Does American Christianity Survive the Epstein Files? with John Fugelsang, Lisa Sharon Harper, and Herb Montgomery
#436
02/17/2026

In this week's main episode, Keith and Matthew sit down with Lisa Sharon Harper, John Fugelsang, and Quoir author Herb Montgomery to discuss how the American church recovers from the Epstein files and their tacit and explicit support for those in it who have been alleged to have done horrific evil.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today! Use code "heretic" to save 10% off...


BONUS SHOW: El Paso Shut Down and Pam Bondi Blow-up
#437
02/13/2026

In this week's bonus show, Keith and Matthew answer a couple of texts and talk about the Pam Bondi testimony. Plus, what is going on over El Paso's skies? Find out!

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today, and use Promo Code "heretic" to save an additional 10% off a yearly subscription (which is already 10% off a monthly subscription).

Pick up Keith and...


#264: The Theology of Food with Lauren Cibene, Dillon Naber Cruz, and Derrick Weston
#434
02/10/2026

In this week's main episode, Keith and Matthew sit down with Lauren Cibene, Dillon Naber Cruz, and Derrick Weston to discuss the theology of food.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today! Use code "heretic" to save 10% off a yearly subscription.

Pick up Keith and Matt's book, Reading Romans Right, today, as well as The UnChristian Truth About White Christian Nationalism.
<...


BONUS SHOW: Newly Released Epstein Files SHOCKER
#435
02/06/2026

In this week's bonus show, Keith and Matthew answer a couple of texts and discuss the recent tranche of released Epstein files.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today, and use Promo Code "heretic" to save an additional 10% off a yearly subscription (which is already 10% off a monthly subscription).

Pick up Keith and Matt's book, Reading Romans Right, today!

Please...


#263: The Curian Network with Shaleen Kendrick and Jonathan Foster
#431
02/03/2026

In this week's main episode, Keith and Matthew sit down with Shaleen Kendrick and Jonathan Foster about the Curian Network... what it is, how it can be a leader in faith spaces, and how it is different than standard ordination programs.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today! Use code "heretic" to save 10% off a yearly subscription.

Pick up Keith and Matt's...


BONUS SHOW: Which Disciple Would Belong to Which Denomination?
#432
01/30/2026

In this week's bonus show, Keith and Matthew take a handful of calls into the hotline and try to guess which disciples would belong to which denomination.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today, and use Promo Code "heretic" to save an additional 10% off a yearly subscription (which is already 10% off a monthly subscription).

Pick up Keith and Matt's book, Reading Romans...


#262: Putting the "US" back in USA with Mattie Jo Cowsert and Jaxon Phoenix
#429
01/27/2026

In this week's main episode, Keith chats with Mattie Jo Cowsert and Jaxon Phoenix about how to put the "us" in "USA." With such a divided country, what can we do to bring some unity to the situation?

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today! Use code "heretic" to save 10% off a yearly subscription.

Pick up Keith and Matt's book, Reading Romans...


BONUS SHOW: Riley Gaines and the Culture War
#430
01/23/2026

In this week's bonus show, Keith and Matthew take a couple calls from the hotline, plus a commentary on Riley Gaines and the Right's insistence on fighting the culture war.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today, and use Promo Code "heretic" to save an additional 10% off a yearly subscription (which is already 10% off a monthly subscription).

Pick up Keith and Matt's...


#261: Surviving the End Times Tribulation with Stuart Delony and Adam Ericksen
#425
01/20/2026

In this week's main episode, Keith chats with Stuart Delony and Adam Ericksen about how to survive the end times tribulation.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today! Use code "heretic" to save 10% off a yearly subscription.

Pick up Keith and Matt's book, Reading Romans Right, today, as well as The UnChristian Truth About White Christian Nationalism.

Please consider signing...


BONUS SHOW: Escalating ICE Tensions and Authoritarianism
#428
01/16/2026

In this week's bonus show, Keith and Matthew take a couple calls from the hotline, plus provide their comments on the escalating tensions between the US citizens and the authoritarian ICE agents.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today, and use Promo Code "heretic" to save an additional 10% off a yearly subscription (which is already 10% off a monthly subscription).

Pick up Keith...


#260: Dark Star Sunflower with Darrell Epp
#423
01/13/2026

In this week's main episode, Keith and Matthew sit down with poet Darrell Epp to discuss why poetry (and art in general) is important in times such as these.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today! Use code "heretic" to save 10% off a yearly subscription.

Pick up Keith and Matt's book, Reading Romans Right, today, as well as The UnChristian Truth About...


BONUS SHOW: Government-Sponsored Murder of US Citizens
#427
01/09/2026

In this week's bonus show, Keith and Matthew take a call about MTG to the hotline, and discuss the murder of a 37-year-old woman by ICE agents.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today, and use Promo Code "hereic" to save an additional 10% off a yearly subscription (which is already 10% off a monthly subscription).

Pick up Keith and Matt's book, Reading Romans...


#259: Toxic Purity with Sara Moslener and Halley Kim
#415
01/06/2026

In this week's main episode, Keith chats with Halley Kim and Sara Moslener about toxic purity and how it both stifles and corrupts our true nature. Trigger Warning: topics include SA and marital r*pe.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today! Use code "heretic" to save 10% off a yearly subscription.

Pick up Keith and Matt's book, Reading Romans Right, today, as...


BONUS SHOW: Holiday Catch-up and New Year Hopes
#426
01/02/2026

In this week's bonus show, the guys catch up after the holidays and take your messages into the hotline.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today, and use Promo Code "hereic" to save an additional 10% off a yearly subscription (which is already 10% off a monthly subscription).

Pick up Keith and Matt's book, Reading Romans Right, today!

Please consider signing up...


REPLAY: #001: Heresy Is in the Eye of the Beholder
#424
12/30/2025

For our fifth and final "best of" episode for December, we revisit the place it all started: Episode #001!

On today's show, we jump in the way-way back machine and revisit the very first episode, featuring Matt, Keith, and that man Jamal! Is this really what the Heretic Happy Hour sounded like all those years ago? Tune in to find out!

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

<...


REPLAY: #197: How to Be Antiracist with Lisa Sharon Harper, Desimber Rose, and Daniel Henderson
#419
12/23/2025

For our fourth of five "best of" episodes for December, we revisit episode #197.

On today's show, our panel discusses the differences between "non-racism" and "anti-racism," and why the latter is far superior to the former. Join Matthew and Keith, alongside Lisa Sharon Harper, Desimber Rose, and Daniel Henderson, to discuss this important topic.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today! Use code "...


BONUS SHOW: Trump vs. Jesus and MAGA Cancel Culture
#422
12/19/2025

In this week's bonus show, the guys talk about their new book, Trump vs. Jesus, which is available now and crushing the charts. That, plus a story out of Chico that perfectly encapsulates the divide in America.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today, and use Promo Code "slayfascism50" to save an additional 50% off a yearly subscription (which is already 10% off a monthly subscription).<...


REPLAY: #193: The Gospel of Mary with Candida Moss and Elizabeth Schrader Polczer
#418
12/16/2025

For our third of five "best of" episodes for December, we revisit episode #193.

On today's show, Keith and Matthew sit down with Candida Moss and Libbie Schrader, two experts on the Gospel of Mary (Magdalene?). If you love the Gnostic texts, Christian history, and all that deliciously nerdy stuff, tune in for a deep dive into your favorite topics.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

...


BONUS SHOW: Hotline Madness and Nearly Losing a Thumb
#421
12/12/2025

In this week's bonus show, the guys take a handful of texts into the hotline, Matthew talks about how he almost cut off his thumb, and we end with some theology insights.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today, and use Promo Code "slayfascism50" to save an additional 50% off a yearly subscription (which is already 10% off a monthly subscription).

Pick up Keith...


REPLAY: #192: MAGA, Fascism, and Nazis Oh My with John Fugelsang, Jesse Dollemore, and Doug Pagitt
#417
12/09/2025

For our second of five "best of" episodes for December, we revisit episode #192.

On this week's panel, we are joined by the illustrious panel of John Fugelsang, Jesse Dollemore, and Doug Pagitt to talk about the similarities and differences between fascist movements like Nazism and MAGA.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today! Use code "slayfascism50" to save 50% off a yearly subscription...


BONUS SHOW: Hotline Madness!
#420
12/05/2025

In this week's bonus show, Matthew and Keith take a handful of texts into the hotline.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today, and use Promo Code "slayfascism50" to save an additional 50% off a yearly subscription (which is already 10% off a monthly subscription).

Pick up Keith and Matt's book, Reading Romans Right, today!

Please consider signing up to financially support...


REPLAY: #182: The False White Gospel with Jim Wallis, Herb Montgomery, and Dillon Naber Cruz
#416
12/02/2025

For our first of five "best of" episodes for December, we revisit episode #182.

White Christian Nationalism threatens American Democracy and American Christianity, but how did we get here, what happens next, and why won't this election solve the problem?

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today! Use code "slayfascism50" to save 50% off a yearly subscription. Valid now through the end of 2025.
<...


BONUS SHOW: Bobby's Poetry Masterclass
#414
11/28/2025

In this week's bonus show, Matthew and Keith provide some news and notes for this holiday season after hearing from a new exciting sponsor from RFK Jr. himself.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today, and use Promo Code "heretic" to save an additional 10% off a yearly subscription (which is already 10% off a monthly subscription).

Pick up Keith and Matt's book, Reading...


#258: The Continued Dangers of Christian Nationalism with Stuart Delony, Michael Burns, and Lisa Sharon Harper
#413
11/25/2025

In this week's main episode, Matthew and Keith chat with Stuart Delony, Michael Burns, and Lisa Sharon Harper about the continued dangers of Christian Nationalism.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today! Use code "heretic" to save 10% off a yearly subscription.

Pick up Keith and Matt's book, Reading Romans Right, today, as well as The UnChristian Truth About White Christian Nationalism.
<...


HERESY AFTER HOURS LIVESTREAM: Special Guest Lauren Cibene
#412
11/24/2025

In this special edition livestream, Matthew sits down with Lauren Cibene to talk about the theology and philosophy of The Last of Us, as well as Matthew's book that comes out next year on the same topic.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today, and use Promo Code "heretic" to save an additional 10% off a yearly subscription (which is already 10% off a monthly subscription).<...


BONUS SHOW: Hotline Messages and American Fascism
#411
11/21/2025

In this week's bonus show, Matthew and Keith take a couple of messages to the hotline and discuss the current state of the union after the Epstein file vote passed all branches of government. Plus, a special track from the one and only, Alex Jones.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today, and use Promo Code "heretic" to save an additional 10% off a yearly...


#257: The Death of Supernaturalism with Chad Bahl and D.T. Bryant
#410
11/18/2025

In this week's main episode, Matthew and Keith sit down with Chad Bahl and D.T. Bryant to discuss the death of supernaturalism.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today! Use code "heretic" to save 10% off a yearly subscription.

Pick up Keith and Matt's book, Reading Romans Right, today, as well as The UnChristian Truth About White Christian Nationalism.

Please...


BONUS SHOW: How Not to Be a Guest on Heretic Happy Hour
#409
11/14/2025

In this week's bonus show, Matthew and Keith address the behavior of a certain guest from this week's main show before discussing a hotline message and the recent dump of Epstein emails.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today, and use Promo Code "heretic" to save an additional 10% off a yearly subscription (which is already 10% off a monthly subscription).

Pick up Keith...


#256: Quantum Theology with Nish Dubashia, Mo Thomas, Jackson Peterson, and William Sarill
#408
11/11/2025

In this week's main episode, Keith is back and the guys are joined by a panel that delves deep into the intersection of theology and quantum physics.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today! Use code "heretic" to save 10% off a yearly subscription.

Pick up Keith and Matt's book, Reading Romans Right, today, as well as The UnChristian Truth About White Christian...


BONUS SHOW: Keith Is Back!
#407
11/07/2025

Keith is back for the bonus show, where we catch up with what's been going on and take a couple messages into the hotline.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today, and use Promo Code "heretic" to save an additional 10% off a yearly subscription (which is already 10% off a monthly subscription).

Pick up Keith and Matt's book, Reading Romans Right, today!
<...


#255: Scholarship and Mysticism with Dr. Dan McClellan and Heather Hamilton (with Guest Host Jeremy Steele)
#406
11/04/2025

In this week's main episode, Matthew is joined by guest host Jeremy Steele and panelists Dr. Dan McClellan and Heather Hamilton to discuss the balance between scholarship and mysticism.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today! Use code "heretic" to save 10% off a yearly subscription.

Pick up Keith and Matt's book, Reading Romans Right, today, as well as The UnChristian Truth About...


BONUS SHOW: Terms Other than "Christian" with Guest Host Jeremy Steele
#405
10/31/2025

It's Bonus Show time and Jeremy Steele is here to help Matthew queer-up the Heretic Happy Hour. Plus, a text from the hotline and what terms we use other than "Christian."

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today, and use Promo Code "heretic" to save an additional 10% off a yearly subscription (which is already 10% off a monthly subscription).

Pick up Keith and...


#254: Jesus Washing Charlie Kirk with Matthew Boedy and D.T. Bryant (with Guest Host Stuart Delony)
#404
10/28/2025

In this week's main episode, Matthew is joined by guest host Stuart Delony of the Snarky Faith podcast, as well as authors Matthew Boedy and D.T. Bryant to talk about the Jesus-washing of Charlie Kirk.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today! Use code "heretic" to save 10% off a yearly subscription.

Pick up Keith and Matt's book, Reading Romans Right, today...


BONUS SHOW: Bulldozing the White House with Guest Host Stuart Delony
#403
10/24/2025

The Trump Regime bulldozed the White House, and George Soros paid millions of people to protest. What else could happen while Keith is on vacation? Find out what Matt along with Stuart Delony think about the whole thing.

If you want to call in to the Bonus Show, leave a voicemail at (530) 332-8020. We'll get to your calls on next Friday's Bonus Show. Or, you can email Matthew at matthew@quoir.com.

Join The Quollective today, and use Promo Code "heretic" to save an additional 10% off a yearly subscription (which is already 10% off a monthly...