Creep Your Heart Out

Creep Your Heart Out signs off for the last time.  Thank you so much to all of our listeners who have supported us over the last half a year!  We had so much fun creating this show for you guys.

Unfortunately we haven't really had the time in the last couple of months to truly make the show what we dreamed it would be.  We want to create the very best listening experience for our fans!  So it is time to bring the show to an end.  The episodes will still be available online for anyone who wishe...

UFO sightings, encounters with Bigfoot , paranormal entities, and mysterious disappearances.  Strange events such as these happen all over the world nearly every day.  But what happens when this activity is concentrated in one specific area?  In this episode, we will bring you to three special places you’ll be sure to never want to visit, for you could be next.


Join us each and every Monday for a new episode!

Theme music by Nick Ferrero

In mid-September of 1961, a couple driving through the mountains of New Hampshire encounter a strange object in the night sky.   At first they believe it to be nothing more than a satellite or an airplane, but quickly realize it is something much more sinister and frightening.  This incident fast became known as the first widely publicized report of alien abduction in the United States.

Join us each and every Monday for a new episode!

Theme music by Nick Ferrero

In the spring of 1999 in a city in Hong Kong, China, a teenage girl bursts through the front doors of her local police station with the most baffling story they had ever heard.  She claimed that she had been involved in the torture and murder of a local sex worker, and according to her, she was now being haunted by the distressed woman’s spirit.   The story you are about to hear describes in brutal detail the torture one woman had to endure that ultimately lead to her death and is not one for the faint of heart.

...

This week, Monica and Nick discuss the strange case of the Yuba County five.  On a winter evening in 1978 a group of five men leaving a collage basketball game mysteriously disappear.  Months later, the remains of four of the men are found scattered in the woods 70 miles away from their homes.  But the fifth man was never accounted for.  Could this be a case of foul play or did some evil force lead the group to their untimely death?


Join us each and every Monday for a new episode!

Music by Nick Ferrero

In the final episode of this 3 parter, Monica and Nick conclude the case of the tragic death of Phoebe Handsjuk.  In August of 2013, nearly 3 years after she died, an inquest was held to re-examine evidence in the strange and brutal death of Phoebe Handsjuk. 26 witnesses gave their testimony and provided evidence to the coroner that Phoebe’s death could not absolutely be ruled an accident simply due to the influence of drugs and alcohol in her system. Will the coroner change his decision and open the doors for a new investigation?

New episodes each and every Monday!

In this week's episode, Monica and Nick continue the discussion of the tragic death of Phoebe Handsjuk.  In 2010, a 24 year old Australian woman is found dead in a pool of her own blood on the floor of the trash compactor room in the luxury apartment building where she lived.  Her distraught boyfriend tells police over and over that she was depressed and suicidal and that he knew she was going to do something like this.  But the evidence isn’t adding up.  Could this be a gruesome murder made to look like suicide?

 New episodes each and every M...

In the first part of this 2 part episode, Monica and Nick discuss the life and tragic death of Phoebe Handsjuk.  On a warm summer evening in 2010 a concierge working at a high rise luxury apartment building  in Melbourne, Australia is looking for a broom when she makes a grizzly discovery.  A stunning young woman is found dead in a pool of blood inside a garbage compactor room, her right foot almost completely severed.   Her death was ruled an accident and no further investigation was done.  Poor police work, among other things, lead to losing critical evidence that could have helpe...

This week, Monica and Nick discuss the legend of the Mothman.  In  November of 1966 the people of Point Pleasant, West Virginia began to see a huge, winged man-like apparition with glowing red eyes.  The entity chased cars and stared through windows, terrifying 100 or so adult members of the community over the course of a year.  Mysterious grinning strangers began appearing all over the town, interrogating citizens and taking pictures of them.  The strange events only came to an end when the Silver Bridge, a 700 foot suspension bridge that linked West Virginia to Ohio, collapsed just days before Christmas in 1967, leadi...

This week, Monica and Nick discuss horrific events of The Christmas Eve Massacre.  On Christmas Eve, 2008 in a quiet neighborhood of Covina, California, an 8 year old girl excitedly opens the front door of her grandparent's home to greet the big man in red: Santa Claus.  Her squeals of delight quickly turned to screams of terror when the man dressed as Santa began to unload the clip of a 9mm handgun into her and her family members.  The events that followed left 9 innocent people dead and 3 wounded. For those who survived, Christmas would never be the same again.

New...